Stalked by My Amish Boyfriend (2024) Movie Script
[soft music]
[birds chirping]
[hooves clopping]
[crow cawing]
[horse whinnying]
[broom swishing]
[dog barking]
Hello?
Is someone there?
[ominous music]
[tense music]
[Rachel gasps]
[Isaiah chuckles]
Isaiah, you scared me.
[Isaiah chuckles]
[Rachel gasps]
[peaceful music]
[dog barking]
[Rachel panting]
We can't.
Well, when?
Tonight, down by the lake.
Okay, go. I have
to clean. [giggles]
[water swishes]
[ominous music]
[horse whinnying]
[water splashes]
[feet plodding]
Oh?
Hi.
What are you doing here?
I have to go.
Anna, she told me
to clean, so--
[Rachel panting]
We'll talk later, okay?
[Rachel panting]
[Rachel screams]
[head cracks]
[birds chirping]
[intense music]
[eerie music]
[upbeat music]
[girls laughing]
[Jenna] There is nothing wrong
with using your femininity
to get what you want in life.
And honestly, I would've
done it a lot more.
He has got that distinguished
zaddy vibe going on. [laughs]
Oh, summer's gonna be
so boring without you!
- I invited you to come along.
- Hey.
Youabandoned me!
Come with me?
I can't.
It's my mom's birthday
in a few weeks,
and I don't wanna
leave him alone for it.
Girl, I get it.
It's just, it's the first
summer since kindergarten
that we've been apart.
There you ladies are.
Dad! You're home early.
[Grant] Yeah, I
was thinking of
throwing some burgers
on the grill.
Jen, are you staying for dinner?
Yeah, I'd love to, Mr. B.,
but I can't.
I gotta go home and pack.
You guys going on a trip?
Not me. Just her.
[Jenna] Well, I stupidly agreed
to go on a six-week sailing trip
with my mother and her new
boyfriend, lucky number 27.
[Carly chuckles]
Promised her I'd give this
one an actual chance, though.
Why aren't you going?
It's not your
arrhythmia, is it?
No, I just...
want a relaxing summer.
That's all.
Carly!
Dad, drop it.
It's my decision, okay?
Okay.
I'll light the grill.
- [Carly] Love you.
- [Grant] Love you more!
[Carly chuckles]
[uplifting music]
[Carly] So just a muffin
and a latte for me.
[Barista] You got it.
Scan right there.
[phone chiming]
Oh, it's my dad, sorry.
Hey, Dad.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
No, it doesn't
close until noon.
I can pick up everything.
A muffin.
Thank you.
Uh-huh, no, I have
plenty of time.
Don't worry, okay?
All right, I love you.
- Ooh, ooh!
- [Abram] Oh!
- [Carly] Oh, I'm--
- I'm so sorry.
I'mso sorry!
My coffee, it's all
over your shoes.
[Abram]
It's fine. It's no big deal.
- [Carly] Oh, geez.
- It's okay, here,
I'll buy you another one.
- Seriously?
- [Abram] Yeah.
It's not your fault.
I mean, if anything, Ishould
be buying youone and, um--
- [Abram] It's fine.
- And a pair of new shoes.
- No, it's okay. I got it.
- [Carly chuckles]
Yeah, I'll buy
her another, uh--
What did you have?
Uh, just a latte.
[Abram]
Can I get justa latte?
[Carly chuckles]
I mean, it's the least
I can do, you know.
Oh, and, um, black
coffee for me.
- How much is that?
- Uh, $7.50.
Okay.
[Carly giggles]
Am I short?
Uh, four more cents.
[Abram]
Four more pennies.
One--
Thanks.
You're not from
around here, are you?
How can you tell?
I don't know.
I mean, Midwest
people are nice,
but there's something
different about you?
I'm visiting, uh, sort of,
on kind of a sabbatical,
I think you call it?
Like from work?
From my community.
Are you Amish?
Born and bred.
I hope this doesn't
come out wrong,
but you don't lookAmish.
Well, looks can be deceiving.
[Carly chuckles]
I'm on Rumspringa.
Ditched the hat
and the suspenders
for the appropriate
English attire.
English?
[Abram] It's just what we
call non-Amish people.
The ones who speak
English, anyway.
- [Barista] Here you go.
- [Abram] Thanks.
[Carly] So, wait, from what I
do know about the Amish,
which is very little,
I thought they did
Rumspringa at like 16, right?
Yeah.
- You've done your research.
- [Carly chuckles]
[Abram] So there's Old-Order
Amish, New-Order,
and everything in between.
And, each one of those
has their own Ordnung.
It's like our agreed-upon laws,
but even then, every
individual family is different.
So, it's really up to you--
Uh, you need to--
Excuse me, ma'am.
I, I can get--
I'll get that for you.
Oh, thank you.
- Thank you.
- [Abram] You got it.
[Carly giggles]
That was very nice. [chuckles]
[Abram] Well, she's really
sweet.
[Carly] Yeah.
Okay, so, um, tell me then,
why Rumspringa now and
not when you were 16?
I planned on it,
but, um,
then my mom got sick,
so I stayed back to help her.
She hung on for a while,
even started to get better,
but then things
just took a turn.
After she passed, I just--
I just stayed back
with my family
'cause I couldn't
bear to see them
mourn by themselves, you know?
I know exactly what you mean.
Um, my mom also passed away
recently, a few months ago.
So now I just feel super
protective of my dad.
I am so sorry.
It seems like we've been
through the exact same thing.
[Carly]
Sorry for yours, too.
So you're what now?
Sowing your wild oats
or something? [laughs]
I'm trying to live life
like the English do.
So I just bought
myself an old truck.
Ooh.
[Abram]
And, uh, check this out;
- got a phone.
- [Carly] Oh?
- Can I see it?
- Sure.
I haven't seen
this kind of relic
in a very long time.
- [Abram] It's not a relic.
It is a fine phone.
[Carly] Okay!
Wow, it even has a camera.
- [Carly giggles]
- [Abram] Mmm-hmm.
Hey, should we take a picture?
I've never done one before.
- Sure.
- [Carly] Okay.
Um--
I don't think it has
a front camera here.
- Come in here.
- [Abram] Okay, yeah.
[Carly giggles]
- Okay, uh--
- Yeah.
Yeah.
Okay, ready?
One, two, three.
[camera clicks]
[giggles] It's cute.
[Carly chuckles]
There you go. [chuckles]
- Wow.
- [Carly laughing]
[Abram]
You know, in my community,
we're not even allowed to have
pictures of ourselves, so--
- [Carly] Oh, I'm sorry.
- No, it's okay.
This is--
This is really great.
Well, um, actually,
I need to go.
- Oh, it's okay.
- [Carly] I'm sorry.
But it was really nice
meeting you, um--
- Oh, Abram.
- [Carly] Carly,
and I hope to see you around.
- Mmm-hmm.
- Bye.
Uh, Carly?
Yeah?
[Abram] I don't know
anyone around here.
Do you think I
could see you again?
Yeah.
Yeah, totally, um--
Let me have your phone
and I'll put my number in.
Okay.
[laughs] Great.
I should be the first
one on your call list.
Well, give me a ring sometime.
- [Abram] I will.
- Or you can text me.
Does that phone text?
- [Carly giggles]
- [Abram] Yes, it does.
- Okay, bye.
- Bye.
[ominous music]
[birds chirping]
[hooves clopping]
[Abram laughing]
[Carly giggles]
Uh-oh, I know that look.
What's his name?
His name is Abram, and
he's just a friend.
That is not the look of a girl
who is texting with a friend.
Fine.
He's very kind and sweet.
[Grant]
You deserve kind and sweet.
[gentle music]
[traffic humming]
[Carly] So my mom bought this
necklace for my sixth birthday.
Yeah?
Had a hummingbird
charm on it, [chuckles]
and it was silver and had a
little turquoise on the wings.
That's cute.
[Carly] I wore it every day.
It was like a limb.
But then one day,
shortly after she died,
it just disappeared.
I literally cried for days,
but it was just a thing, but--
It was your connection to her!
Yeah.
[phone chimes]
Oh, um,
I'm actually supposed
to meet my dad.
- I'm sorry.
- It's okay.
- See you tomorrow?
- Yeah.
[stern music]
[stern music continues]
[Grant] We sure do
miss you, honey.
Wish?
Same time?
- [Carly] Yeah.
- Yeah.
[Both] One, two, three.
[ominous music]
[crickets chirping]
[Carly] I'll go get some
plates and some forks.
Sound good?
[intense music]
[birds chirping]
[wind rustling]
[Carly] This lake is one of my
favorite spots in town.
Wait, do you see--
Hang on, past this bush,
do you see the gazebo there?
- [Abram] Yeah.
[Carly] That's actually where
my parents got engaged.
My dad proposed to
my mom right there.
That's really sweet.
It's kind of a special spot.
Since you shared
something special with me,
I, I actually got you something.
- [chuckles] Really?
- [Abram] Yeah.
[gentle music]
[Carly] Oh?
[Carly gasps]
[Abram] I searched every
jewelry and thrift store
in a 50-mile radius.
What?
I doubt it's the exact
same one your mom got you,
but I think it's pretty close.
It's perfect.
I can't believe you
did this for me!
Thank you.
Hey.
Come here.
[peaceful music]
Was that okay?
[chuckles] More than okay.
[Carly giggles] I can't
believe you got me this.
It's so sweet.
- [Abram] Wanna try it on?
- [Carly] Sure!
[Abram panting]
Are you sure you wanna do this?
[soft music]
[soft music continues]
[soft music continues]
- [Abram laughing]
- [Carly laughing]
[Carly] Hey that's not what
I said!
[Abram]
It's not bright red.
- It's, it's--
- [giggles] I meant the shape.
Maybe my hair in 50 years,
but not exactly now.
Maybe you're right.
I really like your
perception, though.
- You're really good. [chuckles]
- [chuckles] Yeah.
You have a good imagination.
Mm, man, I can't believe
this summer's almost over.
I don't want it to end.
[Carly sighs]
Well, it doesn't
have to, you know?
I mean,
look, I go back to
school in a week
and you're going back home.
Remember?
What if I didn't?
What if I stayed here with you?
You're really sweet,
but I'm not staying here, Abram.
[Abram sighs]
I mean, this summer's
been amazing.
Totally unexpected. [chuckles]
I'm never gonna forget it,
or forget you.
[unsettling music]
But I think it's
time we both go back
to our separate worlds.
You gonna be okay?
Yeah.
I mean, what do
you want me to say?
It's okay.
I understand.
We'll see each other.
Okay.
I gotta go.
[ominous music]
Bye.
[ominous music continues]
[door clicking]
[door thudding]
- Carly?
- [Carly] Right here!
Oh, I hate that I have
to leave you right now.
Carly, we've been over this.
[Carly]
I'm only an hour away.
- I can come home on weekends.
- Don't you dare.
Did you get your extra meds?
Yep, got 'em.
- [Grant] All right?
- [Carly] Okay, I'll be fine.
[Grant] All right, drive safe.
[Carly] I will.
- Love you.
- [Grant] Love you more.
[engine starts]
[ominous music]
[stern music]
[distant police siren]
[gentle music]
- [Jenna squeals] Hey!
- [Carly] Hi!
[Jenna] I thought you
would never get here.
- [Carly] I'm so excited.
- [Jenna] So happy to see you.
[Jenna] So what did you do
this summer without me?
Well, [giggles]
I actually met someone.
Spill.
[chuckles] His name is Abram.
He's really cute, unbelievably
sweet, and he's... Amish.
You're dating an Amish guy?
[Carly chuckles]
- [Jenna] So naughty! [laughs]
- [Carly] Okay, not--
We're notdating,
but we just hung out.
Mm.
[Carly] He had to go back.
I mean, he was on Rumspringa.
And honestly, it was one of
the best summers I've ever had.
[ominous music]
[students chattering]
[thudding]
Oh, sorry, I--
[gentle music]
Carly?
Abram?
What, what are you doing here?
Well, I, um,
I go to college here.
What--
What are youdoing here?
Oh, um, I just enrolled.
"Enrolled"?
Yeah. [laughs]
[Carly] In college?
Yeah, um, I guess
we both go here now.
[chuckles] Okay.
Oh, after you.
Thanks.
[Abram] You showed me this whole
side of English life
that I had never expected.
I want to know more.
I want to learn more.
I want to experience more.
I just have this thirst for
life I'd never had before.
Yeah.
Did I tell you that I go here?
You didn't follow me, did you?
No, I had no idea.
I mean, this is crazy.
[chuckles] Yeah.
It's a big step.
Are you okay
with leaving everything
you've ever known behind you?
I just think there's so
much more out there for me.
Wait, I thought education
stopped for the Amish
in eighth grade?
How did you get them
to let you in here?
Uh, so back in my old
community, I was actually able
to complete a high school
curriculum by mail,
so I have a high school diploma.
I didn't know you could do that.
[Abram]
It's not common at all,
but, um, I was actually able
to convince my community
that my education would
be good for all of us.
Well, how would
you like to learn
what a real college
party is like?
[upbeat music]
- [Partier] Let's see you, baby!
- [Partier] Woo!
- Yeah, baby!
- [students cheering]
- [Partier laughs] Nice.
- [Partier] Woo!
[students chattering]
[student laughing]
- [Jenna] Hey.
- [Partier] Hey, Jenna!
- [Partier] Hey, girl.
- [Partier] You look great.
- [Jenna] Yes, hey!
- [Partier] Woo!
- [Partier] Whoa, awesome.
- [Jenna] Hi.
[Jenna] Nice!
[upbeat music continues]
- [Partier] Hi.
- [Jenna] Get it, get it, get it!
- Ah, there you are.
- Oh my God, hi.
- Oh, you look so amazing.
- So do you.
