ReMastered: Tricky Dick & The Man in Black (2018) Movie Script
[overlapping songs]
[crowd shouting]
[birds twittering]
[rooster crows]
[muted cheering]
[Johnny Cash] I thank God for all
the freedoms we've got in this country.
-I cherish them.
-[cheering continues]
Even the rights to burn the flag,
you know, I'm proud of those rights.
-[crowd shouting, booing]
-But I'll tell you what,
we've also got--
Let me tell you something. Shh.
We've also got a right to bear arms,
and if you burn my flag, I'll shoot you.
-[crowd cheering]
-[Cash playing guitar]
But I'll shoot you with a lot of love,
like a good American.
[wild cheering]
[chanting indistinctly]
[Mark Stielper] In the '60s and '70s,
America was torn apart
around issues of race, war, peace,
and a battle for the heart and soul of
what it meant to be an American patriot.
[Nixon] We will determine
what kind of nation America will be.
[Cash] It's the prettiest country
in the world that we've got.
-There ain't nothing like it anywhere.
-[applause]
Mr. Nixon said Johnny Cash speaks
to all America.
[Aram Bakshian] He understood
Johnny Cash's symbolic importance.
[Nixon speaking on tape]
Country music is the Johnny Cash crowd.
-[aide] It gets you elected.
-[Nixon] Yeah. You know, it's Southern.
[Pat Buchanan] Nixon wanted to identify
with Middle America,
and Johnny Cash was as Middle America
as you can get.
[Joanne Cash] We got a phone call from
the White House. It was President Nixon.
He had invited Johnny to sing
and do a concert there.
[Stielper] President Nixon
requested that John sing
redneck country music songs,
affiliating country music
with the president's cause,
and the result was just catastrophic.
How could the president
be so mean-spirited?
Johnny was very, very conflicted.
It was a defining moment for him.
[announcer]
Ladies and gentlemen, Johnny Cash!
[cheers and applause]
Thank you very much.
[Stielper] Who was going to show up
to the White House?
Johnny Cash of "Folsom Prison Blues,"
"The Rebel"...
So, what do you want to hear?
[Stielper] ...the guy who was photographed
flippin' off the man,
or the God-fearing family man
with a baby on the way,
gospel-singing Johnny Cash.
How do you be both?
What did Johnny Cash stand for?
Carl Perkins wrote a song
that tells about the reason for it all.
It takes us back home and again,
tells it like it was
when I was a little-bitty kid
and we gathered around the piano,
and me and little brother would join in
and Mama'd sing tenor and Daddy sang bass.
[band playing]
I remember when I was a lad
Times were hard and things were bad...
Johnny was born in Kingsland,
in south Arkansas.
Just poor people
That's all we were
Trying to make a living
Out of black land dirt
We'd get together
In a family circle singing loud...
When my family came to Dyess,
Johnny was three years old.
Singin' seems to help a troubled soul
One of these days and it won't be long
I'll rejoin them in a song
I'm gonna join the family circle
At the Throne
[Cash]
Now each one of these houses had a barn,
a chicken house, and a smoke-house
where the farmers raised their own hogs
and cured their meat.
And they had a mule
and 20 acres of land here.
It was a beautiful little place.
The Dyess, Arkansas experience
was part ofFDR's New Deal.
They moved people from terrible situations
where they had no hope, no future,
and gave them an opportunity.
My clothes may be ragged
And my shoes may be worn
But I've been a wealthy boy
Since I've been born...
We were a happy family.
We didn't know we were poor.
We always had plenty to eat
and plenty of clothes.
We were happy to be part
of the American dream.
[Joanne] Our family would start the day
in the cotton fields,
singing old church hymns andsongs
that we all knew, we'd sing together.
Gospel songs or country songs
because it's about our life with the Lord.
Johnny's grandfather was
a hellfire preacher.
He had preacher grandparents
on multiple lines of his family tree.
They spoke of hell and damnation,
and what it was like if you did not live
the right kind of a life.
John was a dyed-in-the-wool
conservative person
because his parents were.
He was from that part of Arkansas.
I don't remember anybody in our family
criticizing the government.
We were patriotic
no matter who the president was.
We loved to see the American flag flown.
My daddy flew it every day
until the day he died.
Johnny loved America.
He believed that you should
support your government
and support the president.
[Joanne] He was one of the most patriotic
men I've ever known.
In 1968, the idea of patriotism itself
became controversial.
[sirens blaring]
[Nixon] As we look at America, we see
cities enveloped in smoke and flames.
We hear sirens in the night.
We see Americans dying
on distant battlefields abroad.
[machine gun fire]
We see Americans hating each other,
fighting each other,
killing each other at home.
It was a period where
lots of stuff came to a boil
at the same time.
We not only have a right to be free,
we have a duty to be free.
[Bakshian]
There were civil rights protests.
There was this unpopular war.
We will prevail in Vietnam
over the Communist aggressor!
The country split into what has
come to be called hawks and doves.
Doves wanted to end the war.
Hawks wanted to pursue the war.
-[man] What do you want?
-[all] Peace!
-[man] When do we get it?
-[all] Now!
And these two sides, both Americans,
both claiming to be patriots,
went to war with each other.
[Bakshian] It was the perfect storm,
and Nixon understood that.
And I pledge to you tonight
that the firstpriority
foreign policy objective
of our next administration
will be to bring an honorable end
to the war in Vietnam.
[crowd cheering]
Nixon lost the 1960 presidential election
to Kennedy,
and he was traumatized by that defeat.
In 1968, he was running for president
in a desperate attempt
to resurrect his career.
The time has come for honest government
in the United States of America!
[crowd cheering]
-Thank you!
-Thank you, girls.
My father was never afraid
to stand up for someone in need.
And he would always put himself
in a position to help those if he could.
It was that simplicity that was within
the heart of the man.
It wasn't the complications of politics.
[fans murmuring]
[Cash] Thank you.
[John Carter] I think that empathy
goes back to the loss of his brother.
[Cash playing slow guitar]
Beside a singin' mountain stream...
Growing up,
my father and his brother, Jack,
were dearest of friends.
Jack was a man of God at 14 years old.
He studied the Bible all the time.
He knew in his heart
that he was going to be a pastor.
They were so inseparable.
But flesh and blood
Needs flesh and blood
And you are what I need
On Saturdays, Johnny,
Jack, and my other brothers,
all of us, would do odd jobs
to help Mama with the groceries.
In May of 1944,
Jack was sawing some fence post.
As he was pushing the fence post
into the saw,
it jerked... and jerked him into the saw.
It was beyond horrible.
I remember Johnny crying
and holding his hand,
saying, "Somebody do something!"
It was as bad as you can imagine.
The next day after the funeral,
we were all back
in the cotton fields, working.
I can't even describe the emptiness
and the hurt.
[Stielper] Ray and Carrie,
Johnny's mother and father,
and 12-year-old Johnny
are the ones
that had to shoulder that burden.
It was back-breaking.
They were working every day
and not getting anywhere.
Ray Cash, who had thought
Dyess was his promised land,
found that it wasn't.
Jack was going to be a preacher.
He was going to be the son of Dyess
that made it.
Johnny was a very sensitive young man.
There was not room for sensitivity.
There was not room for dreamers
in Dyess, Arkansas in the 1940s.
Ray became so bitter, he resented his son.
He would look at Johnny and he would say,
"You weren't the right son.
You should've died."
Johnny Cash grew up feeling unworthy
of being himself.
He felt that he would nevermeasure up
to what his father wanted him to be.
Something happened within my dad,
and there was this deep wound
that was placed there,
this hollow well.
There was also a drive that was installed,
and all these different faces
that were Johnny Cash were developed
through that great loss at an early age.
[indistinct chatter]
A prison's a prison.
And that's all it is.
[June] I'm sure you'll enjoy him
this afternoon.
He seems to have a lot of things
in common with you, Mr. Johnny Cash!
[crowd cheering]
[John Carter] My father knew
what it was like to suffer.
He knew what it was like to feel lost.
And so, he could connect
with other people's suffering.
He sang for those who needed something
to believe in and needed to be lifted up.
[Stielper] In January of 1968,
Johnny Cash went to Folsom Prison
and performed for the inmates.
I hear the train a comin'
It's rollin' 'round the bend
And I ain't seen the sunshine
Since I don't know when
I'm stuck in Folsom Prison
And time keeps draggin' on
-[crowd cheers]
-Yeah!
[Stielper]
He looked on some of those guys in there,
looked on the desperation in their eyes,
and he thought,
"There but for the grace of God goes me.
I made some stumbles in my life.
That could've been me."
But I shot a man in Reno
Just to watch him die...
He brought recording equipment
because he wanted people to hear
the rawness of what it was like
to perform for these men.
John always related to prisoners,
amongst others that had drug troubles.
My father was full of love.
He was full of faith. He worked hard.
He was self-made.
But he was also a man who
hit hard rock bottom quite a few times.
Whether it's alcohol, drugs, whatever
it is that changes your personality,
your demeanor, your physical look,
and he went through all of this.
[John Carter] He could be a liar.
He struggled. He made mistakes.
He was a different man
when he was in that mode.
My father had never been an inmate,
but they accepted him as one of their own.
He was a champion of theunderdog
and the downtrodden.
[interviewer]
Do you have political leanings?
No, not all that much.
If somebody says,
"I'm not my brother's keeper,"
he's wrong 'cause he is.
He is his brother's keeper.
[Stielper] In May 1968,
Johnny Cash At Folsom Prison is released.
"Folsom Prison Blues" gets to number one.
