A Christmas Murder Mystery (2025) Movie Script
What's happening...?
His...
Dad.
He is dead.
"A Midtown Vacation Miracle"?
What a miracle! This guy wasn't hit by a bus.
-He saved a dog. -I saved a newsroom.
Where is my headline? Metro wants a decision
on that double page of photographs.
Tell them it's a newspaper, not a Christmas card.
Hey, I didn't leave my keys at that editorial meeting,
-Did I do it? -Planning a getaway?
Ugh, not if I can't find those keys.
If we don't use that spread, we'll need something
-To fill that space. -You.
-Yes? -What's in fashion?
Hey, a moose walked into a supermarket.
Oh. Let it be a reindeer.
and I will pass the food collection on to A2.
-You have it. -Did you see my...?
Oh, I don't have my keys. Sorry.
And we still need Vera's puzzle for C7.
What is the four-letter word for procrastination?
That's right. I...
-Vera.-Ten letters.
It's 1 o'clock.
12:58. The deadline is at 6:00.
The deadline is usually 6:00.
But today is Christmas Eve.
And on Christmas Eve, the deadline is 1:00.
Didn't you receive my...?
My memo?
Tannenbaum.
So, are you finished?
Here you are. And right at the end of the road.
Thank you.
Cintia.
-Yes? -You never responded to my proposal.
about the expansion of the puzzle section.
You know, most people here like it...
spend Christmas Eve at home with their families.
-If you could take a look. -Actually, I have.
-And? -And the puzzle section.
It's a quarter of a page.
It has always been a quarter of a page.
That doesn't mean it can't grow.
Anagrams, cryptic crosswords.
Look...
If I promise to consider it,
Do you promise to come home and do whatever it is you do?
I have plans.
Back to working at the sheriff's department again?
The Sterlings have invited me to their estate for the weekend.
Hmm, what a shame.
I could really use a detective around here.
-to find-- -Your car keys?
They are in the break room.
-How do you know...? -This is what we know.
You and I always arrive at work at the same time,
And you weren't there today, which indicates
You arrived late.
You always pass through the break room.
To have a coffee upon arrival.
And the coffee stain on your notebook
He tells me you were holding a cup
and not your car keys when you left,
What do your car keys mean?
They are to the right of the coffee machine.
-Vera, that's... -Observant?
-Something like that. -Hmph.
Wait.
There's just one puzzle here.
And what about tomorrow?
-What's wrong? -It's Christmas.
The office is closed.
"Was it inside?" "The memo, right?"
However,
because you're actually making an attempt
in human interaction,
I'll let you email me, but only this once.
-Thank you. -Don't make me call you.
Hmm.
Everything is polished and ready.
The only thing missing is the staff.
Are you sure we didn't make a mistake sending them home?
If we didn't give them a free Christmas,
They'll be in a bad mood until the New Year.
Besides,
The food is ready.
But what about the gifts?
Already under the tree,
Including one for Darren.
Why did you invite him?
We never invite outsiders to our house at Christmas.
If I remember correctly, you also invited a guest.
Ah, yes, but Vera had no one to spend Christmas with.
And I thought the company would seem interesting to him.
-Like Darren would. -Darren is your lawyer.
If I had no one to spend Christmas with,
-It was well deserved. -As is often the case,
I have business to discuss with him.
Hmm, well, Catherine could have handled that.
You know what I think about our daughter working.
for the family business.
He specializes in real estate law.
We've had this discussion.
It would be a conflict of interest.
Come on. Many children join the family business.
No, if they work for the competition.
Oh. Thank you, Drew.
-Everything is ready.-Perfect.
-Merry Christmas. -To you too.
Merry christmas.
-Oh. -Look,
Ellen, I'd love to.
If Catherine came to work for me.
But she has never shown the slightest interest.
Fun.
I always thought I had made my interests quite clear.
Father.
Catalina.
That's my girl.
-We were arguing... -I know.
And I'm very interested in the family business.
After all, someone has to protect us.
the audience of people like you.
Fun.
So where is everyone?
Your father sent them home for Christmas.
He thought it would be good for morale.
Not the staff.
-Miguel, and Jan, and Troy. -Ah.
Your brothers are late as usual.
Okay then,
I'd better go and settle in.
She has always had a predilection for the theater.
Just like his father.
I would like to spend Christmas alive.
thank you so much.
All my friends are in Cabo, Belize or Aspen.
And I'm stuck here.
In the middle of the glacial cold of nowhere.
Say the word, Jan.
I'll take you back to the airport.
The bags are in the car.
You can take them to the room here.
The gifts go under the tree.
So...
I don't work here.
They don't expect us to carry things in our bags, do they?
I hope not.
Hello?
Hmm.
-Hmm. -Vera.
Hello. I'm so glad you're here.
Hmm.
Your mother would kill me.
If your daughter spent Christmas alone.
Oh, you remember Catherine?
-Of course. -Hello.
Oh.
I'm sorry about your engagement.
Excuse me?
You have a tan line where your ring used to be.
Here we are,
-Carrying the bags.-Oh.
-Hello.-Michael.
-I thought this was a party. -Hi, honey.
Oh my God.
Sister.
-Ah.-Hmm.
"I see you came alone again." "Ask her."
-She'll tell you everything. -Hmm.
Well, I always thought I could do better.
Oh, my brother, always so romantic.
-Well... -Look who I found.
walking outside.
-Oh, well, hi, Darren. -Hi, Ellen.
-What are you doing here? -Ah, always so kind.
To see you too, Michael.
Don't tell me you're afraid of lawyers.
Only those who think they are family.
-We'll get you a drink, Darren. -Yes.
These poinsettias stay in good condition.
Most people don't know it, but they thrive in cooler air.
There's a lot of cold air in this house.
How did you meet the Sterlings?
Family friend. Vera Vexley.
-Oh. -Full-time puzzle editor
and part-time consulting detective
for the sheriff's department.
And an observer of vacation dysfunction.
In other words, you are perfectly qualified.
It was an investment, Michael, not a loan.
I am your son, Dad.
And that's one reason for a man
Making bad investments?
"I raised you better than this." "Come on, Dad."
There will be some big changes around here.
Money doesn't grow on trees.
-Although you children act
-Like he does. -Yes, of course.
-Listen to me. -I just need.
-A little help. -How much?
Only one hundred thousand.
Maybe $125,000.
I agree,
It will be added at the beginning.
I know it's not a gift,
Unlike Troy's endless registration.
What I do with my money is my own business.
I know. But I'm family.
Unfortunately.
Good job, Dad.
I'll go and check it out in January.
Please don't be late for dinner.
You know how much it bothers your mother.
I won't do it.
What are you looking at?
-Hey-- -Not now!
Careful.
If you fix that, they'll make you reorganize the whole house.
Troy Sterling.
Black sheep in the residence.
Is that a habit of yours?
Sneak up to your house guests from the shadows?
Oh, I'm just hiding from the family drama.
between Russian literature and a slight existential fear.
It sounds productive.
You must be Vera.
You write the puzzles that keep my mother humble.
There is nothing humble about your mother.
He also mentioned that you're a part-time detective.
Consulting detective.
"I'm surprised we haven't met." "I'm not. I've been buried."
PhD in comparative literature for seven years.
They only let me go out on vacation.
and funerals.
And what is this?
Ask me after dinner.
So how does a puzzle editor become a detective?
They called me.
They needed help with a case.
It's quite a puzzle, isn't it?
Finding the missing pieces,
Connecting the dots,
Discover which details don't quite fit.
And to think I was starting to worry
Nobody here could keep up.
Hmm.
"I speak without a mouth,
I hear without ears,
I have no body, but I come to life with the wind.
What am I?
It's a riddle.
A challenge.
So go ahead.
Why don't you see if you can keep up with me?
This looks delicious, Ellen.
-Thank you. -Oh, of course.
I would like to thank all of you.
for coming here for Christmas.
Your mother and I greatly appreciate it.
There is nothing more important than family.
Hmm.
And family friends.
-And family lawyers, apparently. -Darren was invited.
not only because he's a friend of the family,
but for another reason that will soon become clear.
-What's wrong, Dad? -Not now.
Tonight, let's enjoy the food and the company.
-Merry Christmas. -Listen, listen.
-Listen, listen. -Yes.
-Merry christmas.
Merry Christmas. Merry Christmas.
Thank you for inviting me. I appreciate it.
-Hmm.
Hmm.
Are there vegetarian options?
Oh, since when are you a vegetarian?
I'm pretty sure I saw you eating ham last year.
The first thing that came to mind was bacon.
-Oh. -Second,
It was just a bite.
-Mm. -Okay. Be nice to her.
Hmm. You've been in school so long,
I'm surprised you remember what real food is.
-Oh. -Yes. Are you still going?
To get a degree in, uh, "books that nobody reads"?
Uh, comparative literature, yes.
Oh, exactly.
Okay. Enough.
Please.
We have sweet potatoes and green beans.
and lots of bread.
Nobody dies of hunger.
Are they always so festive?
Oh, this is nothing.
However, if someone mentions politics or wills,
run.
This looks amazing.
Very good. Enjoy your meal.
Alright.
If I want to change my position,
I'm going to have to do something about it.
This has become clear.
Let's talk tomorrow
Once I can get away from here for a while.
No, no, thank you. You're just as I thought.
Yeah.
Some things never change.
Wait a second.
One last time, sir,
I beg you.
You're not going to convince me, Darren.
I've already made a decision.
When will you make the announcement?
Tomorrow during Christmas dinner,
We can discuss the new parameters.
And then afterwards we will have the signature.
Is there something that's worrying you, Darren?
I've been your trusted advisor, haven't I?
-Indeed. -And a trustworthy advisor?
Of course.
I expected the revised will to reflect that.
If you are not satisfied with the agreement,
You are free to leave at any time.
"It's a matter of justice, sir." "Justice?"
If I knew that word was in your vocabulary,
I would never have hired you.
Good evening, sir.
Lawyers. Hmm.
Have you tried CPR?
I woke up and knew it immediately.
that something was wrong.
Your father never slept later than I did.
I'll call the sheriff.
-This is Congressman Neal. -I'm Vera.
Vera. Well, Merry Christmas. You know my mom's been stuck
Did you spend all morning on any of your puzzles?
You're welcome. Please take this to the sheriff.
Um, Sheriff Brackett is in Alaska doing...
His polar bear dive,
But I'm sure I can be of help.
To our best consulting detective.
Harold Sterling is dead.
-Oh.
I want to ask how you know that?
Because I'm standing in front of her house
and he's not breathing.
That will do it.
His wife found him unconscious in bed this morning.
Right at Christmas.
-I'm on my way. -Hurry up.
We may have a second body when you get here.
Oh, wow.
Merry Christmas, Harold.
So Vera, what do you think?
Hmm.
Hmm.
Disgusting.
Be.
Poison.
Don't you think we should wait for the toxicology results?
This is what we know.
The eyes suggest sudden heart failure.
Bluish tint to the lips and tongue,
and the faint scent of almonds.
Whatever he drank was the last thing he did.
So you know they're going to want it
The whole kit and set.
Crime scene investigators, lab technicians...
Or you can leave me alone to work in peace
And you'll be the man who solved the case.