Hey, this guy from your
class, Wyatt something,
he came by looking for you.
He had to go, but he said
he was gonna hit you up.
- Girl, he's cute.
- [Carly] I know, I know.
- He's just a friend.
- [Jenna] Okay, well,
where were you?
- [Carly] I had to change, duh.
[giggles] Hey, wait, um, do
you remember that guy
that I was telling
you about this summer?
- Abram?
- [Jenna] Yeah, the Amish guy?
[Carly]
Yeah, well, he's here.
Apparently he just enrolled
at Southern Penn University.
[Jenna] So what, he followed
you here or something?
What?
No, no, he didn't
even know I go here.
It's just a crazy coincidence.
Wait, I want you to meet him.
Abram, Abram, come
here, come here.
Abram, Jenna. Jenna, Abram.
Jenna's been my best friend
since we were like five.
Nice to meet you.
I've heard so much about you.
Oh, wish I could say the same.
So tell me, Abram, how is it
that you found yourself here?
Say again?
How is it that you
found yourself here?
Oh, Carly brought me.
She told me about tonight.
No, I mean, at Southern Penn.
You meet Carly
and then somehow you enroll
at the same college as her?
- Jenna, stop.
- [Jenna] What?
[Carly] She grills everyone.
Don't worry about it.
She's gonna grill you, too.
Um, you want a drink?
Yes.
Okay, um, the keg
is in the kitchen?
Yeah, it's in the kitchen.
It's really nice to meet you.
[Jenna] Sure, you too.
[upbeat music continues]
[unsettling music]
I think I'm falling in
love with you, Carly.
[ominous music]
[students chattering]
[Carly] Wait, he did not
say that!
[Jenna] Wait, who is this?
Our philosophy professor.
And yes, he absolutely
called himself
- Marcus Aurelius incarnate.
- [Jenna laughing]
- Marcus Aurelius incarnate!
- [Carly giggling]
You must have been distracted
by my bulging bicep.
[Carly] Oh. [laughs]
- Hey, baby.
- [Carly] Hey!
[lips smacking]
[unsettling music]
[Abram] Um, sorry, I didn't
mean to interrupt.
What's so funny?
Oh, nothing, just something
Wyatt was talking about.
Wyatt?
Abram Mast, it's really
nice to meet you.
Nice handshake you got there.
I'm Carly's boyfriend.
- [Wyatt] Nice to meet you.
- [Abram] Yeah.
[Jenna]
So Abram's your boyfriendnow?
Mm, maybe. [giggles]
What?
I didn't say anything.
No, but I know that you wantto.
So why don't you save us
both the time and torture
and say it?
Fine, he creeps me out.
[Carly] Abram?
Why? He's so sweet.
[scoffs] Exactly!
He is hot, he is
sweet, it's unnatural.
You always see the
worst in people.
[Jenna] Seriously, there's
something about the guy!
Already calling
you his girlfriend
when you guys just
reconnected a couple days ago.
And then did you realize
he just popped in there
the second you started
talking to another guy?
Okay, he was on his
way to class, Jen.
Mm, yeah, that's another thing.
You guys spent an
entire summer together
and then he just
happens to enroll
at the same college as you?
How would he have known
what college I was going to?
Uh, he could've Googled it.
It's all over your
social media, girl!
Okay, well, he's Amish.
They're not exactly
considered tech savvy.
I mean, he barely knows
how to send an email,
let alone engage in some
light internet stalking.
Maybe he's a little much,
but social norms are
different where he's from.
You don't honestly fully
believe that, do you?
[Carly]
Jen, he's a nice guy,
and I like being with him.
We have chemistry.
And also, his mom died, too.
And he's the only one
who really knows what
I'm going through.
That's not true. I lost my dad.
I know, but he walked
out on your mom.
He didn't die.
He's dead to me.
[phone chiming]
Speaking of dads, time for
my weekly chat with mine.
- Okay, bye.
- [Jenna] Bye.
[Carly] Hi, Dad.
[stern music]
Hey. Sean, right?
Remember me? Jenna?
We sit next to each
other in American Lit.
Oh, yeah, hey.
I was wondering if you
could do me a favor.
I need some information
on a student.
Oh, I, I don't think I'm allowed
to give anything like that out.
No?
I can tell you don't
follow the rules.
Well, uh...
Yeah, sure, maybe I
can tell you something.
Who is it you need
to know about?
His name's Abram Mast.
I got nothing here, I'm sorry.
I, I don't see anything.
[unsettling music]
Thanks anyway.
[Lecturer] That's it.
Have a great weekend, everyone.
[students chattering]
- I gotta go.
- Yeah, you do.
- [Carly chuckles]
- Bye.
Bye.
[unsettling music continues]
Boy, you seem to be everywhere
with her these days.
Uh, I like her a lot.
I'm guessing you do, too?
Yeah, she's an amazing person.
That's why we've
been best friends
for practically
our entire lives.
But you, you just
kinda popped into it.
I, I'm sorry, Jenna, did
I do something wrong?
It just seems like you
don't trust me or something.
Sort of hard to trust liars.
Especially ones
stalking my best friend.
I don't--
What are you talking about?
You never enrolled
at this school,
but somehow here you are.
Yeah, I am here,
so you must be mistaken.
I don't think I am.
You're right about
one thing, though.
I don't trust you.
The problem with Carly
is that she doesn't
wanna hurt anyone.
She's too nice.
Luckily for her, I am
not, so I'll say it.
It's nevergonna work out
between the two of you
so just leave her alone.
I haven't told her about your
little secret yet, but I will.
Bye, Abram.
[unsettling music continues]
[Student] Good luck on the test.
All right, I'll see you
in class. [chuckles]
[Student] See ya.
[door clicks]
[door thudding]
[Jenna clears throat]
[object thuds]
[Jenna clears throat]
[ominous music]
[phone chimes]
[Jenna giggles]
[suspenseful music]
Ah!
[fist thumps]
[dog barking]
[unsettling music]
[Carly] Oh my God.
Oh my God, Jenna.
Hey,
you okay?
[Jenna] I got hit on the side
of the head by some freak,
but I'm fine.
Jenna and I was just
having a little chat
about what she remembers
from last night.
Yeah, it's all kind of
a blur right now, but--
[Officer] Do you have any idea
who might have done this?
No.
No, not at all.
[Officer]
Well, if you think of anything
that might help us in
this investigation,
please let us know.
Absolutely.
- You take care, okay?
- [Jenna] Got it.
- [Carly] Come on.
- All right.
Let's get you inside, okay?
Here.
Thanks.
It's so weird.
I didn't even take anything.
Just doesn't make any sense.
Listen, I didn't
tell police this,
but I think I know who did it.
Who?
Abram.
You're kidding, right?
Why would he even do
something like that?
[Jenna] Because I told him to
stay away from you.
He's a liar, Carly.
He never actually
enrolled in this school.
I confirmed that with
administration yesterday.
So you were... what?
Investigating him?
What if it's just missing
paperwork or a clerical error?
[Jenna] I think he is
dangerously obsessed with you.
Dangerously obsessed?
You know what I think?
I think maybe
you're just jealous.
Jealous over what?
[Carly] That he and I got so
close this summer
when you were gone?
That we're getting
even closer now?
Why would I care about that?
Because you do this
with every guy I date.
You just wanna control
everyone around me.
And if you don't like them,
you just find a way for
me to get rid of them.
That is so off base!
I am just looking out for you,
'cause God knows you don't
look out for yourself.
Abram is a stalker.
Carly, you need to
break up with this guy
before something
bad happens to you!
[sighs] You just can't stand it
when I spend time with
anyone other than you.
You know, not everyone
is your dad, Jenna.
Not everyone's gonna leave you.
Wow, that was harsh, Car.
- [Carly] I'm sorry.
- [Jenna] You know what?
I suddenly have a
splitting headache.
Probably from somebody
bashing me in my head.
I'm gonna go lay down.
[Carly sighs]
[unsettling music continues]
[Abram] Is something wrong?
Jenna was attacked last night.
What? That's awful.
Is she okay?
She's shaken up,
but she'll be fine.
That's terrible.
[Carly] She also told me you
weren't enrolled at the school.
Is that true?
Wait, you don't think
that, like, um--
No, uh--
No.
Well, except she's right.
No, it's, [sighs]
I did apply, and I thought
I was accepted, but as--
[Abram sighs]
But as it turns out,
my, my mail order
diploma wasn't credited.
I got scammed.
I found out the
day after I saw you
on the quad for the first time,
and I was so embarrassed, I--
I didn't know what to tell you,
and I'm so sorry I lied
and I never should have.
It's okay.
I get it.
[gentle music]
- [Wyatt] So then I said--
- [Carly] Uh-uh.
[Wyatt] Let's not put that
cart before the horse.
- [Wyatt laughs]
- [laughs] You're so stupid.
[Wyatt] I am stupid.
That's why I'm a
philosophy major.
[Carly laughing]
[phone chiming]
- Sorry.
- [Wyatt] Oh, you're good.
Oh, I gotta go.
- See you in class?
- [Carly] Okay, yeah, for sure.
[phone chimes]
[unsettling music]
[Carly sighs]
[ominous music]
[keys tapping]
[message whooshing]
[students chattering]
[ominous music continues]
[phone chiming]
[phone chiming continues]
[Carly sighs]
[ominous music]
[phone ringing]
[phone buzzing]
[ominous music continues]
[Grant Voicemail] Hi, this is
Grant. Leave a message.
[Carly gasps]
[suspenseful music]
[engine humming]
[Carly panting]
[suspenseful music continues]
Dad?
Dad!
Dad?
Dad!
- Dad, oh my God!
- Hey, babe.
You didn't answer your
calls or your texts.
- Where's your phone?
- [Grant] I didn't have it on me.
[unsettling music]
Abram's here.
Hey, Carly.
[Grant] We just been chatting,
looking at baby pictures.
[Abram]
This one's my favorite.
- Ooh, looky, looky, looky.
- Pinch the little cheekies.
- [Grant laughing]
- [Abram laughing]
[Abram] I love pinching
her little cheeks.
[Grant] I wish I could still
pinch 'em. [laughs]
- [Abram] Adorable.
- [Grant] I miss that.
Yeah, that's great. Um--
Abram, can I talk to
you outside for a minute?
- Sure.
- [Grant] Yeah, go ahead.
Go ahead. Don't
worry about me.
We'll get back to
this later, go ahead.
[unsettling music continues]
[door thudding]
What?
Is this some kind of threat?
"Threat"?
Why would I threaten you?
I don't--
What are you doing here?
Coming in and sending
me photos of my dad?
You weren't
answering your calls,
and I missed you,
and I thought--
I wanted to meet your dad
and I thought you would
appreciate the text.
Appreciate it?
Listen, Abram,
this is messed up.
You can't do stuff like this.
What stuff?
Coming to my house to meet
my dad without me here?
The constant calls and texts?
Showing up wherever I go?
It's bordering on stalking.
I'm sorry, I didn't know.
It's fine.
I'll do better.
Okay, I promise I will,
just, you know, teach me.
Show me how to be.
Abram.
[Abram] What?
I think we need to take a break.
Look, I like you.
I just--
I can't be in a
relationship right now.
It's my senior year of college.
My mom just passed away.
Like, I just, I need
to focus on myself.
I love you.
I love you, Carly.
You should go.
I love you, Carly.
[Carly] Please go.
- I--
- [Carly] Just go.
Please, just go, Abram, okay?
Just go, Abram.
[door thudding]
[unsettling music continues]
- [Carly laughs] Stop it, Wyatt.
- [Wyatt laughing]
I need to study.
[Wyatt] We are!
[Carly] Okay, I officially
cannot concentrate,
thank you very much.
[chuckles] Well, me either.
Hey, wanna get outta here?
Get some food?
- Yeah, let's go.
- All right.
[gentle music]
[Student]
Hey, how's it going?
[upbeat music]
[dog barking]
[Carly] Hey, thanks
for the ride home.
- I really appreciate it.
- Oh, no problem.
[Carly]
Sounds like there's a party.
Do you wanna go to the party?
- Come on, come inside.
- [Wyatt] Uh--
I know that look. Come on.
I'd love to, but I
should probably study.
No.
No, I wanna see your
dance moves. [giggles]
Mm?
Come here.
All right, okay,
go study, you studious,
studious man, you. [giggles]
This was fun.
[Carly] This was really fun.
Thank you so much--
- [Wyatt] Hey!
- [Carly] Hey!
Abram? What the hell!
You lied to me.
You said you didn't
wanna date anybody.
Wyatt's just my friend.
But I love you.
Don't you see that?
- [Carly] You're insane!
- [Wyatt] Man, leave her alone!
[fist thumping]
[Wyatt grunts]
[Carly] Oh my God!
Wyatt!
Wyatt?
Are you--
[gasps] Oh my God.
[Carly panting]
Oh my-- Wyatt?
[ominous music]
Oh my God, you--
You killed him?
Oh my God.
[gasps] Oh my God.
What are you doing?
Calling the police.
- Hey!
- No, I don't think so.
Abram, give me my phone back!
No, no.
Help, help!
- Help me!
- [Abram] No, don't do that!
- [Carly] Hey!
- [Abram] Don't do that.
- Don't do that.
- [Carly screaming muffled]
Shh, shh.
[birds chirping]
[Carly grunts]
[eerie music]
[Carly panting]
[eerie music continues]
[Carly whimpering]
[Carly whimpering continues]
[unsettling music]
[Carly grunting]
[suspenseful music]
Help, help, help!
Help me!
[Carly screams]
Shh.
- [Carly whimpering]
- Shh.
Don't scream.
It's annoying, okay?
It's okay, I'm not gonna hurt
you, but you can't scream.
- Okay?
- Mm.
- You're gonna be good?
- [Carly whimpers]
Okay.
