When a Witness Recants (2026) Movie Script
Okay.
[director]
Tell me about Baltimore
in the early '80s.
-Hmm.
-Like, if you closed your eyes
and what images
come to your mind
when you think about Baltimore?
I loved Baltimore, I loved it.
[upbeat music playing]
Baltimore was home, you know,
it's Rhythm Skate,
it's Shake & Bake,
it's shooting basketball
on a crate
nailed to a telephone pole,
summer and the sun setting
really, really late.
These are just
incredible memories.
[music fades]
But in my mind,
this case is the break.
[suspenseful music playing]
That was, like, the moment
for me where, you know,
part of maturation
is you just realize
horrible things happen
in the world
and children seeing things
that they probably
shouldn't have saw.
I talked about that case
all the time.
And my wife was up one night
and could not sleep,
and picked up The New Yorker.
And I woke up the next morning
and I had a text message
from her and it said,
"Is this the case
you always talk about?"
I looked at, I said,
"It can't be."
I said, "It can't be."
And I started reading,
I said, "My God."
[man] In my neighborhood,
we call it Sandtown.
This is West Baltimore.
We call it Sandtown.
But it was
the most lively place ever.
Feelin'
Happy feelin'
In the music
That we're givin'
Feel the power
Of the hour
Every moment
That you're livin'
[Ransom] Like in my mind,
if I close my eyes,
I see the recreation center,
the football field,
the skating rink that
they had built for the kids.
But most of all, how we used
to sit on the steps.
The whole neighborhood,
everybody be out
in the summertime.
Everybody was just friendly.
[Andrew] Me, Ransom, Alfred.
We loved to be
around each other.
The best friends in the world.
We would just play sports.
[Alfred] We played basketball,
football, baseball,
jumping alleys,
climbing fences and trees.
[Andrew] We thought
we was the best at everything.
Boys being boys.
[Ta-Nehisi]
I have memories that are
really beautiful to me,
and then I laugh,
and I realize
that people thought Baltimore
was a really,
really dangerous place.
[solemn music playing]
[reporter 1] Downtown Baltimore
is surrounded still
by urban decay.
[man] About the last six weeks,
we've had 15 burglaries
in the neighborhood.
[reporter 2]
Baltimore City cab driver
was fatally shot
once in the neck
on the steps of his home
in the 1400 block
of Myrtle Avenue.
[reporter 1] Maryland State
Police have jailed five people
in a major drug bust
involving more than
$3 million worth of cocaine
and several hundred thousand
dollars worth of Quaaludes.
[Ta-Nehisi] But the violence
doesn't quite capture it,
because there's things
that are happening
underneath the violence
as a culture.
I felt very much loved.
[gentle music playing]
[Andrew] We belonged to
a community of kids our age.
Alfred mother would call you,
"Come here,
you sit right here
until your mother come."
Ransom mother and father,
"Come here, boy.
You hungry?" "Yes, sir."
"Okay, come on up here
and get something to eat."
It was the village raising us
and loving us
the way you're supposed to.
And we grew up
with all of that love.
You was precious cargo.
Like, we never felt so safe
in our lives.
Until we were 16.
-[music fades]
-[clicks]
[somber music playing]
That day was just
a different day.
-[children shouting]
-[basketball bouncing]
[Andrew] We all met
down the basketball court
and we all
just played basketball.
So we got so sweaty
and played basketball
that we said, "Well, look,
we gonna meet up later,
everybody got to go home
and get changed."
I said, "Well, I got to go get
the key from my sister,
she in Harlem Park."
[Alfred] I used to go
to Harlem Park School.
I liked my teachers back then,
and I would go in there
and visit them
and stuff like that.
[Ransom] So we just go in the
building, laughing, joking.
We went to some classes,
talked to the teachers.
[Alfred] And then Mr. Kelly,
the security guard,
came out then,
he know every last one of us.
So he was like, "Can't be
out here around this time."
[Ransom] "Alright, Mr. Kelly,
ain't no big thing."
-We just leave.
-[Andrew] The security guard
escorted us
off the school premises.
We all going home, we took
showers, we meet up again.
We meet this girl that grew up
with us named Duchess.
She's like, "You know somebody
got killed in Harlem Park?"
"Killed?
No, we was up there early,
ain't nobody got killed
while we was up there." So...
She said, "Yeah,
somebody killed DeWitt."
I said, "DeWitt?"
Now, DeWitt is a friend
that live in my neighborhood.
I know his mother, I've been
in his house, all of us had.
So to hear that he got killed
was, like, crazy.
I went home
and watched it on the news.
[reporter] Harlem Park
ninth grader DeWitt Duckett
was shot here
as he stood in the hallway
of the junior high school.
Whoever shot him fled.
Duckett made his way
downstairs,
heading for the cafeteria.
The teenager collapsed
before he got there.
[soft, somber music playing]
-[director] You ready?
-Yes.
[director]
Mm-hmm.
[pensive music playing]
I remember specifically,
I was the one
that didn't complete
my work on time,
so DeWitt and Eddie,
they were waiting
for me to finish.
Once I finish,
we walked out of class,
and we were just
walking down the hallway,
just laughing at each other,
telling jokes, nothing,
and, um, I think we were
the last to leave class.
[boys laughing]
When we got close to the end
of the hallway,
that's when someone
came up on us.
When I turned around,
someone had a gun in my face,
and then the gun went
from my face
to the back of DeWitt's neck.
And then when he said,
"Take off your jacket,"
that's when I realized
this person is serious.
I just took a few steps back,
and I got the attention
of Eddie and he turned around.
There's a guy standing there
behind him,
holding him by his neck
with a gun to his head.
We couldn't hear him talking
at first,
but then when we focused
on it, you can hear him
clearly telling him
to take his jacket off.
As all this is going on,
we still walking backwards.
We get close
to the stairwell...
[panting]
...we rush down the stairwell
to go get help,
and that's when
we hear the gunshot.
-[gunshot blasts, echoes]
-[solemn music playing]
-[running footsteps]
-[panting]
[Ron] We go into the cafeteria
and that's when we see
Mr. English,
the unit D's principal.
So we run to him
and we tell him
that DeWitt just got shot.
That is when DeWitt came
into the cafeteria,
and he saw us standing
in the middle of the cafeteria
and he was running to us,
holding his neck,
and that's when we really knew
he got shot.
[labored breathing]
He was struggling
to get to us.
He just dove
in Mr. English arms.
[Mr. English] I picked him up
and took him
out of the cafeteria
and took him
to the main office,
and I laid him on the floor
where we could be in seclusion
from everybody else
in the school.