He is viewed as Johnny Cash, this rebel.
And that appealed to a broad audience.
[John Carter]
People responded to that rebel identity,
but what was amazing is
they'd think they knew him,
and then he'd change.
The Album of the Year,
Johnny Cash, At Folsom Prison!
He had a lot of songs
that he would cut as a country song,
and it would spill over
into the pop charts.
I think that was why he was so successful.
There was no limit
to who wanted to listen to Johnny Cash.
[Stielper]
By the late '60s, Johnny's star rises,
as does Mr. Nixon's.
He wins the presidency in 1968.
Having lost a close one eight years ago
and having won a close one this year,
I can say this...
winning's a lot more fun!
[laughing]
But we won narrowly,
we won with 43% of the vote.
I, Richard Milhous Nixon,
do solemnly swear...
That you will faithfully
execute the office...
That I will faithfully...
The Southern strategy that Nixon used
to win the 1968 presidential election
has been used by every Republican
presidential candidate since.
[excited chatter]
The Southern strategy sends out
dog whistles to racists
and dog whistles to conservatives,
using key phrases like
"the silent majority."
The Southern strategy basically was
to hold the South,
bringing those people
into the Nixon Coalition.
The essence was traditional conservatives
and law and order,
supporting Americans in Vietnam,
standing up against the demonstrators
who were against the war,
and basically representing the values
and beliefs of Middle America
against the rising social and cultural
revolution in the country.
The peace of the world will depend
not just on America's military might,
which is the greatest in the world,
but it's going to depend on our character,
our love of our country,
our willingness to not only wear the flag
but stand up for the flag,
and country music does that.
[Buchanan]
Throughout Nixon's entire presidency,
well, even into his second term,
he attempted to cultivate the support
of the South.
[all] God bless America
My home sweet home
[crowd cheering]
[intro music plays]
Hello, I'm Johnny Cash.
[cheering]
[Stielper] In 1969, The Johnny Cash Show
first aired on national TV.
Oh, hi, there!
It was a variety entertainment show,
and it was unlike anything
anyone had ever seen.
Certainly unlike anything that anybody
had ever seen in country music.
He healed the leper and the lame...
Mm-hmm.
[Stielper] He sings gospel songs.
Make welcome my brother, Tommy Cash.
Hey, Tommy! Welcome!
He'd say do what you do, do well, boy!
Do what you do, do well!
[Stielper]
It was a family affair all around.
You say you're lookin' for someone
Who's never weak
But always strong...
He puts on a special segment on every show
called "Ride This Train."
Ride this train with me
to San Antonio, Texas;
Springfield, Missouri;
Boise, Idaho.
It's a quintessentially
American experience.
And he puts people on TV
that nobody's ever seen before,
but it's not just country people.
Please make welcome Ms. Joni Mitchell.
Rows and flows of angel hair...
[Stielper] Bob Dylan...
Love is all there is
It makes the world go 'round...
He puts on Pete Seeger.
-That's nice. [chuckles]
-[applause]
That's nice.
[Stielper] These were all leaders
of the anti-war movement.
The people that I'm contracted with
said that,
"How dare you,
supposedly such a good American,
have a Communist like Pete Seeger
on your TV show?"
The Pete Seeger I know
and the Pete Seeger that June and I
have come to love is,
I'd say, one of the best Americans
and patriots I've ever known.
But Pete Seeger is not coming on there
and singing
"Where Have All the Flowers Gone?"
This is a non-political venue.
[John Carter] My father did not adhere
to any certain party.
A Republican would claim him
and also a Democrat would,
and my father wouldn't argue either point.
I keep my eyes wide open all the time
John walked a political line.
Iwalk the line
Yes, he tried. He tried to walk the line.
People will say,
"Oh, he tried to have it both ways."
Because you're mine
I walk the line...
This was in the midst of
tremendous social turmoil.
Johnny Cash doesn't get involved in that.
He is not political.
He does not take a stand.
[applause]
I thank you very much.
While you could be neutral
in the middle of those polarities,
culturally and politically,
it was difficult.
And the more time went by,
the harder it was to be neutral.
[chanting] Peace over war! Peace over war!
Peace over war! Peace over war!
[Buchanan] In the Fall of '69,
a huge demonstration was planned
to bring out hundreds of thousands
of people
to break the Nixon presidency on Vietnam.
We have been too often disappointed
by the optimism of the American leaders,
both in Vietnam and Washington,
to have faith any longer...
When parts of the news media
projected the failures of US policy,
it began to create a gap
between what the government was telling us
and what the news media started to report.
In the midst of this war,
we began to understand
that we were being lied to,
and that further polarized society.
[Nixon] The radical fuel that you seeon
your television screens night after night,
they're not a majority of
American youth today
and they will not be the leaders
of America tomorrow.
[cheering]
Nixon was paranoid about
these antiwar protesters,
most of whom were young.
[crowd] One, two, three, four,
Tricky Dick passed a law!
He used to say to me sometimes,
"What is it with these young people?
What don't they understand?"
We felt that we were being patriotic.
He wanted them to look shameful.
We're in the middle of a revolution.
So, I told the president,
"If we don't stand up here,
your presidency is going to be broken."
Tonight I want to talk to you on a subject
of deep concern to all Americans,
the war in Vietnam.
The American people are entitled
to know the truth...
but as President of the United States,
I would be untrue to my oath of office
if I allowed the policy of this nation
to be dictated by the minority
mounting demonstrations in the street.
North Vietnam cannot defeat
or humiliate the United States.
Only Americans can do that.
And so tonight, to you,
the great Silent Majority
of my fellow Americans,
I ask for your support.
I have initiated a plan
which will end this war
in a way that will bring us closer
to that great goal:
the goal of a just and lasting peace.
Johnny Cash was, like most Southerners,
supportive of the president's position
and strategy in ending the war.
From his TV show,
he gets up there and he says...
My family here and I stand behind
the President of the United States
in his quest for a just
and lasting peace.
He's surrounded by a crew
and by producers
who are from California,
who are from New York,
who do not believe what they are hearing.
"What did you just do?
You have just alienated
half of your audience.
This is outrageous!"
Johnny Cash said, "You put that in
or I do not come back to work."
They put it in.
Johnny's message
that goes out across the airwaves
gets to the White House,
and the president writes a letter.
"Dear Mr. Cash,
Pat and I were so appreciative
of what you said about us.
We want to find
an honorable end to the war.
Thank you for your support.
Richard Nixon."
Johnny Cash had been
one of my favorites since the mid-1950s.
And so I started pushing,
and others did,
"Let's being Johnny Cash
to the White House!"
[Joanne] One day, I was at work
at the House of Cash
and we got a phone call
from the White House.
And it was President Nixon.
We were sayin', "What? What?"
He had invited John and June
and the Cash family
to come visit the White House,
and for Johnny to sing
and do a concert there.
Having Johnny Cash at the White House
symbolizes the kind of base that
Richard Nixon was trying to appeal to,
which wasn't
a traditional Republican base:
blue collar Americans
that did go for Nixon in millions,
and who liked Johnny Cash's music.
[Buchanan] Nixon liked classical music,
but we persuaded him
that this would be a great evening.
Also, culturally and socially,
Johnny Cash represented Nashville,
he represented country and western.
This is culturally us.
We had someone mainstream
who had not been at Woodstock.
He and June are over-the-top.
June goes out and gets herself
a custom-made dress,
gorgeous, still in a museum.
Everybody wants to be on the guest list.
There's only 250 people that can get into
the East Room,
and the White House had never seen
anything like it.
They got requests
from literally everywhere
to get a ticket to this moment.
Anybody who wasn't Johnny Cash's friend
suddenly became his friend,
and his friends became his best friends.
President Nixon requested that
my father perform "Okie from Muskogee"...
And I'm proud to be
An Okie from Muskogee
...which Merle Haggard had recorded
that was a big country hit.
We don't smoke marijuana
In Muskogee
We don't burn our draft cards
Down on Main Street...
[Buchanan] It was about the values
of somebody in Muskogee, Oklahoma,
and how their way of life differed utterly
from the counter-culture hippies
from San Francisco.
[Stielper]
The other was "Welfare Cadillac."
It was a very mean-spirited song that
made fun of people who were on welfare.
Well, I've never worked much
In fact, I've been poor all my life
I guess about all I really own
Is ten kids and a wife
Of course
This house that I live in is mine
But it's really a shack
But I always managed
To drive me a brand new Cadillac!
[Stielper] When a press release went out
from the White House staff
that announced that President Nixon
had requested that John sing those songs,
immediately there was this brouhaha
in the media.
Country singer Johnny Cash is booked
for a White House appearance April 17th.
The performance already
is stirring some protest though.
Not about the singer, but about a song.
[Dan Rather] The name of the song
is on jukeboxes all over the country,
"Welfare Cadillac,"
a man who drives to pick up
his welfare checks in a big automobile.
[Stielper] It was on the CBS News.
It was in Time magazine, in newspapers.
"Nixon wants Cash to sing these songs."
Well, now there are some protests from
welfare and civil rights leaders.
One says, "A song like that
distorts the facts about welfare
and further irritates those
who pay their taxes."
How could the president ask for this song
that put down citizens of this country?
A White House spokesman said
the president didn't know whether
Johnny Cash would sing it or not.
[Stielper]
The response from the Cash side was
"Johnny's learning them now."
Johnny Cash says he will sing it
at the White House
if that's what the president wants.
The White House says,
the president wants it.
[Stielper] The president has asked John
to come and sing
for this great cultural moment.
This is as great a stage
as you could possibly imagine.