Do you think someone...?
Do you think someone meant to hurt him?
I think someone wanted to kill him.
And the killer is in this house.
Well, I guess I could always forget to call the coroner.
because it's Christmas and all that.
So it's time to connect the dots.
Do you want a handkerchief?
Um, I'm fine.
I wanted to talk to you first.
Were you the one who found Harold?
Yeah.
What time did you go to sleep?
I don't know. Um...
10:30, 11:00?
Hmm. And Harold?
He was already asleep.
Or at least that's what I thought.
He was dead.
-Excuse me? -Well, the body gets cold.
at one and a half degrees Fahrenheit per hour.
Taking into account the blanket and the fact
which was warmer than the room,
five plus two plus one, he had been dead for eight hours.
I believe he was poisoned in an act of foul play.
Do you have any idea what Harold was doing?
Before going to bed?
He was here. He was in the office.
-Alone? -No, uh...
Darren was with him.
Do you know what they talked about?
I suppose it was the will.
Whatever it was,
We were going to discuss it during dinner.
Rosie played us for fools.
Thank you, Ellen.
Hmm.
So that's it?
What is it?
I felt like I was just warming up.
No dark circles, no jewelry, no makeup.
Have you ever seen Ellen Sterling without makeup?
I mean, well, her husband just died.
Exactly.
That wasn't acting.
That was a woman in shock.
She shuddered when I said Harold's name, but not Darren's.
Hmm.
So she didn't do it?
I'm not sure.
Remind me why Vera is there interrogating our mother?
-She's a puzzle editor. -Who better?
Is it more difficult to assemble a jigsaw puzzle if a professional does it?
Not to mention that she is also
A part-time consulting detective.
What does that mean?
It's a little early for drama, Michael.
We just lost our father, Catherine.
That may not mean anything to you,
But some of us are truly human.
How dare you?
Please, I saw more emotion in you.
-When we had to sacrifice Bella. -Excuse me?
I can't believe you're doing this right now.
Okay. This won't get us anywhere.
Actually, Troy, he's taking us somewhere.
-Oh? -While some of us are grieving,
Others are just looking for their next tuition check.
Now, I'm putting my life on pause.
You left a stable job
So you can go into academic exile.
It was better than selling my soul for a tie.
Enough!
Enough is enough, everyone!
Your father wouldn't want this.
Actually, Darren, this is exactly what he would want.
He liked to pit us against each other.
It gave her something to look at during breakfast.
Your father was a very complicated man.
Oh.
Darren, what are you doing here?
I'm here because your father invited me.
Why would anyone invite their lawyer?
A family Christmas?
Perhaps because it was much more
More than just a lawyer to him
And you know it.
My brother is falling apart,
But let's not pretend he's wrong.
I'm here because I'm trying to help all of you.
Okay. Then maybe you'll try acting like we lost.
a human being, not a customer.
Mom? Mom, are you okay?
Mother.
I'm fine.
Uh, you don't look good.
Darren, she's ready for you now.
Well.
What's wrong, Mom?
Your father's death...
he...
It was not due to natural causes.
Hmm.
Are you really going to ask me questions?
Sure.
What is your opinion, Mr. Caldwell?
I am not a doctor.
But you were the last person to see him alive.
I don't know. Tired, I guess.
But I'll save you the trouble.
I didn't kill Harold.
I haven't asked you yet
Still?
She's just getting warmed up.
Let's try a different approach.
Who would benefit most from Harold's death?
Do you think someone killed him for money?
Money, fear, revenge.
Houses of this size have many reasons.
I have worked with this family for a long time.
And now they're dysfunctional?
Sure.
Defective?
You have no idea.
But...a murderer?
You met with Harold late last night.
What did they discuss?
-That's confidential. -Attorney-client privilege ends.
when the customer does it.
You know it.
What then happens to attorney privilege?
I don't want to tell you.
This is what we know.
A glass,
His partner was found on top of the body.
It was an expensive single malt whisky.
So it was probably a festive spill, not an accidental one.
Judging by the fact that one chair is closer
At the other people's table
It indicates that you were here for work.
And it was late on Christmas Eve,
So it was probably a personal matter.
Like a will?
I heard you storming out of here from upstairs,
who says whatever happened at this meeting,
You didn't like it.
You wouldn't have participated in the toast,
However, your glass was empty.
The only explanation is that you threw it away.
Before leaving the room.
How is it possible that you know that?
Because you're still alive.
Was he poisoned?
Where did you go after your meeting?
-Outside. -Alone?
What's the difference?
Do you really think I'm stupid enough?
Poison a drink so they'll serve it to me?
Or smart enough not to drink it when you were.
Are we finished?
Yeah.
You know, you really should work on your social skills.
You know, just a little bit.
If I had friends, I could ask them.
That was a joke.
Yeah.
I don't know what we're doing sitting here doing nothing.
We have no idea what's going on right now.
All I'm saying is that we shouldn't speculate.
Well, you say? We've only heard from you.
Uh, no, no, what I'm saying is...
Who does she think she is? A great detective?
As if I didn't even understand what this is.
I don't understand why you're not speaking.
For me right now. I have so many questions.
What did she say?
She...
He asked many questions.
If something were to happen to him,
So Darren had something to do with it!
-Uh, that's exactly right. -Mr. Sterling?
"Did they murder our father?" "Except you didn't."
You're in the family photo, right?
What really happened?
We are still investigating.
So why would you suggest that to my mother?
Look how upset she is!
All I did was point out some missing pieces.
-What pieces are missing? -Missing pieces?
I have no idea what you're talking about.
"But I need to know who..." "Hey! Hey! Okay! Everyone!"
Please, there's no need to shout at each other, okay?
Everyone will have their turn.
I'll get to you, Mrs. Sterling.
But first I'd like to talk to Michael.
I'd love to learn a few words. I have some questions.
Okay, guide me, assistant. In fact, you know what?
-I'll guide you. -Incredible.
Are you always this popular during Christmas?
Only when there is a corpse.
Is that really necessary?
You don't want to ask him that.
Oh, I want to ask you so many things.
I would like to ask you about your father's business.
-Why? -Excuse me?
Why do I have to answer your questions and not his?
This is because Vera is holding an official position.
as a representative of the Sheriff's department.
So a crossword columnist
Are you conducting murder investigations?
And does the Sheriff agree with this?
So you're saying this is murder?
Well, the police wouldn't be involved.
Otherwise, would they do it now?
Well, now Vera has the best.
The best observation skills I've ever seen.
Furthermore, it turns out she's also the Sheriff's deputy.
preferred researcher
So is it true?
Was Dad murdered?
Would that surprise you?
Did someone want him dead? No.
What was a relative?
That's...impossible.
What about enemies?
My father was a powerful man.
Powerful men don't make friends, they create friction.
And why didn't you join him?
Real estate didn't really excite me,
Do you know what I mean?
What makes your blood pump?
I'm in the hospitality business.
He owns a nightclub.
So velvet ropes and bottle service.
Instead of zoning permits and property taxes?
Better margins, better stories.
And fewer board meetings with your father.
Feel free to drop by sometime. I'll add you to the list.
And congressman, why don't you bring your mother?
We're more like a "Wheel of Fortune" family.
Oh. Do you still live with your mom?
And what about your wife?
Do you work in the hospitality sector?
She was a floral designer when we met.
Now we are partners in all the aspects that matter.
Except romantic.
Excuse me?
Her diamond ring.
It's an Asscher cut.
which is a favorite among the old rich and aristocrats.
I suppose it's a family heirloom.
which means she likes playing the role of Mrs. Sterling.
But when you arrived,
You took her hand and she didn't take it.
And then, during dinner, you didn't take away his chair.
Incidentally, she noticed.
-I warned you.
She wears Chanel perfume, but it doesn't leave a trace.
And you've mentioned it three times so far.
but never by his name.
Phew.
Have you finished analyzing my marriage?
That depends. Is there anything left to analyze?
-Oh, I should--
January! January!
Look at me. Look at me. Say something.
Where did he go?
Are you OK?
Let's take a look.
Does your head spin? Do you feel nauseous?
No. I'm dizzy.
I hit my head.
Although I'm fine.
Can you tell us what happened?
-Um... -Here.
Well, I went up to the room to look for something.
And then when I was going down...
Someone pushed me.
I'll check upstairs, see if anyone's lurking around.
Where was everyone else?
I was in the kitchen making coffee.
My mother and I were downstairs.
What's happening?
-Where were you? -Excuse me?
Someone pushed Jan down the stairs.
That?
-Jan, are you okay? -Yes, I scraped my knee.
-Oh, let me see. -Don't touch my wife!
Okay. Relax.
Mr. Caldwell, where were you?
Outside.
Just getting some fresh air.
Didn't you hear anything?
-No. -Raised voices? A fall?
No, I didn't do it.
There's nobody upstairs.
At least not for now.
Come on, we'll take you to the doctor.
Oh, no. No, Michael.
I'm not going to wait in the emergency room for 10 hours on Christmas.
Jan, let's go.
At least we'll get this knee checked out.
Ellen, do you have a first aid kit?
Yes, it's in the guest bathroom.
Uh-hmm. Come, come.
There it is. How so?
Hurts.
But I will live.
You fell quite a bit.
Yeah.
-Mrs. Sterling, I... -Oh.
You don't need to call me that.
Michael and I,
We're getting a divorce.
Well.
I'm sorry.
No. No. Don't be. I'm not.
Does anyone else in the family know?
Uh, not that I know of. Why?
Someone might have wanted to send a message.
Okay. Remind me never to miss Christmas.
In this house again.
Yes, it's exhausting to always be the outsider.
Tell me about it.
All the sweetness,
and the polite smiles,
and the holidays, and the dinners.
Please.
It's just a facade for a family.
who can't stand being in the same room together.
-Troy seems nice. -Yes. Well,
Or he is genuinely interested in learning
or has found the perfect getaway.
Either way, he's an intelligent man.
So you didn't see anything when you fell?
Think about it carefully, please.
I, uh...
I felt a push
and...
The next thing I knew,
I was at the bottom of the stairs.
Thanks for the chat.
You are officially discharged.
-She will live. -Well...
-Jan. -Jan. Hello.
-Michael, are you okay? -Fine.
There's no fracture. Just a little swelling.
-Okay. -Oh, thank God.
Troy is not here.
He's upstairs.
He said he needed some peace and quiet.
-Oh, should I go look for him? -No.
-Yes, I'm fine. -No, I'm leaving.
You should stay together.
Statistically speaking, fewer people fall down the stairs.
when they are not in them.
That?
-Hmm. -Then,
What does your instinct tell you?
No signs of chafing.
Still dusty.
I suppose the maid took Christmas off.
Maybe.
How far do you think it fell?
The landing consists of only nine steps.
It couldn't have fallen very far.
Her shoes.
Oh, I couldn't see her shoes properly.
They were still standing.
Does that mean anything?
I'm not sure yet.
Forward.
Oh.
I didn't think you'd get this far.
I don't usually climb stairs for no reason.
or a good book.
-Well, you found both. -Yes, you didn't seem...
too nervous downstairs
If I left every time a Sterling self-destructed,
I would need a revolving door.