Great.
[Carly panting]
Where--
Where am I?
You're safe.
I'm sorry I had to do that.
It's just you were gonna go to
the police and I, I can't...
If you let me go, I
won't talk to the police.
I won't talk to
anyone about anything.
He's not dead.
Wyatt?
That's, that's good.
But I hurt him
really bad.
He's in a coma,
and if he wakes up and
remembers what happened, then--
I could tell the police
that you thought
he was attacking me
and that you were just
trying to protect me.
I was.
Yeah, I wastrying
to protect you.
You believe me, right, Carly?
[unsettling music]
I do,
but, Abram, you can't
keep me tied up here.
You have to let me go.
I want you to see how
much I care about you
and that I'm nota bad man.
I do too.
I see that.
Good.
But I can't let you go.
Not yet.
What?
No one can hear you scream.
If I was you, I'd get some rest.
Abram, wait! Wait, Abram!
[door thudding]
[lock clicking]
Abram!
Abram, Abram!
[door banging]
[Abram] No one can
hear you scream.
Get some rest.
[Carly panting]
Help me!
Hello?
Oh my God. [gasps]
Help me!
[Abram] Carly, no
one can hear you.
[ominous music]
Ah!
[Abram] Carly, go to bed!
[Carly screams]
[Carly sobbing]
[Carly Voicemail] Hi, you've
reached Carly Brooks.
I can't come to
the phone right now
so please leave me a message.
[phone beeps]
Okay, if you are with
him, I'm not mad.
Just please let me know.
You didn't come home last night
and you turned off your phone.
Carly, really, what the heck?
I just wanna make sure you're
okay, so call me back, please!
[Jenna sighs]
[ominous music]
[Carly grunts]
[Carly panting]
[Carly grunting]
[Carly grunts]
[Carly panting]
[suspenseful music]
[shoes tapping]
[Carly gasps]
[door thudding]
I thought you might be hungry.
[Carly]
Why did you lock me in here?
[Abram] I mean, I can't
let you out there.
Not until I'm sure you're
not gonna try and run.
What are you gonna do with me?
So the biscuits are
made with buttermilk.
That's some kind of
egg, bacon, and, um, oh,
gravy.
It's good.
All right, I'm just
gonna leave this for you
whenever you're ready.
Abram, wait.
Can I call my dad or Jenna
just to let them know I'm okay?
They'll be worried if they
haven't heard from me.
Wait, Abram, wait.
Wait, come back, I--
[door closes and latches]
Why are you leaving?
What do you want with me?
[door bangs]
[unsettling music]
[siren wailing]
[phone chimes]
[eerie music]
"I think we need
some space, Jen.
I've decided to
stay with Abram."
Oh.
[Jenna gasps]
[birds chirping]
[horse whinnying]
[crow cawing]
[people murmuring]
[horse snorting]
[crow cawing]
[birds chirping]
[crow cawing]
[stern music]
[Carly whimpering]
[Abram] Morning, sleepyhead.
[Carly gasps]
Abram, [sighs]
what time is it?
I really don't feel well.
7 a.m.
You've been sleeping
all morning and night.
You must be exhausted.
Where's my bag?
[sighs] I have it.
I need it.
Why?
I have a medication that
I need to take, I--
I've already skipped a day.
Please, Abram.
I feel really weak and sick.
[stern music continues]
[shoes tapping]
[Carly sighs]
[bag thumps]
It'll be in the side pocket.
I don't see a
prescription bottle.
It'll be in a floral pill box.
[unsettling music]
I don't see it.
Must have fallen out.
Okay, listen to me, Abram.
I have a heart condition.
It's called cardiac arrhythmia.
I--
I neethat medication!
Why didn't you tell
me about this before?
Does it matter?
I need you to take me to
a pharmacy or a doctor
- [Abram sighs]
- or the hospital or something.
I can't do that.
You have to.
[Abram] I can't.
I can't.
Abram, if I don't have that
medication, I could die.
[Abram]
I'm not taking you to a doctor!
So forget it!
[Carly gasps]
No, you have to, please.
The reason why you're sick
is because you're not
eating the food I made you.
Please, Abram, I could die.
Abram!
Abram, no, please!
Please don't go!
[lock clicking]
Abram!
[Carly sobbing]
[Abram grunts]
[Carly sobbing continues]
[Abram grunts]
[feet stomping]
[Carly sobbing continues]
Oh, please!
[stern music]
[Jenna sighs]
[gentle music]
[unsettling music]
[suspenseful music]
[door clicking]
There's someone
here to help you.
Yes.
Oh, please.
She was adamant that she
wants to see you, though.
I won't say anything.
I'm gonna need some
assurances, Carly.
I promise.
Please.
You're wearing the
necklace I bought you.
What are you doing?
[sighs] Getting you ready.
Take these off.
You asked me about
where you were.
You're in a new community
of Amish people.
We came together,
formed a place for
people like us.
We have our own Ordnung,
rules that we created that work,
for people like us.
[unsettling music]
They are rules
that are better for us.
Here, I'll let you do this.
[eerie music]
We are accepting,
a welcoming group,
unlike the communities we left.
I think you'll really--
I'd like it if you'll
give it a chance.
Okay, let's look at you.
You look so beautiful.
So beautiful.
[gentle music]
And by the way,
I know where your dad and
your best friend live,
but I hope it
won't come to that.
[unsettling music]
I don't wanna hurt
anyone anymore.
Especially you.
It's called foxglove.
I grow it myself.
I've been using it for years.
It's safe in the proper dosage.
It contains the
compound digoxin,
the same one they use
in heart medications.
I'm sure you know of it.
It's such a beautiful plant,
but deceptively potent.
I use it for a lot of things.
For you, it will help
prevent any arrhythmias.
Thank you.
I'm Mona, by the way. [laughs]
Carly.
Not a typical Amish name,
but, um, we're not exactly
typical here either.
We're pretty...
unorthodox.
I'll leave this
tincture with you.
You just add five drops
to your tea, no more.
It can cause side effects,
nausea, vomiting, dizziness.
But I'll come back
and check on you,
make sure you're
handling everything okay.
Mona, I'm not
sure how to thank you.
It's no need.
It's my job.
Okay.
Thank you.
[Mona] You're welcome.
[ominous music]
Thank you, Abram.
Of course.
Told you I'd take care of you.
[ominous music continues]
Why don't you get some rest?
No, wait.
[door slams and latches]
[engine humming]
Jenna, what are you doing here?
Have you heard from Carly?
I got a few text messages,
but she canceled our
weekly face chat.
Why? What's wrong?
I think she's been kidnapped.
What?
[Jenna]
I, I know that sounds crazy,
but she hasn't been back to
the apartment in two days
and the first text message
that I get from her
says that she wants
to stay with Abram
because she's mad at me.
The Amish guy she's
been hanging out with?
[Jenna]
And there's something else.
There was another student
attacked on campus
the night that she went missing.
- Oh God.
- [Jenna] She knew him.
And I found this
near the crime scene.
[suspenseful music]
That's her medication.
We need to go to the police.
[sighs] Okay, let's
go inside, come on.
[crow cawing]
[ominous music]
[phone cracking]
[Abram grunting]
[suspenseful music]
[drawer clattering]
[Carly sighs]
[birds chirping]
[ominous music]
[reins clinking]
[wheel thuds]
[apple crunches]
[Carly exhales]
[birds chirping]
[Carly grunts]
[teacup smashing]
[Carly gasps]
[Carly panting]
[unsettling music]
[lock clicking]
[suspenseful music]
[door thudding]
[Carly gasping]
[shoes plodding]
[Carly panting]
[Carly gasps]
[stern music]
[Carly panting]
[eerie music]
[Carly panting]
[door creaking]
[shoes plodding]
[suspenseful music]
[Carly screams]
[Abram gasps]
[Carly] No, no, wait!
Abram, stop!
[Carly panting]
- [Carly grunts]
- Carly, stop!
[Carly panting]
What are you doing?
Why did you try and do that?
Because I thought you
were gonna hurt me.
What?
No, no, no.
What you said the other
day about my dad and Jenna,
I just, I didn't know
what you were gonna do.
[Abram]
I would never do that.
I'm sorry.
I let the emotions that I feel
inside get the better of me.
And, and, and I--
I, I shouldn't have.
I, I'm sorry. Please forgive me.
I'm sorry, too.
Forgive me?
[Carly gasps]
[unsettling music]
Of course I forgive you.
Please forgive me.
Please forgive me.
Okay.
[wolf howling]
[Carly]
I'm a little uncomfortable.
I feel like a mummy.
I can't even move.
I'm sorry you feel that way,
but it's not a
punishment, Carly.
It's a courting ritual.
We face each other, look
into each other's eyes
so that we can really
get to know each other
without carnal temptation.
We should've been doing
this from the beginning.
You don't have to
be afraid of me.
It's just that, here,
women are submissive
to their husbands.
"Husbands"?
It's God's will, Carly,
that we'll be together.
I want you to see how
beautiful it can really be.
And what if I don't like it?
You will.
You just have to give
this life a chance.
[sighs] Don't reject me, Carly.
It'll only get more
difficult for you.
Goodnight.
[Officer] Well, I'm not sure
you have a case here
if you're both getting
text messages from her.
[Jenna]
They're not from her.
They don't sound
like my daughter.
[Jenna] Saying that she's
in love with him
and she's run away
to be with him?
No. [scoffs]
Well, I've seen it before.
[Jenna] He is a psycho.
She would never run
off with this guy.
Yeah, it's definitely
not in her character.
[Jenna] Because he is the
one sending the messages.
[Grant] Look, I have no doubt
that you've seen a lot, okay,
but I know my daughter.
She canceled our weekly face
chat, and that is not like her.
[Officer] But that doesn't mean
she's been kidnapped.
Well, that does mean
something isn't right.
I have a daughter, too.
I understand both
of your concerns.
I'll go back to the station,
file a missing persons report.
But if it turns out
she did run away
to one of these
Amish communities,
it'll be like finding
a needle in a haystack.
They're not exactly
in the system.
I'm sorry.
I wish there was something
else we could do,
but if you think of anything
or find something else,
please, let us know.
We'll let ourselves out.
Thanks.
[stern music]
Why do I feel like we're
on our own for this one?
Because we are.
If there's anything
that I've learned
in my 40-plus years
on this planet,
it's if you want
something done right,
we're gonna have
to do it ourselves.
[birds chirping]
Let us pray.
[table bangs]
[cutlery clinking]
Pray!
Lord in heaven,
hallowed be Thy name,
give us this day our daily bread
and deliver us from evil, amen.
Amen.
[cutlery clinking]
[Abram munching]
[cutlery clinking]
Abram, I wanted--
Silent supper means no talking.
[Abram slurping]
[meat squelching]
[door knocking]
[stern music]
[shoes plodding]
- Mona.
- Hey. [chuckles]
What are you doing here?
Um, I just wanted to
check in on Carly.
[Carly panting]
[suspenseful music]
[cutlery clinking]
Well, give her these.
Let her know I came by.
Can do.
[door clicking]
[Carly gasps]
[suspenseful music]
[sighs] She brought
these for you.
[Abram sighs]
[Abram slurping]
[ominous music]
[Abram slurping]
[ominous music continues]
[eerie music]
[suspenseful music]
[drawer thudding]
[unsettling music]
[Abram] Stand up.
But I didn't do--
Stand up!
[unsettling music continues]
[Carly gasps]
[unsettling music continues]
Sit.
[unsettling music continues]
I'm sorry, I just
thought that--
You know.
I don't know what I thought.
[Carly sighs]
[unsettling music continues]
[Carly sighs]
[stern music]
[eerie music]
[Carly panting]
[Carly gasps]
[Carly gags]
[Carly coughing]
[Carly vomiting]
[Carly coughing]
Carly?
[Carly retching]
Carly, are you all right?
[Carly sobbing]
Carly, are you okay?
No, I think I'm reacting
badly to the foxglove.
I don't feel good.
[Abram sighs]
I think I need to see Mona.
[Carly sobbing]
[sighs] I'll get Mona.
[Carly panting]
[Mona] Okay.
And pupils aren't
dilated, so that's good.
I felt nauseous and dizzy and
then I started throwing up.
[Mona] Well, it's probably
the foxglove.
Um, try doing four
drops instead of five.
You should be fine.
Okay.
You said the other day that
this community was unorthodox.
What did you mean?
Well, being a community of, um,
shunned Amish,
we, um, formed our own Ordnung,
a mix of old laws and new.
Some of them are, um,
pretty unconventional.
Everyonehere was shunned?
Isn't that why you're here?
Why were you shunned?
I questioned my faith.
Wasn't allowed in my old
community in here, either,
but, um, no one wants
to be without a tribe.
[Carly]
Have you ever thought of
leaving the Amish
life altogether?
I mean, I've, um,
I've thought about it,
but who do I know there?
I know how you feel.
Sometimes I want to escape, too.
[Abram] How's the patient?
[Mona] Uh, She's, um,
she's fine.
Yeah.
I'd, um,
I'd love to see you
out in the community.
We all have our specific jobs
and I could use your help,
if it's okay with
Abram, of course.
Well, think about it.
Um, see you later.
Bye.
Thank you, Mona.
I'd like that.
[unsettling music]
Being out in the community.
I could see what life
is really like here.
I'd like that, too,
but I need to be able
to trust you, Carly.
Can I do that?
You can trust me.
All right.
Let's go today.
[stern music]
[Jenna] So what
are you doing then?
[Grant] I am searching for
the land records
for any property owners
with the last name Mast.
The deeds will have
a legal description.
If I can find a section,
a lot, a township,
we can plot it on a map and
narrow in on the communities
that his relatives are from.
[computer bleeping]
- Wait.
- [Jenna] What is it?