At that point, I had someone
call the ambulance.
You know, right now
even talking about it,
it just sends chills
through me right now.
-[siren wailing]
-[indistinct radio chatter]
Good evening, everybody.
Tonight, an intensive search
is on for the killers
of 14-year-old DeWitt Duckett.
He was shot in the hallway of
Harlem Park Junior High School
this afternoon after he
refused to give up his jacket.
[reporter 1]
The Harlem Park principal says
before DeWitt died,
he told him about the attack.
It was labored, but he talked.
I was able to find out
and piece things together.
[reporter 1] DeWitt Duckett
said his attacker stole
his blue satin
Georgetown jacket.
[Ta-Nehisi] The jacket he had
was a statement piece.
It had that, you know,
beautiful royal blue
and the silver and everything,
so this was a coveted item.
It didn't occur to me
that people would kill
each other over them
until this happened.
[reporter 2] DeWitt Duckett
died at University Hospital
at 2:35 this afternoon.
What I want now is that person
caught, that's what I want.
Now, police are really
concentrating on that,
and I want that person
apprehended.
[reporter 2] Police say the
investigation is continuing.
They are working on leads
supplied by eyewitnesses,
but so far, no word as to when
an arrest could be made.
First time I was contacted
by a patrol officer at home,
and he said, well, he has
to take me down to homicide.
As a kid growing up
in Baltimore,
I learned a lot of the
negative stuff about cops.
So my father taught me
if, you know,
if a cop ever pull you over,
you keep your calm,
you be cool about situations.
I remember going up
this elevator,
and we step out in the lobby
and that's when
Donald Kincaid comes out.
He individually pulled us
into a room, and he said,
"I'm sorry,
DeWitt didn't make it."
And I just sat in the chair
in the homicide office, like,
I just cannot believe this,
like, this is a bad dream.
[solemn music playing]
[door slams]
[reporter] Duckett was
the first student ever murdered
inside a Baltimore school.
It was not normal for kids
to have guns, it just wasn't.
Like, like, the world
was really changing.
What I have
is this kind of haze of memory
of everyone being
really, really bothered
and disturbed, like, everyone.
It felt like a change,
you know?
It felt like childhood
ain't childhood no more.
He was in my class.
[reporter] 14-year-old
Richard Williams,
a ninth grader,
is among the students
who believe security
should be tightened
in the 87-door school.
They letting outsiders in.
Anybody can come in.
Well, we mostly scared
and worried about the security
and what's been happening.
I feel that it should--
it should have been prevented.
I don't know how, but that's
what we're working on finding.
[reporter] The fire department
is already reassessing
the necessity to keep
all of the school's
87 doors unlocked,
and the possibility
of installing
a TV monitoring system
is being investigated.
The safety of our children
is what we want
and we intend to get it,
and we don't care
what the system costs,
we want it in the school.
[man] I'm afraid
if we don't do anything,
and Mr. Duckett is buried,
and six months pass,
that another child
will be murdered
and we will find ourselves back
in essentially
the same position.
[solemn organ music playing]
[reporter]
About 200 people came
to St. Peter Claver's
Catholic Church
in West Baltimore today
to say goodbye
for the last time
to DeWitt Duckett.
DeWitt's family members,
city and school officials,
and some of his classmates
from Harlem Park Junior High
all find it hard to accept
the sudden loss
of this young man
who's been described
as studious,
hardworking, and quiet.
He was a very good friend
of mine, but...
I just feel so sad
that he's gone, right,
that I really can't express
what I want to say.
I just hope they catch
the people who shot him.
[Ta-Nehisi] The community
was deeply traumatized
and wanted something done.
Had you interviewed me
at eight years old
and you asked me
what I thought about that,
I would have told you,
"This makes me feel unsafe,"
or however I would have said,
you know, in that vocabulary
at the time,
and "I hope they get who did it.
And I hope whoever did it
is not anywhere near
any other child."
That's what I would have felt,
because I'm sure
that's what the adults felt.
[lawyer 1] Mr. Kincaid,
can you please state
and spell your full name
for the record, sir?
First name is Donald,
D-O-N-A-L-D,
Kincaid, K-I-N-C-A-I-D.
[lawyer 1] When did you work for
the Baltimore Police Department?
[Donald] From 1966 to 1990.
[lawyer 2] Can you please state
and spell your name
for the record?
Name, Ron Bishop, R-O-N,
Bishop, B-I-S-H-O-P.
Edward Capers.
E-D-W-A-R-D, C-A-P-E-R-S.
[lawyer 2] When Detective
Kincaid came in the room,
what, if anything,
did he say to you?
He seemed concerned, um,
and just asked me
a few questions,
like, how am I feeling?
[lawyer 2] What, if anything,
did you say in response?
I said I was-- I was--
I told him I was okay,
just nervous, anxious...
shocked.
They gave me the impression
they was truly concerned,
they was trying to get
this case over with,
they was trying to figure out
who did this and who did that.
I told him that the person
that came up behind us,
myself, Edward Capers,
and DeWitt Duckett,
dark-skinned guy,
light colored pants, um,
a white or grayish hoodie
and, um, slight mustache.
How many people did you say
were involved in the shooting?
I told Mr. Kincaid
only one person.
[lawyer 2]
How many people did you say
were involved in the shooting?
One person.
[lawyer 1]
Mr. Kincaid, do you see
that first paragraph?
"According to Detective
Donald L. Kincaid,
the victim's two friends said
they were walking in the hall
when a teenage boy," singular,
"walked up behind them
and grabbed the collar
of DeWitt Duckett's jacket."
Did I read that correctly?
-Mm-hmm. Yes, sir.
-[lawyer 1] Okay. All right.
How did you get
to three suspects?
-How did I get three suspects?
-[lawyer 1] Yeah.
I was teaching a class,
three young men came to my door,
and one of them came in the room
to talk to somebody he knew,
and I was trying to get him
to leave, you know,
asked him nicely to leave.
And then the other ones
was out in the hallway,
hollering in the room, trying
to talk to other people.
So they was disrupting my class.
So then I was getting
very annoyed,
so I went to the door
and nicely pushed, pushed
one of them out the door,
and then I locked the door
and I went on with my quiz.
[lawyer 2] Did those boys, um,
two of which you identified
as Alfred Chestnut
and Ransom Watkins,
did they make any threats
to other students
in the classroom?
No.
[lawyer 2] Did you see
any of those boys
carrying any weapons?
No.