No, I came here to think...
That's all about what happened.
I never really said I was sorry for what happened.
You know, the people at the bottom see... income.
A food voucher.
And I see a man who taught me how to throw a ball.
So forgive me if Jan's hysteria isn't really my priority.
Even if Harold had a soft spot for her for some reason.
Do you mind if I ask where you were?
When did your father die?
I was in the library. I couldn't sleep.
Any witnesses?
Plenty.
If we count the greatest literary minds
of the last century.
I'd like to ask about your brother's club.
-Carousel. -More specifically
your father's financial interest in it.
It was Harold's money that got it started.
But when Carousel wasn't making a profit fast enough,
Michael partnered with other associates.
A different kind of family, let's say.
Organized crime?
Harold was not happy.
He said he would go public if Michael didn't buy it.
-For New Year's. -A revelation like that.
-It would ruin the business. -And the marriage.
There will be no trophy handcuffs for second place.
So we have some suspicious characters,
a ticking clock,
and a guy with a big mouth.
As I said.
Self-destruction.
And are you sure you didn't hear anything when Jan fell?
I don't feel it.
What are you listening to?
It's a lo-fi studio mix.
-Can I?-Uh-hmm.
I like it.
I'm sure it's simply great.
But we have a killer to catch, so...
One, echo.
The answer to your riddle is an echo.
-Troy. -Huh?
You're thinking about something.
It could be nothing.
Okay, what is it?
It could be something.
Well. You know, I skipped breakfast because of this.
Harold did it too.
Okay. That's not fair.
You'd better call me to tell me there's a puzzle.
-Waiting in my inbox. -You'll receive it.
I was hoping you could do me a favor.
Have you heard of a nightclub in town called Carousel?
Are you kidding?
Federal authorities have been investigating.
-That place for months. -Really?
Chuck has been working on an exhibition.
Apparently, some very bad people
He invested a lot of money in it.
Wait.
Are these the Sterlings?
I can't say
So you'll check it?
Am I creating a puzzle for myself?
Yes, you're facing a puzzle.
Give me a minute.
Aconite.
Interesting.
Hello.
Hmm.
Hmm, I wonder what he has to say.
I hope I'm not intruding.
No, dear. No.
-Any news?-No.
She hoped she could borrow her daughter for a moment.
Can it wait?
I am taking care of my mother.
I'm fine.
I'm just tired.
I want to be close
In case you need anything.
So what's up?
You had a seat in your father's company.
Even so, you rejected it.
Not everyone dreams of working for their father.
Not everyone leaves a company
with his name on the door.
Harold didn't exactly make room on the table.
He did...
demands,
criticisms,
and ultimatums.
Real estate law was a way for me
Stay close without getting burned.
What is your relationship with Mr. Caldwell?
Cordial.
Cordially distant or cordially adversarial?
He was jealous.
Mother, please.
She deserves the truth.
You should be resting.
Darren always thought Harold saw something.
special in him.
Something like a surrogate son.
And then Catherine...
It started making waves.
He saw her as a threat.
And Darren didn't like threats.
Harold was her only real connection to power.
And now the next in line were the children.
I need to go check something.
Thank you for your time.
Oh, and I'm sorry for, you know.
-Guilty. -In something?
Suspect.
Guilty,
red herring.
Hey, would you mind sharing it?
It's a puzzle.
Yes. Yes, it is.
No. This is it.
Would you give this to my editor?
Uh, sure.
So, is there anything new in the research?
I spoke with Ellen and Catherine.
Oh, you've got something.
I asked my editor at the Chronicle
To see if it can dig up some dirt
at Michael's club.
AND?
The FBI detected it last year.
for suspicious activity.
Anything about Michael's mysterious business partners?
He thought it might be related to organized crime.
We know that Harold invested.
He discovered who else was involved and wanted out.
He gave Michael an ultimatum: buy his share...
or I would make it public.
That would have destroyed the club.
And marriage.
Well, you don't seem that surprised.
For a family full of secrets,
They're not very good at keeping them.
Well, maybe you'd like to take a look at this then.
I didn't think it was their kind of place.
Me neither.
Do you think his bookworm act is appealing?
Is he hiding something?
Elegant?
Vera Vexley, you're not softening up to him, are you?
No. I was just making an observation.
That's all.
Don't forget to send it.
Yes, ma'am.
Oh.
There you are.
This is where Dad keeps the good things.
Hmm.
Uh, there she is.
Could you talk for a moment?
It doesn't look like we're going anywhere.
Only.
I'll be fine.
Well.
I'll be right back.
I can't wait to hear what an interesting topic...
It is more important that I take care of my injured wife.
Their divorce.
Turn from the puzzle pages to page six now?
She's not one to chat about unimportant things, is she?
I'm afraid not.
Yeah.
Jan and I separated.
And how do you know that?
Oh, she lives for this.
And most importantly: Did your father know?
Of course. Blame me.
So who will keep the club?
She can have it
Anyway, it's going to fall apart.
What do their investors think about this?
What do you want to ask me, Vera?
Who would you ask to pay the bill?
I know he wasn't your father.
And I doubt that your brother is that liquid.
So who do you owe?
You know nothing
I know enough to recognize when someone
It's far beyond his capabilities.
I think you're surrounded by people.
who have a lot to lose.
Perhaps they are getting desperate.
Perhaps you're getting desperate.
Either way, that inheritance money
I'd definitely dig you up.
So you think I'm behind my own father's death?
And what about the attack on my wife?
Not necessarily.
But I wonder who else you've brought.
-In this mess. -How dare you!
Hey, just tell him what he needs to know.
Do you want me to tell you something?
Okay. Call my lawyer.
You know I can call your lawyer, Michael.
-Yes? -I really could.
But I suppose you and I know how that would turn out.
And I don't think your so-called friends
I would be too excited.
That's what I thought.
Excuse me.
What's going on?
We've been going back and forth for hours.
Okay. I know this must be frustrating for all of you.
But I would like to ask for a little more time.
Time? Time for what?
We don't even know what you were doing!
We are investigating the death of your father.
In addition to the attack on Mrs. Sterling.
Yes, well, we'll see.
what your senior officers
I have something to say about this.
-Ma'am? -I'm not a child.
"Don't talk to me like that." "Ma'am!"
-Incredible. -Look, I...
We don't even know what you're doing.
-Madam.-Thank you.
What are you doing here?
Yes, indeed.
But I know my family.
They're not just going to admit they did it.
...patience from all of you.
And soon all this will be resolved.
Did you hang out at the Carousel?
-Ma'am. -Incredible.
Troy,
If you're hiding something...
...the death of your father,
as well as the attack on Mrs. Sterling.
No, I...
I hated the fact that Harold was paying for my education.
And then, from time to time, he would make some changes.
You know?
I'm not going to lie. I had a reason.
Just like everyone else in this room.
Am I under arrest, congressman?
Perhaps even more.
Let's see what he has to say about the matter.
Why don't you let Vera do her job?
Your job?
His job is to write jigsaw puzzles for the newspaper.
Well.
I'd like to see you actually try to solve one.
The point is that she's a guest.
who can be uninvited just as easily.
"I built it with my own hands,
But that's not what I intended.
I thought I could escape it,
But now I'm the one trapped in it."
Someone?
A lie.
Yeah.
Just give me time.
I'll let you know when I need you.
-Okay. That's all. -What's wrong with him?
Don't worry. I'll take care of it.
Darren was on the porch.
Troy was in the library.
Ellen was getting ready to go to bed.
Catherine was in her bedroom.
Hmm.
Do you have anything?
Be.
I asked you if you found anything.
I'm just trying to put the puzzle pieces together.
You sure don't seem like a happy family.
More like a survival game.
Troy?
Harold Sterling was murdered by someone in this house.
Troy lives in this house.
He does, but, you know, you...
No, I don't know.
You like him.
Just because you like someone doesn't make them innocent.
Okay. I want to make sure you see things clearly.
My vision is fine.
Each of them is hiding something.
The more they try to cover it up,
The clearer it becomes.
Is that really necessary?
Christmas music?
Our father lies dead upstairs, so no.
I'm really not in the mood for dancing sugar fairies.
Nothing represents holiday homicide like Tchaikovsky.
What's wrong with this family?
Oh, Michael, please.
-Everyone's upset. -Are they?
Because Catherine is here pretending that this is...
some twisted Christmas party,
And Troy is going to get a PhD in presumption.
No, I'm just trying not to add anything.
to the shrill chorus.
I apparently failed.
Oh, well, God forbid.
Someone tries to break the tension.
Sorry, I didn't bring a black veil or a pipe organ.
Perhaps you could tone it down a bit, Catherine.
It's not all about acting.
Hmm. Coming from man.
who pretended to love Dad for 15 years
-Just to be included in the will. -Really?
Is this what you want to do? Do you want to do it now?
-Hey! -Actually.
Enough! All of you!
In the 19th century, mass printing
It led to the emergence of illustrated magazines and storybooks.
who often use visual puzzles
Designed to take advantage of the environment.
Find the difference.
I think it's the same. No...
Almost.
This is exactly what your father didn't want.
How could any of us know what he wanted?
There was...
There were some things I couldn't tell you.
How to change your will?
-Wait, what? -What?
Do you want to change your will?
She was weighing her options.
And now he's dead. Hmm.
Well, things got dark quickly.
Is that why I wanted you here?
Who is he cutting?
I am not free to say so.
What are you not telling us?
Well, I know he wasn't going to leave me out.
because I have been with him more than any of you.
Seriously, what was going to change?
I told you. That's confidential.
-Miguel!
Good heavens! They don't need a detective.
They need a referee.
Guys!
What's going on here?
Can we talk?
Of course.
Um, I'll stay here and take care of the cattle.
to avoid getting too noisy.
I apologize.
It seems that self-control is not a sterling virtue.
What about those who aren't Sterlings?
That?
You know what I'm talking about.
Slide the panel to open it.
Five-six-three-one.
How did you know?
You said earlier that the children were next in line.
Normally, that would be you.
The spouse.
So, something must have happened.
so that you are removed from the equation.
Something a man like Harold Sterling
I would find it unforgivable.
You should know that he knows.
That?
Troy?
What? I never told him.
There was an envelope on his desk.
from the genealogy company.
Since I've been here, he has never mentioned Harold.
like his father.
Just by his name.
He also works part-time at his brother's club.
And that's not something a child receiving a trust fund would do.
Unless he thought that trust was running out.
His father was an employee of Harold.
It doesn't matter who it was.
He did not know that Troy was his.
But Harold knew it.
Harold caught us.
What did he do?
Harold was pragmatic.
He didn't want to make a scene.
He fired the employee, of course.
And then he tried with me.
I knew that divorce wouldn't help.
It would be a public spectacle.
I would be ruined.
Your company,
his legacy.
Harold was not willing to allow that to happen.
And Troy?
Harold treated him as if he were his own.
And what about his share of the will?
Did he even have one?
I threatened to tell the truth if Harold refused.
So none of the children knew?
No.
Darren was the only one who knew.
He managed the finances, the trust.
He had access to everything.
Hmm.
Does Troy really know?
I'm sure of it.
Don't you think so...?