- Did you find something?
- [Grant] I think so.
So, what, are we gonna do
this the old-fashioned way
and knock on their door?
From what I've heard,
they're not exactly gonna
invite us in for pie.
Yeah, probably not.
[engine humming]
[plate clattering]
[Martha] He hasn't spoken to us
in years,
not since he was shunned.
He kept coming back,
begging to be let back in.
He was most angry and hurt by me
because I would
not change my mind.
And you are--?
Abram's mother.
[Jenna]
He said you were dead.
To him, maybe.
[Jenna] So he didn't willingly
leave on some late Rumspringa
after staying to
take care of you?
No.
Why was he shunned?
Abram was a wonderful son.
He was sweet,
loving, protective,
but he has a
dark side to him,
an uncontrollable,
violent temper.
It wasn't until he
brutally attacked an elder
that he was finally kicked out.
[Sarah] We're very sorry about
your daughter, Mr. Brooks.
If she's with my brother,
then I don't think
we can help you.
[horse whinnying]
[people chattering]
Mona,
will you show Carly how we
gather food for our community?
Of course.
Huh, get you a basket.
It's good to see you out.
Yes, it's good to beout.
[Mona giggles]
[grass rustling]
You said everyone in this
community has been shunned?
Yes.
When I met Abram, he told
me he was on Rumspringa.
Said he stayed back to
take care of his sick mom,
and that when she died, he
didn't wanna leave his family.
From what I know, Abram's
mom is still alive.
He hates her for shunning him.
Why was he shunned?
He doesn't talk about it at all.
But last year, there was
a girl in our community
who Abram was courting, Rachel.
He became increasingly
possessive of her,
almost obsessed.
One night I saw them arguing.
A few days later,
she had an accident.
Accident?
Hit her head on a
rock, died instantly.
But some people don't believe
that's what really happened.
What do you believe?
You're not here by choice,
that Abram is dangerous, and
that you're the new Rachel.
Abram knows these woods
like the back of his hands.
If you go, you have to
have a plan and food.
And even then, he'll find you.
And kill me like he did Rachel.
[stern music]
You know, when I
first met Abram,
he had this green pickup truck.
[Mona] It's behind the barn.
He took me for a
ride in it once.
He keeps the key under
the passenger seat.
[unsettling music]
[unsettling music continues]
[suspenseful music]
[door clicking]
[grass rustling]
[Carly panting]
[tarpaulin rattling]
Oh, okay.
[suspenseful music continues]
Help me.
[Abram grunts]
Carly!
[intense music]
[Carly panting]
[Carly gasping]
[intense music continues]
[Abram] Carly!
[Carly gasps]
[Carly panting]
Carly!
[Carly panting]
[suspenseful music]
[door clicking]
[Abram grunting]
[door slams]
[Abram sighs]
[stern music]
[tarpaulin rattling]
[Abram panting]
[suspenseful music]
[intense music]
Abram, where did you go?
[lantern thuds]
Where were you?
I just went for a walk.
- [Abram] Mm-mm.
- No, I couldn't sleep.
I, I just needed to
get some fresh air.
"I just needed to get
some fresh air." [laughs]
You're a liar.
No, no, I--
[Abram]
You, Carly Brooks,
are a liar,
and lying is a sin.
It's against the rules
of our sacred Ordnung.
I could tell you're
up to something
so I needed to give you a test.
That's why I let the door open
and put the tarp on the truck.
[Abram chuckles]
Oh, the key was not where
you thought it would be?
[Abram chuckles]
You're a fricking psychopath!
[Abram laughing]
Here, women are submissive
to their husband.
You're notmy husband.
[Abram] You have broken two
of our sacred laws.
Now I have to punish you.
I didn't want to do that.
[Carly gasps]
Get some sleep.
Abram--
- I'll see you in the morning.
- What are you gonna do?
What are you gonna do? Please.
[door thudding]
[Abram]
You'll find out in the morning.
Get some rest.
[ominous music]
[crow cawing]
[Abram] Brothers and sisters,
thank you for joining us today.
We gather for a sacred assembly
to discuss matters of
wrongdoing within the community.
Carly Brooks, you stand accused
of violating our sacred Ordnung
and straying from the
path of righteousness.
Others in your position have
faced severe punishment,
but here, we offer you
a chance at redemption.
[horse whinnying]
Wait, no, no.
[Abram]
Acknowledge your sins!
Repent!
Embrace the teachings
of the community.
[stern music]
Abram, I'm sorry.
Please don't do this.
[Abram]
In accordance with our Ordnung,
she will be subjected
to a Meidung
and shunned by the community.
This is so that you
might fully understand
the consequences of
your sins unrepented.
That is all,
everyone. Thank you.
[stern music continues]
[stern music continues]
[Mona] I'm sorry!
Abram, please don't
leave me here.
I'm sorry.
Abram, come back!
[horse whinnying]
[Carly gasps]
[ominous music]
[crickets chirping]
[stern music]
[Carly] Hello, anyone?
Hello?
[dog barking]
[door creaking]
Hello?
Hello, I know--
I know you can't talk to
me, but can you please--
Can you please
give me some water?
- Mona, thank God.
- Shh, someone will hear you.
[Carly gasping]
Thank you.
Mona, I need to get out of here.
He's crazy and he's
going to kill me.
If, if you try to run,
you won't make it.
He's watching every
move you make.
Then, um, we have--
We have to get him
to stop watching.
How?
He wants to believe
that I love him, right?
[stern music]
[Jenna] I posted about Carly
in one of those online sleuthing
groups for missing persons
and immediately got hundreds
of hits from people.
Then there was this girl in
the group whose ex-Amish,
and she said that
she'd heard rumors
about this breakaway
Amish community
that was formed a couple
years ago east of Meadville.
Then there was this woman
who's a real estate agent,
she posted about a
cluster of farmhouses
that were sold years
ago to this developer.
They ended up going bankrupt.
Never did anything
with the properties.
So, then I put the
addresses into maps
and pulled up the street view.
You'd think that
abandoned farmland
would be overgrown,
right, but...
It's been recently plowed.
Good work, Jenna.
[Jenna chuckles]
[eerie music]
[Carly sniffles]
I was wrong.
I understand that now.
I know you love me and you
just want what's best for me.
That's good to hear.
I hope your punishment
serves us well.
I'll be good, I swear.
Heard that before.
But how can I know that you're
telling me the truth, Carly?
Let's get married.
Really?
[Carly] Yes, really.
That way I can prove I love
you and that I'm yours.
You have no idea how
happy this makes me, but
you know a marriage bond
can't be broken, right?
I know that.
Let's do it today.
Today.
[eerie music continues]
[door thudding]
Turn around.
[keys jingling]
Jacob will make the food
and conduct the ceremony.
I'm so happy that
you chose to do this.
[stern music]
[door closes]
Jenna, I need you to stay here.
What? No. I have to go.
I need to see her.
She and I got into a fight,
and that cannot
be the last thing.
She has to know that I love her
and I would come
looking for her.
Look, she knows, okay?
If something happens to me
out there, who's gonna know?
Who's gonna tell anybody?
Okay.
[Grant] All right, you stay here
and you have my back, okay?
- Okay.
- Okay?
All right.
I'll call you as soon
as I know something.
Okay.
[light guitar music]
[crow cawing]
[Jacob]
Brothers and sisters,
we are gathered here in
this beautiful valley
under these beautiful trees
to celebrate and to unite
two beautiful lives.
Come together.
[guitar music continues]
[Both] I promise to
be loyal and faithful
for all days of my life.
[guests applauding]
- Amen. [chuckles]
- [Jacob] Amen!
- [Group of Amish Men] Amen.
- [Abram] Amen.
- [Jacob] Amen, amen.
- [Abram] Amen. [laughs]
- [Jacob] Amen.
- [Carly] Amen.
[eagle calling]
[crickets chirping]
[uplifting music]
[Carly laughing]
[uplifting music continues]
[Carly chuckles]
I'm thirsty.
I'm gonna get some water, okay?
[Abram chuckles] Okay.
[lively folk music]
- [Mona] Here's a beat!
- Oh.
[guests cheering]
[guests laughing]
[lively folk music continues]
[guests clapping]
- Ooh!
- [Mona laughing]
[live folk music continues]
[guests clapping]
Thirsty?
[Abram] Yes.
[giggles] I thought
the Amish didn't dance.
[Abram] We don't. [chuckles]
That's the beauty of this place.
We do what we want.
- Oh, I'm so sorry.
- [Abram] Oh!
Deja vu. [laughs]
- And from your shirt.
- [Abram] That's okay.
- [Carly] I'll go get a towel.
- [Abram] No, it's okay, stay.
I'll change.
I'll be back, my wife.
[lips smacking]
Be careful! It's dark.
[grass rustling]
[lively folk music continues]
[guests clapping]
[guests cheering]
[shoes plodding]
[lively folk music continues]
[guests cheering]
[shoes plodding]
[lively folk music continues]
[guests cheering]
[Carly panting]
[drawer thudding]
[Carly panting]
[lively folk music continues]
[guests cheering]
[Abram] Hey, Mona!
Where's Carly?
I'm not sure.
You're not sure?
- [Mona gasps]
- Where is she?
She, um, she left.
- She left?
- [Mona] I, I guess.
- [Abram] What?
- Um, she left!
You helped her.
- No, no, no, no, no.
- [Abram] Yes.
- Yes, you did.
- No, I didn't, no.
She just, she went
running toward the woods.
Liar!
[suspenseful music]
[Carly panting]
[dramatic music]
[Carly panting]
[Abram panting]
[suspenseful music]
[tarpaulin whooshing]
[Carly panting]
[suspenseful music continues]
[Carly panting]
Hey!
Hey, help!
Help, wait, stop!
Wait, stop, stop, stop!
Oh, stop!
Wait, oh my God! [gasps]
Thank you!
[sobs] Thank you!
[stern music]
[door slams]
[Abram] Why'd you run?
- Abram!
- Why did you run?
- Why did you run?
- Help me!
- Help me!
- What are you doing?
- [Carly] Help me, help!
- What are you doing?
- Why are you doing this?
- [Carly gasping]
Why are you doing this?
You're leaving me?
- You're leaving me?
- [Carly panting]
You stalked me, targeted me.
You made up whatever lie you
could to get close to me.
Your mom didn't die.
You weren't on Rumspringa.
She shunned you!
You're making things up
in your head, Carly!
- You're outcasted
by your entire community
because you're a sinner!
That's not true.
That's not true!
You attacked Jenna because
she found you out,
and you killed Rachel, too!
Watch what you say.
Watch what you say.
Abram.
Abram, no, stop.
Abram, stop, stop! [screams]
[door slams]
[Carly panting]
[suspenseful music]
[Abram groaning]
[fist thumping]
[Abram grunting]
[Abram groans]
[suspenseful music]
[Carly screams]
I knew I should have
got those locks fixed.
[Carly] Oh no, Abram, stop!
We are gonna talk about this
like a nice married couple!
[keys jingling]
[ominous music]
No, no, no!
[keys rattle]
Now none of us can leave.
None of us?
Oh, that's right, I
forgot to tell you.
I got you a wedding gift.
It was supposed
to be a surprise,
but, ooh, I guess
now will have to do.
Found him snooping around
the barn earlier today.
[suspenseful music]
[Carly] Dad!
Dad, oh my God!
- No, no!
- [Abram] Oh, no, no, no, no.
- He's fine.
- Abram, stop!
- He's fine.
- [Carly] Let go of me!
- Let go of me!
- [Abram] We're all gonna be
one big happy family now.
[Carly] Let go of me!
[elbow thumping]
[Abram grunting]
[Abram retching]
Oh.
[Carly panting]
What did you do to me?
Foxglove.
Put it in your tea
at our wedding.
It's got some pretty
nasty side effects
if you take too much.
[Abram coughing]
Don't worry, it's not
enough to kill you.
Mona told me just
the right amount
to render you incapacitated.
Oh, great.
I love you, Carly.
[Abram grunts]
[Abram groaning]
I'm sorry, Abram, but I think
we should see other people.
[necklace clinks]
[Carly grunts]
[Abram grunting]
[stern music]
Dad!
Daddy!
Oh my God, Dad!
[Grant grunts]
Daddy!
Dad, oh, thank God.
- [Grant] Oh God.
- I'm right here.
Here.
[Grant grunts]
[Carly] Oh, Dad!
[sirens wailing]
Wait, the police.
The police, how did they know?
Jenna.
She was tracking me.
She must have
called the calvary.
I'm so glad you're okay.
[sirens wailing]
[police radio chattering]
[ominous music]
Hi, Mona.
I was so scared something
happened to you.
[Carly]
No, no, it's okay. I'm okay.
Thank you for everything.
Well, I decided
I'm leaving, too.
I don't know where I'll go,
but that's part of
the journey, right?
Finding where you belong?
[gentle music]
Well, my best friend
and I rent a house.
It has an extra bedroom if
you need a place to stay.
Yeah. [chuckles]
Thank you.
Be well.
[Carly] You too.
Thank you.
[Jenna] Carly?
- Carly, oh my God!
- Jenna.
[Jenna sobs]
I'm so glad you're okay.
I'm fine.
I'm fine, I'm fine.
Hey, um, is Wyatt okay?
You just escaped the clutches
of a psycho kidnapper
and of course you're
worried about someone else.
He's awake. He's okay.
Hey, Jenna, I'm sorry.
You were right about everything.
It honestly does not matter.
I'm just so glad you're okay.
I love you.
[Carly] I love you, too.
I love you guys.
[Carly] I love you more.
I changed my mind.
I don't really like that guy.
