Earth: A New Wild (2015) s01e04 Episode Script

Oceans

[ Music .]
The wilds of planet Earth are spectacular.
Yet one species is always framed out of the picture-- us.
I'm Dr.
M.
Sanjayan.
As a scientist and conservationist, I've dedicated the past 25 years of my life to studying and protecting the wildlife I love.
Hold on, buddy! [ Laughs .]
Now my mission is to tell you an untold story.
Where we humans are not separate from nature, we are part of it.
[ Elephant blares .]
The oceans are Earth's last wild frontier.
But now they're threatened with a manmade invasion.
Big predators reveal clues to an incredible past.
You cannot believe what I'm seeing.
And understanding them could help us create solutions for the future.
Where both ocean wildlife and humans can thrive Baby's coming out.
There it comes.
There it is.
in a new kind of wild.
February 18th, 2015 Dr.
Sanjayan: This is one of the most isolated islands on Earth-- Palmyra.
A hidden atoll smack bang in the middle of the pacific, 3,000 miles from the nearest continent.
[ Birds chirping .]
It's so remote, it shows what our oceans would have looked like before we came along.
As a scientist, this is the sort of place you dream of studying.
It's an ideal refuge for millions of long-range flyers.
But I've come here to study what's underwater.
Scientists on Palmyra had made a revolutionary discovery about how our oceans once worked.
To get a glimpse of what they discovered, I don't even need to leave the shallows.
Sharks.
They're everywhere.
Fives times more than on most reefs.
And when sharks start to circle you like this, it can mean they're in hunting mode.
Their sheer numbers is what makes this place so special.
The only safe way to see this is to get out of the water.
All I'm doing is waving this little tiny piece of fish in the water like that.
Yeah.
And just a little tiny smell and fish protein going in the water gets that happening.
Look at this, look at this, look at this.
Kydd Pollock is a marine scientist who uses this very simple method to figure out just how many sharks there are.
And they are now extending all the way back there.
Torpedo after torpedo after torpedo.
Oh, my God.
Oh, my God.
You cannot believe what I'm seeing.
There are dozens and dozens and dozens.
In less than a minute, we're completely surrounded.
Whoa, whoa, whoa! That shark went after the camera just now.
Looking at the mass of sharks, you question how there can be enough fish to feed all these mouths.
It's like seeing more lions than wildebeests on the African plains.
For me as a biologist, that's like changing the rules.
But it turns out in the ocean, the food chain works differently.
Predators drive a fast-breeding cog of smaller fish, smaller fish that reproduce so quickly that it allows for a larger mass of predators than prey.
It's a hungry ocean.
Just the sheer weight of all these sharks, they have to eat.
So basically, all the little fish in the ocean around here have to be reproducing fast in order to feed all these hungry mouths.
Everything's being eaten.
So everything is forced to reproduce younger.
Grow faster, recruit faster.
And that's that machine that's just driving this top-level weight of all these sharks.
What's been discovered on Palmyra turns the textbook understanding of the predator-prey system on its head.
What's surprising to me about this place is that it's kind of like a topsy-turvy world.
Look, any place I've ever been to, the Serengeti or the plains of Montana, you see predator-prey systems.
And they look like that classic triangle that you all know.
I mean, basically you've got loads and loads of little things that eat grass.
And then you've got some predators that keep things essentially in check.
When you come out here, what scientists are discovering is this part of the pyramid is completely different.
It's more like this.
This completely changed our understanding about how these oceans work.
Instead of a triangle, now you have something that looks more like this.
And these little guys now have to work much, much harder and cycle through and reproduce just about as fast as they can in order to feed all those hungry mouths.
It's kind of like be or be eaten.
And everything out there looks hungry.
This is how all our oceans would have once functioned before humans came along.
Super-productive, fast-breeding engines of life driven by predators.
So if all our oceans were once like this, what changed? Finding the answer to that question is what this man has dedicated his life to.
He knows that before we humans were around, even this Florida dock would have been just like Palmyra.
If you fell off this 100 years ago, there would be a very high probability of a shark attack.
And there would have been 500 six-foot sharks swimming around, swimming around.
That would not be a really cool place to jump into the water.