The politicians in the White House
had another agenda, though.
They wanted to use Johnny Cash
as part of their Southern strategy,
especially as it related to
the upcoming Senate election in Tennessee.
[Bakshian] Almost since the Civil War,
Tennessee was a Democratic state,
but with the Southern strategy,
the new Republican party
is being born in the South.
The old Democratic party is dying.
I am target number one
of the Southern strategy.
And President Nixon anointed
in the White House
his chosen instrument
of the Southern strategy,
Congressman Brock of Chattanooga.
Well, I appreciate your help my friend,
very much.
Good to see you.
[Bakshian] And Bill Brock is one of
the key people in the vanguard
on the Southern strategy.
And William Brock III, whose
conservative record has been unsullied
in eight years
in the House of Representatives.
[Bakshian]
Bill Brock was being opposed by Tex Ritter
for the Republican Senate nominee
in Tennessee.
-Hello there!
-Hello.
-Tex Ritter.
-Good evening.
[Bakshian] Tex Ritter was
an old Country Western singer.
[Buchanan]
Cash was a great friend of Tex Ritter's.
There was a memo written
by a guy named Murray Chotiner
roughly a month prior to
Johnny Cash appearing at the White House.
It said, "To Bob Haldeman,
From Murray Chotiner:
Johnny Cash is great with
a certain block of voters in Tennessee.
Obviously, he will not say or do anything
against Tex Ritter,
who is running for the US Senate
against Congressman Bill Brock
for the GOP nomination.
At the Johnny Cash evening
at the White House, it'll be most helpful
if privately the president can
neutralize Johnny Cash
so he does not campaign for Tex Ritter."
Nixon was thematically appealing
to the Silent Majority,
but more than wanting to
take advantage of Johnny Cash,
Richard Nixon really identified with him.
And he thought they were kindred souls
because they both had had
really tough upbringings
and everything they got
and everything they achieved
they had earned for themselves
against tight odds.
Well, Nixon was raised by
a sometimes abusive father.
You know, out there
on a struggling lemon farm in California.
Two of his brothers died of tuberculosis.
And he grew up poor, poor as hell.
And because of these parallels,
you know, Nixon, he thought
he understood Johnny Cash.
He felt that he knew
what kind of person Cash was.
But when someone's invited to perform
at the White House,
there always is some
political danger involved.
During the Lyndon Johnson administration,
Lady Bird Johnson had a big event
where Eartha Kitt was invited
to the White House,
where she proceeded to denounce
Lyndon Johnson to his face
for his Vietnam policies.
There was another time
when that kind of thing happened.
President Nixon, stop bombing
human beings, animals, and vegetation.
You go to church on Sundays
and pray to Jesus Christ.
If Jesus Christ were here tonight,
you would not dare drop another bomb.
-[man] Throw her outta here!
-[crowd] Yeah!
All right. [chuckles nervously]
I think you ought to...
[Carole] Certainly.
[scattered applause]
[Butterfield] In Nixon's estimation,
Johnny Cash wouldn't pose a risk
to the White House.
But the Nixon administration
may not have been aware
that my father was paying attention
to what was happening in the world.
In example,
he was the champion for such rights
as Native American rights.
This down here is where they were?
Yeah. They was all hunted down
up this canyon...
across the creek over there.
The American government,
with Gatling guns, machine guns,
killed innocent women and children
on December 29th, 1890 at Wounded Knee.
They shoved 'em into one mass grave.
The United States lied
about the atrocities they've done
against American Indians.
Johnny Cash came and heard
the real stories.
Is that the names of the people
that are there?
[Miller] Over a period of years,
he met with several of the tribes
that were still dealing with
the Bureau of Indian Affairs. There were
still triballand issues going on.
People were seeing us as outsiders,
and I think Johnny Cash always felt
somewhat as an outcast
trying to prove himself, not only to
his father, butto a society that
didn't accept people
who've been downtrodden.
The beauty of Johnny Cash was
he'd bring it into the songs.
Bitter Tears was a serious record about
United States indigenous people,
and there was nothing like it
in the world.
He had songs like
"The Ballad of Ira Hayes."
Ira Hayes was a Pima Indian man
who'd joined the Marines at a young age.
He was one of the men who actually
hoisted the flag
upon victory in Iwo Jima.
And when that fight was over
And when Old Glory raised
Among the men to hold it high
Was the Indian, Ira Hayes
[John Carter]
Ira Hayes died a sad, lonely death
at the hands of alcoholism
and depression.
[Stielper] Johnny Cash,
this atypical son of the South,
is singing about social causes
that aren't necessarily norms
for people to be hearing from
Tennessee or Arkansas or Louisiana.
The Bitter Tears album was boycotted
by the music industry
and John became enraged by that.
This offense brought out
the rebel inside him.
He wrote a letter to the music industry,
which he had published as a full-page ad
in Billboard magazine.
[John Carter]
"Why don't you play 'Ira Hayes'?"
It's like, hey, this song has purpose.
This song is important.
"Okay, country world, play this.
I dare you."
[Miller] Johnny Cash was giving a voice
to us who weren't being heard.
[Stielper] And what the brain trust
at the White House also didn't know
is that Johnny Cash had experienced
the personal side of war.
His views were changing.
His dying barely made
The morning paper...
Jan Howard is a very well-known
Grand Ole Opry star.
She sang with the Carter Family,
with Johnny for many years.
Jimmy, my oldest son, was drafted.
He said, "Well, I'm no better
than anybody else."
He said, "I'll be fine."
[Cash] He grew up on a little farm
just a couple of miles out of town.
Her son was in Vietnam
and was killed.
[Stielper] Johnny Cash was deeply upset.
He wrote a song called
"Route #1, Box 144."
It was a very...
quietly eloquent statement
about war.
[Cash] His body was sent back on a plane,
and then by train.
[Stielper]
Like so many in this country
who were called out of the fields,
called out of their homes,
off the assembly line,
and sent to Vietnam.
...thought that he was
President or something
At Route #1, Box 144
My father always supported
people within the Armed Forces.
Of course, my father himself served
in the Air Force
during the Korean conflict.
He would set aside any political notion
or any consideration of whether
one certain battle was right or wrong,
and support the men and young women
that were fighting
and giving their lives for us.
And so, he went to Vietnam
and performed for the troops.
Well, one morning at breakfast
I said to my wife
We've been everywhere once
And some places twice
AsI had another helping
Of country ham
She said we've never been to Vietnam
There'sa quarter of a million
Of our boys over there...
[Stielper] He went to Vietnam
in December of 1969,
just months before
the White House concert.
And he and June laid there in the tent
listening to the shells exploding,
listening to the sounds of war,
of people dying,
of watching the carnage.
It made a very serious impression on him.
Then we did our last song
For the night
And we crawled into bed
For some peace and quiet
But things weren't peaceful
Things weren't quiet
I'd gone over with my father to Vietnam.
I was at the airport,
the Tan Son Nhat airport,
getting ready to fly back,
and I said, "That looks like
John and June Cash!"
And so I made my way over,
and I said, "John, what're you doing
in Vietnam?"
He said, "I'm in a search mode right now."
He said, "I'm troubled about
what's happening here."
He said, "You know, Jimmie, I was raised
in a Baptist church in Arkansas.
I know what's right."
He said, "What troubled me was
it had taken our soldiers down."
It had pulled their... their morale,
their spirit down
because of what they heard back home.
Because of the way
our country was so divided.
Some of them hadreached a point where...
"What're we doing this for?
Why are we over here?"
Because politics had entered so strongly
into Vietnam.
[voice trembling] They were... looking for
a little bit of hope.
We prayed about that.
Servicemen and prisoners
have a lot in common.
There is a kind of a brotherhood
about the whole situation.
I think they feel
a lot of the same things.
The loneliness,
and a lot of times, boredom,
and isolation.
[Snow] "And he said there are some things
that I want to do
that I feel like I need to do now
with my voice."
We oughta live every day just as though
the Lord's coming!
Doing all we can...
to help our neighbor!
And above all, loving!
One of the people who
was watching Johnny Cash
is this superstar preacher,
the evangelist, Billy Graham.
President Nixon and Dr. Graham
had been friends for decades.
Billy Graham called John and said,
"May I meet Mr. Cash?
My son is a rebellious teenager.
I want to ask John advice."
One Sunday in December 1969,
Billy and Ruth Graham
came to supper at the Cash's.
Billy Graham says to him,
"Johnny, you are somebody
who speaks to youth
because you are so authenticand
that's what they are looking for today.
And I hope that you will use this gift
to further good purpose
in speaking to young people today."
This is the Arkansas sharecropper's son,
sitting there listening to this.
June is five months pregnant at the time.
This is their first child together.
He hasn't necessarily been
the best father
to his four girls that he left
with Vivian in California.
He is thinking about his responsibility
to the future now.
And when Billy Graham left,
John said to his father, "Well, Daddy,
Billy Graham just had supper in my house.
That was pretty good, wasn't it?"
And Ray said, "You ain't shit, boy.
That's nothing."
It was devastating.
Throughout his life, my father saw
a lot of struggle, a lot of troubles.
When I was born and I was healthy,
he was lifted up inside.
[Tommy] He was just ecstatic.
He thought that that was a great blessing.
[Stielper] Here's the chance to be
the father that he never had
to his own son.
-He's doing all right, ain't he, Mama?
-[June] He's doing fine.
[Stielper] John was so moved and inspired
after meeting Billy Graham
and becoming a father,
that he wrote a new song
about young people and the future.