[girls laughing]
[siren wailing]
[gentle music continues]
[crickets chirping]
[ominous music]
[ominous music continues]
[soaring music]
[gentle orchestral music]
[film reel clicking]
[dramatic music]
[birds chirping]
[hooves clopping]
[crow cawing]
[horse whinnying]
[broom swishing]
[dog barking]
Hello?
Is someone there?
[ominous music]
[tense music]
[Rachel gasps]
[Isaiah chuckles]
Isaiah, you scared me.
[Isaiah chuckles]
[Rachel gasps]
[peaceful music]
[dog barking]
[Rachel panting]
We can't.
Well, when?
Tonight, down by the lake.
Okay, go. I have
to clean. [giggles]
[water swishes]
[ominous music]
[horse whinnying]
[water splashes]
[feet plodding]
Oh?
Hi.
What are you doing here?
I have to go.
Anna, she told me
to clean, so--
[Rachel panting]
We'll talk later, okay?
[Rachel panting]
[Rachel screams]
[head cracks]
[birds chirping]
[intense music]
[eerie music]
[upbeat music]
[girls laughing]
[Jenna] There is nothing wrong
with using your femininity
to get what you want in life.
And honestly, I would've
done it a lot more.
He has got that distinguished
zaddy vibe going on. [laughs]
Oh, summer's gonna be
so boring without you!
- I invited you to come along.
- Hey.
Youabandoned me!
Come with me?
I can't.
It's my mom's birthday
in a few weeks,
and I don't wanna
leave him alone for it.
Girl, I get it.
It's just, it's the first
summer since kindergarten
that we've been apart.
There you ladies are.
Dad! You're home early.
[Grant] Yeah, I
was thinking of
throwing some burgers
on the grill.
Jen, are you staying for dinner?
Yeah, I'd love to, Mr. B.,
but I can't.
I gotta go home and pack.
You guys going on a trip?
Not me. Just her.
[Jenna] Well, I stupidly agreed
to go on a six-week sailing trip
with my mother and her new
boyfriend, lucky number 27.
[Carly chuckles]
Promised her I'd give this
one an actual chance, though.
Why aren't you going?
It's not your
arrhythmia, is it?
No, I just...
want a relaxing summer.
That's all.
Carly!
Dad, drop it.
It's my decision, okay?
Okay.
I'll light the grill.
- [Carly] Love you.
- [Grant] Love you more!
[Carly chuckles]
[uplifting music]
[Carly] So just a muffin
and a latte for me.
[Barista] You got it.
Scan right there.
[phone chiming]
Oh, it's my dad, sorry.
Hey, Dad.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
No, it doesn't
close until noon.
I can pick up everything.
A muffin.
Thank you.
Uh-huh, no, I have
plenty of time.
Don't worry, okay?
All right, I love you.
- Ooh, ooh!
- [Abram] Oh!
- [Carly] Oh, I'm--
- I'm so sorry.
I'mso sorry!
My coffee, it's all
over your shoes.
[Abram]
It's fine. It's no big deal.
- [Carly] Oh, geez.
- It's okay, here,
I'll buy you another one.
- Seriously?
- [Abram] Yeah.
It's not your fault.
I mean, if anything, Ishould
be buying youone and, um--
- [Abram] It's fine.
- And a pair of new shoes.
- No, it's okay. I got it.
- [Carly chuckles]
Yeah, I'll buy
her another, uh--
What did you have?
Uh, just a latte.
[Abram]
Can I get justa latte?
[Carly chuckles]
I mean, it's the least
I can do, you know.
Oh, and, um, black
coffee for me.
- How much is that?
- Uh, $7.50.
Okay.
[Carly giggles]
Am I short?
Uh, four more cents.
[Abram]
Four more pennies.
One--
Thanks.
You're not from
around here, are you?
How can you tell?
I don't know.
I mean, Midwest
people are nice,
but there's something
different about you?
I'm visiting, uh, sort of,
on kind of a sabbatical,
I think you call it?
Like from work?
From my community.
Are you Amish?
Born and bred.
I hope this doesn't
come out wrong,
but you don't lookAmish.
Well, looks can be deceiving.
[Carly chuckles]
I'm on Rumspringa.
Ditched the hat
and the suspenders
for the appropriate
English attire.
English?
[Abram] It's just what we
call non-Amish people.
The ones who speak
English, anyway.
- [Barista] Here you go.
- [Abram] Thanks.
[Carly] So, wait, from what I
do know about the Amish,
which is very little,
I thought they did
Rumspringa at like 16, right?
Yeah.
- You've done your research.
- [Carly chuckles]
[Abram] So there's Old-Order
Amish, New-Order,
and everything in between.
And, each one of those
has their own Ordnung.
It's like our agreed-upon laws,
but even then, every
individual family is different.
So, it's really up to you--
Uh, you need to--
Excuse me, ma'am.
I, I can get--
I'll get that for you.
Oh, thank you.
- Thank you.
- [Abram] You got it.
[Carly giggles]
That was very nice. [chuckles]
[Abram] Well, she's really
sweet.
[Carly] Yeah.
Okay, so, um, tell me then,
why Rumspringa now and
not when you were 16?
I planned on it,
but, um,
then my mom got sick,
so I stayed back to help her.
She hung on for a while,
even started to get better,
but then things
just took a turn.
After she passed, I just--
I just stayed back
with my family
'cause I couldn't
bear to see them
mourn by themselves, you know?
I know exactly what you mean.
Um, my mom also passed away
recently, a few months ago.
So now I just feel super
protective of my dad.
I am so sorry.
It seems like we've been
through the exact same thing.
[Carly]
Sorry for yours, too.
So you're what now?
Sowing your wild oats
or something? [laughs]
I'm trying to live life
like the English do.
So I just bought
myself an old truck.
Ooh.
[Abram]
And, uh, check this out;
- got a phone.
- [Carly] Oh?
- Can I see it?
- Sure.
I haven't seen
this kind of relic
in a very long time.
- [Abram] It's not a relic.
It is a fine phone.
[Carly] Okay!
Wow, it even has a camera.
- [Carly giggles]
- [Abram] Mmm-hmm.
Hey, should we take a picture?
I've never done one before.
- Sure.
- [Carly] Okay.
Um--
I don't think it has
a front camera here.
- Come in here.
- [Abram] Okay, yeah.
[Carly giggles]
- Okay, uh--
- Yeah.
Yeah.
Okay, ready?
One, two, three.
[camera clicks]
[giggles] It's cute.
[Carly chuckles]
There you go. [chuckles]
- Wow.
- [Carly laughing]
[Abram]
You know, in my community,
we're not even allowed to have
pictures of ourselves, so--
- [Carly] Oh, I'm sorry.
- No, it's okay.
This is--
This is really great.
Well, um, actually,
I need to go.
- Oh, it's okay.
- [Carly] I'm sorry.
But it was really nice
meeting you, um--
- Oh, Abram.
- [Carly] Carly,
and I hope to see you around.
- Mmm-hmm.
- Bye.
Uh, Carly?
Yeah?
[Abram] I don't know
anyone around here.
Do you think I
could see you again?
Yeah.
Yeah, totally, um--
Let me have your phone
and I'll put my number in.
Okay.
[laughs] Great.
I should be the first
one on your call list.
Well, give me a ring sometime.
- [Abram] I will.
- Or you can text me.
Does that phone text?
- [Carly giggles]
- [Abram] Yes, it does.
- Okay, bye.
- Bye.
[ominous music]
[birds chirping]
[hooves clopping]
[Abram laughing]
[Carly giggles]
Uh-oh, I know that look.
What's his name?
His name is Abram, and
he's just a friend.
That is not the look of a girl
who is texting with a friend.
Fine.
He's very kind and sweet.
[Grant]
You deserve kind and sweet.
[gentle music]
[traffic humming]
[Carly] So my mom bought this
necklace for my sixth birthday.
Yeah?
Had a hummingbird
charm on it, [chuckles]
and it was silver and had a
little turquoise on the wings.
That's cute.
[Carly] I wore it every day.
It was like a limb.
But then one day,
shortly after she died,
it just disappeared.
I literally cried for days,
but it was just a thing, but--
It was your connection to her!
Yeah.
[phone chimes]
Oh, um,
I'm actually supposed
to meet my dad.
- I'm sorry.
- It's okay.
- See you tomorrow?
- Yeah.
[stern music]
[stern music continues]
[Grant] We sure do
miss you, honey.
Wish?
Same time?
- [Carly] Yeah.
- Yeah.
[Both] One, two, three.
[ominous music]
[crickets chirping]
[Carly] I'll go get some
plates and some forks.
Sound good?
[intense music]
[birds chirping]
[wind rustling]
[Carly] This lake is one of my
favorite spots in town.
Wait, do you see--
Hang on, past this bush,
do you see the gazebo there?
- [Abram] Yeah.
[Carly] That's actually where
my parents got engaged.
My dad proposed to
my mom right there.
That's really sweet.
It's kind of a special spot.
Since you shared
something special with me,
I, I actually got you something.
- [chuckles] Really?
- [Abram] Yeah.
[gentle music]
[Carly] Oh?
[Carly gasps]
[Abram] I searched every
jewelry and thrift store
in a 50-mile radius.
What?
I doubt it's the exact
same one your mom got you,
but I think it's pretty close.
It's perfect.
I can't believe you
did this for me!
Thank you.
Hey.
Come here.
[peaceful music]
Was that okay?
[chuckles] More than okay.
[Carly giggles] I can't
believe you got me this.
It's so sweet.
- [Abram] Wanna try it on?
- [Carly] Sure!
[Abram panting]
Are you sure you wanna do this?
[soft music]
[soft music continues]
[soft music continues]
- [Abram laughing]
- [Carly laughing]
[Carly] Hey that's not what
I said!
[Abram]
It's not bright red.
- It's, it's--
- [giggles] I meant the shape.
Maybe my hair in 50 years,
but not exactly now.
Maybe you're right.
I really like your
perception, though.
- You're really good. [chuckles]
- [chuckles] Yeah.
You have a good imagination.
Mm, man, I can't believe
this summer's almost over.
I don't want it to end.
[Carly sighs]
Well, it doesn't
have to, you know?
I mean,
look, I go back to
school in a week
and you're going back home.
Remember?
What if I didn't?
What if I stayed here with you?
You're really sweet,
but I'm not staying here, Abram.
[Abram sighs]
I mean, this summer's
been amazing.
Totally unexpected. [chuckles]
I'm never gonna forget it,
or forget you.
[unsettling music]
But I think it's
time we both go back
to our separate worlds.
You gonna be okay?
Yeah.
I mean, what do
you want me to say?
It's okay.
I understand.
We'll see each other.
Okay.
I gotta go.
[ominous music]
Bye.
[ominous music continues]
[door clicking]
[door thudding]
- Carly?
- [Carly] Right here!
Oh, I hate that I have
to leave you right now.
Carly, we've been over this.
[Carly]
I'm only an hour away.
- I can come home on weekends.
- Don't you dare.
Did you get your extra meds?
Yep, got 'em.
- [Grant] All right?
- [Carly] Okay, I'll be fine.
[Grant] All right, drive safe.
[Carly] I will.
- Love you.
- [Grant] Love you more.
[engine starts]
[ominous music]
[stern music]
[distant police siren]
[gentle music]
- [Jenna squeals] Hey!
- [Carly] Hi!
[Jenna] I thought you
would never get here.
- [Carly] I'm so excited.
- [Jenna] So happy to see you.
[Jenna] So what did you do
this summer without me?
Well, [giggles]
I actually met someone.
Spill.
[chuckles] His name is Abram.
He's really cute, unbelievably
sweet, and he's... Amish.
You're dating an Amish guy?
[Carly chuckles]
- [Jenna] So naughty! [laughs]
- [Carly] Okay, not--
We're notdating,
but we just hung out.
Mm.
[Carly] He had to go back.
I mean, he was on Rumspringa.
And honestly, it was one of
the best summers I've ever had.
[ominous music]
[students chattering]
[thudding]
Oh, sorry, I--
[gentle music]
Carly?
Abram?
What, what are you doing here?
Well, I, um,
I go to college here.
What--
What are youdoing here?
Oh, um, I just enrolled.
"Enrolled"?
Yeah. [laughs]
[Carly] In college?
Yeah, um, I guess
we both go here now.
[chuckles] Okay.
Oh, after you.
Thanks.
[Abram] You showed me this whole
side of English life
that I had never expected.
I want to know more.
I want to learn more.
I want to experience more.
I just have this thirst for
life I'd never had before.
Yeah.
Did I tell you that I go here?
You didn't follow me, did you?
No, I had no idea.
I mean, this is crazy.
[chuckles] Yeah.
It's a big step.
Are you okay
with leaving everything
you've ever known behind you?
I just think there's so
much more out there for me.
Wait, I thought education
stopped for the Amish
in eighth grade?
How did you get them
to let you in here?
Uh, so back in my old
community, I was actually able
to complete a high school
curriculum by mail,
so I have a high school diploma.
I didn't know you could do that.
[Abram]
It's not common at all,
but, um, I was actually able
to convince my community
that my education would
be good for all of us.
Well, how would
you like to learn
what a real college
party is like?
[upbeat music]
- [Partier] Let's see you, baby!
- [Partier] Woo!
- Yeah, baby!
- [students cheering]
- [Partier laughs] Nice.
- [Partier] Woo!
[students chattering]
[student laughing]
- [Jenna] Hey.
- [Partier] Hey, Jenna!
- [Partier] Hey, girl.
- [Partier] You look great.
- [Jenna] Yes, hey!
- [Partier] Woo!
- [Partier] Whoa, awesome.
- [Jenna] Hi.
[Jenna] Nice!
[upbeat music continues]
- [Partier] Hi.
- [Jenna] Get it, get it, get it!
- Ah, there you are.
- Oh my God, hi.
- Oh, you look so amazing.
- So do you.
Hey, this guy from your
class, Wyatt something,
he came by looking for you.