Didn't you know about the promise you made to Harold?
Troy is not a murderer.
But then, you don't need me.
To tell you that, do you do it?
You have a connection, right?
Glad to hear it.
He needs someone who sees him, who really sees him.
Miguel?
Yes, Mom?
Had you seen your brother?
Upper floor.
Excuse me.
I would like to speak with him personally.
Of course.
Shirley Temple for the puzzle editor?
I'm fine.
Well.
You must think we're a pathetic bunch, huh?
Why do you say that?
I mean, look at us.
I believe you are a family that has suffered a great tragedy.
Yeah.
I'd love to see what my father would say about all this.
I'm not entirely sure I understand.
My father used to write a diary when he was younger.
I literally recorded everything.
Business meetings, family outings,
blah, blah, blah.
It would be hilarious to see, huh?
How would you describe your own death?
"Final entry.
I can't say I didn't see it coming.
Do you know if he still has them?
His diaries?
I don't know. Why?
Do you mind if I join you?
Mmm. Sure.
I just spoke to my mom.
I understand.
Family doesn't always feel like family,
Especially when things are so messy.
I think that always, you know,
As if I were a stranger looking from the outside.
He just never quite fit in.
It's difficult when...
Everything you're supposed to have feels...
mistaken.
It's all a lie.
Our family.
Everything I thought I was.
Sometimes, the truth shows us where we belong.
Even if we don't want to see it.
Do you always speak in riddles?
Only when I try to get to the heart of things.
Good,
I guess we'll have to work all this out together.
And if only we could have known what Harold was thinking.
Yeah.
If only.
Where are they?
-What's wrong? -I don't know.
My head.
Michael, do you know who did this to you?
-No. -What happened?
Someone hit him on the head.
Miguel? Miguel, can you hear me?
Did you see who did this to you?
Is there anything we can do?
-I'm going to call an ambulance. -Okay.
Miguel? Miguel, stay with me! Hey!
What is everything...?
Miguel?
He reached the door and collapsed.
The ambulance will take at least 30 minutes to arrive.
Don't they know who owns this house?
It doesn't matter.
It matters. I'll call you.
What is all this noise?
Miguel! Oh my God!
Michael, are you okay?
Michael, talk to me. Are you hurt?
-What happened? -I don't know.
Hey, could you come with me for a second?
-Sure. -Relax.
Alright.
Okay. Please tell me you're close to solving this case.
Because the Sterlings are dropping like flies.
Actually, I had a question about your father.
Harold.
Ah.
Michael mentioned that he kept diaries.
And I've turned his whole office upside down.
And I've looked through this library
and I can't find them anywhere.
Actually?
Didn't you happen to know...?
I've already looked at everything here.
-Intelligent. -Oh, yes.
He had a knack for hiding things and tricks and stuff like that.
You know, he used to do your jigsaw puzzles every morning.
-Really? -Oh, yes.
We used to think he was obsessed with his stock portfolio.
or the latest mergers, but no,
It was called "Vera Vexley's Puzzles".
Here. Will that help?
It's time to connect the dots.
How is he?
Uh, he took quite a hard hit,
But it doesn't look like a concussion.
It wouldn't hurt for the paramedics to take a look.
Darren, I'd like to talk to you alone for a moment.
So that?
I knew it.
Please?
Yeah.
Feel.
I will remain standing. Thank you.
No, sit down.
Well.
That?
I need to see the will.
No, it's not going to happen.
I can obtain a court order or a subpoena.
Go ahead, I'm not going to just give it to you.
Do you recognize that document?
This could be critical to this investigation, right?
Then it shouldn't be too difficult to obtain a court order.
Or you can wait until the will is processed.
We don't have that time, and you know it.
That's not my problem.
One Sterling is dead and two others have been injured.
Once again, that's not...
It's not your problem. I know.
How long have you been in a relationship with Jan?
How did you know?
The way she looked at you,
The way your husband distrusted you.
The two glasses by the porch.
after sharing a kiss against the window.
You didn't want to arouse suspicion,
So you went through the back...
And I dropped this, by the way.
And you smell like Chanel perfume.
Don't worry.
I'm a consulting detective, not the morality police.
Are we finished?
Almost.
Right here.
-They're here. -Oh.
Is he going to the hospital?
That may not be necessary, ma'am.
Congressman, a word?
Okay. Take a deep breath.
Pleasant and easy.
-Okay. -Are you sure?
Okay. Now you're going to follow my finger.
Okay? Ready?
"Oh, oh, oh! What is this?" "Mr. Caldwell..."
I knew it! I knew he'd done it!
Wow. What... what's going on?
You have the right to remain silent.
Everything you say can and will be used against you.
-In a court of law. -Okay. I know my rights.
You have the right to a lawyer.
If you cannot afford a lawyer,
You will be provided with one.
You'd better hope this continues.
Okay. Okay.
I'm sure this isn't what anyone expected at Christmas.
I can't believe it was Darren.
He will have a fair trial like everyone else.
Please!
You wouldn't risk arrest unless you were sure.
So, what do you have?
He had no alibi for Harold's murder.
And what about Jan and Michael?
Would he have attacked them too?
The probability of having two assassins
It's very low at Christmas dinner.
He is stable.
Make sure he gets enough rest and...
-You need to avoid alcohol. -Hmm.
-What? -Good luck with that.
-Let's go. -Merry Christmas.
Merry christmas.
Merry christmas.
This is all very good.
But even so, it is mostly circumstantial.
You wouldn't arrest someone just for that.
What are you not telling us?
I probably shouldn't tell you this.
But it's going to be on Discovery anyway.
This is what we know.
Harold kept diaries for most of his life.
He detailed his work extensively.
and all those he met.
You told me.
It's true.
I haven't read them all yet,
But I have read the last two entries.
AND?
And he explained
A terrible argument with Mr. Caldwell.
It appears that Mr. Sterling was reviewing his will.
and left Mr. Caldwell out.
Given his years of loyalty,
Mr. Caldwell believed he deserved something.
But why would he attack Michael?
And why would he come after me?
Mr. Caldwell believed it was Michael
who convinced Harold to leave him out of the will.
-No. -And as for you...
Hmm.
...maybe he was the jealous type.
But why would you need the diaries?
Harold wrote everything down.
Business meetings, family trips.
If Darren confronted him, it would most likely be there.
So what do we do now?
Nothing. In the next few days,
Deputy Neal will bring them all to the station.
for their official statement.
Well, thanks for everything.
I'm sure this isn't the way.
You wanted to spend your Christmas.
Oh, I had a great time.
And I'm happy to have been able to give you some closure.
I'll go upstairs and pack.
I will help you.
Are you sure you won't stay for dinner?
Consulting detectives do not receive risk pay.
Fun.
You know, it's going to be boring not having you around.
Could you give me your email address?
and I could send you some puzzles.
I suppose I couldn't...
Perhaps we'll meet again?
Sometimes.
At the Rialto they are performing "It's a Wonderful Life!"
-I could give you a ride. -Could you give me a ride?
I said we don't receive risk pay, but we do get paid.
Another joke.
Yeah.
Okay, so it's a date.
-Thank you.-Ah.
Vera, II era--
Looking for a midnight snack?
What are you doing here?
I wonder what you're doing
snooping around your father-in-law's office.
I was just...
Looking for memories for Michael.
This must be a difficult time for you, Mrs. Sterling.
Is.
No!
Jan Sterling, you are under arrest.
Oh!
Hmm.
Hmm.
This is what we know.
The autopsy results will be available in the coming days.
And I'm sure we'll find aconite in your system.
-What is it? -Poison
derived from aconite.
A highly toxic plant that you have
growing up next to your viewpoint.
Any former floral designer
with experience in horticulture
I would know its uses.
She should have picked the flowers.
sometime after their arrival.
So, Jan knew that Michael had spoken to our father.
about their impending divorce?
And she also knew that Harold was going to announce
a change in his will, leaving her out.
Why would he try to kill Michael?
As Michael's widow,
She would receive her share of the inheritance
Even if she herself was removed from the will.
Exactly. I was afraid the New Testament would prevail.
I knew she was capable of doing some pretty twisted things,
But... not this.
So...
Who tried to kill her?
That's what initially puzzled me.
When I first examined the stairs,
There were no signs of a struggle,
She had no chafing marks and still had her shoes on.
So who pushed her down the stairs?
Nobody.
Jan faked his fall.
She thought that by being the next victim,
She wanted to shift the blame from herself, and she was right.
So when did you know Darren was innocent?
The first column of any logic puzzle is the motif.
Darren didn't have any.
You had every reason to be angry with Harold, you know?
You served him faithfully for many years.
But Harold Sterling did not die in a fit of rage.
He was killed in a meticulously planned assassination.
Furthermore, with the death of Mr. Sterling,
It was less likely that Darren would get anything.
When did you tell Darren your plan?
When I invited him to the office.
And I accepted immediately.
I had to completely convince Jan.
that we had our man.
Okay. So how did you know?
Would Jan go to get the diaries?
Because they were the only thing that could trip her up.
I had a strong suspicion that Jan had gone to blackmail Harold.
That's why she was having an affair with Darren.
to get dirty information about Harold.
I'm sorry.
Now, if I was wrong,
The newspapers wouldn't have made any difference.
But he was right,
The diaries would have contained a record
of exactly what I was trying to do.
That's why I had to find them.
-Yes. -Oh,
So where exactly are these diaries?
Oh, Harold hadn't actually kept a diary for years.
This was evident from the amount of dust they had.
But Jan didn't know that.
The important thing was that she thought she did it.
Now, I'm sure you have many more questions,
But you could use your privacy.
You have a lot to discuss.
Well, actually we've already discussed this quite a bit.
And considering that the three
control the assets in equal measures,
We have decided to divide the assets.
An equitable division.
Something we could all be happy about.
That's a good idea.
Now, if you'll excuse me.
My editor will be furious
If I don't finish the puzzle tomorrow.
Come here.
Merry Christmas, Mom.
Welcome to the family, Darren.
-Hugs. -That was incredible.
Yeah.
"This is what we know."
It was nice having you around.
I don't get to test my skills every day.
for a Christmas mystery.
Hey, I'm serious.
It was nice having you around.
You could always email me for those puzzles, you know?
I'll take you up on that.
We're going to print in an hour. What's my lead story?
"Real estate tycoon found dead on Christmas Day."
"Found dead?" You say it as if
The guy died in his sleep.
How about "murdered"?
-Done. -I got an interview.
with the congressman who broke the case.
Ah, the great minds of law enforcement.
-To the rescue again. -Sidebar, A2.
Sidebar, A5.
They're not that great
-Has anyone seen...? -Handbag. Side pocket.
-How did you do it...? -I saw you put it there.
-When did you get in? -Ugh. The deadline is almost here.
-Where's my crossword puzzle? -The crossword puzzle is in your inbox.
And my New Year's puzzle?
I thought you'd want to be the first to read it.
Happy new year.
Happy New Year, Vera.
"This is what we know."
A man in his 60s was found dead in his bed
in a house with his wife,
three adult children,
a sister-in-law and a lawyer,
They all have an alibi for the moment of death.
Did you know that his will had recently been changed?
and you suspect something's fishy. Now..."