Dr.
Jeremy Jackson is considered one of the world's leading ocean scientists.
He has spent his life analyzing data that reveals the full story of our human relationship with the sea.
Over a cold beer, Jackson tells me there's one factor that really stands out in explaining what changed our oceans-- over-fishing.
And to convince me, he's brought along an unusual bit of evidence.
So these are a series of pictures that started out from the Photographs taken right here in Florida across the decades showing sports fishermen with their catch.
Same dock, same season, same ocean.
But very different fish.
I mean, there's just no way that one can misinterpret what's happened here.
Which is that we've eaten all of these.
And then we've eaten all of these.
And now all we have left is these.
So these are just emblematic of a panoply of gigantic creatures that used to live here.
So once upon a time, the oceans had monsters.
Today, it's down to shrimp.
Today it's down to shrimp and clams and squid and whatever.
And that is what's going on in the ocean today.
Today we take more fish from the ocean every year than three times the weight of the entire population of the United States.
Jackson dug deep into the past compiling one of the most comprehensive records ever of our human impact on the oceans.
He spent 40 years mapping the change from a productive predator-filled ocean like Palmyra to where we are today.
And projected this timeline into the future.
Dr.
Jackson: There used to be a lot of big animals.
We ate them.
There used to be a lot of three-dimensional structure.
Mangroves, kelp forests, coral reefs.
They're being leveled.
There used to be very few bacteria and stuff in the water.
Now there's a massive cloud of bacteria.
That is what's going on in the ocean today.
That is the rise of slime.
Dr.
Sanjayan: This sobering idea of a rise of slime is not just about over-fishing.
It's fueled by coastal development and pollution and even climate change.
It's a perfect storm.
I like to sometimes talk about the dead zonification of the global coastal ocean.
It's basically a reversal of 600 million years of evolution.
It's the taking over of the ocean by the bottom of the food chain.
And so what we get is the over-running of the coastal ocean by a pea soup of bacteria and other microbes.
And then that sets off an explosion of jellyfish which are really the only things that can eat these microbial plankton.
This rise of slime is already starting to take hold.
Around the world, fishermen are under siege.
Instead of sharks at the top of the food chain, the top predators here are primordial brainless jellyfish.
A lot of the microbes in the rising slime will kill you.
Dr.
Sanjayan: Now, our annual catch of jellyfish is approaching half a million tons.
We get the explosions of everything we don't want.
What I like to call the rats and cockroaches of the apocalypse.
Dr.
Sanjayan: Maybe this is Jackson's apocalypse playing out right in front of us.
But I know there are ways to tackle each and every element that make up Jackson's perfect storm.
You know, the guy's nickname is Dr.
Doom.
But he's a really nice guy.
And he laughs when he's telling you these most horrific things that are gonna happen to the ocean.
But the key word, I think, for me is the rise.
Slime hasn't fully risen yet.
Which means there's some hope.
There is some possibility that we could escape that fate at least in some parts of the planet.
The first hurdle to overcome in averting the rise of slime is dealing with over-fishing.
And that all starts with understanding in detail what the fish in our oceans are doing.
For so long, they've been out of sight and out of mind.
Now new technology has given us the tools to probe their secrets and it's research that starts in a surprising place.
This tuna fishing boat is homing in on its target.
It's been sailing for weeks off the coast of Papua New Guinea to find it.
These yellowfin tuna are crossing the Pacific Ocean.
Some tuna will travel 12,000 miles in a year.
Unlike most fish, they're warm-blooded which enables them to get more heat to their muscle and generate more power and speed making them one of the ocean's top predators.
Today there just aren't that many populations of migrating tuna left on Earth.
These fishermen are heading right into a huge score.
Sakana! [ Bell ringing, shouting .]
Sakana! You might think this is the tuna's last gasp.
But this is just a brief trip into our strange human world.
[ Distorted voices .]
These tuna aren't being killed but fitted with a tracking device and then released to continue their migration.
We've been tagging fish everywhere from Indonesia, Philippines in the west.
Through to Hawaii, Kiribati, Marshall Islands in the east.
Since we started in 2006, almost 400,000 fish have been tagged, 65,000 of which have been recaptured so far.