[lawyer 2]
You described the boys as,
quote, "real polite," quote,
"They were just, you know,
really silly and immature"?
Yes.
According to a security guard,
that they were in the school
without permission.
So they-they actually,
although this speaks
to one-one defendant,
they actually became possible
suspects in the investigation.
[soft, tense music playing]
[Alfred] From that day
when it happened
and then come questioning us
on a Saturday,
they told us that, um,
we weren't being arrested,
we were just being questioned.
They said that they had
witnesses saying
that they saw us
inside that school that day
and which I said, "Yeah.
Yeah, we were inside
the school. Yes, we were."
I had my Georgetown jacket on
that day.
I didn't hide from the police.
We walked right
in front of them,
and I was in the car
with my Georgetown jacket on.
And then you're going to joke
with me in the car about it,
like-- like, "Did you kill
that boy for that jacket?"
And I'll tell you, I said,
"No, this is my jacket.
No, no, we didn't."
He asked us,
what time did we leave?
I had a watch on. I knew
exactly what time we left.
From leaving there
from the security guard
talking to us
was like 12:45 maybe.
It took 15 minutes to get
from Harlem Park
to Mount Street for walking,
compared to when my friend
got killed in Harlem Park.
We never lied to the police
about nothing that we did
that day inside that school.
Nothing.
[soft, gentle music playing]
[Ron] I remember Donald Kincaid
coming by the house
with pictures
and showing me, like,
several pictures of guys,
Alfred, Ransom, Andrew,
asked me, "Does anyone look
familiar in the pictures?"
I'm like,
"No, no, I do recognize them,
but no one
in the set of pictures
that I recognize
as the shooter."
[indistinct radio chatter]
There was a time
when an officer came by
and asked, "Can you come down
to homicide with us?"
And, you know, I'm thinking,
"Oh, they got good news."
When we get there,
Donald Kincaid,
he doesn't really have
eye contact with me,
and he said,
"Can you have a seat?"
[lawyer 2] Did you have
any adult relatives
with you at that time?
No adult relatives.
[lawyer 2] Were you accompanied
by any adult relative of yours?
No, ma'am.
[lawyer 1] Were Mr. Bishop's
parents present?
-No, sir.
-Did you tell Mr. Bishop
he could have
his parents present?
No, sir.
[lawyer 1]
Did you tell Mr. Capers
that if he wanted to have
his parents present,
he could have
his parents present?
No, I did not.
He says, um...
"We have someone of interest,
and, um, and we think
you know who the person is."
I'm like,
"Well, the only person I know
is the description I gave you."
And he said, "No,
we have someone and, um,
you haven't been-- you haven't
been honest to us."
They said they had,
uh, new evidence
that it was more
than one person involved
and, uh, I wasn't
totally truthful with them.
I'm like, "What, what?
What do you mean?"
Like, "No, no, I told you,
it was only one person."
Then he said,
"Well, I believe you've been
holding back information."
I'm like, "No,
I've been honest with you."
So it went back and forth
and back and forth,
and then he said,
"Well, the person or persons
that committed this crime
or killed DeWitt,
they're in this photo."
I'm like, "No, no, no way."
He already told me
he had a witness,
and the witness
was this young girl,
and the witness
told him everything,
so therefore I'm lying to him.
That's when, uh, I first heard
about Yvette Thomas,
and, um, he was telling me
how her statement
don't coincide
with mine's or Ron's.
I'm like,
"Why would they?
Where were she? Who is she?"
[lawyer 2] Did he tell you
that he had spoken
to Yvette Thomas?
Yes. Actually,
he said she came to him.
[lawyer 2]
And what did he tell you
about his meeting with Yvette?
He said, uh, Yvette witnessed
the whole thing,
she was standing
in the side corridor,
and she witnessed
the whole thing.
She saw three people
approach, uh, DeWitt,
uh, grab him, hold him,
one was pointing a gun to him,
another one standing
to the side,
and, uh...
then, um, the guy shot him,
and they all ran back
the other way.
I told him,
"There's no way in the world
any of this
could have been true because
it was only four of us
in the corridor."
There's no way possible
she could place herself
in this hallway
because there is a gate.
There's no way.
[Edward] It's a gate there
that's locked.
[lawyer 2]
And from your memory,
were you standing
in front of that gate
at the time the shooter
approached Mr. Duckett?
[Edward] No, ma'am.
We haven't reached it yet.
[lawyer 2] So if someone
were standing in that hallway,
would it have been possible
for that person
to see anything?
No.
[lawyer 1] Let me ask you
about, um, uh, Yvette Thomas
and when she gives you
this information
on November the 23rd.
What did you do to corroborate
whether her statement
was truthful or not?
Nothing that I recall,
just that we had
the other three witnesses
come down and showed them
the photograph.
[lawyer 1] Right. You didn't do
any follow-up
to corroborate the veracity
of Miss Yvette Thomas's
statement or identification
of Mr. Stewart, Mr. Chestnut,
and Mr. Watkins, correct?
No. Correct.
[lawyer 1] You took
Yvette Thomas's statement,
um, as credible,
even though you didn't get
that statement
until five days after the murder
on November the 23rd, correct?
Correct.
[solemn music playing]
[Edward] He just kept repeating
what she said happened.
I-I even explained to him
the layout of the place.
I explained all that
and he just got infuriated,
he started yelling
and screaming. I was like,
the more truth I bring out,
the worse it got,
so I just shut down.
And then he starts
threatening me,
"I'll put your head
through a goddamn wall,
you fucking whatever."
He say, "You know what?
Your goddamn ass
is not leaving here.
You're going to be here
all night."
I said, uh, "Can we, uh...
Can we get my mother to come
get me so I can go home?"
He say, "You ain't going home."
I'm not going back home.
[Ron] He yells,
he bangs on the table.
-[table thuds]
-He said,
"I can charge your ass
with accessory to murder."
You know, I felt like
I want to cry.
Kincaid told me that, uh,
if I'm going to continue
to, um, disagree with it,
then that means
I'm a part of it,
and he's going to charge me.
If we don't get on board,
me and Ron will be charged
with accessories,
and we'll be taken away
from our families.
That mean they going
to lock me up
and, um, put the blame on me.
[lawyer 2] And how did that
make you feel?
I was terrified.
I'm 16 years old, you going
to put me in a prison
with grown freak-ball men?
Man.
You know,
I'm starting to realize
he just wants me to lie.
He's going to frame me
to say someone did it,
I didn't know at the time,
like, who is he talking about?