[Jim Lovell over radio]
Uh, Houston, we've had a problem.
[Stielper] As it happened, the same week
as the White House concert,
the Apollo 13 astronauts
were stranded in space.
[reporter] The Apollo 13 space craft has
had a serious power supply malfunction.
But they came down to Earth safely.
[reporter 2]
Just a beautiful sight to see!
[man] And welcome home!
Theirs is the spirit that built America.
Johnny Cash would be at
the White House that night.
We arrived at the White House that very
afternoon that Apollo 13 splashed down.
We were excited to go.
Although, you know, there was a lot of
turmoil with the war going on,
and marching in the streets
and violence
and a lot of hatred on both sides.
But we said, "No, this is the White House.
This is history."
We were looking forward to this.
[Stielper] The president had so many
Southern Congressmen,
White House staff.
HR Haldeman,
the White House Chief of Staff,
who was a great, great Johnny Cash fan,
was there, as were other people
in the Nixon administration.
They were all clamoring to get in.
It was very, very tight.
These were all prominent
conservative supporters of the president.
John invited his family.
All of his siblings were there.
His father, Ray, was there.
It's the first time
he's ever worn a tux in hislife.
[Joanne] And I remember we had
these beautifullong dresses.
We're actually in the White House
with the president.
It was awesome and scary and wonderful,
all at the same time.
[John Carter]
I would've been barely over one month old
when they put me down for a nap
in the Lincoln bed.
[Nixon] We're very happy to welcome
all of you tonight
at this evening at the White House.
It's rather hard to describe Johnny Cash
in terms that are perhaps adequate.
The music that he represents tonight
is called country music and western music,
but I think it's really American music,
because it speaks in stories
about America,
in a way that touches the hearts
of all Americans, north, east,
west, and south.
Ladies and gentlemen, Johnny Cash.
[applause]
[Reid] I was a little bit uptight
because you never know
exactly what's going to work.
This is a different audience.
And when you put a tuxedo
and gowns on people,
they become different people.
They're not as loose and
as jovial as they usually are.
Thank you very much.
You got the president and the first lady
sitting in the first row staring at you,
and you think,
"Wow, let's hope this comes off."
[Cash] We hope to show you a little bit of
the soul of the South tonight.
[band playing]
Well, they gave him his orders
At Monroe, Virginia...
I never had any idea
what we were gonna play.
It didn't do any good to rehearse
with Johnny Cash
because he didn't know
what he was going do.
...poor boy
[applause]
My father made a decision
and refused to sing the two songs
that the president had asked him to sing.
[Cash] Daddy. Daddy, you remember this.
How high is the water, Papa?
He said
It's two feet high and rising...
However, the president and the audience
did not know
or have any idea what he would sing.
High and rising...
[applause]
I get asked a lot of questions
about war and...
drugs and youth and...
this and that. Well...
We took our show to Long Bihn
Air Force Base near Saigon, Vietnam.
We did shows for the men over there,
as many as we could
for the time that we had.
Somebody said, "That makes you a hawk.
You went to Vietnam."
No, but after you watch
the wounded come in in the helicopters,
if you were a dove, you might come away
a dove with claws.
[Reid] All of a sudden,
John got very quiet.
We were in trouble...
We're waiting with these solemn looks
on our faces. "What's going on?"
[Cash] Of course, um,
in order to say something to somebody
that might be meaningful, you...
gotta kind of get them on your side.
So I had these words, a poem that I wrote
to the youth of America.
And the lonely voice of youth cries
"What is truth?"
Little boy of three
Sitting on the floor
Looks up and says
"Daddy, what is war?"
"Son, that's when people
Fight and die"
Little boy of three says
"Daddy, why?"
A young man of 17 in Sunday school
Being taught the Golden Rule
And by the time
Another year has gone around
It may be his turn
To lay his life down
Can you blame the voice of youth
For asking
"What is truth?"
I saw the squirming in Nixon's chair
when Johnny was singing "What is Truth."
Nixon was smart enough and
attentive enough to be uncomfortable.
Young man sitting
On the witness stand
Man with a book says
"Raise your hand, repeat after me
I solemnly swear"
Judge looked down at his long hair
And although the young man
Solemnly swore
Nobody seemed to hear anymore
And it didn't really matter
If the truth was there
It was the cut of his clothes
And the length of his hair
And the lonely voice of youth cries
"What is truth?"
Young girl dancing to the latest beat
Found new ways to move her feet
Young man speaking in the city square
Trying to tell somebody that he cares
Yeah, the ones
That you're callin' wild
Gonna be the leaders
In a little while
This old world's waking
To a newborn day
And I solemnly swear
That it'll be their way
We better help that
Voice of youth find
"What is truth?"
And the lonely voice of youth cries
"What is truth?"
[applause]
Johnny had a way
to say something in a song
to get a point across,
and he did it well.
The most powerful man
in the United States at that time,
I think it got to him.
He understood the message.
[John Carter] My father wasn't afraid
to say what he thought,
which was, "I hope to bring peace.
But I'm not afraid to get dirty.
And I'm not afraid to fight
for what I believe in.
And I'm not afraid
to go where I'm uncomfortable
to stand up for love.
I'm a dove with claws."
[Stielper] Johnny Cash was putting himself
front-and-center.
He had gone out on a limb there.
This song was delivering a message
that the current leaders who were
looking on young people
and marginalizing them
need to understand that
this is the future,
and we need to honor and respect that.
Mr. Nixon, whose personal taste in music
runs more to tunes from South Pacific,
threw himself into the foot-tapping spirit
of Cash's twanging guitar,
and when it was over,
heaped praise on the entire troupe.
The closest Cash came to a song
with obvious political overtones
has a theme not from the '30s,
but from now,
and the thrust of it seemed
to surprise the president a bit.
Johnny Cash, you've played country fairs,
Grand Ole Oprys
and before prison audiences.
Was it any different tonight,
playing before the President of the
United States and at the White House?
Well, in several ways, it was, Dan.
It was quite different, uh...
We were playing for some
very important people tonight, of course.
I tried to keep the performance honest.
Good or bad,
it was honest, I think.
My dad would never, in his life,
disrespect the office of the presidency.
It was part of his patriotism.
He had a history of being bold.
But his performance at the White House
was a turning point.
[Snow] Evidently, John knew something
or picked up on something
and I think he was trying to say,
powerfully, to President Nixon,
"You need to think about
what you're doing.
And you need to be truthful."
Who would have ever thought that that
song would have been so prophetic?
I have concluded
that the time has come for action.
Attacks are being launched this week
to clean out major enemy sanctuaries
on the Cambodian/Vietnam border.
Shortly after the Johnny Cash event,
Nixon announced
the Cambodian Incursion.
The speech basically said that Americans
are going to be fighting in Cambodia.
Cambodia was a neutral country.
Nixon had been bombing it secretly,
without Congressional approval,
and without the knowledge
of the American people.
[Stielper] It galvanized those who said,
"Well, wait a minute.
We're supposed to be getting
out of Vietnam.
Now, we're expanding the war."
[Snow] We all thought
he was doing one thing,
and they were actually doing another.
Nixon lied not only to America
but to our soldiers.
The country went into flames.
[Buchanan] At Kent State University,
there had been riots.
National Guard troops were
on the campuses.
Instantly, there were four dead
and nine wounded.
[Stielper] Kent State happened two weeks
after the White House performance.
For all of his support for the president
and for the government,
Johnny Cash was blindsided.
John didn't like the idea of being used.
[Cash] Those young people out there
seem to be
trying to hold on to that part of our
American heritage
that they believe was good and beautiful.
All they desire is to be listened to.
They're only exercising
their freedom of speech
and God help you if that's
ever taken away from them, America.
John starts thinking much harder
about the totality of what's going on.
He sang "Blowin' in the Wind"
on his television show.
How many times
Must the cannonballs fly
Before they're forever banned?
"Blowin' in the Wind" was a whistle.
The quintessential anti-war anthem.
The answer is blowin' in the wind
The people in the audience,
half of them sat on their hands.
The other half burst into
a standing ovation.
That was America.
Johnny Cash was America.
[reporter] Five men
arrested early Saturday,
who were charged with breaking into
the party's national headquarters
at the Watergate in Washington.
[Fred Thompson] Mr. Butterfield,
are you aware
of the installation
of any listening devices
in the Oval Office of the President?
I was aware of listening devices.
Yes, sir.
[Butterfield] I'm from a military family.
Lying was just considered--
We just didn't do it.
[Stielper]
In August 1974, the president resigned
in the face of almost certain impeachment.
John attended the trial of HR Haldeman
amid the trials associated with
the Watergate break-ins.
You guys have to get up awfully early,
don't you?
Watergate was personal to him
because of what it represented,
of what Johnny Cash was always seeing
as the nobility
of the American people.
And when our leaders let us down,
he felt it very personally.
So, here is Johnny Cash watching
HR Haldeman on trial,
who had been at the White House
four years before
for Johnny's White House performance.
Haldeman turned to John and said,
"I'm sorry. I let you down."
If Johnny were here today,
and he is in spirit,
he'd play that song.
I'm going to go request it to be played
on the airwaves,
because that message in that song,
"What is Truth,"
needs to be heard today.
[John Carter] It was not long after
his performance at the White House
that Dad released the song "Man in Black."
And if you want to understand
what my dad stood for,
the words to the song "Man in Black"
exemplify that.