"It's time to connect the dots."
His...
Dad.
He is dead.
"A Midtown Vacation Miracle"?
What a miracle! This guy wasn't hit by a bus.
-He saved a dog. -I saved a newsroom.
Where is my headline? Metro wants a decision
on that double page of photographs.
Tell them it's a newspaper, not a Christmas card.
Hey, I didn't leave my keys at that editorial meeting,
-Did I do it? -Planning a getaway?
Ugh, not if I can't find those keys.
If we don't use that spread, we'll need something
-To fill that space. -You.
-Yes? -What's in fashion?
Hey, a moose walked into a supermarket.
Oh. Let it be a reindeer.
and I will pass the food collection on to A2.
-You have it. -Did you see my...?
Oh, I don't have my keys. Sorry.
And we still need Vera's puzzle for C7.
What is the four-letter word for procrastination?
That's right. I...
-Vera.-Ten letters.
It's 1 o'clock.
12:58. The deadline is at 6:00.
The deadline is usually 6:00.
But today is Christmas Eve.
And on Christmas Eve, the deadline is 1:00.
Didn't you receive my...?
My memo?
Tannenbaum.
So, are you finished?
Here you are. And right at the end of the road.
Thank you.
Cintia.
-Yes? -You never responded to my proposal.
about the expansion of the puzzle section.
You know, most people here like it...
spend Christmas Eve at home with their families.
-If you could take a look. -Actually, I have.
-And? -And the puzzle section.
It's a quarter of a page.
It has always been a quarter of a page.
That doesn't mean it can't grow.
Anagrams, cryptic crosswords.
Look...
If I promise to consider it,
Do you promise to come home and do whatever it is you do?
I have plans.
Back to working at the sheriff's department again?
The Sterlings have invited me to their estate for the weekend.
Hmm, what a shame.
I could really use a detective around here.
-to find-- -Your car keys?
They are in the break room.
-How do you know...? -This is what we know.
You and I always arrive at work at the same time,
And you weren't there today, which indicates
You arrived late.
You always pass through the break room.
To have a coffee upon arrival.
And the coffee stain on your notebook
He tells me you were holding a cup
and not your car keys when you left,
What do your car keys mean?
They are to the right of the coffee machine.
-Vera, that's... -Observant?
-Something like that. -Hmph.
Wait.
There's just one puzzle here.
And what about tomorrow?
-What's wrong? -It's Christmas.
The office is closed.
"Was it inside?" "The memo, right?"
However,
because you're actually making an attempt
in human interaction,
I'll let you email me, but only this once.
-Thank you. -Don't make me call you.
Hmm.
Everything is polished and ready.
The only thing missing is the staff.
Are you sure we didn't make a mistake sending them home?
If we didn't give them a free Christmas,
They'll be in a bad mood until the New Year.
Besides,
The food is ready.
But what about the gifts?
Already under the tree,
Including one for Darren.
Why did you invite him?
We never invite outsiders to our house at Christmas.
If I remember correctly, you also invited a guest.
Ah, yes, but Vera had no one to spend Christmas with.
And I thought the company would seem interesting to him.
-Like Darren would. -Darren is your lawyer.
If I had no one to spend Christmas with,
-It was well deserved. -As is often the case,
I have business to discuss with him.
Hmm, well, Catherine could have handled that.
You know what I think about our daughter working.
for the family business.
He specializes in real estate law.
We've had this discussion.
It would be a conflict of interest.
Come on. Many children join the family business.
No, if they work for the competition.
Oh. Thank you, Drew.
-Everything is ready.-Perfect.
-Merry Christmas. -To you too.
Merry christmas.
-Oh. -Look,
Ellen, I'd love to.
If Catherine came to work for me.
But she has never shown the slightest interest.
Fun.
I always thought I had made my interests quite clear.
Father.
Catalina.
That's my girl.
-We were arguing... -I know.
And I'm very interested in the family business.
After all, someone has to protect us.
the audience of people like you.
Fun.
So where is everyone?
Your father sent them home for Christmas.
He thought it would be good for morale.
Not the staff.
-Miguel, and Jan, and Troy. -Ah.
Your brothers are late as usual.
Okay then,
I'd better go and settle in.
She has always had a predilection for the theater.
Just like his father.
I would like to spend Christmas alive.
thank you so much.
All my friends are in Cabo, Belize or Aspen.
And I'm stuck here.
In the middle of the glacial cold of nowhere.
Say the word, Jan.
I'll take you back to the airport.
The bags are in the car.
You can take them to the room here.
The gifts go under the tree.
So...
I don't work here.
They don't expect us to carry things in our bags, do they?
I hope not.
Hello?
Hmm.
-Hmm. -Vera.
Hello. I'm so glad you're here.
Hmm.
Your mother would kill me.
If your daughter spent Christmas alone.
Oh, you remember Catherine?
-Of course. -Hello.
Oh.
I'm sorry about your engagement.
Excuse me?
You have a tan line where your ring used to be.
Here we are,
-Carrying the bags.-Oh.
-Hello.-Michael.
-I thought this was a party. -Hi, honey.
Oh my God.
Sister.
-Ah.-Hmm.
"I see you came alone again." "Ask her."
-She'll tell you everything. -Hmm.
Well, I always thought I could do better.
Oh, my brother, always so romantic.
-Well... -Look who I found.
walking outside.
-Oh, well, hi, Darren. -Hi, Ellen.
-What are you doing here? -Ah, always so kind.
To see you too, Michael.
Don't tell me you're afraid of lawyers.
Only those who think they are family.
-We'll get you a drink, Darren. -Yes.
These poinsettias stay in good condition.
Most people don't know it, but they thrive in cooler air.
There's a lot of cold air in this house.
How did you meet the Sterlings?
Family friend. Vera Vexley.
-Oh. -Full-time puzzle editor
and part-time consulting detective
for the sheriff's department.
And an observer of vacation dysfunction.
In other words, you are perfectly qualified.
It was an investment, Michael, not a loan.
I am your son, Dad.
And that's one reason for a man
Making bad investments?
"I raised you better than this." "Come on, Dad."
There will be some big changes around here.
Money doesn't grow on trees.
-Although you children act
-Like he does. -Yes, of course.
-Listen to me. -I just need.
-A little help. -How much?
Only one hundred thousand.
Maybe $125,000.
I agree,
It will be added at the beginning.
I know it's not a gift,
Unlike Troy's endless registration.
What I do with my money is my own business.
I know. But I'm family.
Unfortunately.
Good job, Dad.
I'll go and check it out in January.
Please don't be late for dinner.
You know how much it bothers your mother.
I won't do it.
What are you looking at?
-Hey-- -Not now!
Careful.
If you fix that, they'll make you reorganize the whole house.
Troy Sterling.
Black sheep in the residence.
Is that a habit of yours?
Sneak up to your house guests from the shadows?
Oh, I'm just hiding from the family drama.
between Russian literature and a slight existential fear.
It sounds productive.
You must be Vera.
You write the puzzles that keep my mother humble.
There is nothing humble about your mother.
He also mentioned that you're a part-time detective.
Consulting detective.
"I'm surprised we haven't met." "I'm not. I've been buried."
PhD in comparative literature for seven years.
They only let me go out on vacation.
and funerals.
And what is this?
Ask me after dinner.
So how does a puzzle editor become a detective?
They called me.
They needed help with a case.
It's quite a puzzle, isn't it?
Finding the missing pieces,
Connecting the dots,
Discover which details don't quite fit.
And to think I was starting to worry
Nobody here could keep up.
Hmm.
"I speak without a mouth,
I hear without ears,
I have no body, but I come to life with the wind.
What am I?
It's a riddle.
A challenge.
So go ahead.
Why don't you see if you can keep up with me?
This looks delicious, Ellen.
-Thank you. -Oh, of course.
I would like to thank all of you.
for coming here for Christmas.
Your mother and I greatly appreciate it.
There is nothing more important than family.
Hmm.
And family friends.
-And family lawyers, apparently. -Darren was invited.
not only because he's a friend of the family,
but for another reason that will soon become clear.
-What's wrong, Dad? -Not now.
Tonight, let's enjoy the food and the company.
-Merry Christmas. -Listen, listen.
-Listen, listen. -Yes.
-Merry christmas.
Merry Christmas. Merry Christmas.
Thank you for inviting me. I appreciate it.
-Hmm.
Hmm.
Are there vegetarian options?
Oh, since when are you a vegetarian?
I'm pretty sure I saw you eating ham last year.
The first thing that came to mind was bacon.
-Oh. -Second,
It was just a bite.
-Mm. -Okay. Be nice to her.
Hmm. You've been in school so long,
I'm surprised you remember what real food is.
-Oh. -Yes. Are you still going?
To get a degree in, uh, "books that nobody reads"?
Uh, comparative literature, yes.
Oh, exactly.
Okay. Enough.
Please.
We have sweet potatoes and green beans.
and lots of bread.
Nobody dies of hunger.
Are they always so festive?
Oh, this is nothing.
However, if someone mentions politics or wills,
run.
This looks amazing.
Very good. Enjoy your meal.
Alright.
If I want to change my position,
I'm going to have to do something about it.
This has become clear.
Let's talk tomorrow
Once I can get away from here for a while.
No, no, thank you. You're just as I thought.
Yeah.
Some things never change.
Wait a second.
One last time, sir,
I beg you.
You're not going to convince me, Darren.
I've already made a decision.
When will you make the announcement?
Tomorrow during Christmas dinner,
We can discuss the new parameters.
And then afterwards we will have the signature.
Is there something that's worrying you, Darren?
I've been your trusted advisor, haven't I?
-Indeed. -And a trustworthy advisor?
Of course.
I expected the revised will to reflect that.
If you are not satisfied with the agreement,
You are free to leave at any time.
"It's a matter of justice, sir." "Justice?"
If I knew that word was in your vocabulary,
I would never have hired you.
Good evening, sir.
Lawyers. Hmm.
Have you tried CPR?
I woke up and knew it immediately.
that something was wrong.
Your father never slept later than I did.
I'll call the sheriff.
-This is Congressman Neal. -I'm Vera.
Vera. Well, Merry Christmas. You know my mom's been stuck
Did you spend all morning on any of your puzzles?
You're welcome. Please take this to the sheriff.
Um, Sheriff Brackett is in Alaska doing...
His polar bear dive,
But I'm sure I can be of help.
To our best consulting detective.
Harold Sterling is dead.
-Oh.
I want to ask how you know that?
Because I'm standing in front of her house
and he's not breathing.
That will do it.
His wife found him unconscious in bed this morning.
Right at Christmas.
-I'm on my way. -Hurry up.
We may have a second body when you get here.
Oh, wow.
Merry Christmas, Harold.
So Vera, what do you think?
Hmm.
Hmm.
Disgusting.
Be.
Poison.
Don't you think we should wait for the toxicology results?
This is what we know.
The eyes suggest sudden heart failure.
Bluish tint to the lips and tongue,
and the faint scent of almonds.
Whatever he drank was the last thing he did.
So you know they're going to want it
The whole kit and set.
Crime scene investigators, lab technicians...
Or you can leave me alone to work in peace
And you'll be the man who solved the case.