That's about 17%.
And, of course, more are still coming in.
[ Speaking French .]
This tuna tagging is part of a global effort to understand the movement of ocean predators.
Scientists have tagged tens of thousands.
They've gathered 300,000 days worth of data, and counting.
Individual animals can now have their profiles followed globally.
It's like a Facebook for fish.
These predators also reveal where the other fish, their prey, congregate.
All this data builds a remarkable living map of the ocean to help us pinpoint the parts that matter most.
Patterns emerge, highways for hammerheads.
Pit stops for whales, where the krill spawn.
And, off the coast of Costa Rica, breeding areas for snapper.
In the North Pacific, a highway of life is visible that shifts and moves on an annual cycle.
Now we know that these ocean hotspots also move with the seasons.
I'm tracking down one of these hotspots as it moves towards the coastline of British Columbia.
It's amazing what technology can now do.
I mean, I can sit here and see these tracks of ocean predators in time and space.
There's one that just goes all the way halfway out to Hawaii, and then comes right back.
Right back up here.
Today the predators are following a wildlife event that transforms this coastline.
Pacific herring are coming here to spawn in their billions.
These sea lions are following them.
Some have come from as far away as Mexico.
Look at these guys.
They're huge.
They're half the size of this kayak.
And I'm picking up their wake.
That chop is from them.
And it's not just sea lions.
Orcas and humpback whales are also drawn to this banquet.
The predator data we have allows us to pinpoint the exact time and location of spawning hotspots like this.
If we leave these places alone for just a few weeks of the year when it all kicks off, we give fish stocks the chance to recover.
Enough to reseed the ocean and keep the multimillion dollar fishery that works this coastline going for the rest of the year.
Rebuilding the diversity of fish stocks is a major step if we're to fend off Jeremy Jackson's vision of slime.
But it's only one step.
Jackson also highlighted how human development and pollution fuel the problems by threatening our most important coastal habitats.
Like these mangroves around Florida and the Bahamas that play a surprising role even for deep ocean fish.
This is the setting of one of the most astonishing wildlife events I have ever been part of.
Lemon sharks are coming in from the deep.
They're headed right into the shallows.
And they're here to give birth where the gnarly roots of the mangrove forests will provide some protection for their offspring.
These waters once teemed with lemon sharks.
But now they're an increasingly rare sight.
But one scientist is consumed by an obsession with bringing them back.
Do you love sharks? Well, I don't love all sharks.
I love pretty much lemon sharks.
[ Laughs .]
That's called a sharkist.
Dr.
Samuel Gruber, or The Doc, as he's known, is the world's leading expert on lemon sharks.
Over 50 years, he's watched as the oceans have emptied of these predators.
The Doc wants to make sure the next generation has a future, and the only way to do that is to get hands on with a pregnant shark.
He's stationed his researchers around the lagoon to intercept any females.
As soon as they spot one, they move in.
And that's when the lagoon becomes a maternity ward and The Doc gets called in as the midwife.
[ Radio chatter .]
Okay.
Things are about to get busy.
Busy.
Dr.
Gruber wanted in the delivery room.
Stop and go.
Nobody really knows what happens to baby sharks after they're born and The Doc is carrying out a study into this vulnerable stage in their life-cycle.
His plan is to get hold of two or three precious shark pups from this mother and move them to a part of the mangrove where they will be safe and where he can study them.
Come on, guys! Come on, think! Work! Babies are coming! Like any maternity ward, things get crazy really quickly.
It's a gigantic shark.
She's just turning right now.
And Doc just jumped in the water with her.
He's basically got her by the tail.
Get ready! Jesus, you guys are so fucked up! Come on! Work! And somewhere along here, I'm supposed to go in there with the shark.
Right now? Being around a nine-foot predator that's giving birth is a little dodgy.
Come on, guys! Get that shark! I got it, I got it, I got it! - Got it! - DJ! Got it! It's a humongous shark! All right.
This seems familiar, this position.
Now let us walk very slowly forward.
Underneath the shark, scavenging remora fish are constant companions.
Grab that.
- I feel a baby.
- You feel a baby? I believe I do.
Oh, yeah.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, I feel a baby.