He's going to frame me
to say someone did it,
and now he's going to make me
a snitch, a lying snitch.
And not only that,
if I don't do what he says,
I'm going to prison.
I'm 14, so I'm like,
are you going to put me
in a Maryland state
penitentiary at 14?
I ain't never been nowhere
without my family.
I ain't never been separated
from my family.
I was 16 years old, I ain't
never been in no trouble,
nothing.
When he told me
that he would charge me,
have me put in prison,
separated from my family,
he became-- he became
a god right there.
I know I am not leaving alive
if I don't tell him
that Alfred shot DeWitt,
Alfred had the gun,
Andrew and Ransom were pulling
the jacket off of him.
[lawyer 1] You tell Mr. Bishop
that if he didn't cooperate
with you,
that he could be charged
as an accessory
to this murder-robbery?
I don't recall saying that,
no, sir.
[lawyer 1] You recall, um,
being physical with Mr. Bishop,
-putting your hands on him?
-Physical?
-[lawyer 1] Yes.
-No, sir.
[lawyer 1] Did you make
any threatening gestures
toward Mr. Bishop?
No, sir. None that I recall.
[lawyer 1] When Mr. Bishop
changed his story
on November 23, 1983,
and all of a sudden was able
to select Mr. Chestnut,
Mr. Watkins, and Mr. Stewart,
why did you believe him?
I believed him because of what
Yvette Thomas had told me.
I think they were at a point
where they were ready
to tell the truth.
[light music playing]
[Ron] When I got home,
I just kept it to myself.
I never told my parents
because I knew my parents
would confront them,
and I was afraid that somehow
they would kill my parents
because I'm like,
if you're willing to do this
to those three guys,
then you're willing to kill,
and that's what I was afraid of.
I didn't want my parents
to get killed,
or hurt, or go to jail.
You know, I felt
so ashamed of myself.
I couldn't even talk
to my mother about it.
I was scared
to say something to her
because my mother
ain't going to bite her tongue,
and I didn't want her
to get in trouble.
You're living
in this nightmare, a dream.
Just nightmares all over.
[reporter] Police believe
they have in custody
all of those involved
in the Harlem Park
Junior High murder.
They have yet to recover
the weapon.
All these polices just start
coming in the house.
They say, "We want
to search your house."
I said, "For what?"
They bust in the door,
they searched the living room,
they flipped my bed over
upstairs.
They was just
all over the house.
[Alfred] They taken me
out of my bed
one o'clock in the morning
on Thanksgiving,
arrest us and taken me
to Western District.
[reporter] Police spokesman
Dennis Hill says
information from witnesses
led to these arrests.
[Dennis] They were able to get
enough concurring information
to begin writing warrants
about nine o'clock last night,
and at about midnight
they began arresting, uh,
the boys at home.
[reporter] These are two
of the suspects,
16-year-old Alfred Chestnut,
a student at Harlem Park
Junior High,
the school where
the murder took place.
Police allege that Chestnut
was the trigger man.
The second suspect here is
16-year-old Ransom Watkins,
a student
at Walbrook Senior High.
The third suspect is
16-year-old Andrew Stewart,
a student at Douglass High.
[Alfred] I remember
what was going in my mind
and the expression on my face
when I was in the paddy wagon.
I just did like this, and I
turned around and I looked,
because I was in my head like,
"What? What is going on?"
I can't believe
what's going on with me.
"What's-what's happening?"
[Dennis] At the home
of one of them,
the jacket, believed
to have been taken
from, uh, the victim,
was recovered.
[reporter]
But Alfred Chestnut's mother
says the jacket belonged
to her son
and she has a receipt
to prove it.
After they had searched
the house,
you know, and everything,
I showed them the receipt
for the jacket.
[reporter] And the store
receipt confirmed the date
of the purchase was two weeks
before the murder.
Sarah Chestnut also claims
DeWitt Duckett and her son
were friends.
Whoever did this, you know,
I wish they would come forward
and give theirself up
because my son didn't have
anything to do with this.
[reporter] But police
are looking for a gun,
which they say Alfred Chestnut
used to shoot Duckett.
Last night, the police
just going to come
busting in the house
searching for it.
They said they searching
for a .22 gun.
[interviewer]
Did your brother have a gun?
No, my brother
don't have no gun.
The three young suspects
will appear
before a district court judge
tomorrow
for their bail review.
[Andrew] It was horrible
how you tried to tear me apart
from my friends.
[clock ticking]
"Ransom said this,"
"Alfred said that."
"They was doing this for you
or they was doing that
for this reason,"
this, that, and another.
What?
"If you don't tell us,
you're gonna spend
the rest of your life in prison.
Your mother gonna die
before you get out of prison."
The worst stuff
you could tell somebody.
It was terrible.
Finally, they let me go in
and see him,
and, oh, he was a mess.
He was crying, he was like,
"Ma, you know
I ain't kill nobody.
They said we killed
the-the boy."
I said, "What boy, Andrew?"
He said, "Ma, you know DeWitt,
don't you?" I said, "Yeah."
He said, "They said
we killed him over a jacket."
He said, "You know
I wouldn't do that,
I didn't kill him
and they keep--
they keep badgering us
and badgering us."
[Alfred] That was like
a nightmare, like,
and they gonna say
something like,
Ransom and them was saying
that I did this and did that.
And I said, "They couldn't
have said nothing like that
because all of us was together
and we ain't do nothing,
so I know you...
I know you lying.
I know you lying.
'Cause we ain't do nothing.
Neither one of us
ain't do nothing."
So, and they said
the same thing to them.
[Ransom] The officer
that had locked us up,
there's something
he told me as a kid
that no kid should hear.
And at 16 years old,
he told me, he said, "Listen,
you Black, I'm white,
I have a badge.
Who do you think
they're going to believe?"
[reporter] Alfred Chestnut
was brought back
to Western District
from city jail this morning.
Also spending the night
in jail, Ransom Watkins.
Andrew Stewart spent the night
at Western's lockup,
joining his co-defendants
in court,
where a large contingent
of family, friends,
and Harlem Park PTA members
were also.
Taking us to court
from city jail,
we're getting on a bus,
like, uh, getting shackled.
You get taken
to, uh, the courtroom,
then you sit in the bullpen,
the cold bullpen.
As a kid, we were scared, like,
I mean, yeah, I was scared.
When we went
in front of the judge,
they talked to us
like we was trash,
like we shouldn't be breathing.
And we looked at each other,
"Man, I love you.
You're my brother for life.
We didn't kill him.