Do you think someone...?
Do you think someone meant to hurt him?
I think someone wanted to kill him.
And the killer is in this house.
Well, I guess I could always forget to call the coroner.
because it's Christmas and all that.
So it's time to connect the dots.
Do you want a handkerchief?
Um, I'm fine.
I wanted to talk to you first.
Were you the one who found Harold?
Yeah.
What time did you go to sleep?
I don't know. Um...
10:30, 11:00?
Hmm. And Harold?
He was already asleep.
Or at least that's what I thought.
He was dead.
-Excuse me? -Well, the body gets cold.
at one and a half degrees Fahrenheit per hour.
Taking into account the blanket and the fact
which was warmer than the room,
five plus two plus one, he had been dead for eight hours.
I believe he was poisoned in an act of foul play.
Do you have any idea what Harold was doing?
Before going to bed?
He was here. He was in the office.
-Alone? -No, uh...
Darren was with him.
Do you know what they talked about?
I suppose it was the will.
Whatever it was,
We were going to discuss it during dinner.
Rosie played us for fools.
Thank you, Ellen.
Hmm.
So that's it?
What is it?
I felt like I was just warming up.
No dark circles, no jewelry, no makeup.
Have you ever seen Ellen Sterling without makeup?
I mean, well, her husband just died.
Exactly.
That wasn't acting.
That was a woman in shock.
She shuddered when I said Harold's name, but not Darren's.
Hmm.
So she didn't do it?
I'm not sure.
Remind me why Vera is there interrogating our mother?
-She's a puzzle editor. -Who better?
Is it more difficult to assemble a jigsaw puzzle if a professional does it?
Not to mention that she is also
A part-time consulting detective.
What does that mean?
It's a little early for drama, Michael.
We just lost our father, Catherine.
That may not mean anything to you,
But some of us are truly human.
How dare you?
Please, I saw more emotion in you.
-When we had to sacrifice Bella. -Excuse me?
I can't believe you're doing this right now.
Okay. This won't get us anywhere.
Actually, Troy, he's taking us somewhere.
-Oh? -While some of us are grieving,
Others are just looking for their next tuition check.
Now, I'm putting my life on pause.
You left a stable job
So you can go into academic exile.
It was better than selling my soul for a tie.
Enough!
Enough is enough, everyone!
Your father wouldn't want this.
Actually, Darren, this is exactly what he would want.
He liked to pit us against each other.
It gave her something to look at during breakfast.
Your father was a very complicated man.
Oh.
Darren, what are you doing here?
I'm here because your father invited me.
Why would anyone invite their lawyer?
A family Christmas?
Perhaps because it was much more
More than just a lawyer to him
And you know it.
My brother is falling apart,
But let's not pretend he's wrong.
I'm here because I'm trying to help all of you.
Okay. Then maybe you'll try acting like we lost.
a human being, not a customer.
Mom? Mom, are you okay?
Mother.
I'm fine.
Uh, you don't look good.
Darren, she's ready for you now.
Well.
What's wrong, Mom?
Your father's death...
he...
It was not due to natural causes.
Hmm.
Are you really going to ask me questions?
Sure.
What is your opinion, Mr. Caldwell?
I am not a doctor.
But you were the last person to see him alive.
I don't know. Tired, I guess.
But I'll save you the trouble.
I didn't kill Harold.
I haven't asked you yet
Still?
She's just getting warmed up.
Let's try a different approach.
Who would benefit most from Harold's death?
Do you think someone killed him for money?
Money, fear, revenge.
Houses of this size have many reasons.
I have worked with this family for a long time.
And now they're dysfunctional?
Sure.
Defective?
You have no idea.
But...a murderer?
You met with Harold late last night.
What did they discuss?
-That's confidential. -Attorney-client privilege ends.
when the customer does it.
You know it.
What then happens to attorney privilege?
I don't want to tell you.
This is what we know.
A glass,
His partner was found on top of the body.
It was an expensive single malt whisky.
So it was probably a festive spill, not an accidental one.
Judging by the fact that one chair is closer
At the other people's table
It indicates that you were here for work.
And it was late on Christmas Eve,
So it was probably a personal matter.
Like a will?
I heard you storming out of here from upstairs,
who says whatever happened at this meeting,
You didn't like it.
You wouldn't have participated in the toast,
However, your glass was empty.
The only explanation is that you threw it away.
Before leaving the room.
How is it possible that you know that?
Because you're still alive.
Was he poisoned?
Where did you go after your meeting?
-Outside. -Alone?
What's the difference?
Do you really think I'm stupid enough?
Poison a drink so they'll serve it to me?
Or smart enough not to drink it when you were.
Are we finished?
Yeah.
You know, you really should work on your social skills.
You know, just a little bit.
If I had friends, I could ask them.
That was a joke.
Yeah.
I don't know what we're doing sitting here doing nothing.
We have no idea what's going on right now.
All I'm saying is that we shouldn't speculate.
Well, you say? We've only heard from you.
Uh, no, no, what I'm saying is...
Who does she think she is? A great detective?
As if I didn't even understand what this is.
I don't understand why you're not speaking.
For me right now. I have so many questions.
What did she say?
She...
He asked many questions.
If something were to happen to him,
So Darren had something to do with it!
-Uh, that's exactly right. -Mr. Sterling?
"Did they murder our father?" "Except you didn't."
You're in the family photo, right?
What really happened?
We are still investigating.
So why would you suggest that to my mother?
Look how upset she is!
All I did was point out some missing pieces.
-What pieces are missing? -Missing pieces?
I have no idea what you're talking about.
"But I need to know who..." "Hey! Hey! Okay! Everyone!"
Please, there's no need to shout at each other, okay?
Everyone will have their turn.
I'll get to you, Mrs. Sterling.
But first I'd like to talk to Michael.
I'd love to learn a few words. I have some questions.
Okay, guide me, assistant. In fact, you know what?
-I'll guide you. -Incredible.
Are you always this popular during Christmas?
Only when there is a corpse.
Is that really necessary?
You don't want to ask him that.
Oh, I want to ask you so many things.
I would like to ask you about your father's business.
-Why? -Excuse me?
Why do I have to answer your questions and not his?
This is because Vera is holding an official position.
as a representative of the Sheriff's department.
So a crossword columnist
Are you conducting murder investigations?
And does the Sheriff agree with this?
So you're saying this is murder?
Well, the police wouldn't be involved.
Otherwise, would they do it now?
Well, now Vera has the best.
The best observation skills I've ever seen.
Furthermore, it turns out she's also the Sheriff's deputy.
preferred researcher
So is it true?
Was Dad murdered?
Would that surprise you?
Did someone want him dead? No.
What was a relative?
That's...impossible.
What about enemies?
My father was a powerful man.
Powerful men don't make friends, they create friction.
And why didn't you join him?
Real estate didn't really excite me,
Do you know what I mean?
What makes your blood pump?
I'm in the hospitality business.
He owns a nightclub.
So velvet ropes and bottle service.
Instead of zoning permits and property taxes?
Better margins, better stories.
And fewer board meetings with your father.
Feel free to drop by sometime. I'll add you to the list.
And congressman, why don't you bring your mother?
We're more like a "Wheel of Fortune" family.
Oh. Do you still live with your mom?
And what about your wife?
Do you work in the hospitality sector?
She was a floral designer when we met.
Now we are partners in all the aspects that matter.
Except romantic.
Excuse me?
Her diamond ring.
It's an Asscher cut.
which is a favorite among the old rich and aristocrats.
I suppose it's a family heirloom.
which means she likes playing the role of Mrs. Sterling.
But when you arrived,
You took her hand and she didn't take it.
And then, during dinner, you didn't take away his chair.
Incidentally, she noticed.
-I warned you.
She wears Chanel perfume, but it doesn't leave a trace.
And you've mentioned it three times so far.
but never by his name.
Phew.
Have you finished analyzing my marriage?
That depends. Is there anything left to analyze?
-Oh, I should--
January! January!
Look at me. Look at me. Say something.
Where did he go?
Are you OK?
Let's take a look.
Does your head spin? Do you feel nauseous?
No. I'm dizzy.
I hit my head.
Although I'm fine.
Can you tell us what happened?
-Um... -Here.
Well, I went up to the room to look for something.
And then when I was going down...
Someone pushed me.
I'll check upstairs, see if anyone's lurking around.
Where was everyone else?
I was in the kitchen making coffee.
My mother and I were downstairs.
What's happening?
-Where were you? -Excuse me?
Someone pushed Jan down the stairs.
That?
-Jan, are you okay? -Yes, I scraped my knee.
-Oh, let me see. -Don't touch my wife!
Okay. Relax.
Mr. Caldwell, where were you?
Outside.
Just getting some fresh air.
Didn't you hear anything?
-No. -Raised voices? A fall?
No, I didn't do it.
There's nobody upstairs.
At least not for now.
Come on, we'll take you to the doctor.
Oh, no. No, Michael.
I'm not going to wait in the emergency room for 10 hours on Christmas.
Jan, let's go.
At least we'll get this knee checked out.
Ellen, do you have a first aid kit?
Yes, it's in the guest bathroom.
Uh-hmm. Come, come.
There it is. How so?
Hurts.
But I will live.
You fell quite a bit.
Yeah.
-Mrs. Sterling, I... -Oh.
You don't need to call me that.
Michael and I,
We're getting a divorce.
Well.
I'm sorry.
No. No. Don't be. I'm not.
Does anyone else in the family know?
Uh, not that I know of. Why?
Someone might have wanted to send a message.
Okay. Remind me never to miss Christmas.
In this house again.
Yes, it's exhausting to always be the outsider.
Tell me about it.
All the sweetness,
and the polite smiles,
and the holidays, and the dinners.
Please.
It's just a facade for a family.
who can't stand being in the same room together.
-Troy seems nice. -Yes. Well,
Or he is genuinely interested in learning
or has found the perfect getaway.
Either way, he's an intelligent man.
So you didn't see anything when you fell?
Think about it carefully, please.
I, uh...
I felt a push
and...
The next thing I knew,
I was at the bottom of the stairs.
Thanks for the chat.
You are officially discharged.
-She will live. -Well...
-Jan. -Jan. Hello.
-Michael, are you okay? -Fine.
There's no fracture. Just a little swelling.
-Okay. -Oh, thank God.
Troy is not here.
He's upstairs.
He said he needed some peace and quiet.
-Oh, should I go look for him? -No.
-Yes, I'm fine. -No, I'm leaving.
You should stay together.
Statistically speaking, fewer people fall down the stairs.
when they are not in them.
That?
-Hmm. -Then,
What does your instinct tell you?
No signs of chafing.
Still dusty.
I suppose the maid took Christmas off.
Maybe.
How far do you think it fell?
The landing consists of only nine steps.
It couldn't have fallen very far.
Her shoes.
Oh, I couldn't see her shoes properly.
They were still standing.
Does that mean anything?
I'm not sure yet.
Forward.
Oh.
I didn't think you'd get this far.
I don't usually climb stairs for no reason.
or a good book.
-Well, you found both. -Yes, you didn't seem...
too nervous downstairs
If I left every time a Sterling self-destructed,
I would need a revolving door.
No, I came here to think...