Oh, yeah! Oh, yeah! They're in there! They're in there! I felt it kick! Now it's a matter of time.
Here we go, here we go, here we go.
Here they come! Let's get ready for babies! Dip nets and babies.
Don't look around! Dip nets and babies! It's coming! I can feel it.
I can feel the baby kicking.
I can feel it kicking on my hand.
I know, I know, I know.
They're in there.
They're in there and she's gonna give birth imminently.
Here we go.
The tip of the tail is out.
Baby's coming out now.
Baby's coming out.
Here it comes.
There it is.
Oh, my God! Damn you guys, damn it, take it! Come on, guys! Wake the fuck up! [ Shouting .]
Okay, get ready for more.
Lemon sharks only give birth to a handful of pups every two years.
It's estimated that only half of those survive in natural conditions.
Often taken by other predators before they can make it to the safety of the mangrove roots.
It's why the stakes are so high here.
It's gone! It's gone out! It's why you want to make sure there are no holes in your net.
Fuck! Fuck! Fuck! Fuck! - I see it, I see it! - I see it right there.
- Where? - Right there, right there! Grab it, grab it! Here comes another! I got my hand on her tail.
There's a shark in here.
Now look.
There it comes! It's out! It's out! It's out right here.
- I see it, I see it! - Right there! - It came out.
- Oh, there it is.
I know.
After giving a helping hand Natural birth, natural birth.
The Doc lets the mother birth the remaining pups on her own.
- Now.
- Let go? Let go of the shark.
Just step away from the shark.
Woo! That's amazing.
I mean, it's kind of crazy.
But we just played midwife to a shark.
The baby came out about the length of a human baby and as white as can be.
As white as the sandy bottom.
And the mom, I mean, you could just feel her pulse.
You could just feel her tick.
And just sort of her whole body would tense.
And that baby would squeeze out.
The pups are taken to the mangrove study site nearby.
And, unorthodox as ever, The Doc follows.
Here The Doc and his team can watch how these juveniles develop during this vulnerable stage in their lives.
Oh my God, just born.
So this could be her home for the next three or four years.
And then a little bit deeper.
And a little bit deeper.
Then she becomes a big shark in about 12 years, mates.
And then hopefully comes back here.
Exactly.
Comes back exactly where she was born to give birth.
By monitoring young sharks over the years, The Doc has discovered they imprint on the mangroves from the day they're born.
This, then, is the exact location this young female will come back to to give birth to her own pups.
If these mangroves are gone, that's a big problem.
There really is here or nowhere.
These baby sharks that depend on the mangroves also help the mangrove ecosystem in return.
They're miniature predators doing the same job as their parents in the deep ocean.
They drive a productive food chain feeding on a vast number of other animals that also use the mangroves as a nursery ground before they too can head for the deep.
Mangroves like these make up millions of acres of our coastline, enough to wrap around the planet twice.
These places nurture ocean life.
It's why human impact on coastlines is another fundamental part of what causes Jeremy Jackson's rise of slime.
These bizarre-looking creatures help support arguably the most important coastal environment of all.
Coral reefs make up less than 1% of the ocean, but support a quarter of all marine life.
They are the rainforests of our seas.
And the bump-headed parrot fish are the gardeners of these reefs.
They prune the coral with their beaks and clean them of algae.
Then they defecate, fertilizing the whole reef.
This gardening turns out to be even more crucial to coral survival than we first thought.
Alongside over-fishing and damage to the coastlines, the rise of slime is also fueled by climate change.
If the ocean is just a single degree warmer, corals start to bleach.
But bleached coral is not always dead.
It just has a damaged immune system that leaves it susceptible to invading algae that smother them and block out the sunlight, preventing their recovery.
With parrot fish cleaning the coral, algae can be kept in check and reefs can recover.
And while the bump-head may be one of the biggest grazers on the reef, they're not alone.
They're flanked by a wide range of others each fighting for their own patch of grazing.
The lesson here is that reefs can only survive with a wide range of grazing fish.
And if we can keep these systems working, then there's even better news.
Coral has a remarkable way to cope with a warming ocean.
And at night, you can see just how they're doing it.
When you shine an ultraviolet light on them, they fluoresce.