He had to go, but he said
he was gonna hit you up.
- Girl, he's cute.
- [Carly] I know, I know.
- He's just a friend.
- [Jenna] Okay, well,
where were you?
- [Carly] I had to change, duh.
[giggles] Hey, wait, um, do
you remember that guy
that I was telling
you about this summer?
- Abram?
- [Jenna] Yeah, the Amish guy?
[Carly]
Yeah, well, he's here.
Apparently he just enrolled
at Southern Penn University.
[Jenna] So what, he followed
you here or something?
What?
No, no, he didn't
even know I go here.
It's just a crazy coincidence.
Wait, I want you to meet him.
Abram, Abram, come
here, come here.
Abram, Jenna. Jenna, Abram.
Jenna's been my best friend
since we were like five.
Nice to meet you.
I've heard so much about you.
Oh, wish I could say the same.
So tell me, Abram, how is it
that you found yourself here?
Say again?
How is it that you
found yourself here?
Oh, Carly brought me.
She told me about tonight.
No, I mean, at Southern Penn.
You meet Carly
and then somehow you enroll
at the same college as her?
- Jenna, stop.
- [Jenna] What?
[Carly] She grills everyone.
Don't worry about it.
She's gonna grill you, too.
Um, you want a drink?
Yes.
Okay, um, the keg
is in the kitchen?
Yeah, it's in the kitchen.
It's really nice to meet you.
[Jenna] Sure, you too.
[upbeat music continues]
[unsettling music]
I think I'm falling in
love with you, Carly.
[ominous music]
[students chattering]
[Carly] Wait, he did not
say that!
[Jenna] Wait, who is this?
Our philosophy professor.
And yes, he absolutely
called himself
- Marcus Aurelius incarnate.
- [Jenna laughing]
- Marcus Aurelius incarnate!
- [Carly giggling]
You must have been distracted
by my bulging bicep.
[Carly] Oh. [laughs]
- Hey, baby.
- [Carly] Hey!
[lips smacking]
[unsettling music]
[Abram] Um, sorry, I didn't
mean to interrupt.
What's so funny?
Oh, nothing, just something
Wyatt was talking about.
Wyatt?
Abram Mast, it's really
nice to meet you.
Nice handshake you got there.
I'm Carly's boyfriend.
- [Wyatt] Nice to meet you.
- [Abram] Yeah.
[Jenna]
So Abram's your boyfriendnow?
Mm, maybe. [giggles]
What?
I didn't say anything.
No, but I know that you wantto.
So why don't you save us
both the time and torture
and say it?
Fine, he creeps me out.
[Carly] Abram?
Why? He's so sweet.
[scoffs] Exactly!
He is hot, he is
sweet, it's unnatural.
You always see the
worst in people.
[Jenna] Seriously, there's
something about the guy!
Already calling
you his girlfriend
when you guys just
reconnected a couple days ago.
And then did you realize
he just popped in there
the second you started
talking to another guy?
Okay, he was on his
way to class, Jen.
Mm, yeah, that's another thing.
You guys spent an
entire summer together
and then he just
happens to enroll
at the same college as you?
How would he have known
what college I was going to?
Uh, he could've Googled it.
It's all over your
social media, girl!
Okay, well, he's Amish.
They're not exactly
considered tech savvy.
I mean, he barely knows
how to send an email,
let alone engage in some
light internet stalking.
Maybe he's a little much,
but social norms are
different where he's from.
You don't honestly fully
believe that, do you?
[Carly]
Jen, he's a nice guy,
and I like being with him.
We have chemistry.
And also, his mom died, too.
And he's the only one
who really knows what
I'm going through.
That's not true. I lost my dad.
I know, but he walked
out on your mom.
He didn't die.
He's dead to me.
[phone chiming]
Speaking of dads, time for
my weekly chat with mine.
- Okay, bye.
- [Jenna] Bye.
[Carly] Hi, Dad.
[stern music]
Hey. Sean, right?
Remember me? Jenna?
We sit next to each
other in American Lit.
Oh, yeah, hey.
I was wondering if you
could do me a favor.
I need some information
on a student.
Oh, I, I don't think I'm allowed
to give anything like that out.
No?
I can tell you don't
follow the rules.
Well, uh...
Yeah, sure, maybe I
can tell you something.
Who is it you need
to know about?
His name's Abram Mast.
I got nothing here, I'm sorry.
I, I don't see anything.
[unsettling music]
Thanks anyway.
[Lecturer] That's it.
Have a great weekend, everyone.
[students chattering]
- I gotta go.
- Yeah, you do.
- [Carly chuckles]
- Bye.
Bye.
[unsettling music continues]
Boy, you seem to be everywhere
with her these days.
Uh, I like her a lot.
I'm guessing you do, too?
Yeah, she's an amazing person.
That's why we've
been best friends
for practically
our entire lives.
But you, you just
kinda popped into it.
I, I'm sorry, Jenna, did
I do something wrong?
It just seems like you
don't trust me or something.
Sort of hard to trust liars.
Especially ones
stalking my best friend.
I don't--
What are you talking about?
You never enrolled
at this school,
but somehow here you are.
Yeah, I am here,
so you must be mistaken.
I don't think I am.
You're right about
one thing, though.
I don't trust you.
The problem with Carly
is that she doesn't
wanna hurt anyone.
She's too nice.
Luckily for her, I am
not, so I'll say it.
It's nevergonna work out
between the two of you
so just leave her alone.
I haven't told her about your
little secret yet, but I will.
Bye, Abram.
[unsettling music continues]
[Student] Good luck on the test.
All right, I'll see you
in class. [chuckles]
[Student] See ya.
[door clicks]
[door thudding]
[Jenna clears throat]
[object thuds]
[Jenna clears throat]
[ominous music]
[phone chimes]
[Jenna giggles]
[suspenseful music]
Ah!
[fist thumps]
[dog barking]
[unsettling music]
[Carly] Oh my God.
Oh my God, Jenna.
Hey,
you okay?
[Jenna] I got hit on the side
of the head by some freak,
but I'm fine.
Jenna and I was just
having a little chat
about what she remembers
from last night.
Yeah, it's all kind of
a blur right now, but--
[Officer] Do you have any idea
who might have done this?
No.
No, not at all.
[Officer]
Well, if you think of anything
that might help us in
this investigation,
please let us know.
Absolutely.
- You take care, okay?
- [Jenna] Got it.
- [Carly] Come on.
- All right.
Let's get you inside, okay?
Here.
Thanks.
It's so weird.
I didn't even take anything.
Just doesn't make any sense.
Listen, I didn't
tell police this,
but I think I know who did it.
Who?
Abram.
You're kidding, right?
Why would he even do
something like that?
[Jenna] Because I told him to
stay away from you.
He's a liar, Carly.
He never actually
enrolled in this school.
I confirmed that with
administration yesterday.
So you were... what?
Investigating him?
What if it's just missing
paperwork or a clerical error?
[Jenna] I think he is
dangerously obsessed with you.
Dangerously obsessed?
You know what I think?
I think maybe
you're just jealous.
Jealous over what?
[Carly] That he and I got so
close this summer
when you were gone?
That we're getting
even closer now?
Why would I care about that?
Because you do this
with every guy I date.
You just wanna control
everyone around me.
And if you don't like them,
you just find a way for
me to get rid of them.
That is so off base!
I am just looking out for you,
'cause God knows you don't
look out for yourself.
Abram is a stalker.
Carly, you need to
break up with this guy
before something
bad happens to you!
[sighs] You just can't stand it
when I spend time with
anyone other than you.
You know, not everyone
is your dad, Jenna.
Not everyone's gonna leave you.
Wow, that was harsh, Car.
- [Carly] I'm sorry.
- [Jenna] You know what?
I suddenly have a
splitting headache.
Probably from somebody
bashing me in my head.
I'm gonna go lay down.
[Carly sighs]
[unsettling music continues]
[Abram] Is something wrong?
Jenna was attacked last night.
What? That's awful.
Is she okay?
She's shaken up,
but she'll be fine.
That's terrible.
[Carly] She also told me you
weren't enrolled at the school.
Is that true?
Wait, you don't think
that, like, um--
No, uh--
No.
Well, except she's right.
No, it's, [sighs]
I did apply, and I thought
I was accepted, but as--
[Abram sighs]
But as it turns out,
my, my mail order
diploma wasn't credited.
I got scammed.
I found out the
day after I saw you
on the quad for the first time,
and I was so embarrassed, I--
I didn't know what to tell you,
and I'm so sorry I lied
and I never should have.
It's okay.
I get it.
[gentle music]
- [Wyatt] So then I said--
- [Carly] Uh-uh.
[Wyatt] Let's not put that
cart before the horse.
- [Wyatt laughs]
- [laughs] You're so stupid.
[Wyatt] I am stupid.
That's why I'm a
philosophy major.
[Carly laughing]
[phone chiming]
- Sorry.
- [Wyatt] Oh, you're good.
Oh, I gotta go.
- See you in class?
- [Carly] Okay, yeah, for sure.
[phone chimes]
[unsettling music]
[Carly sighs]
[ominous music]
[keys tapping]
[message whooshing]
[students chattering]
[ominous music continues]
[phone chiming]
[phone chiming continues]
[Carly sighs]
[ominous music]
[phone ringing]
[phone buzzing]
[ominous music continues]
[Grant Voicemail] Hi, this is
Grant. Leave a message.
[Carly gasps]
[suspenseful music]
[engine humming]
[Carly panting]
[suspenseful music continues]
Dad?
Dad!
Dad?
Dad!
- Dad, oh my God!
- Hey, babe.
You didn't answer your
calls or your texts.
- Where's your phone?
- [Grant] I didn't have it on me.
[unsettling music]
Abram's here.
Hey, Carly.
[Grant] We just been chatting,
looking at baby pictures.
[Abram]
This one's my favorite.
- Ooh, looky, looky, looky.
- Pinch the little cheekies.
- [Grant laughing]
- [Abram laughing]
[Abram] I love pinching
her little cheeks.
[Grant] I wish I could still
pinch 'em. [laughs]
- [Abram] Adorable.
- [Grant] I miss that.
Yeah, that's great. Um--
Abram, can I talk to
you outside for a minute?
- Sure.
- [Grant] Yeah, go ahead.
Go ahead. Don't
worry about me.
We'll get back to
this later, go ahead.
[unsettling music continues]
[door thudding]
What?
Is this some kind of threat?
"Threat"?
Why would I threaten you?
I don't--
What are you doing here?
Coming in and sending
me photos of my dad?
You weren't
answering your calls,
and I missed you,
and I thought--
I wanted to meet your dad
and I thought you would
appreciate the text.
Appreciate it?
Listen, Abram,
this is messed up.
You can't do stuff like this.
What stuff?
Coming to my house to meet
my dad without me here?
The constant calls and texts?
Showing up wherever I go?
It's bordering on stalking.
I'm sorry, I didn't know.
It's fine.
I'll do better.
Okay, I promise I will,
just, you know, teach me.
Show me how to be.
Abram.
[Abram] What?
I think we need to take a break.
Look, I like you.
I just--
I can't be in a
relationship right now.
It's my senior year of college.
My mom just passed away.
Like, I just, I need
to focus on myself.
I love you.
I love you, Carly.
You should go.
I love you, Carly.
[Carly] Please go.
- I--
- [Carly] Just go.
Please, just go, Abram, okay?
Just go, Abram.
[door thudding]
[unsettling music continues]
- [Carly laughs] Stop it, Wyatt.
- [Wyatt laughing]
I need to study.
[Wyatt] We are!
[Carly] Okay, I officially
cannot concentrate,
thank you very much.
[chuckles] Well, me either.
Hey, wanna get outta here?
Get some food?
- Yeah, let's go.
- All right.
[gentle music]
[Student]
Hey, how's it going?
[upbeat music]
[dog barking]
[Carly] Hey, thanks
for the ride home.
- I really appreciate it.
- Oh, no problem.
[Carly]
Sounds like there's a party.
Do you wanna go to the party?
- Come on, come inside.
- [Wyatt] Uh--
I know that look. Come on.
I'd love to, but I
should probably study.
No.
No, I wanna see your
dance moves. [giggles]
Mm?
Come here.
All right, okay,
go study, you studious,
studious man, you. [giggles]
This was fun.
[Carly] This was really fun.
Thank you so much--
- [Wyatt] Hey!
- [Carly] Hey!
Abram? What the hell!
You lied to me.
You said you didn't
wanna date anybody.
Wyatt's just my friend.
But I love you.
Don't you see that?
- [Carly] You're insane!
- [Wyatt] Man, leave her alone!
[fist thumping]
[Wyatt grunts]
[Carly] Oh my God!
Wyatt!
Wyatt?
Are you--
[gasps] Oh my God.
[Carly panting]
Oh my-- Wyatt?
[ominous music]
Oh my God, you--
You killed him?
Oh my God.
[gasps] Oh my God.
What are you doing?
Calling the police.
- Hey!
- No, I don't think so.
Abram, give me my phone back!
No, no.
Help, help!
- Help me!
- [Abram] No, don't do that!
- [Carly] Hey!
- [Abram] Don't do that.
- Don't do that.
- [Carly screaming muffled]
Shh, shh.
[birds chirping]
[Carly grunts]
[eerie music]
[Carly panting]
[eerie music continues]
[Carly whimpering]
[Carly whimpering continues]
[unsettling music]
[Carly grunting]
[suspenseful music]
Help, help, help!
Help me!
[Carly screams]
Shh.
- [Carly whimpering]
- Shh.
Don't scream.
It's annoying, okay?
It's okay, I'm not gonna hurt
you, but you can't scream.
- Okay?
- Mm.
- You're gonna be good?
- [Carly whimpers]
Okay.
Great.