I wear the black for the poor
And the beaten-down
Livin'in the hopeless
Hungry side of town
And I wear it for the prisoner
Who has long paid for his crime
Butstill is there because
He's the victim of the times
I'm the man in black
[crowd whistling, applauding]
[crowd shouting]
[birds twittering]
[rooster crows]
[muted cheering]
[Johnny Cash] I thank God for all
the freedoms we've got in this country.
-I cherish them.
-[cheering continues]
Even the rights to burn the flag,
you know, I'm proud of those rights.
-[crowd shouting, booing]
-But I'll tell you what,
we've also got--
Let me tell you something. Shh.
We've also got a right to bear arms,
and if you burn my flag, I'll shoot you.
-[crowd cheering]
-[Cash playing guitar]
But I'll shoot you with a lot of love,
like a good American.
[wild cheering]
[chanting indistinctly]
[Mark Stielper] In the '60s and '70s,
America was torn apart
around issues of race, war, peace,
and a battle for the heart and soul of
what it meant to be an American patriot.
[Nixon] We will determine
what kind of nation America will be.
[Cash] It's the prettiest country
in the world that we've got.
-There ain't nothing like it anywhere.
-[applause]
Mr. Nixon said Johnny Cash speaks
to all America.
[Aram Bakshian] He understood
Johnny Cash's symbolic importance.
[Nixon speaking on tape]
Country music is the Johnny Cash crowd.
-[aide] It gets you elected.
-[Nixon] Yeah. You know, it's Southern.
[Pat Buchanan] Nixon wanted to identify
with Middle America,
and Johnny Cash was as Middle America
as you can get.
[Joanne Cash] We got a phone call from
the White House. It was President Nixon.
He had invited Johnny to sing
and do a concert there.
[Stielper] President Nixon
requested that John sing
redneck country music songs,
affiliating country music
with the president's cause,
and the result was just catastrophic.
How could the president
be so mean-spirited?
Johnny was very, very conflicted.
It was a defining moment for him.
[announcer]
Ladies and gentlemen, Johnny Cash!
[cheers and applause]
Thank you very much.
[Stielper] Who was going to show up
to the White House?
Johnny Cash of "Folsom Prison Blues,"
"The Rebel"...
So, what do you want to hear?
[Stielper] ...the guy who was photographed
flippin' off the man,
or the God-fearing family man
with a baby on the way,
gospel-singing Johnny Cash.
How do you be both?
What did Johnny Cash stand for?
Carl Perkins wrote a song
that tells about the reason for it all.
It takes us back home and again,
tells it like it was
when I was a little-bitty kid
and we gathered around the piano,
and me and little brother would join in
and Mama'd sing tenor and Daddy sang bass.
[band playing]
I remember when I was a lad
Times were hard and things were bad...
Johnny was born in Kingsland,
in south Arkansas.
Just poor people
That's all we were
Trying to make a living
Out of black land dirt
We'd get together
In a family circle singing loud...
When my family came to Dyess,
Johnny was three years old.
Singin' seems to help a troubled soul
One of these days and it won't be long
I'll rejoin them in a song
I'm gonna join the family circle
At the Throne
[Cash]
Now each one of these houses had a barn,
a chicken house, and a smoke-house
where the farmers raised their own hogs
and cured their meat.
And they had a mule
and 20 acres of land here.
It was a beautiful little place.
The Dyess, Arkansas experience
was part ofFDR's New Deal.
They moved people from terrible situations
where they had no hope, no future,
and gave them an opportunity.
My clothes may be ragged
And my shoes may be worn
But I've been a wealthy boy
Since I've been born...
We were a happy family.
We didn't know we were poor.
We always had plenty to eat
and plenty of clothes.
We were happy to be part
of the American dream.
[Joanne] Our family would start the day
in the cotton fields,
singing old church hymns andsongs
that we all knew, we'd sing together.
Gospel songs or country songs
because it's about our life with the Lord.
Johnny's grandfather was
a hellfire preacher.
He had preacher grandparents
on multiple lines of his family tree.
They spoke of hell and damnation,
and what it was like if you did not live
the right kind of a life.
John was a dyed-in-the-wool
conservative person
because his parents were.
He was from that part of Arkansas.
I don't remember anybody in our family
criticizing the government.
We were patriotic
no matter who the president was.
We loved to see the American flag flown.
My daddy flew it every day
until the day he died.
Johnny loved America.
He believed that you should
support your government
and support the president.
[Joanne] He was one of the most patriotic
men I've ever known.
In 1968, the idea of patriotism itself
became controversial.
[sirens blaring]
[Nixon] As we look at America, we see
cities enveloped in smoke and flames.
We hear sirens in the night.
We see Americans dying
on distant battlefields abroad.
[machine gun fire]
We see Americans hating each other,
fighting each other,
killing each other at home.
It was a period where
lots of stuff came to a boil
at the same time.
We not only have a right to be free,
we have a duty to be free.
[Bakshian]
There were civil rights protests.
There was this unpopular war.
We will prevail in Vietnam
over the Communist aggressor!
The country split into what has
come to be called hawks and doves.
Doves wanted to end the war.
Hawks wanted to pursue the war.
-[man] What do you want?
-[all] Peace!
-[man] When do we get it?
-[all] Now!
And these two sides, both Americans,
both claiming to be patriots,
went to war with each other.
[Bakshian] It was the perfect storm,
and Nixon understood that.
And I pledge to you tonight
that the firstpriority
foreign policy objective
of our next administration
will be to bring an honorable end
to the war in Vietnam.
[crowd cheering]
Nixon lost the 1960 presidential election
to Kennedy,
and he was traumatized by that defeat.
In 1968, he was running for president
in a desperate attempt
to resurrect his career.
The time has come for honest government
in the United States of America!
[crowd cheering]
-Thank you!
-Thank you, girls.
My father was never afraid
to stand up for someone in need.
And he would always put himself
in a position to help those if he could.
It was that simplicity that was within
the heart of the man.
It wasn't the complications of politics.
[fans murmuring]
[Cash] Thank you.
[John Carter] I think that empathy
goes back to the loss of his brother.
[Cash playing slow guitar]
Beside a singin' mountain stream...
Growing up,
my father and his brother, Jack,
were dearest of friends.
Jack was a man of God at 14 years old.
He studied the Bible all the time.
He knew in his heart
that he was going to be a pastor.
They were so inseparable.
But flesh and blood
Needs flesh and blood
And you are what I need
On Saturdays, Johnny,
Jack, and my other brothers,
all of us, would do odd jobs
to help Mama with the groceries.
In May of 1944,
Jack was sawing some fence post.
As he was pushing the fence post
into the saw,
it jerked... and jerked him into the saw.
It was beyond horrible.
I remember Johnny crying
and holding his hand,
saying, "Somebody do something!"
It was as bad as you can imagine.
The next day after the funeral,
we were all back
in the cotton fields, working.
I can't even describe the emptiness
and the hurt.
[Stielper] Ray and Carrie,
Johnny's mother and father,
and 12-year-old Johnny
are the ones
that had to shoulder that burden.
It was back-breaking.
They were working every day
and not getting anywhere.
Ray Cash, who had thought
Dyess was his promised land,
found that it wasn't.
Jack was going to be a preacher.
He was going to be the son of Dyess
that made it.
Johnny was a very sensitive young man.
There was not room for sensitivity.
There was not room for dreamers
in Dyess, Arkansas in the 1940s.
Ray became so bitter, he resented his son.
He would look at Johnny and he would say,
"You weren't the right son.
You should've died."
Johnny Cash grew up feeling unworthy
of being himself.
He felt that he would nevermeasure up
to what his father wanted him to be.
Something happened within my dad,
and there was this deep wound
that was placed there,
this hollow well.
There was also a drive that was installed,
and all these different faces
that were Johnny Cash were developed
through that great loss at an early age.
[indistinct chatter]
A prison's a prison.
And that's all it is.
[June] I'm sure you'll enjoy him
this afternoon.
He seems to have a lot of things
in common with you, Mr. Johnny Cash!
[crowd cheering]
[John Carter] My father knew
what it was like to suffer.
He knew what it was like to feel lost.
And so, he could connect
with other people's suffering.
He sang for those who needed something
to believe in and needed to be lifted up.
[Stielper] In January of 1968,
Johnny Cash went to Folsom Prison
and performed for the inmates.
I hear the train a comin'
It's rollin' 'round the bend
And I ain't seen the sunshine
Since I don't know when
I'm stuck in Folsom Prison
And time keeps draggin' on
-[crowd cheers]
-Yeah!
[Stielper]
He looked on some of those guys in there,
looked on the desperation in their eyes,
and he thought,
"There but for the grace of God goes me.
I made some stumbles in my life.
That could've been me."
But I shot a man in Reno
Just to watch him die...
He brought recording equipment
because he wanted people to hear
the rawness of what it was like
to perform for these men.
John always related to prisoners,
amongst others that had drug troubles.
My father was full of love.
He was full of faith. He worked hard.
He was self-made.
But he was also a man who
hit hard rock bottom quite a few times.
Whether it's alcohol, drugs, whatever
it is that changes your personality,
your demeanor, your physical look,
and he went through all of this.
[John Carter] He could be a liar.
He struggled. He made mistakes.
He was a different man
when he was in that mode.
My father had never been an inmate,
but they accepted him as one of their own.
He was a champion of theunderdog
and the downtrodden.
[interviewer]
Do you have political leanings?
No, not all that much.
If somebody says,
"I'm not my brother's keeper,"
he's wrong 'cause he is.
He is his brother's keeper.
[Stielper] In May 1968,
Johnny Cash At Folsom Prison is released.
"Folsom Prison Blues" gets to number one.
He is viewed as Johnny Cash, this rebel.