That's all about what happened.
I never really said I was sorry for what happened.
You know, the people at the bottom see... income.
A food voucher.
And I see a man who taught me how to throw a ball.
So forgive me if Jan's hysteria isn't really my priority.
Even if Harold had a soft spot for her for some reason.
Do you mind if I ask where you were?
When did your father die?
I was in the library. I couldn't sleep.
Any witnesses?
Plenty.
If we count the greatest literary minds
of the last century.
I'd like to ask about your brother's club.
-Carousel. -More specifically
your father's financial interest in it.
It was Harold's money that got it started.
But when Carousel wasn't making a profit fast enough,
Michael partnered with other associates.
A different kind of family, let's say.
Organized crime?
Harold was not happy.
He said he would go public if Michael didn't buy it.
-For New Year's. -A revelation like that.
-It would ruin the business. -And the marriage.
There will be no trophy handcuffs for second place.
So we have some suspicious characters,
a ticking clock,
and a guy with a big mouth.
As I said.
Self-destruction.
And are you sure you didn't hear anything when Jan fell?
I don't feel it.
What are you listening to?
It's a lo-fi studio mix.
-Can I?-Uh-hmm.
I like it.
I'm sure it's simply great.
But we have a killer to catch, so...
One, echo.
The answer to your riddle is an echo.
-Troy. -Huh?
You're thinking about something.
It could be nothing.
Okay, what is it?
It could be something.
Well. You know, I skipped breakfast because of this.
Harold did it too.
Okay. That's not fair.
You'd better call me to tell me there's a puzzle.
-Waiting in my inbox. -You'll receive it.
I was hoping you could do me a favor.
Have you heard of a nightclub in town called Carousel?
Are you kidding?
Federal authorities have been investigating.
-That place for months. -Really?
Chuck has been working on an exhibition.
Apparently, some very bad people
He invested a lot of money in it.
Wait.
Are these the Sterlings?
I can't say
So you'll check it?
Am I creating a puzzle for myself?
Yes, you're facing a puzzle.
Give me a minute.
Aconite.
Interesting.
Hello.
Hmm.
Hmm, I wonder what he has to say.
I hope I'm not intruding.
No, dear. No.
-Any news?-No.
She hoped she could borrow her daughter for a moment.
Can it wait?
I am taking care of my mother.
I'm fine.
I'm just tired.
I want to be close
In case you need anything.
So what's up?
You had a seat in your father's company.
Even so, you rejected it.
Not everyone dreams of working for their father.
Not everyone leaves a company
with his name on the door.
Harold didn't exactly make room on the table.
He did...
demands,
criticisms,
and ultimatums.
Real estate law was a way for me
Stay close without getting burned.
What is your relationship with Mr. Caldwell?
Cordial.
Cordially distant or cordially adversarial?
He was jealous.
Mother, please.
She deserves the truth.
You should be resting.
Darren always thought Harold saw something.
special in him.
Something like a surrogate son.
And then Catherine...
It started making waves.
He saw her as a threat.
And Darren didn't like threats.
Harold was her only real connection to power.
And now the next in line were the children.
I need to go check something.
Thank you for your time.
Oh, and I'm sorry for, you know.
-Guilty. -In something?
Suspect.
Guilty,
red herring.
Hey, would you mind sharing it?
It's a puzzle.
Yes. Yes, it is.
No. This is it.
Would you give this to my editor?
Uh, sure.
So, is there anything new in the research?
I spoke with Ellen and Catherine.
Oh, you've got something.
I asked my editor at the Chronicle
To see if it can dig up some dirt
at Michael's club.
AND?
The FBI detected it last year.
for suspicious activity.
Anything about Michael's mysterious business partners?
He thought it might be related to organized crime.
We know that Harold invested.
He discovered who else was involved and wanted out.
He gave Michael an ultimatum: buy his share...
or I would make it public.
That would have destroyed the club.
And marriage.
Well, you don't seem that surprised.
For a family full of secrets,
They're not very good at keeping them.
Well, maybe you'd like to take a look at this then.
I didn't think it was their kind of place.
Me neither.
Do you think his bookworm act is appealing?
Is he hiding something?
Elegant?
Vera Vexley, you're not softening up to him, are you?
No. I was just making an observation.
That's all.
Don't forget to send it.
Yes, ma'am.
Oh.
There you are.
This is where Dad keeps the good things.
Hmm.
Uh, there she is.
Could you talk for a moment?
It doesn't look like we're going anywhere.
Only.
I'll be fine.
Well.
I'll be right back.
I can't wait to hear what an interesting topic...
It is more important that I take care of my injured wife.
Their divorce.
Turn from the puzzle pages to page six now?
She's not one to chat about unimportant things, is she?
I'm afraid not.
Yeah.
Jan and I separated.
And how do you know that?
Oh, she lives for this.
And most importantly: Did your father know?
Of course. Blame me.
So who will keep the club?
She can have it
Anyway, it's going to fall apart.
What do their investors think about this?
What do you want to ask me, Vera?
Who would you ask to pay the bill?
I know he wasn't your father.
And I doubt that your brother is that liquid.
So who do you owe?
You know nothing
I know enough to recognize when someone
It's far beyond his capabilities.
I think you're surrounded by people.
who have a lot to lose.
Perhaps they are getting desperate.
Perhaps you're getting desperate.
Either way, that inheritance money
I'd definitely dig you up.
So you think I'm behind my own father's death?
And what about the attack on my wife?
Not necessarily.
But I wonder who else you've brought.
-In this mess. -How dare you!
Hey, just tell him what he needs to know.
Do you want me to tell you something?
Okay. Call my lawyer.
You know I can call your lawyer, Michael.
-Yes? -I really could.
But I suppose you and I know how that would turn out.
And I don't think your so-called friends
I would be too excited.
That's what I thought.
Excuse me.
What's going on?
We've been going back and forth for hours.
Okay. I know this must be frustrating for all of you.
But I would like to ask for a little more time.
Time? Time for what?
We don't even know what you were doing!
We are investigating the death of your father.
In addition to the attack on Mrs. Sterling.
Yes, well, we'll see.
what your senior officers
I have something to say about this.
-Ma'am? -I'm not a child.
"Don't talk to me like that." "Ma'am!"
-Incredible. -Look, I...
We don't even know what you're doing.
-Madam.-Thank you.
What are you doing here?
Yes, indeed.
But I know my family.
They're not just going to admit they did it.
...patience from all of you.
And soon all this will be resolved.
Did you hang out at the Carousel?
-Ma'am. -Incredible.
Troy,
If you're hiding something...
...the death of your father,
as well as the attack on Mrs. Sterling.
No, I...
I hated the fact that Harold was paying for my education.
And then, from time to time, he would make some changes.
You know?
I'm not going to lie. I had a reason.
Just like everyone else in this room.
Am I under arrest, congressman?
Perhaps even more.
Let's see what he has to say about the matter.
Why don't you let Vera do her job?
Your job?
His job is to write jigsaw puzzles for the newspaper.
Well.
I'd like to see you actually try to solve one.
The point is that she's a guest.
who can be uninvited just as easily.
"I built it with my own hands,
But that's not what I intended.
I thought I could escape it,
But now I'm the one trapped in it."
Someone?
A lie.
Yeah.
Just give me time.
I'll let you know when I need you.
-Okay. That's all. -What's wrong with him?
Don't worry. I'll take care of it.
Darren was on the porch.
Troy was in the library.
Ellen was getting ready to go to bed.
Catherine was in her bedroom.
Hmm.
Do you have anything?
Be.
I asked you if you found anything.
I'm just trying to put the puzzle pieces together.
You sure don't seem like a happy family.
More like a survival game.
Troy?
Harold Sterling was murdered by someone in this house.
Troy lives in this house.
He does, but, you know, you...
No, I don't know.
You like him.
Just because you like someone doesn't make them innocent.
Okay. I want to make sure you see things clearly.
My vision is fine.
Each of them is hiding something.
The more they try to cover it up,
The clearer it becomes.
Is that really necessary?
Christmas music?
Our father lies dead upstairs, so no.
I'm really not in the mood for dancing sugar fairies.
Nothing represents holiday homicide like Tchaikovsky.
What's wrong with this family?
Oh, Michael, please.
-Everyone's upset. -Are they?
Because Catherine is here pretending that this is...
some twisted Christmas party,
And Troy is going to get a PhD in presumption.
No, I'm just trying not to add anything.
to the shrill chorus.
I apparently failed.
Oh, well, God forbid.
Someone tries to break the tension.
Sorry, I didn't bring a black veil or a pipe organ.
Perhaps you could tone it down a bit, Catherine.
It's not all about acting.
Hmm. Coming from man.
who pretended to love Dad for 15 years
-Just to be included in the will. -Really?
Is this what you want to do? Do you want to do it now?
-Hey! -Actually.
Enough! All of you!
In the 19th century, mass printing
It led to the emergence of illustrated magazines and storybooks.
who often use visual puzzles
Designed to take advantage of the environment.
Find the difference.
I think it's the same. No...
Almost.
This is exactly what your father didn't want.
How could any of us know what he wanted?
There was...
There were some things I couldn't tell you.
How to change your will?
-Wait, what? -What?
Do you want to change your will?
She was weighing her options.
And now he's dead. Hmm.
Well, things got dark quickly.
Is that why I wanted you here?
Who is he cutting?
I am not free to say so.
What are you not telling us?
Well, I know he wasn't going to leave me out.
because I have been with him more than any of you.
Seriously, what was going to change?
I told you. That's confidential.
-Miguel!
Good heavens! They don't need a detective.
They need a referee.
Guys!
What's going on here?
Can we talk?
Of course.
Um, I'll stay here and take care of the cattle.
to avoid getting too noisy.
I apologize.
It seems that self-control is not a sterling virtue.
What about those who aren't Sterlings?
That?
You know what I'm talking about.
Slide the panel to open it.
Five-six-three-one.
How did you know?
You said earlier that the children were next in line.
Normally, that would be you.
The spouse.
So, something must have happened.
so that you are removed from the equation.
Something a man like Harold Sterling
I would find it unforgivable.
You should know that he knows.
That?
Troy?
What? I never told him.
There was an envelope on his desk.
from the genealogy company.
Since I've been here, he has never mentioned Harold.
like his father.
Just by his name.
He also works part-time at his brother's club.
And that's not something a child receiving a trust fund would do.
Unless he thought that trust was running out.
His father was an employee of Harold.
It doesn't matter who it was.
He did not know that Troy was his.
But Harold knew it.
Harold caught us.
What did he do?
Harold was pragmatic.
He didn't want to make a scene.
He fired the employee, of course.
And then he tried with me.
I knew that divorce wouldn't help.
It would be a public spectacle.
I would be ruined.
Your company,
his legacy.
Harold was not willing to allow that to happen.
And Troy?
Harold treated him as if he were his own.
And what about his share of the will?
Did he even have one?
I threatened to tell the truth if Harold refused.
So none of the children knew?
No.
Darren was the only one who knew.
He managed the finances, the trust.
He had access to everything.
Hmm.
Does Troy really know?
I'm sure of it.
Don't you think so...?
Didn't you know about the promise you made to Harold?