And they fluoresce in the most unbelievable way.
I mean, it looks like a little mini discotheque out here.
I mean, just take a look at this.
By using ultraviolet light, we can now reveal the coral's in-built defenses to changes in ocean temperature.
Scientists studying reefs have found that those with more fluorescent coral will cope better with rising sea temperatures.
In warmer waters, the effects of sunlight become extremely dangerous for corals.
But the fluorescent cells absorb dangerous ultraviolet rays, acting as a sunscreen.
Basically, the more psychedelic the show, the better for the coral.
And for a whole lot of other animals that make it home.
Wean now use this new understanding of corals' secret resilience to bring them back even when they've completely disappeared.
Here in Florida, reefs have been suffering from the effects of a warmer ocean.
But now we can use our knowledge of what makes a healthy, resilient coral and apply it.
Even try and grow a coral reef from scratch.
Of course, on a global scale, this may be a small experiment.
But it's still possibly the biggest manmade coral garden on Earth.
The scientists use their new understanding of which corals are most resilient to select cuttings from healthy reefs to try to engineer a more robust ecosystem.
They've learned from the fish how to garden coral, working alongside the grazers to keep the coral clear of algae.
It may be a partly artificial manmade ecosystem, but it has all the right species doing the right job.
And now we can count ourselves amongst them.
There's no doubt that Jeremy Jackson's apocalypse still looms large.
Over-fishing, damaged coastlines and climate change.
Those are the big factors for him and they haven't disappeared.
But even Jackson knows that the oceans can still be healthy although it does mean accepting things will never be the way they once were.
The way it all works is it used to be good, whatever that meant.
And now we're out here someplace and over here is the apocalypse.
Forget it, end of story.
We know we don't want to go there.
We've finally woken up to the fact that this is not a good thing.
We are nostalgic about this But we're not going to get back to here, are we? We will never get there.
Maybe we'll end up here.
Or we'll end up around here.
But it won't be the way it was here.
But it'll be a hell of a lot better than there or there.
And if I can have a totally artificial ecosystem which has a significant component of the species that do different jobs, well, then that's great.
And I'd be happy with that.
Is that the reality of nature or wilderness in a world with seven to nine billion people? That's right.
So where is this all leading us? In Mexico's Sea of Cortez, they're taking this idea of artificial ecosystems and engineering the wild to try to solve the big problems.
Pretty nice going to work every day.
Here, they're farming fish, and normally that can be a pretty unappealing way to go.
Most of the time, it pollutes bays and estuaries.
If you do it on land, you got to deal with this enormous amount of waste.
And it's a bit of a dark art.
But these guys say that what they're doing here is really different.
And when I get on-site, I start to see what they mean.
Underwater, you can just make out the edge of a giant sphere.
I mean, this I gotta see.
And these scientists from Earth Ocean Farms tell me that it's part of their futuristic plan to keep our planet fed.
Underwater, it's industrial.
There are structures and people everywhere Although it's nothing compared to what appears out of the gloom.
A colossal geodesic sphere measuring nearly 100 feet across floating like a planet in the deep water.
A planet with a front door.
Inside, suddenly the boundary between wild nature and this captive enclosure seems to disappear.
Being out here in the deep ocean is what makes this form of farming more effective than the old in-shore methods.
The idea is that powerful ocean currents flush through the cages, washing away waste and preventing the spread of parasites that plague the old style fish farms.
The fish here also have to swim harder, which keeps them healthier and these totoaba can grow up to six feet and over 200 pounds.
If we can use methods like these to ease the pressure on wild stocks and protect natural breeding hotspots, incredible regeneration can happen.
This is truly a vision for the 21st century.
But this modern farming still faces a challenge because the food for these fish is derived from other fish.
Every day, they're working to make the feeds more sustainable.
And while it still might not be perfect, we need to get it right because of one simple fact-- For the first time in human history, we now eat more farmed fish than we do wild fish.
That's as big a shift as when we moved from hunter-gatherers on land to a settled agricultural society, something that changed the face of the planet.
Our intervention in the oceans is only increasing.
It makes you realize that this veneer between what we control and what's wild nature, it's sort of disappearing in some ways.