And that appealed to a broad audience.
[John Carter]
People responded to that rebel identity,
but what was amazing is
they'd think they knew him,
and then he'd change.
The Album of the Year,
Johnny Cash, At Folsom Prison!
He had a lot of songs
that he would cut as a country song,
and it would spill over
into the pop charts.
I think that was why he was so successful.
There was no limit
to who wanted to listen to Johnny Cash.
[Stielper]
By the late '60s, Johnny's star rises,
as does Mr. Nixon's.
He wins the presidency in 1968.
Having lost a close one eight years ago
and having won a close one this year,
I can say this...
winning's a lot more fun!
[laughing]
But we won narrowly,
we won with 43% of the vote.
I, Richard Milhous Nixon,
do solemnly swear...
That you will faithfully
execute the office...
That I will faithfully...
The Southern strategy that Nixon used
to win the 1968 presidential election
has been used by every Republican
presidential candidate since.
[excited chatter]
The Southern strategy sends out
dog whistles to racists
and dog whistles to conservatives,
using key phrases like
"the silent majority."
The Southern strategy basically was
to hold the South,
bringing those people
into the Nixon Coalition.
The essence was traditional conservatives
and law and order,
supporting Americans in Vietnam,
standing up against the demonstrators
who were against the war,
and basically representing the values
and beliefs of Middle America
against the rising social and cultural
revolution in the country.
The peace of the world will depend
not just on America's military might,
which is the greatest in the world,
but it's going to depend on our character,
our love of our country,
our willingness to not only wear the flag
but stand up for the flag,
and country music does that.
[Buchanan]
Throughout Nixon's entire presidency,
well, even into his second term,
he attempted to cultivate the support
of the South.
[all] God bless America
My home sweet home
[crowd cheering]
[intro music plays]
Hello, I'm Johnny Cash.
[cheering]
[Stielper] In 1969, The Johnny Cash Show
first aired on national TV.
Oh, hi, there!
It was a variety entertainment show,
and it was unlike anything
anyone had ever seen.
Certainly unlike anything that anybody
had ever seen in country music.
He healed the leper and the lame...
Mm-hmm.
[Stielper] He sings gospel songs.
Make welcome my brother, Tommy Cash.
Hey, Tommy! Welcome!
He'd say do what you do, do well, boy!
Do what you do, do well!
[Stielper]
It was a family affair all around.
You say you're lookin' for someone
Who's never weak
But always strong...
He puts on a special segment on every show
called "Ride This Train."
Ride this train with me
to San Antonio, Texas;
Springfield, Missouri;
Boise, Idaho.
It's a quintessentially
American experience.
And he puts people on TV
that nobody's ever seen before,
but it's not just country people.
Please make welcome Ms. Joni Mitchell.
Rows and flows of angel hair...
[Stielper] Bob Dylan...
Love is all there is
It makes the world go 'round...
He puts on Pete Seeger.
-That's nice. [chuckles]
-[applause]
That's nice.
[Stielper] These were all leaders
of the anti-war movement.
The people that I'm contracted with
said that,
"How dare you,
supposedly such a good American,
have a Communist like Pete Seeger
on your TV show?"
The Pete Seeger I know
and the Pete Seeger that June and I
have come to love is,
I'd say, one of the best Americans
and patriots I've ever known.
But Pete Seeger is not coming on there
and singing
"Where Have All the Flowers Gone?"
This is a non-political venue.
[John Carter] My father did not adhere
to any certain party.
A Republican would claim him
and also a Democrat would,
and my father wouldn't argue either point.
I keep my eyes wide open all the time
John walked a political line.
Iwalk the line
Yes, he tried. He tried to walk the line.
People will say,
"Oh, he tried to have it both ways."
Because you're mine
I walk the line...
This was in the midst of
tremendous social turmoil.
Johnny Cash doesn't get involved in that.
He is not political.
He does not take a stand.
[applause]
I thank you very much.
While you could be neutral
in the middle of those polarities,
culturally and politically,
it was difficult.
And the more time went by,
the harder it was to be neutral.
[chanting] Peace over war! Peace over war!
Peace over war! Peace over war!
[Buchanan] In the Fall of '69,
a huge demonstration was planned
to bring out hundreds of thousands
of people
to break the Nixon presidency on Vietnam.
We have been too often disappointed
by the optimism of the American leaders,
both in Vietnam and Washington,
to have faith any longer...
When parts of the news media
projected the failures of US policy,
it began to create a gap
between what the government was telling us
and what the news media started to report.
In the midst of this war,
we began to understand
that we were being lied to,
and that further polarized society.
[Nixon] The radical fuel that you seeon
your television screens night after night,
they're not a majority of
American youth today
and they will not be the leaders
of America tomorrow.
[cheering]
Nixon was paranoid about
these antiwar protesters,
most of whom were young.
[crowd] One, two, three, four,
Tricky Dick passed a law!
He used to say to me sometimes,
"What is it with these young people?
What don't they understand?"
We felt that we were being patriotic.
He wanted them to look shameful.
We're in the middle of a revolution.
So, I told the president,
"If we don't stand up here,
your presidency is going to be broken."
Tonight I want to talk to you on a subject
of deep concern to all Americans,
the war in Vietnam.
The American people are entitled
to know the truth...
but as President of the United States,
I would be untrue to my oath of office
if I allowed the policy of this nation
to be dictated by the minority
mounting demonstrations in the street.
North Vietnam cannot defeat
or humiliate the United States.
Only Americans can do that.
And so tonight, to you,
the great Silent Majority
of my fellow Americans,
I ask for your support.
I have initiated a plan
which will end this war
in a way that will bring us closer
to that great goal:
the goal of a just and lasting peace.
Johnny Cash was, like most Southerners,
supportive of the president's position
and strategy in ending the war.
From his TV show,
he gets up there and he says...
My family here and I stand behind
the President of the United States
in his quest for a just
and lasting peace.
He's surrounded by a crew
and by producers
who are from California,
who are from New York,
who do not believe what they are hearing.
"What did you just do?
You have just alienated
half of your audience.
This is outrageous!"
Johnny Cash said, "You put that in
or I do not come back to work."
They put it in.
Johnny's message
that goes out across the airwaves
gets to the White House,
and the president writes a letter.
"Dear Mr. Cash,
Pat and I were so appreciative
of what you said about us.
We want to find
an honorable end to the war.
Thank you for your support.
Richard Nixon."
Johnny Cash had been
one of my favorites since the mid-1950s.
And so I started pushing,
and others did,
"Let's being Johnny Cash
to the White House!"
[Joanne] One day, I was at work
at the House of Cash
and we got a phone call
from the White House.
And it was President Nixon.
We were sayin', "What? What?"
He had invited John and June
and the Cash family
to come visit the White House,
and for Johnny to sing
and do a concert there.
Having Johnny Cash at the White House
symbolizes the kind of base that
Richard Nixon was trying to appeal to,
which wasn't
a traditional Republican base:
blue collar Americans
that did go for Nixon in millions,
and who liked Johnny Cash's music.
[Buchanan] Nixon liked classical music,
but we persuaded him
that this would be a great evening.
Also, culturally and socially,
Johnny Cash represented Nashville,
he represented country and western.
This is culturally us.
We had someone mainstream
who had not been at Woodstock.
He and June are over-the-top.
June goes out and gets herself
a custom-made dress,
gorgeous, still in a museum.
Everybody wants to be on the guest list.
There's only 250 people that can get into
the East Room,
and the White House had never seen
anything like it.
They got requests
from literally everywhere
to get a ticket to this moment.
Anybody who wasn't Johnny Cash's friend
suddenly became his friend,
and his friends became his best friends.
President Nixon requested that
my father perform "Okie from Muskogee"...
And I'm proud to be
An Okie from Muskogee
...which Merle Haggard had recorded
that was a big country hit.
We don't smoke marijuana
In Muskogee
We don't burn our draft cards
Down on Main Street...
[Buchanan] It was about the values
of somebody in Muskogee, Oklahoma,
and how their way of life differed utterly
from the counter-culture hippies
from San Francisco.
[Stielper]
The other was "Welfare Cadillac."
It was a very mean-spirited song that
made fun of people who were on welfare.
Well, I've never worked much
In fact, I've been poor all my life
I guess about all I really own
Is ten kids and a wife
Of course
This house that I live in is mine
But it's really a shack
But I always managed
To drive me a brand new Cadillac!
[Stielper] When a press release went out
from the White House staff
that announced that President Nixon
had requested that John sing those songs,
immediately there was this brouhaha
in the media.
Country singer Johnny Cash is booked
for a White House appearance April 17th.
The performance already
is stirring some protest though.
Not about the singer, but about a song.
[Dan Rather] The name of the song
is on jukeboxes all over the country,
"Welfare Cadillac,"
a man who drives to pick up
his welfare checks in a big automobile.
[Stielper] It was on the CBS News.
It was in Time magazine, in newspapers.
"Nixon wants Cash to sing these songs."
Well, now there are some protests from
welfare and civil rights leaders.
One says, "A song like that
distorts the facts about welfare
and further irritates those
who pay their taxes."
How could the president ask for this song
that put down citizens of this country?
A White House spokesman said
the president didn't know whether
Johnny Cash would sing it or not.
[Stielper]
The response from the Cash side was
"Johnny's learning them now."
Johnny Cash says he will sing it
at the White House
if that's what the president wants.
The White House says,
the president wants it.
[Stielper] The president has asked John
to come and sing
for this great cultural moment.
This is as great a stage
as you could possibly imagine.
The politicians in the White House
had another agenda, though.