Troy is not a murderer.
But then, you don't need me.
To tell you that, do you do it?
You have a connection, right?
Glad to hear it.
He needs someone who sees him, who really sees him.
Miguel?
Yes, Mom?
Had you seen your brother?
Upper floor.
Excuse me.
I would like to speak with him personally.
Of course.
Shirley Temple for the puzzle editor?
I'm fine.
Well.
You must think we're a pathetic bunch, huh?
Why do you say that?
I mean, look at us.
I believe you are a family that has suffered a great tragedy.
Yeah.
I'd love to see what my father would say about all this.
I'm not entirely sure I understand.
My father used to write a diary when he was younger.
I literally recorded everything.
Business meetings, family outings,
blah, blah, blah.
It would be hilarious to see, huh?
How would you describe your own death?
"Final entry.
I can't say I didn't see it coming.
Do you know if he still has them?
His diaries?
I don't know. Why?
Do you mind if I join you?
Mmm. Sure.
I just spoke to my mom.
I understand.
Family doesn't always feel like family,
Especially when things are so messy.
I think that always, you know,
As if I were a stranger looking from the outside.
He just never quite fit in.
It's difficult when...
Everything you're supposed to have feels...
mistaken.
It's all a lie.
Our family.
Everything I thought I was.
Sometimes, the truth shows us where we belong.
Even if we don't want to see it.
Do you always speak in riddles?
Only when I try to get to the heart of things.
Good,
I guess we'll have to work all this out together.
And if only we could have known what Harold was thinking.
Yeah.
If only.
Where are they?
-What's wrong? -I don't know.
My head.
Michael, do you know who did this to you?
-No. -What happened?
Someone hit him on the head.
Miguel? Miguel, can you hear me?
Did you see who did this to you?
Is there anything we can do?
-I'm going to call an ambulance. -Okay.
Miguel? Miguel, stay with me! Hey!
What is everything...?
Miguel?
He reached the door and collapsed.
The ambulance will take at least 30 minutes to arrive.
Don't they know who owns this house?
It doesn't matter.
It matters. I'll call you.
What is all this noise?
Miguel! Oh my God!
Michael, are you okay?
Michael, talk to me. Are you hurt?
-What happened? -I don't know.
Hey, could you come with me for a second?
-Sure. -Relax.
Alright.
Okay. Please tell me you're close to solving this case.
Because the Sterlings are dropping like flies.
Actually, I had a question about your father.
Harold.
Ah.
Michael mentioned that he kept diaries.
And I've turned his whole office upside down.
And I've looked through this library
and I can't find them anywhere.
Actually?
Didn't you happen to know...?
I've already looked at everything here.
-Intelligent. -Oh, yes.
He had a knack for hiding things and tricks and stuff like that.
You know, he used to do your jigsaw puzzles every morning.
-Really? -Oh, yes.
We used to think he was obsessed with his stock portfolio.
or the latest mergers, but no,
It was called "Vera Vexley's Puzzles".
Here. Will that help?
It's time to connect the dots.
How is he?
Uh, he took quite a hard hit,
But it doesn't look like a concussion.
It wouldn't hurt for the paramedics to take a look.
Darren, I'd like to talk to you alone for a moment.
So that?
I knew it.
Please?
Yeah.
Feel.
I will remain standing. Thank you.
No, sit down.
Well.
That?
I need to see the will.
No, it's not going to happen.
I can obtain a court order or a subpoena.
Go ahead, I'm not going to just give it to you.
Do you recognize that document?
This could be critical to this investigation, right?
Then it shouldn't be too difficult to obtain a court order.
Or you can wait until the will is processed.
We don't have that time, and you know it.
That's not my problem.
One Sterling is dead and two others have been injured.
Once again, that's not...
It's not your problem. I know.
How long have you been in a relationship with Jan?
How did you know?
The way she looked at you,
The way your husband distrusted you.
The two glasses by the porch.
after sharing a kiss against the window.
You didn't want to arouse suspicion,
So you went through the back...
And I dropped this, by the way.
And you smell like Chanel perfume.
Don't worry.
I'm a consulting detective, not the morality police.
Are we finished?
Almost.
Right here.
-They're here. -Oh.
Is he going to the hospital?
That may not be necessary, ma'am.
Congressman, a word?
Okay. Take a deep breath.
Pleasant and easy.
-Okay. -Are you sure?
Okay. Now you're going to follow my finger.
Okay? Ready?
"Oh, oh, oh! What is this?" "Mr. Caldwell..."
I knew it! I knew he'd done it!
Wow. What... what's going on?
You have the right to remain silent.
Everything you say can and will be used against you.
-In a court of law. -Okay. I know my rights.
You have the right to a lawyer.
If you cannot afford a lawyer,
You will be provided with one.
You'd better hope this continues.
Okay. Okay.
I'm sure this isn't what anyone expected at Christmas.
I can't believe it was Darren.
He will have a fair trial like everyone else.
Please!
You wouldn't risk arrest unless you were sure.
So, what do you have?
He had no alibi for Harold's murder.
And what about Jan and Michael?
Would he have attacked them too?
The probability of having two assassins
It's very low at Christmas dinner.
He is stable.
Make sure he gets enough rest and...
-You need to avoid alcohol. -Hmm.
-What? -Good luck with that.
-Let's go. -Merry Christmas.
Merry christmas.
Merry christmas.
This is all very good.
But even so, it is mostly circumstantial.
You wouldn't arrest someone just for that.
What are you not telling us?
I probably shouldn't tell you this.
But it's going to be on Discovery anyway.
This is what we know.
Harold kept diaries for most of his life.
He detailed his work extensively.
and all those he met.
You told me.
It's true.
I haven't read them all yet,
But I have read the last two entries.
AND?
And he explained
A terrible argument with Mr. Caldwell.
It appears that Mr. Sterling was reviewing his will.
and left Mr. Caldwell out.
Given his years of loyalty,
Mr. Caldwell believed he deserved something.
But why would he attack Michael?
And why would he come after me?
Mr. Caldwell believed it was Michael
who convinced Harold to leave him out of the will.
-No. -And as for you...
Hmm.
...maybe he was the jealous type.
But why would you need the diaries?
Harold wrote everything down.
Business meetings, family trips.
If Darren confronted him, it would most likely be there.
So what do we do now?
Nothing. In the next few days,
Deputy Neal will bring them all to the station.
for their official statement.
Well, thanks for everything.
I'm sure this isn't the way.
You wanted to spend your Christmas.
Oh, I had a great time.
And I'm happy to have been able to give you some closure.
I'll go upstairs and pack.
I will help you.
Are you sure you won't stay for dinner?
Consulting detectives do not receive risk pay.
Fun.
You know, it's going to be boring not having you around.
Could you give me your email address?
and I could send you some puzzles.
I suppose I couldn't...
Perhaps we'll meet again?
Sometimes.
At the Rialto they are performing "It's a Wonderful Life!"
-I could give you a ride. -Could you give me a ride?
I said we don't receive risk pay, but we do get paid.
Another joke.
Yeah.
Okay, so it's a date.
-Thank you.-Ah.
Vera, II era--
Looking for a midnight snack?
What are you doing here?
I wonder what you're doing
snooping around your father-in-law's office.
I was just...
Looking for memories for Michael.
This must be a difficult time for you, Mrs. Sterling.
Is.
No!
Jan Sterling, you are under arrest.
Oh!
Hmm.
Hmm.
This is what we know.
The autopsy results will be available in the coming days.
And I'm sure we'll find aconite in your system.
-What is it? -Poison
derived from aconite.
A highly toxic plant that you have
growing up next to your viewpoint.
Any former floral designer
with experience in horticulture
I would know its uses.
She should have picked the flowers.
sometime after their arrival.
So, Jan knew that Michael had spoken to our father.
about their impending divorce?
And she also knew that Harold was going to announce
a change in his will, leaving her out.
Why would he try to kill Michael?
As Michael's widow,
She would receive her share of the inheritance
Even if she herself was removed from the will.
Exactly. I was afraid the New Testament would prevail.
I knew she was capable of doing some pretty twisted things,
But... not this.
So...
Who tried to kill her?
That's what initially puzzled me.
When I first examined the stairs,
There were no signs of a struggle,
She had no chafing marks and still had her shoes on.
So who pushed her down the stairs?
Nobody.
Jan faked his fall.
She thought that by being the next victim,
She wanted to shift the blame from herself, and she was right.
So when did you know Darren was innocent?
The first column of any logic puzzle is the motif.
Darren didn't have any.
You had every reason to be angry with Harold, you know?
You served him faithfully for many years.
But Harold Sterling did not die in a fit of rage.
He was killed in a meticulously planned assassination.
Furthermore, with the death of Mr. Sterling,
It was less likely that Darren would get anything.
When did you tell Darren your plan?
When I invited him to the office.
And I accepted immediately.
I had to completely convince Jan.
that we had our man.
Okay. So how did you know?
Would Jan go to get the diaries?
Because they were the only thing that could trip her up.
I had a strong suspicion that Jan had gone to blackmail Harold.
That's why she was having an affair with Darren.
to get dirty information about Harold.
I'm sorry.
Now, if I was wrong,
The newspapers wouldn't have made any difference.
But he was right,
The diaries would have contained a record
of exactly what I was trying to do.
That's why I had to find them.
-Yes. -Oh,
So where exactly are these diaries?
Oh, Harold hadn't actually kept a diary for years.
This was evident from the amount of dust they had.
But Jan didn't know that.
The important thing was that she thought she did it.
Now, I'm sure you have many more questions,
But you could use your privacy.
You have a lot to discuss.
Well, actually we've already discussed this quite a bit.
And considering that the three
control the assets in equal measures,
We have decided to divide the assets.
An equitable division.
Something we could all be happy about.
That's a good idea.
Now, if you'll excuse me.
My editor will be furious
If I don't finish the puzzle tomorrow.
Come here.
Merry Christmas, Mom.
Welcome to the family, Darren.
-Hugs. -That was incredible.
Yeah.
"This is what we know."
It was nice having you around.
I don't get to test my skills every day.
for a Christmas mystery.
Hey, I'm serious.
It was nice having you around.
You could always email me for those puzzles, you know?
I'll take you up on that.
We're going to print in an hour. What's my lead story?
"Real estate tycoon found dead on Christmas Day."
"Found dead?" You say it as if
The guy died in his sleep.
How about "murdered"?
-Done. -I got an interview.
with the congressman who broke the case.
Ah, the great minds of law enforcement.
-To the rescue again. -Sidebar, A2.
Sidebar, A5.
They're not that great
-Has anyone seen...? -Handbag. Side pocket.
-How did you do it...? -I saw you put it there.
-When did you get in? -Ugh. The deadline is almost here.
-Where's my crossword puzzle? -The crossword puzzle is in your inbox.
And my New Year's puzzle?
I thought you'd want to be the first to read it.
Happy new year.
Happy New Year, Vera.
"This is what we know."
A man in his 60s was found dead in his bed
in a house with his wife,
three adult children,
a sister-in-law and a lawyer,
They all have an alibi for the moment of death.
Did you know that his will had recently been changed?
and you suspect something's fishy. Now..."
"It's time to connect the dots."