[Carly panting]
Where--
Where am I?
You're safe.
I'm sorry I had to do that.
It's just you were gonna go to
the police and I, I can't...
If you let me go, I
won't talk to the police.
I won't talk to
anyone about anything.
He's not dead.
Wyatt?
That's, that's good.
But I hurt him
really bad.
He's in a coma,
and if he wakes up and
remembers what happened, then--
I could tell the police
that you thought
he was attacking me
and that you were just
trying to protect me.
I was.
Yeah, I wastrying
to protect you.
You believe me, right, Carly?
[unsettling music]
I do,
but, Abram, you can't
keep me tied up here.
You have to let me go.
I want you to see how
much I care about you
and that I'm nota bad man.
I do too.
I see that.
Good.
But I can't let you go.
Not yet.
What?
No one can hear you scream.
If I was you, I'd get some rest.
Abram, wait! Wait, Abram!
[door thudding]
[lock clicking]
Abram!
Abram, Abram!
[door banging]
[Abram] No one can
hear you scream.
Get some rest.
[Carly panting]
Help me!
Hello?
Oh my God. [gasps]
Help me!
[Abram] Carly, no
one can hear you.
[ominous music]
Ah!
[Abram] Carly, go to bed!
[Carly screams]
[Carly sobbing]
[Carly Voicemail] Hi, you've
reached Carly Brooks.
I can't come to
the phone right now
so please leave me a message.
[phone beeps]
Okay, if you are with
him, I'm not mad.
Just please let me know.
You didn't come home last night
and you turned off your phone.
Carly, really, what the heck?
I just wanna make sure you're
okay, so call me back, please!
[Jenna sighs]
[ominous music]
[Carly grunts]
[Carly panting]
[Carly grunting]
[Carly grunts]
[Carly panting]
[suspenseful music]
[shoes tapping]
[Carly gasps]
[door thudding]
I thought you might be hungry.
[Carly]
Why did you lock me in here?
[Abram] I mean, I can't
let you out there.
Not until I'm sure you're
not gonna try and run.
What are you gonna do with me?
So the biscuits are
made with buttermilk.
That's some kind of
egg, bacon, and, um, oh,
gravy.
It's good.
All right, I'm just
gonna leave this for you
whenever you're ready.
Abram, wait.
Can I call my dad or Jenna
just to let them know I'm okay?
They'll be worried if they
haven't heard from me.
Wait, Abram, wait.
Wait, come back, I--
[door closes and latches]
Why are you leaving?
What do you want with me?
[door bangs]
[unsettling music]
[siren wailing]
[phone chimes]
[eerie music]
"I think we need
some space, Jen.
I've decided to
stay with Abram."
Oh.
[Jenna gasps]
[birds chirping]
[horse whinnying]
[crow cawing]
[people murmuring]
[horse snorting]
[crow cawing]
[birds chirping]
[crow cawing]
[stern music]
[Carly whimpering]
[Abram] Morning, sleepyhead.
[Carly gasps]
Abram, [sighs]
what time is it?
I really don't feel well.
7 a.m.
You've been sleeping
all morning and night.
You must be exhausted.
Where's my bag?
[sighs] I have it.
I need it.
Why?
I have a medication that
I need to take, I--
I've already skipped a day.
Please, Abram.
I feel really weak and sick.
[stern music continues]
[shoes tapping]
[Carly sighs]
[bag thumps]
It'll be in the side pocket.
I don't see a
prescription bottle.
It'll be in a floral pill box.
[unsettling music]
I don't see it.
Must have fallen out.
Okay, listen to me, Abram.
I have a heart condition.
It's called cardiac arrhythmia.
I--
I neethat medication!
Why didn't you tell
me about this before?
Does it matter?
I need you to take me to
a pharmacy or a doctor
- [Abram sighs]
- or the hospital or something.
I can't do that.
You have to.
[Abram] I can't.
I can't.
Abram, if I don't have that
medication, I could die.
[Abram]
I'm not taking you to a doctor!
So forget it!
[Carly gasps]
No, you have to, please.
The reason why you're sick
is because you're not
eating the food I made you.
Please, Abram, I could die.
Abram!
Abram, no, please!
Please don't go!
[lock clicking]
Abram!
[Carly sobbing]
[Abram grunts]
[Carly sobbing continues]
[Abram grunts]
[feet stomping]
[Carly sobbing continues]
Oh, please!
[stern music]
[Jenna sighs]
[gentle music]
[unsettling music]
[suspenseful music]
[door clicking]
There's someone
here to help you.
Yes.
Oh, please.
She was adamant that she
wants to see you, though.
I won't say anything.
I'm gonna need some
assurances, Carly.
I promise.
Please.
You're wearing the
necklace I bought you.
What are you doing?
[sighs] Getting you ready.
Take these off.
You asked me about
where you were.
You're in a new community
of Amish people.
We came together,
formed a place for
people like us.
We have our own Ordnung,
rules that we created that work,
for people like us.
[unsettling music]
They are rules
that are better for us.
Here, I'll let you do this.
[eerie music]
We are accepting,
a welcoming group,
unlike the communities we left.
I think you'll really--
I'd like it if you'll
give it a chance.
Okay, let's look at you.
You look so beautiful.
So beautiful.
[gentle music]
And by the way,
I know where your dad and
your best friend live,
but I hope it
won't come to that.
[unsettling music]
I don't wanna hurt
anyone anymore.
Especially you.
It's called foxglove.
I grow it myself.
I've been using it for years.
It's safe in the proper dosage.
It contains the
compound digoxin,
the same one they use
in heart medications.
I'm sure you know of it.
It's such a beautiful plant,
but deceptively potent.
I use it for a lot of things.
For you, it will help
prevent any arrhythmias.
Thank you.
I'm Mona, by the way. [laughs]
Carly.
Not a typical Amish name,
but, um, we're not exactly
typical here either.
We're pretty...
unorthodox.
I'll leave this
tincture with you.
You just add five drops
to your tea, no more.
It can cause side effects,
nausea, vomiting, dizziness.
But I'll come back
and check on you,
make sure you're
handling everything okay.
Mona, I'm not
sure how to thank you.
It's no need.
It's my job.
Okay.
Thank you.
[Mona] You're welcome.
[ominous music]
Thank you, Abram.
Of course.
Told you I'd take care of you.
[ominous music continues]
Why don't you get some rest?
No, wait.
[door slams and latches]
[engine humming]
Jenna, what are you doing here?
Have you heard from Carly?
I got a few text messages,
but she canceled our
weekly face chat.
Why? What's wrong?
I think she's been kidnapped.
What?
[Jenna]
I, I know that sounds crazy,
but she hasn't been back to
the apartment in two days
and the first text message
that I get from her
says that she wants
to stay with Abram
because she's mad at me.
The Amish guy she's
been hanging out with?
[Jenna]
And there's something else.
There was another student
attacked on campus
the night that she went missing.
- Oh God.
- [Jenna] She knew him.
And I found this
near the crime scene.
[suspenseful music]
That's her medication.
We need to go to the police.
[sighs] Okay, let's
go inside, come on.
[crow cawing]
[ominous music]
[phone cracking]
[Abram grunting]
[suspenseful music]
[drawer clattering]
[Carly sighs]
[birds chirping]
[ominous music]
[reins clinking]
[wheel thuds]
[apple crunches]
[Carly exhales]
[birds chirping]
[Carly grunts]
[teacup smashing]
[Carly gasps]
[Carly panting]
[unsettling music]
[lock clicking]
[suspenseful music]
[door thudding]
[Carly gasping]
[shoes plodding]
[Carly panting]
[Carly gasps]
[stern music]
[Carly panting]
[eerie music]
[Carly panting]
[door creaking]
[shoes plodding]
[suspenseful music]
[Carly screams]
[Abram gasps]
[Carly] No, no, wait!
Abram, stop!
[Carly panting]
- [Carly grunts]
- Carly, stop!
[Carly panting]
What are you doing?
Why did you try and do that?
Because I thought you
were gonna hurt me.
What?
No, no, no.
What you said the other
day about my dad and Jenna,
I just, I didn't know
what you were gonna do.
[Abram]
I would never do that.
I'm sorry.
I let the emotions that I feel
inside get the better of me.
And, and, and I--
I, I shouldn't have.
I, I'm sorry. Please forgive me.
I'm sorry, too.
Forgive me?
[Carly gasps]
[unsettling music]
Of course I forgive you.
Please forgive me.
Please forgive me.
Okay.
[wolf howling]
[Carly]
I'm a little uncomfortable.
I feel like a mummy.
I can't even move.
I'm sorry you feel that way,
but it's not a
punishment, Carly.
It's a courting ritual.
We face each other, look
into each other's eyes
so that we can really
get to know each other
without carnal temptation.
We should've been doing
this from the beginning.
You don't have to
be afraid of me.
It's just that, here,
women are submissive
to their husbands.
"Husbands"?
It's God's will, Carly,
that we'll be together.
I want you to see how
beautiful it can really be.
And what if I don't like it?
You will.
You just have to give
this life a chance.
[sighs] Don't reject me, Carly.
It'll only get more
difficult for you.
Goodnight.
[Officer] Well, I'm not sure
you have a case here
if you're both getting
text messages from her.
[Jenna]
They're not from her.
They don't sound
like my daughter.
[Jenna] Saying that she's
in love with him
and she's run away
to be with him?
No. [scoffs]
Well, I've seen it before.
[Jenna] He is a psycho.
She would never run
off with this guy.
Yeah, it's definitely
not in her character.
[Jenna] Because he is the
one sending the messages.
[Grant] Look, I have no doubt
that you've seen a lot, okay,
but I know my daughter.
She canceled our weekly face
chat, and that is not like her.
[Officer] But that doesn't mean
she's been kidnapped.
Well, that does mean
something isn't right.
I have a daughter, too.
I understand both
of your concerns.
I'll go back to the station,
file a missing persons report.
But if it turns out
she did run away
to one of these
Amish communities,
it'll be like finding
a needle in a haystack.
They're not exactly
in the system.
I'm sorry.
I wish there was something
else we could do,
but if you think of anything
or find something else,
please, let us know.
We'll let ourselves out.
Thanks.
[stern music]
Why do I feel like we're
on our own for this one?
Because we are.
If there's anything
that I've learned
in my 40-plus years
on this planet,
it's if you want
something done right,
we're gonna have
to do it ourselves.
[birds chirping]
Let us pray.
[table bangs]
[cutlery clinking]
Pray!
Lord in heaven,
hallowed be Thy name,
give us this day our daily bread
and deliver us from evil, amen.
Amen.
[cutlery clinking]
[Abram munching]
[cutlery clinking]
Abram, I wanted--
Silent supper means no talking.
[Abram slurping]
[meat squelching]
[door knocking]
[stern music]
[shoes plodding]
- Mona.
- Hey. [chuckles]
What are you doing here?
Um, I just wanted to
check in on Carly.
[Carly panting]
[suspenseful music]
[cutlery clinking]
Well, give her these.
Let her know I came by.
Can do.
[door clicking]
[Carly gasps]
[suspenseful music]
[sighs] She brought
these for you.
[Abram sighs]
[Abram slurping]
[ominous music]
[Abram slurping]
[ominous music continues]
[eerie music]
[suspenseful music]
[drawer thudding]
[unsettling music]
[Abram] Stand up.
But I didn't do--
Stand up!
[unsettling music continues]
[Carly gasps]
[unsettling music continues]
Sit.
[unsettling music continues]
I'm sorry, I just
thought that--
You know.
I don't know what I thought.
[Carly sighs]
[unsettling music continues]
[Carly sighs]
[stern music]
[eerie music]
[Carly panting]
[Carly gasps]
[Carly gags]
[Carly coughing]
[Carly vomiting]
[Carly coughing]
Carly?
[Carly retching]
Carly, are you all right?
[Carly sobbing]
Carly, are you okay?
No, I think I'm reacting
badly to the foxglove.
I don't feel good.
[Abram sighs]
I think I need to see Mona.
[Carly sobbing]
[sighs] I'll get Mona.
[Carly panting]
[Mona] Okay.
And pupils aren't
dilated, so that's good.
I felt nauseous and dizzy and
then I started throwing up.
[Mona] Well, it's probably
the foxglove.
Um, try doing four
drops instead of five.
You should be fine.
Okay.
You said the other day that
this community was unorthodox.
What did you mean?
Well, being a community of, um,
shunned Amish,
we, um, formed our own Ordnung,
a mix of old laws and new.
Some of them are, um,
pretty unconventional.
Everyonehere was shunned?
Isn't that why you're here?
Why were you shunned?
I questioned my faith.
Wasn't allowed in my old
community in here, either,
but, um, no one wants
to be without a tribe.
[Carly]
Have you ever thought of
leaving the Amish
life altogether?
I mean, I've, um,
I've thought about it,
but who do I know there?
I know how you feel.
Sometimes I want to escape, too.
[Abram] How's the patient?
[Mona] Uh, She's, um,
she's fine.
Yeah.
I'd, um,
I'd love to see you
out in the community.
We all have our specific jobs
and I could use your help,
if it's okay with
Abram, of course.
Well, think about it.
Um, see you later.
Bye.
Thank you, Mona.
I'd like that.
[unsettling music]
Being out in the community.
I could see what life
is really like here.
I'd like that, too,
but I need to be able
to trust you, Carly.
Can I do that?
You can trust me.
All right.
Let's go today.
[stern music]
[Jenna] So what
are you doing then?
[Grant] I am searching for
the land records
for any property owners
with the last name Mast.
The deeds will have
a legal description.
If I can find a section,
a lot, a township,
we can plot it on a map and
narrow in on the communities
that his relatives are from.
[computer bleeping]
- Wait.
- [Jenna] What is it?
- Did you find something?
- [Grant] I think so.