They wanted to use Johnny Cash
as part of their Southern strategy,
especially as it related to
the upcoming Senate election in Tennessee.
[Bakshian] Almost since the Civil War,
Tennessee was a Democratic state,
but with the Southern strategy,
the new Republican party
is being born in the South.
The old Democratic party is dying.
I am target number one
of the Southern strategy.
And President Nixon anointed
in the White House
his chosen instrument
of the Southern strategy,
Congressman Brock of Chattanooga.
Well, I appreciate your help my friend,
very much.
Good to see you.
[Bakshian] And Bill Brock is one of
the key people in the vanguard
on the Southern strategy.
And William Brock III, whose
conservative record has been unsullied
in eight years
in the House of Representatives.
[Bakshian]
Bill Brock was being opposed by Tex Ritter
for the Republican Senate nominee
in Tennessee.
-Hello there!
-Hello.
-Tex Ritter.
-Good evening.
[Bakshian] Tex Ritter was
an old Country Western singer.
[Buchanan]
Cash was a great friend of Tex Ritter's.
There was a memo written
by a guy named Murray Chotiner
roughly a month prior to
Johnny Cash appearing at the White House.
It said, "To Bob Haldeman,
From Murray Chotiner:
Johnny Cash is great with
a certain block of voters in Tennessee.
Obviously, he will not say or do anything
against Tex Ritter,
who is running for the US Senate
against Congressman Bill Brock
for the GOP nomination.
At the Johnny Cash evening
at the White House, it'll be most helpful
if privately the president can
neutralize Johnny Cash
so he does not campaign for Tex Ritter."
Nixon was thematically appealing
to the Silent Majority,
but more than wanting to
take advantage of Johnny Cash,
Richard Nixon really identified with him.
And he thought they were kindred souls
because they both had had
really tough upbringings
and everything they got
and everything they achieved
they had earned for themselves
against tight odds.
Well, Nixon was raised by
a sometimes abusive father.
You know, out there
on a struggling lemon farm in California.
Two of his brothers died of tuberculosis.
And he grew up poor, poor as hell.
And because of these parallels,
you know, Nixon, he thought
he understood Johnny Cash.
He felt that he knew
what kind of person Cash was.
But when someone's invited to perform
at the White House,
there always is some
political danger involved.
During the Lyndon Johnson administration,
Lady Bird Johnson had a big event
where Eartha Kitt was invited
to the White House,
where she proceeded to denounce
Lyndon Johnson to his face
for his Vietnam policies.
There was another time
when that kind of thing happened.
President Nixon, stop bombing
human beings, animals, and vegetation.
You go to church on Sundays
and pray to Jesus Christ.
If Jesus Christ were here tonight,
you would not dare drop another bomb.
-[man] Throw her outta here!
-[crowd] Yeah!
All right. [chuckles nervously]
I think you ought to...
[Carole] Certainly.
[scattered applause]
[Butterfield] In Nixon's estimation,
Johnny Cash wouldn't pose a risk
to the White House.
But the Nixon administration
may not have been aware
that my father was paying attention
to what was happening in the world.
In example,
he was the champion for such rights
as Native American rights.
This down here is where they were?
Yeah. They was all hunted down
up this canyon...
across the creek over there.
The American government,
with Gatling guns, machine guns,
killed innocent women and children
on December 29th, 1890 at Wounded Knee.
They shoved 'em into one mass grave.
The United States lied
about the atrocities they've done
against American Indians.
Johnny Cash came and heard
the real stories.
Is that the names of the people
that are there?
[Miller] Over a period of years,
he met with several of the tribes
that were still dealing with
the Bureau of Indian Affairs. There were
still triballand issues going on.
People were seeing us as outsiders,
and I think Johnny Cash always felt
somewhat as an outcast
trying to prove himself, not only to
his father, butto a society that
didn't accept people
who've been downtrodden.
The beauty of Johnny Cash was
he'd bring it into the songs.
Bitter Tears was a serious record about
United States indigenous people,
and there was nothing like it
in the world.
He had songs like
"The Ballad of Ira Hayes."
Ira Hayes was a Pima Indian man
who'd joined the Marines at a young age.
He was one of the men who actually
hoisted the flag
upon victory in Iwo Jima.
And when that fight was over
And when Old Glory raised
Among the men to hold it high
Was the Indian, Ira Hayes
[John Carter]
Ira Hayes died a sad, lonely death
at the hands of alcoholism
and depression.
[Stielper] Johnny Cash,
this atypical son of the South,
is singing about social causes
that aren't necessarily norms
for people to be hearing from
Tennessee or Arkansas or Louisiana.
The Bitter Tears album was boycotted
by the music industry
and John became enraged by that.
This offense brought out
the rebel inside him.
He wrote a letter to the music industry,
which he had published as a full-page ad
in Billboard magazine.
[John Carter]
"Why don't you play 'Ira Hayes'?"
It's like, hey, this song has purpose.
This song is important.
"Okay, country world, play this.
I dare you."
[Miller] Johnny Cash was giving a voice
to us who weren't being heard.
[Stielper] And what the brain trust
at the White House also didn't know
is that Johnny Cash had experienced
the personal side of war.
His views were changing.
His dying barely made
The morning paper...
Jan Howard is a very well-known
Grand Ole Opry star.
She sang with the Carter Family,
with Johnny for many years.
Jimmy, my oldest son, was drafted.
He said, "Well, I'm no better
than anybody else."
He said, "I'll be fine."
[Cash] He grew up on a little farm
just a couple of miles out of town.
Her son was in Vietnam
and was killed.
[Stielper] Johnny Cash was deeply upset.
He wrote a song called
"Route #1, Box 144."
It was a very...
quietly eloquent statement
about war.
[Cash] His body was sent back on a plane,
and then by train.
[Stielper]
Like so many in this country
who were called out of the fields,
called out of their homes,
off the assembly line,
and sent to Vietnam.
...thought that he was
President or something
At Route #1, Box 144
My father always supported
people within the Armed Forces.
Of course, my father himself served
in the Air Force
during the Korean conflict.
He would set aside any political notion
or any consideration of whether
one certain battle was right or wrong,
and support the men and young women
that were fighting
and giving their lives for us.
And so, he went to Vietnam
and performed for the troops.
Well, one morning at breakfast
I said to my wife
We've been everywhere once
And some places twice
AsI had another helping
Of country ham
She said we've never been to Vietnam
There'sa quarter of a million
Of our boys over there...
[Stielper] He went to Vietnam
in December of 1969,
just months before
the White House concert.
And he and June laid there in the tent
listening to the shells exploding,
listening to the sounds of war,
of people dying,
of watching the carnage.
It made a very serious impression on him.
Then we did our last song
For the night
And we crawled into bed
For some peace and quiet
But things weren't peaceful
Things weren't quiet
I'd gone over with my father to Vietnam.
I was at the airport,
the Tan Son Nhat airport,
getting ready to fly back,
and I said, "That looks like
John and June Cash!"
And so I made my way over,
and I said, "John, what're you doing
in Vietnam?"
He said, "I'm in a search mode right now."
He said, "I'm troubled about
what's happening here."
He said, "You know, Jimmie, I was raised
in a Baptist church in Arkansas.
I know what's right."
He said, "What troubled me was
it had taken our soldiers down."
It had pulled their... their morale,
their spirit down
because of what they heard back home.
Because of the way
our country was so divided.
Some of them hadreached a point where...
"What're we doing this for?
Why are we over here?"
Because politics had entered so strongly
into Vietnam.
[voice trembling] They were... looking for
a little bit of hope.
We prayed about that.
Servicemen and prisoners
have a lot in common.
There is a kind of a brotherhood
about the whole situation.
I think they feel
a lot of the same things.
The loneliness,
and a lot of times, boredom,
and isolation.
[Snow] "And he said there are some things
that I want to do
that I feel like I need to do now
with my voice."
We oughta live every day just as though
the Lord's coming!
Doing all we can...
to help our neighbor!
And above all, loving!
One of the people who
was watching Johnny Cash
is this superstar preacher,
the evangelist, Billy Graham.
President Nixon and Dr. Graham
had been friends for decades.
Billy Graham called John and said,
"May I meet Mr. Cash?
My son is a rebellious teenager.
I want to ask John advice."
One Sunday in December 1969,
Billy and Ruth Graham
came to supper at the Cash's.
Billy Graham says to him,
"Johnny, you are somebody
who speaks to youth
because you are so authenticand
that's what they are looking for today.
And I hope that you will use this gift
to further good purpose
in speaking to young people today."
This is the Arkansas sharecropper's son,
sitting there listening to this.
June is five months pregnant at the time.
This is their first child together.
He hasn't necessarily been
the best father
to his four girls that he left
with Vivian in California.
He is thinking about his responsibility
to the future now.
And when Billy Graham left,
John said to his father, "Well, Daddy,
Billy Graham just had supper in my house.
That was pretty good, wasn't it?"
And Ray said, "You ain't shit, boy.
That's nothing."
It was devastating.
Throughout his life, my father saw
a lot of struggle, a lot of troubles.
When I was born and I was healthy,
he was lifted up inside.
[Tommy] He was just ecstatic.
He thought that that was a great blessing.
[Stielper] Here's the chance to be
the father that he never had
to his own son.
-He's doing all right, ain't he, Mama?
-[June] He's doing fine.
[Stielper] John was so moved and inspired
after meeting Billy Graham
and becoming a father,
that he wrote a new song
about young people and the future.
[Jim Lovell over radio]
Uh, Houston, we've had a problem.