We're not telling nobody
we killed this dude.
He was a friend of ours,
we gon' be brothers for life."
[reporter] Prosecutors
in court told the judge
they had witnesses
who saw Andrew Stewart
try to remove the jacket
from DeWitt Duckett that day.
The judge gave him $75,000 bond.
Those same witnesses saw
Ransom Watkins
hold the man about the neck.
They gave him $100,000 bail.
And those same witnesses saw
Alfred Chestnut
pull the trigger
and kill DeWitt Duckett,
the judge set his bail
at $150,000.
The boy's not guilty
and neither one of us
had money to, uh, to get bail
after the lawyer.
[reporter 1] Are you gonna make
bail, gonna try and make bail?
No, the money going
for a lawyer, not the bail.
[reporter 2] Are you going
to try and make bail?
Well, it's too high, really,
and I don't have the money,
you know, for the bail
because it's too high.
[reporter] We tried to talk
with Andrew Stewart's mother,
who was also in court,
but she had nothing
to say to us.
Please.
[Ann] Don Scott
was running behind me.
He said, "Miss Stewart,
do you have any comments?"
I said, "No, no comment.
No comment."
And I just went home.
I just went home, and I just
went in the living room,
and I just sit there,
and I just cried
and cried and cried.
I was like, "No,
this can't be happening.
This can't be true.
This is not true.
Why would they do this?"
After that,
they just stayed in jail.
I really couldn't afford
the lawyer,
so they told us that we
could get a public defender.
The lawyer,
Mr. Stewart said to me,
he said,
"This is going to be a hard--"
He said,
"This is going to be hard."
He said, "Because
they want to get somebody."
[solemn music playing]
[Alfred] In around that time,
Black youth was considered
as public enemy number one.
People saying they was afraid
of Black youth.
They walked down the street,
they'd be afraid,
you know what I'm saying?
So time was changing.
Wasn't nobody going to give us
justice on this case
because the media had it.
Three Baltimore teenagers
charged with a...
[overlapping reporting]
[Ransom]
And once the media got it,
everybody was just thinking
that we was guilty.
[Ta-Nehisi] There is
a tremendous amount
of narrative resource
that goes into establishing
police departments
as the institution
within the community
that was most worthy of trust.
A community like Baltimore,
that the Black community
so quickly jumped
to conclusions
about who was guilty
and who was not,
what happened was
that they trusted the cops,
they trusted the police,
they trusted the people
they were told to trust,
and those people
revealed themselves
to be the wrong people.
[director]
I meet Jonathan Shoup,
the district attorney,
and he's describing to us
what the situation is,
and it's the same narrative
that Kincaid
and these other two witnesses
who weren't there,
same exact narrative.
Kincaid, he was present
in the room
as we were rehearsing.
When Kincaid left,
I approached Jonathan Shoup,
I said, "Excuse me, Mr. Shoup,
the stuff that
you're going over,
it really didn't happen
this way.
It's not exactly that way."
And immediately he said,
"Oh, just go over there
and have a seat."
[reporter] Today,
three teenagers went on trial
at Baltimore Circuit Court
for Duckett's murder.
In his opening argument,
Assistant State's Attorney
Jonathan Shoup told the jury
the three had come
to the school that day
looking for someone to rob.
They found Duckett on his way
to the school cafeteria
for lunch.
Franzelle Duckett,
the victim's mother,
was in court today.
She cried when she heard
the description
of how her son died.
Afterwards, Prosecutor Shoup
outlined his case.
What we plan to show
is that there were
several eyewitnesses
to the crime,
and that the case was--
the evidence will demonstrate
that a robbery was committed.
And during the course of that
robbery, the three defendants
were responsible for the death
of DeWitt Duckett.
In their closing arguments,
defense attorneys
called Duckett's death
a hideous crime,
but they said they would be
able to refute testimony
from students and teachers
at Harlem Park
that it was their clients
who did the killing.
Yeah, I thought
I could win it, absolutely.
The jacket was not the jacket,
uh, from DeWitt Duckett.
I told my lawyer
about the receipt.
[Barry] Alfred's mother
produced the receipt.
The store manager, who did
end up being a witness,
proved that the jacket
that Alfred Chestnut had
was not the jacket that
was taken from the victim.
[Alfred] One of the jurors,
he said he saw on TV
that they seized evidence
out of my house,
the Georgetown jacket
out of my house.
He said he formulated his own
opinion that I was guilty.
He still wound up being
on the jury stand.
The judge, he just allowed
all this stuff.
The prosecutor acted
very suspiciously.
Remember, we didn't know
anything at the time
because we were given...
Well, we were given
really scant information.
We knew that there were
many other documents.
The defense tried
to force Shoup
to produce these documents.
Shoup told Judge Bell
that they don't have
anything to do with this case
and the judge just accepted
his answer.
And somehow they were sealed
in an envelope.
We weren't allowed
to look at them.
I've never heard
of anything like that
where they were sealed.
And Judge Bell himself
had apparently
no interest whatsoever,
even by himself in chambers
reading them.
They put a lot of effort
into hiding, uh, the evidence
and the material
they didn't turn over.
I was, like, losing my mind
with the judge after a while,
and I couldn't believe
that he would just accept
the things that, uh,
Shoup was saying.
One time we thought we was
going to have a mistrial.
The security guard said that,
"Ain't no way these boys
could have did this..."
He said,
"...because I found those boys
and I took them
out of the school.
I walked them
out of the school."
[reporter]
The three defendants decided
not to testify
in their own defense,
thus avoiding
cross-examination,
and Shoup said
four witnesses testified
they saw the three do it.
But the lawyers
for the defendant said
most of the same witnesses
had denied
that the three were involved
and only changed their stories
later under pressure.
But the jury was reminded
by the prosecutor
that the witnesses said
they were terrified
because the three defendants
allegedly threatened
to hurt anyone
who told what happened.
They had four witnesses
with completely inconsistent
statements
who could not describe
anything about the scene
or what any of the defendants
were wearing,
how far they were.
Any factual questions
of the situation
they could not answer.
[Ransom] They were saying that
they had four eyewitnesses,
that they looked down a hall
and saw us do a murder.
[Alfred] Ron Bishop,
Edward Capers,
John Caldwell
and Yvette Thomas.
[melancholy music playing]
[Barry] Yvette Thomas,
she was a small, young girl.
You don't want to beat her up
too much on cross-examination,
because then you just come off
as a bully
and take the chance
of losing the jury,
and I-I thought she was
going to be a problem
for-for us as the defense.