So, what, are we gonna do
this the old-fashioned way
and knock on their door?
From what I've heard,
they're not exactly gonna
invite us in for pie.
Yeah, probably not.
[engine humming]
[plate clattering]
[Martha] He hasn't spoken to us
in years,
not since he was shunned.
He kept coming back,
begging to be let back in.
He was most angry and hurt by me
because I would
not change my mind.
And you are--?
Abram's mother.
[Jenna]
He said you were dead.
To him, maybe.
[Jenna] So he didn't willingly
leave on some late Rumspringa
after staying to
take care of you?
No.
Why was he shunned?
Abram was a wonderful son.
He was sweet,
loving, protective,
but he has a
dark side to him,
an uncontrollable,
violent temper.
It wasn't until he
brutally attacked an elder
that he was finally kicked out.
[Sarah] We're very sorry about
your daughter, Mr. Brooks.
If she's with my brother,
then I don't think
we can help you.
[horse whinnying]
[people chattering]
Mona,
will you show Carly how we
gather food for our community?
Of course.
Huh, get you a basket.
It's good to see you out.
Yes, it's good to beout.
[Mona giggles]
[grass rustling]
You said everyone in this
community has been shunned?
Yes.
When I met Abram, he told
me he was on Rumspringa.
Said he stayed back to
take care of his sick mom,
and that when she died, he
didn't wanna leave his family.
From what I know, Abram's
mom is still alive.
He hates her for shunning him.
Why was he shunned?
He doesn't talk about it at all.
But last year, there was
a girl in our community
who Abram was courting, Rachel.
He became increasingly
possessive of her,
almost obsessed.
One night I saw them arguing.
A few days later,
she had an accident.
Accident?
Hit her head on a
rock, died instantly.
But some people don't believe
that's what really happened.
What do you believe?
You're not here by choice,
that Abram is dangerous, and
that you're the new Rachel.
Abram knows these woods
like the back of his hands.
If you go, you have to
have a plan and food.
And even then, he'll find you.
And kill me like he did Rachel.
[stern music]
You know, when I
first met Abram,
he had this green pickup truck.
[Mona] It's behind the barn.
He took me for a
ride in it once.
He keeps the key under
the passenger seat.
[unsettling music]
[unsettling music continues]
[suspenseful music]
[door clicking]
[grass rustling]
[Carly panting]
[tarpaulin rattling]
Oh, okay.
[suspenseful music continues]
Help me.
[Abram grunts]
Carly!
[intense music]
[Carly panting]
[Carly gasping]
[intense music continues]
[Abram] Carly!
[Carly gasps]
[Carly panting]
Carly!
[Carly panting]
[suspenseful music]
[door clicking]
[Abram grunting]
[door slams]
[Abram sighs]
[stern music]
[tarpaulin rattling]
[Abram panting]
[suspenseful music]
[intense music]
Abram, where did you go?
[lantern thuds]
Where were you?
I just went for a walk.
- [Abram] Mm-mm.
- No, I couldn't sleep.
I, I just needed to
get some fresh air.
"I just needed to get
some fresh air." [laughs]
You're a liar.
No, no, I--
[Abram]
You, Carly Brooks,
are a liar,
and lying is a sin.
It's against the rules
of our sacred Ordnung.
I could tell you're
up to something
so I needed to give you a test.
That's why I let the door open
and put the tarp on the truck.
[Abram chuckles]
Oh, the key was not where
you thought it would be?
[Abram chuckles]
You're a fricking psychopath!
[Abram laughing]
Here, women are submissive
to their husband.
You're notmy husband.
[Abram] You have broken two
of our sacred laws.
Now I have to punish you.
I didn't want to do that.
[Carly gasps]
Get some sleep.
Abram--
- I'll see you in the morning.
- What are you gonna do?
What are you gonna do? Please.
[door thudding]
[Abram]
You'll find out in the morning.
Get some rest.
[ominous music]
[crow cawing]
[Abram] Brothers and sisters,
thank you for joining us today.
We gather for a sacred assembly
to discuss matters of
wrongdoing within the community.
Carly Brooks, you stand accused
of violating our sacred Ordnung
and straying from the
path of righteousness.
Others in your position have
faced severe punishment,
but here, we offer you
a chance at redemption.
[horse whinnying]
Wait, no, no.
[Abram]
Acknowledge your sins!
Repent!
Embrace the teachings
of the community.
[stern music]
Abram, I'm sorry.
Please don't do this.
[Abram]
In accordance with our Ordnung,
she will be subjected
to a Meidung
and shunned by the community.
This is so that you
might fully understand
the consequences of
your sins unrepented.
That is all,
everyone. Thank you.
[stern music continues]
[stern music continues]
[Mona] I'm sorry!
Abram, please don't
leave me here.
I'm sorry.
Abram, come back!
[horse whinnying]
[Carly gasps]
[ominous music]
[crickets chirping]
[stern music]
[Carly] Hello, anyone?
Hello?
[dog barking]
[door creaking]
Hello?
Hello, I know--
I know you can't talk to
me, but can you please--
Can you please
give me some water?
- Mona, thank God.
- Shh, someone will hear you.
[Carly gasping]
Thank you.
Mona, I need to get out of here.
He's crazy and he's
going to kill me.
If, if you try to run,
you won't make it.
He's watching every
move you make.
Then, um, we have--
We have to get him
to stop watching.
How?
He wants to believe
that I love him, right?
[stern music]
[Jenna] I posted about Carly
in one of those online sleuthing
groups for missing persons
and immediately got hundreds
of hits from people.
Then there was this girl in
the group whose ex-Amish,
and she said that
she'd heard rumors
about this breakaway
Amish community
that was formed a couple
years ago east of Meadville.
Then there was this woman
who's a real estate agent,
she posted about a
cluster of farmhouses
that were sold years
ago to this developer.
They ended up going bankrupt.
Never did anything
with the properties.
So, then I put the
addresses into maps
and pulled up the street view.
You'd think that
abandoned farmland
would be overgrown,
right, but...
It's been recently plowed.
Good work, Jenna.
[Jenna chuckles]
[eerie music]
[Carly sniffles]
I was wrong.
I understand that now.
I know you love me and you
just want what's best for me.
That's good to hear.
I hope your punishment
serves us well.
I'll be good, I swear.
Heard that before.
But how can I know that you're
telling me the truth, Carly?
Let's get married.
Really?
[Carly] Yes, really.
That way I can prove I love
you and that I'm yours.
You have no idea how
happy this makes me, but
you know a marriage bond
can't be broken, right?
I know that.
Let's do it today.
Today.
[eerie music continues]
[door thudding]
Turn around.
[keys jingling]
Jacob will make the food
and conduct the ceremony.
I'm so happy that
you chose to do this.
[stern music]
[door closes]
Jenna, I need you to stay here.
What? No. I have to go.
I need to see her.
She and I got into a fight,
and that cannot
be the last thing.
She has to know that I love her
and I would come
looking for her.
Look, she knows, okay?
If something happens to me
out there, who's gonna know?
Who's gonna tell anybody?
Okay.
[Grant] All right, you stay here
and you have my back, okay?
- Okay.
- Okay?
All right.
I'll call you as soon
as I know something.
Okay.
[light guitar music]
[crow cawing]
[Jacob]
Brothers and sisters,
we are gathered here in
this beautiful valley
under these beautiful trees
to celebrate and to unite
two beautiful lives.
Come together.
[guitar music continues]
[Both] I promise to
be loyal and faithful
for all days of my life.
[guests applauding]
- Amen. [chuckles]
- [Jacob] Amen!
- [Group of Amish Men] Amen.
- [Abram] Amen.
- [Jacob] Amen, amen.
- [Abram] Amen. [laughs]
- [Jacob] Amen.
- [Carly] Amen.
[eagle calling]
[crickets chirping]
[uplifting music]
[Carly laughing]
[uplifting music continues]
[Carly chuckles]
I'm thirsty.
I'm gonna get some water, okay?
[Abram chuckles] Okay.
[lively folk music]
- [Mona] Here's a beat!
- Oh.
[guests cheering]
[guests laughing]
[lively folk music continues]
[guests clapping]
- Ooh!
- [Mona laughing]
[live folk music continues]
[guests clapping]
Thirsty?
[Abram] Yes.
[giggles] I thought
the Amish didn't dance.
[Abram] We don't. [chuckles]
That's the beauty of this place.
We do what we want.
- Oh, I'm so sorry.
- [Abram] Oh!
Deja vu. [laughs]
- And from your shirt.
- [Abram] That's okay.
- [Carly] I'll go get a towel.
- [Abram] No, it's okay, stay.
I'll change.
I'll be back, my wife.
[lips smacking]
Be careful! It's dark.
[grass rustling]
[lively folk music continues]
[guests clapping]
[guests cheering]
[shoes plodding]
[lively folk music continues]
[guests cheering]
[shoes plodding]
[lively folk music continues]
[guests cheering]
[Carly panting]
[drawer thudding]
[Carly panting]
[lively folk music continues]
[guests cheering]
[Abram] Hey, Mona!
Where's Carly?
I'm not sure.
You're not sure?
- [Mona gasps]
- Where is she?
She, um, she left.
- She left?
- [Mona] I, I guess.
- [Abram] What?
- Um, she left!
You helped her.
- No, no, no, no, no.
- [Abram] Yes.
- Yes, you did.
- No, I didn't, no.
She just, she went
running toward the woods.
Liar!
[suspenseful music]
[Carly panting]
[dramatic music]
[Carly panting]
[Abram panting]
[suspenseful music]
[tarpaulin whooshing]
[Carly panting]
[suspenseful music continues]
[Carly panting]
Hey!
Hey, help!
Help, wait, stop!
Wait, stop, stop, stop!
Oh, stop!
Wait, oh my God! [gasps]
Thank you!
[sobs] Thank you!
[stern music]
[door slams]
[Abram] Why'd you run?
- Abram!
- Why did you run?
- Why did you run?
- Help me!
- Help me!
- What are you doing?
- [Carly] Help me, help!
- What are you doing?
- Why are you doing this?
- [Carly gasping]
Why are you doing this?
You're leaving me?
- You're leaving me?
- [Carly panting]
You stalked me, targeted me.
You made up whatever lie you
could to get close to me.
Your mom didn't die.
You weren't on Rumspringa.
She shunned you!
You're making things up
in your head, Carly!
- You're outcasted
by your entire community
because you're a sinner!
That's not true.
That's not true!
You attacked Jenna because
she found you out,
and you killed Rachel, too!
Watch what you say.
Watch what you say.
Abram.
Abram, no, stop.
Abram, stop, stop! [screams]
[door slams]
[Carly panting]
[suspenseful music]
[Abram groaning]
[fist thumping]
[Abram grunting]
[Abram groans]
[suspenseful music]
[Carly screams]
I knew I should have
got those locks fixed.
[Carly] Oh no, Abram, stop!
We are gonna talk about this
like a nice married couple!
[keys jingling]
[ominous music]
No, no, no!
[keys rattle]
Now none of us can leave.
None of us?
Oh, that's right, I
forgot to tell you.
I got you a wedding gift.
It was supposed
to be a surprise,
but, ooh, I guess
now will have to do.
Found him snooping around
the barn earlier today.
[suspenseful music]
[Carly] Dad!
Dad, oh my God!
- No, no!
- [Abram] Oh, no, no, no, no.
- He's fine.
- Abram, stop!
- He's fine.
- [Carly] Let go of me!
- Let go of me!
- [Abram] We're all gonna be
one big happy family now.
[Carly] Let go of me!
[elbow thumping]
[Abram grunting]
[Abram retching]
Oh.
[Carly panting]
What did you do to me?
Foxglove.
Put it in your tea
at our wedding.
It's got some pretty
nasty side effects
if you take too much.
[Abram coughing]
Don't worry, it's not
enough to kill you.
Mona told me just
the right amount
to render you incapacitated.
Oh, great.
I love you, Carly.
[Abram grunts]
[Abram groaning]
I'm sorry, Abram, but I think
we should see other people.
[necklace clinks]
[Carly grunts]
[Abram grunting]
[stern music]
Dad!
Daddy!
Oh my God, Dad!
[Grant grunts]
Daddy!
Dad, oh, thank God.
- [Grant] Oh God.
- I'm right here.
Here.
[Grant grunts]
[Carly] Oh, Dad!
[sirens wailing]
Wait, the police.
The police, how did they know?
Jenna.
She was tracking me.
She must have
called the calvary.
I'm so glad you're okay.
[sirens wailing]
[police radio chattering]
[ominous music]
Hi, Mona.
I was so scared something
happened to you.
[Carly]
No, no, it's okay. I'm okay.
Thank you for everything.
Well, I decided
I'm leaving, too.
I don't know where I'll go,
but that's part of
the journey, right?
Finding where you belong?
[gentle music]
Well, my best friend
and I rent a house.
It has an extra bedroom if
you need a place to stay.
Yeah. [chuckles]
Thank you.
Be well.
[Carly] You too.
Thank you.
[Jenna] Carly?
- Carly, oh my God!
- Jenna.
[Jenna sobs]
I'm so glad you're okay.
I'm fine.
I'm fine, I'm fine.
Hey, um, is Wyatt okay?
You just escaped the clutches
of a psycho kidnapper
and of course you're
worried about someone else.
He's awake. He's okay.
Hey, Jenna, I'm sorry.
You were right about everything.
It honestly does not matter.
I'm just so glad you're okay.
I love you.
[Carly] I love you, too.
I love you guys.
[Carly] I love you more.
I changed my mind.
I don't really like that guy.
[girls laughing]
[siren wailing]
[gentle music continues]
[crickets chirping]
[ominous music]
[ominous music continues]
[soaring music]
[gentle orchestral music]
[film reel clicking]
[dramatic music]