[Stielper] As it happened, the same week
as the White House concert,
the Apollo 13 astronauts
were stranded in space.
[reporter] The Apollo 13 space craft has
had a serious power supply malfunction.
But they came down to Earth safely.
[reporter 2]
Just a beautiful sight to see!
[man] And welcome home!
Theirs is the spirit that built America.
Johnny Cash would be at
the White House that night.
We arrived at the White House that very
afternoon that Apollo 13 splashed down.
We were excited to go.
Although, you know, there was a lot of
turmoil with the war going on,
and marching in the streets
and violence
and a lot of hatred on both sides.
But we said, "No, this is the White House.
This is history."
We were looking forward to this.
[Stielper] The president had so many
Southern Congressmen,
White House staff.
HR Haldeman,
the White House Chief of Staff,
who was a great, great Johnny Cash fan,
was there, as were other people
in the Nixon administration.
They were all clamoring to get in.
It was very, very tight.
These were all prominent
conservative supporters of the president.
John invited his family.
All of his siblings were there.
His father, Ray, was there.
It's the first time
he's ever worn a tux in hislife.
[Joanne] And I remember we had
these beautifullong dresses.
We're actually in the White House
with the president.
It was awesome and scary and wonderful,
all at the same time.
[John Carter]
I would've been barely over one month old
when they put me down for a nap
in the Lincoln bed.
[Nixon] We're very happy to welcome
all of you tonight
at this evening at the White House.
It's rather hard to describe Johnny Cash
in terms that are perhaps adequate.
The music that he represents tonight
is called country music and western music,
but I think it's really American music,
because it speaks in stories
about America,
in a way that touches the hearts
of all Americans, north, east,
west, and south.
Ladies and gentlemen, Johnny Cash.
[applause]
[Reid] I was a little bit uptight
because you never know
exactly what's going to work.
This is a different audience.
And when you put a tuxedo
and gowns on people,
they become different people.
They're not as loose and
as jovial as they usually are.
Thank you very much.
You got the president and the first lady
sitting in the first row staring at you,
and you think,
"Wow, let's hope this comes off."
[Cash] We hope to show you a little bit of
the soul of the South tonight.
[band playing]
Well, they gave him his orders
At Monroe, Virginia...
I never had any idea
what we were gonna play.
It didn't do any good to rehearse
with Johnny Cash
because he didn't know
what he was going do.
...poor boy
[applause]
My father made a decision
and refused to sing the two songs
that the president had asked him to sing.
[Cash] Daddy. Daddy, you remember this.
How high is the water, Papa?
He said
It's two feet high and rising...
However, the president and the audience
did not know
or have any idea what he would sing.
High and rising...
[applause]
I get asked a lot of questions
about war and...
drugs and youth and...
this and that. Well...
We took our show to Long Bihn
Air Force Base near Saigon, Vietnam.
We did shows for the men over there,
as many as we could
for the time that we had.
Somebody said, "That makes you a hawk.
You went to Vietnam."
No, but after you watch
the wounded come in in the helicopters,
if you were a dove, you might come away
a dove with claws.
[Reid] All of a sudden,
John got very quiet.
We were in trouble...
We're waiting with these solemn looks
on our faces. "What's going on?"
[Cash] Of course, um,
in order to say something to somebody
that might be meaningful, you...
gotta kind of get them on your side.
So I had these words, a poem that I wrote
to the youth of America.
And the lonely voice of youth cries
"What is truth?"
Little boy of three
Sitting on the floor
Looks up and says
"Daddy, what is war?"
"Son, that's when people
Fight and die"
Little boy of three says
"Daddy, why?"
A young man of 17 in Sunday school
Being taught the Golden Rule
And by the time
Another year has gone around
It may be his turn
To lay his life down
Can you blame the voice of youth
For asking
"What is truth?"
I saw the squirming in Nixon's chair
when Johnny was singing "What is Truth."
Nixon was smart enough and
attentive enough to be uncomfortable.
Young man sitting
On the witness stand
Man with a book says
"Raise your hand, repeat after me
I solemnly swear"
Judge looked down at his long hair
And although the young man
Solemnly swore
Nobody seemed to hear anymore
And it didn't really matter
If the truth was there
It was the cut of his clothes
And the length of his hair
And the lonely voice of youth cries
"What is truth?"
Young girl dancing to the latest beat
Found new ways to move her feet
Young man speaking in the city square
Trying to tell somebody that he cares
Yeah, the ones
That you're callin' wild
Gonna be the leaders
In a little while
This old world's waking
To a newborn day
And I solemnly swear
That it'll be their way
We better help that
Voice of youth find
"What is truth?"
And the lonely voice of youth cries
"What is truth?"
[applause]
Johnny had a way
to say something in a song
to get a point across,
and he did it well.
The most powerful man
in the United States at that time,
I think it got to him.
He understood the message.
[John Carter] My father wasn't afraid
to say what he thought,
which was, "I hope to bring peace.
But I'm not afraid to get dirty.
And I'm not afraid to fight
for what I believe in.
And I'm not afraid
to go where I'm uncomfortable
to stand up for love.
I'm a dove with claws."
[Stielper] Johnny Cash was putting himself
front-and-center.
He had gone out on a limb there.
This song was delivering a message
that the current leaders who were
looking on young people
and marginalizing them
need to understand that
this is the future,
and we need to honor and respect that.
Mr. Nixon, whose personal taste in music
runs more to tunes from South Pacific,
threw himself into the foot-tapping spirit
of Cash's twanging guitar,
and when it was over,
heaped praise on the entire troupe.
The closest Cash came to a song
with obvious political overtones
has a theme not from the '30s,
but from now,
and the thrust of it seemed
to surprise the president a bit.
Johnny Cash, you've played country fairs,
Grand Ole Oprys
and before prison audiences.
Was it any different tonight,
playing before the President of the
United States and at the White House?
Well, in several ways, it was, Dan.
It was quite different, uh...
We were playing for some
very important people tonight, of course.
I tried to keep the performance honest.
Good or bad,
it was honest, I think.
My dad would never, in his life,
disrespect the office of the presidency.
It was part of his patriotism.
He had a history of being bold.
But his performance at the White House
was a turning point.
[Snow] Evidently, John knew something
or picked up on something
and I think he was trying to say,
powerfully, to President Nixon,
"You need to think about
what you're doing.
And you need to be truthful."
Who would have ever thought that that
song would have been so prophetic?
I have concluded
that the time has come for action.
Attacks are being launched this week
to clean out major enemy sanctuaries
on the Cambodian/Vietnam border.
Shortly after the Johnny Cash event,
Nixon announced
the Cambodian Incursion.
The speech basically said that Americans
are going to be fighting in Cambodia.
Cambodia was a neutral country.
Nixon had been bombing it secretly,
without Congressional approval,
and without the knowledge
of the American people.
[Stielper] It galvanized those who said,
"Well, wait a minute.
We're supposed to be getting
out of Vietnam.
Now, we're expanding the war."
[Snow] We all thought
he was doing one thing,
and they were actually doing another.
Nixon lied not only to America
but to our soldiers.
The country went into flames.
[Buchanan] At Kent State University,
there had been riots.
National Guard troops were
on the campuses.
Instantly, there were four dead
and nine wounded.
[Stielper] Kent State happened two weeks
after the White House performance.
For all of his support for the president
and for the government,
Johnny Cash was blindsided.
John didn't like the idea of being used.
[Cash] Those young people out there
seem to be
trying to hold on to that part of our
American heritage
that they believe was good and beautiful.
All they desire is to be listened to.
They're only exercising
their freedom of speech
and God help you if that's
ever taken away from them, America.
John starts thinking much harder
about the totality of what's going on.
He sang "Blowin' in the Wind"
on his television show.
How many times
Must the cannonballs fly
Before they're forever banned?
"Blowin' in the Wind" was a whistle.
The quintessential anti-war anthem.
The answer is blowin' in the wind
The people in the audience,
half of them sat on their hands.
The other half burst into
a standing ovation.
That was America.
Johnny Cash was America.
[reporter] Five men
arrested early Saturday,
who were charged with breaking into
the party's national headquarters
at the Watergate in Washington.
[Fred Thompson] Mr. Butterfield,
are you aware
of the installation
of any listening devices
in the Oval Office of the President?
I was aware of listening devices.
Yes, sir.
[Butterfield] I'm from a military family.
Lying was just considered--
We just didn't do it.
[Stielper]
In August 1974, the president resigned
in the face of almost certain impeachment.
John attended the trial of HR Haldeman
amid the trials associated with
the Watergate break-ins.
You guys have to get up awfully early,
don't you?
Watergate was personal to him
because of what it represented,
of what Johnny Cash was always seeing
as the nobility
of the American people.
And when our leaders let us down,
he felt it very personally.
So, here is Johnny Cash watching
HR Haldeman on trial,
who had been at the White House
four years before
for Johnny's White House performance.
Haldeman turned to John and said,
"I'm sorry. I let you down."
If Johnny were here today,
and he is in spirit,
he'd play that song.
I'm going to go request it to be played
on the airwaves,
because that message in that song,
"What is Truth,"
needs to be heard today.
[John Carter] It was not long after
his performance at the White House
that Dad released the song "Man in Black."
And if you want to understand
what my dad stood for,
the words to the song "Man in Black"
exemplify that.
I wear the black for the poor
And the beaten-down
Livin'in the hopeless
Hungry side of town
And I wear it for the prisoner
Who has long paid for his crime
Butstill is there because
He's the victim of the times
I'm the man in black
[crowd whistling, applauding]