Edward Capers like,
I ain't never did nothing
to-- to ever to--
for him to want
to send me to prison
for something I ain't do.
[director]
No, he couldn't look at me.
And a guy named Ron Bishop
who been knowing me
my whole life.
The only thing you understand
is frustration,
anger that somebody's
getting up there and lying
and decimating your character.
People that you went
to school with,
that you knew
in the neighborhood,
sat up there and lie
like that on you,
your heart gonna drop.
In my mind,
I was saying to myself,
"Why would he do that?"
[gavel pounding]
-[whispering]
-[soft, somber music playing]
[Ron] I couldn't even sleep
the day before
and my heart was pounding.
I felt like crying
on the stand because
I'm looking at them
and they're looking at me,
and I'm telling lies.
And this is what I don't get,
the jury never picked up on...
me making
contradictory statements.
[somber music playing]
I was hoping
that Judge Robert Bell
will postpone,
pull me back in his chambers
or in his office,
and say, "Hey, young man,
what's really going on?"
He never did any of that.
[whispering in court]
So now I have to live
with this lie.
The more I think about it,
the more angry I get at Bell.
I mean, he-he bears...
more responsibility,
well, not more than Shoup
or Kincaid,
but he-he bears
a lot of responsibility.
He had to have had that
feeling in his gut, you know,
that it was just wrong,
and I don't know
how you-- how you couldn't.
[somber music playing]
I-I just, I can't tell you
how damaging this shit is.
You know, it's like
you've been violated,
and then you go for help
and the help violates you.
It-it destroys your ability
to trust the state.
I just, I-I can't begin
to express
the-the level of violation
that this is.
[melancholy music playing]
God just-just let me know
that that was it for us,
because it was sunny outside,
and we were sitting
in the courtroom,
big, big windows,
big windows like this
that you could see outside
and the windows was open.
All of a sudden
it just got dark.
[thunder rumbling softly]
It started raining
and thundering real loud.
-[thunder rumbling]
-[rain falling]
I just knew we was going
to get found guilty, that day.
Yep.
I knew it.
When they were found guilty,
I was-- I was pretty shocked.
I was angry and upset.
[reporter] The three
defendants sat emotionless
as Judge Robert Bell
announced the sentence,
first for 16-year-old
Alfred Chestnut.
Judge Bell to Alfred Chestnut,
"It was a useless crime,
a waste of a life,
and by my actions,
by this sentencing,
I'm participating
in the waste of another life,
but under the circumstances,
I think it's justified."
Alfred Chestnut received life
in prison plus 20 years.
Then the judge turned
to Ransom Watkins
and Andrew Stewart and asked
if they had anything to say.
Stewart summed it up,
"We know
we didn't kill DeWitt,
but the jury did what
they thought was best,
and we have to deal with it."
Judge Bell sentenced them
both to life in prison.
[Ta-Nehisi] Was what happened
to them fair?
Let's say they had done it,
let's say we had caught
the right person that did it,
should that person have been
put into an adult prison?
I-I don't think so.
They don't really care
about children.
They don't see children
as children.
I just hollered out,
"No, no, no.
This is not right.
No, it's not right!"
It wasn't right.
They had no right to do that,
because they know,
and they-they knew
that these kids did not do this.
My son, he looked at me,
he said, "Ma, I didn't do this."
I said, "I... I know
you didn't do this."
He said,
"Why I gotta go to jail?"
We couldn't do nothing.
It was over.
[grim, dramatic music playing]
[Alfred] When they found us
guilty and everything,
they sent me straight over
to the Maryland penitentiary.
I was 16, they didn't care,
they didn't care.
And when I first came in there
walking through the doors,
I got my shackles on
and all I saw was, like,
busted windows,
pigeons and stuff
flying all around.
[cooing, wings flapping]
I see a dude say, uh, said,
"Yeah, that's one
of them dudes right there
that killed that boy
for his Georgetown jacket."
Absolutely terrified.
Remember, I may be
the oldest in months,
but I'm absolutely the smallest.
About 5'1", 5'2".
About 112, 113 pounds
soaking wet.
Jail bait, as they say.
I seen men getting raped,
seen men getting stabbed
to death...
[prisoners chattering]
...about nothing,
about a basketball game,
a football game.
[Alfred] I saw people
getting stabbed in the yard,
knife fights in the yard.
You would think like,
"Am I gonna die here?"
I just cry all the time, like,
call my moms, like,
begging her
to try to get me a lawyer.
My moms know I ain't do that,
moms know I-I never did
nothing like that in my life,
never robbed anybody in my life.
Never thought about doing
nothing like that in my life.
[Ann] And you got to listen
to the horrifying stories
that you really don't want
to hear,
then you go home
and the phone rings
and you don't know
if that's somebody calling you
to tell you your son is dead
or he hurt.
[Ransom] No kids
should have to go through
what we went through.
You take a kid at 16,
you put him in an adult system,
and you don't think
that he's going to have
psychological problems
when he get out?
It's literally impossible.
See, at 16, I had to become a,
what I would consider
an animal,
because you put me
in a position
where if I don't act
like an animal,
then they're going to take
advantage of me,
where a place I don't belong.
It was either
you act like they act for now,
or you let them
take advantage of you,
and that I wasn't going to do.
[prisoners chattering]
[Andrew] How do you get over
that psychological hurdle?
[Ransom] Most people go crazy,
and the walls do talk to you,
and if they tell you
they don't, they lying.
[Andrew] Especially when
you had to do it for 36 years.
[dreary music playing]
Thirty-six years...
of trauma.
I made my own life in there,
started putting myself
around things
that I knew would keep
my mind occupied.
So I worked all day,
I drove a forklift
for probably around
about 13 or 14 years.
Like, I was a workaholic.
Had I stopped, then I would
have been thinking about,
"Man, they got me here
for something I didn't do.
I don't deserve this."
And your mind can't take that.
I was offered parole,
only if I admit my guilt.
They was gonna give me
work release,
but I choose to die in prison
before I walk out that door.
If you're wrong, you say
you're wrong, you own up.
But if you're right,
you stand on it till you die.
[dramatic music playing]
[birds chirping]
[music fades]
[Ron] I've been painting
for about 15 years now,
and over time,
it has been therapy
for me, it has.
I never forgot...
I never forgot them.
I could only imagine
the punishment and the abuse
that they were going through
in jail.
You carry that guilt with you.
[dramatic, somber music playing]
Like, the pain
and the guilt of...
like, staying quiet and silent.
I don't know, I started off as
a pretty good student, I did.