And if the wild stocks can recover and we can supplement it with this, then we're in a good place.
Engineering like this helps relieve the pressure we put on the wild fish stocks, allowing us to use our new understanding to help the ocean to replenish itself.
And that applies right on our doorsteps, too.
Here in New York City, there is a remarkable engineering project that uses nature to push back the rise of slime.
This neighborhood has had Jeremy Jackson's whole package-- Over-fishing, massive coastal development and pollution.
Do you worry about walking in this water? Well, one of the issues that we have in the harbor is CSO which is combined sewage overflow.
So when it rains often in New York It's like the toilet overflowing? It's like the toilet overflowing and the water comes in the harbor.
So we have So New York's toilet basically overflows into this water.
Look around you.
That you're now trying to restore.
Kate Orff is an architect who has taken her design inspirations from nature and come up with a plan to let the ocean reclaim this industrial landscape.
Animals and plants take hold wherever you let them take hold.
If you look on these piers, you can see all these blue mussels here.
Yeah, you're right.
All over.
- You're right.
- Yeah, all along here.
- Look at that.
- Exactly.
Kate wants to bring back an animal that once fed this entire city.
One that's just starting to creep back in.
What's this? I think that looks like an oyster.
Hey! That's a live oyster, isn't it? That's it, that's it.
I've eaten many, many, many oysters in my life.
[ Laughs .]
Let's not eat this one.
Kate has found that the rough texture of this broken landscape can be a perfect mimic for a natural shoreline.
It provides ideal foundations for oysters and other filter feeders to take hold.
They remove excess nitrogen from pollutants that the bacteria in the rise of slime thrive on.
Incredibly, a single oyster can filter and clean up to 50 gallons of polluted water a day.
And before this bay was dredged to make way for a growing city, millions of oysters used to purify the water across this entire harbor.
Back in the day, when oysters covered almost 25% of the New York harbor, all the harbor water could be filtered within one week's time.
So all that water you see out there Churned through the stomach of an oyster.
- Every week.
- Every week, right.
But oysters are just the beginning.
As the water clears, more diverse life can move in.
Animals that are building blocks of a healthy ocean and the antidote to the rise of slime.
Suddenly, a wasteland becomes a wild and vibrant neighborhood where migrants can find refuge.
Old residents like these blue crab defend burrows and courting couples dance.
Sometimes for eight hours a day.
[ Laughs .]
He likes that.
He's wagging his tail.
Oh, there we go.
Even horseshoe crabs can come here to mate.
It is sort of odd.
I mean, this is about as modern a city as you're gonna get.
And then there's this thing right out of the Jurassic almost.
I mean, it just crawled its way up here.
If there was a wall here, this wouldn't be happening because they need to kind of crawl up off the sand in a very shallow gradient.
So it's really exciting because these landscapes are the ones that are coming back.
I think that's the future.
You have people, you have animals.
But with design, with a little bit of design, with a little bit of engineering, we can coexist.
Kate, working with others, has convinced the city authorities to leave these broken down landscapes to be reclaimed by nature.
And now even big business is putting up money to bring the oysters back.
Kate's also drawn up blueprints for vast underwater structures that will give oysters a foothold to recolonize Manhattan.
Seven and a half million have already been cultivated.
And when you consider a single oyster can produce 25 million eggs, then billions of them can be just around the corner.
They can purify the harbor, bring back marine life.
If we can fight back the rise of slime here, then you really do get this feeling that we can change the future of our oceans and our entire relationship with the wild for the better.
It's all part of a vision I've seen emerging across this entire planet.
A natural world tended by us but that also supports us.
A place where we can share our homes and even our cities with the wild.
This is humans not separate from nature, but part of it.
Amazing, huh? Where science helps us design ingenious solutions.
We can live, adapt, bring nature back into our world.
And even thrive side by side with our wild neighbors.
And when we do, it makes our lives better.
Are you seeing this? This is the Earth's new wild.
Announcer: To learn more about this program, visit pbs.
org/earthanewwild Earth A New Wild is available on Blu-Ray and DVD.
To order, visit shoppbs.
org or call 1-800-play-pbs
Previous EpisodeNext Episode