I had really good grades.
And after the case,
I couldn't really concentrate
on my work.
You know, after that,
you don't trust people.
I spent a lot of time
to myself.
I think I was in my 20s...
[sighs] ...and I was thinking
about calling the FBI,
see if you could find help
to get those guys free.
But for me,
being Black in this country
and dealing with racist people,
they can set up any situation
they can and frame you,
so I had nowhere to turn to.
When I made it through school
and through college
and I started working,
I'm happy for myself.
But then I just remember
not to be too happy because
I remembered that, um,
that Alfred, Ransom, and Andrew
would never get
the opportunity that I got,
and that stuck with me.
I sent Black boys
who looked just like me,
from the same neighborhood,
to prison
that didn't kill my friend.
The only person I ever spoke to
about this was with Ron,
and we was basically comparing
how differently
things had turned out.
Whenever we got stressed out,
we, uh, found each other
and we just talked.
He was, uh, he was having
similar problems as me
as far as, uh, nightmares
and, um, headaches,
you know, migraines
and all that, but, um,
emotionally, he-he held--
he held on stronger than me
because he ain't get
into a whole lot of crap.
When all this happened,
it just sent my whole life
in a spiral.
I ain't care about nothing
after that.
I lost respect for the law,
I lost faith
in the justice system, period.
[lawyer 2] Did you stop going
to school after the murder,
or did you continue
for some point after that?
I never went back.
[indistinct chatter]
I just gave up on everything.
I started getting high,
using drugs, drinking.
Oh, man, I just,
I was just in a whirl,
a whirlwind spiral of trouble.
One thing after another.
[lawyer 2] Just looking
at that criminal history
beginning in 1989
through 2019, um,
it's obvious that you've been
in some trouble with the law.
So is it accurate
that you're serving
a 28-year sentence currently?
Yes, ma'am.
-[indistinct chatter]
-[music fades]
[Alfred] As years went by,
I was basically trying
to survive.
You can be doing
the bad stuff,
or you can be doing something
that's going to keep you
motivated.
[papers rustling]
All the older guys,
you know, they tell you,
you go to school, you work out,
and you work on your case.
I'm an innocent man,
and to prove it,
it's going to be hard.
We sat around
and, uh, studied our cases
and stuff like that together.
I just wrote everybody,
DC, New York, Virginia,
I wrote everywhere, right?
It took me, like, seven years
to get my transcript,
and I would sit down there
and read it.
And so I started writing
the police department,
asking them, "Can I get
my police reports?"
I would get denied
all the time. They told me,
"You got to pay for it,
it costs this much."
I ain't had that money
to get it.
Even under the Freedom
of Information Act,
they still denied me.
[mellow music playing]
[phone ringing]
[automated voice]
This call is from...
[Alfred] Alfred Chestnut.
...an inmate at a Maryland
correctional facility.
[phone beeps]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
[phone rings]
[Alfred]
[phone rings]
-[Alfred]
-[Angela]
[Alfred]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
Mmm-mmm.
[Angela]
[Alfred]
-Um...
-[Angela]
I mean, when I got
all the, um, police reports,
I got one police report.
I just-- I just knew,
then right there,
because I showed, um, some
of the guys that studied law.
They was like, "Man, that's,
that's all you need, Chestnut.
That's it, that's a done deal.
You out of here, man."
I sat down and I wrote, like,
a five-page letter.
[woman] May of 2019
is when this particular case
came to our attention,
and actually,
I was reviewing
all of the applications
that came in.
It was just
a handwritten letter,
um, from Mr. Chestnut.
[Alfred on phone] I said,
"Dear Ms. Marilyn Mosby,
I've been trying to get help
for a very long time
in my case.
I was trying to get
my police reports for years
and finally after 35 years
I got them.
The things I read
in my police report,
I've never seen before.
All of this is newly
discovered evidence."
[Lauren] At the time
of receiving that letter,
I did what I would normally do,
which is pull back
certain documents
to figure out exactly
whether or not this has merit.
I mean, it took me two minutes,
and I'm like,
"Okay, I don't see how
they got to these people."
Usually you are able
to clearly see
where they were headed.
This case however,
when you look at the timeline,
it's not clear.
While you had
these three individuals
and you actually had
additional individuals
who were in the school
at the time,
but then you almost have
this leap
in the police reports
to fast forward
to about a week later,
and all of a sudden, you've got
locked-in identifications
and these people
are under arrest.
But what you don't see
is any sort
of logical development
of how that occurred.
I realized that, no,
this needs to be investigated.
The Maryland
Public Information Act request
that Mr. Chestnut had filed
with the Attorney General's
office,
usually we don't tend
to have their file
yielding anything
that would be of use.
That's not the case here.
He got documents
that included police reports
that we actually did not have
at all in our file, period.
Those police reports
did not match
what I saw in the transcript
and what I saw
in the file documents
that we already had,
and that was a major problem.
[Alfred]
[Lauren]
They had anonymous tips,
they had people who called in,
they had people
who made statements,
and all of those individuals
were clearly identifying
another individual
named Michael Willis
as being the person
who had committed that murder,
by name.
[Alfred]
[Angela shouting]
One of the witnesses who
had actually called in said,
"I was at the Shake & Bake
that night
and Michael Willis came in
wearing the victim's jacket
and was bragging about
the fact that he was wearing
the victim's jacket."
That's in the police reports.
[Alfred]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
[Alfred laughs]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
There was no evidence
to suggest,
"Well, we... we ran down
that lead."
He should have been considered.
[lawyer 1] Do you recall,
um, Theresa Moody, uh, saying
that another person told her
that Michael Willis was at
Harlem Park Junior High School
on the day of the shooting,
had a gun,
he threw down the gun,
and he ran away
with some other boys?
You recall Miss Moody
giving you that information?
Yes, I think I recall that.
[lawyer 1]
And why did you go interview
Mr. Chestnut, Mr. Stewart,
and Mr. Watkins
before you created
the photo array
if you didn't interview
Mike Willis?
Well... [clears throat]
I think Michael Willis's name
came through,
like, two or three
different parties.
The names of, um, Ransom,
Alfred, and Andrew
came up from Mrs. Woodworth,
the school teacher.
[lawyer 1]
Regarding Michael Willis,
when, if ever,
did you interview him?
-Michael Willis?
-Yes.
I never interviewed
Michael Willis.
I-I can't recall whether
it was John Caldwell,
Bishop, or Mr. Capers,
but I went to show him
and he picked out,
he picked out his picture
and said, "Oh, I know him.
He lives down the street.
He's not involved in this."
So he was basically cleared
that way.
[director]
I knew of him because he was
from the neighborhood.
He lived, like,
a block and a half
from where I lived.
[lawyer 1] And when
Mr. Bishop, Mr. Caldwell, um,
did not pick out Mr. Watkins,
Mr. Chestnut, Mr. Stewart,
why didn't you at that time
determine that they, too,
were not involved in this?
I have no answer for that.
I don't recall why.
[lawyer 1] Help me understand,
why did you believe
John Caldwell or Ron Bishop
with respect to Michael Willis,
but you didn't believe them
with respect
to, um, their negative
photo identification
of the three suspects?
I don't have any--
I don't have any recollection
or have any recall
as to why I did either one.
[Alfred]
-[Angela]
-[Alfred]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
The trial transcript shed
some light on those documents.
We're a page into the transcript
when the defense
is standing up and saying,
"I have received nothing
from the State.
I've received
no police reports.
I don't know anything about
the police investigation.
I don't know how they arrived
at arresting my clients.
I have no information
whatsoever
that's been provided to me
about this investigation
and how my clients
are sitting here today."
And that was them starting
a murder trial
for Mr. Chestnut,
Mr. Watkins, and Mr. Stewart.
They had all kinds
of information
about this Michael Willis
and just plain ignored it
and hid it.
Uh...
If there's anything
more egregious
than what was done
with not turning that over,
not letting us explore it,
not even letting us know
that there could possibly be
another, uh, suspect...
I've never seen
Brady violations like this,
where somebody's just lying
directly to the judge.
[dramatic music playing]
[woman] So I was aware that
there was a case that came in
and that Lauren was concerned
because there had been
some exculpatory evidence
that had not been turned over.
The prosecutor misrepresented
facts to the court,
which is prosecutorial
misconduct.
You have to take
responsibility for that,
and even though it didn't happen
under my administration,
I was then the state's attorney,
and I have to recognize
that we messed up.
The four witnesses
who had direct evidence
that testified at trial,
their testimony
was incredibly vague.
That is extremely unusual
where you've got four kids
who can't answer
any basic questions
about a homicide they saw.
"What was the shooter
wearing?" "I don't know."
"Was the shooter tall?"
"I don't know."
"Where was the shooter
standing?" "I don't know."
So at that point,
it became urgent
to try to get a hold
of the witnesses in the case.
While it was not hard
to find Mr. Bishop,
as with anyone who gets
a letter out of the blue
from the state's attorney's
office,
it took us a few weeks to, um,
to convince Mr. Bishop,
uh, that it would be
a good idea to talk to us.
This is the same
state's attorney's office
that I told the truth
in the beginning,
and they framed those guys
and they were framing me
and threatening me as well,
so I don't trust anyone.
It changed
when I got the letter,
that et al. letter from
Conviction Integrity Unit.
So I said, "Well,
I'll give it one more shot."
Finally, Mr. Bishop did agree
to talk to us,
and, um, and he came in,
uh, and just,
it was a very long interview.
But he, uh,
he broke down at points, um,
and he-he said that he,
uh, had not been truthful.
And what really,
I will always remember
about that conversation was
that he thanked us at the end,
and he thanked us
for our resilience
in getting a hold of him
and for listening to him
and for, you know,
letting him kind of come clean
after all of these years.
It was fantastic to hear that
they were listening to me.
They believed me.
[lawyer 2] Why should
we believe you today?
First of all, I ain't
the same scared little kid
from '83 in November.
I don't have nothing to gain
or nothing to lose
by lying to you.
So why?
I just want everybody
to know what happened.
[soft, somber music playing]
I need closure for myself.
[lawyer 2] Do you have
any memory, Miss Thomas, of...
attending Harlem Park
Junior High School in 1983?
Yeah, I used to go there.
[lawyer 2] And do you remember
being at school
on the day that DeWitt Duckett
was murdered?
Yes. According to the
transcript, yes, I was there.
[lawyer 2] But you don't have
any independent memory
of being there
that day, is that right?
-Right.
-And so sitting here today,
is it your testimony that
you have no memory whatsoever
about seeing DeWitt Duckett
get murdered in 1983?
I have-- I haven't, no.
[somber music playing]
At the end
of this investigation,
what I had was four
of the eyewitnesses,
the only four individuals
who testified at trial
who said that they saw something
directly related
to the homicide,
now, every single one of them
has recanted.
Our main witness
upon whom was placed
the tremendous burden
of really being the foundation
of-- for the, um,
for all four of the kids,
she has said
she did not see a murder.
Every single one
of the witnesses
said the same thing,
they used the same language.
They were, in their words,
told what to say,
get with the program.
These kids were told
by someone, clearly,
that this was how the criminal
justice system works.
[lawyer 1]
From your perspective,
all you did in this case
was proper, correct?
-To my knowledge, yes, sir.
-[lawyer 1] Right.
And as far as you're concerned,
this was a perfect
investigation, correct?
[laughs] Yes, sir.
If you had to do
this investigation over again,
Mr. Kincaid, what,
if anything, would you change?
Nothing.
[music fades]
I-I just-- I just don't
get it. I just don't get it.
I have to believe
there's something, you know,
there was or is
something going on
in the Baltimore City
Police Department
that would allow for that.
When the police do things
like this, they're fine.
Right, they just got away
with it. It was okay.
Um...
So they're kind of immunized
to do, like,
to come into our community
and do whatever they want,
you know, and taking advantage
of whatever, you know, pain,
you know, we're feeling
and use it however they want.
I mean, the law
is above the law.
In my career, certainly,
this is the most egregious
wrongful conviction case
that I have worked on.
Someone is in prison,
and the moment you believe
that that person
should not be in prison,
that becomes
a full-blown emergency,
and you move heaven and earth
to correct the situation.
[spirited music playing]
I was so outraged
by the injustice
that these men had gone through.
I knew that Alfred was the one
who wrote my office, um,
and Alfred
had not given up hope, right?
And so for me,
I wanted to deliver
that news to him myself,
because I wanted him
to know that he was heard.
When I seen her come
through the door, I was like,
"That's-that's Marilyn Mosby."
I was like, I sat down,
I was shaking,
my hands were shaking.
And I could just see,
like, relief.
It was kind of emotional
for the two of us.
We walked into a little room,
and I said,
"You know why I'm here?"
And he said, "I do."
[Alfred] I smiled,
and she smiled at me.
She said,
"You ain't going home today,
but you'll be going home
on Monday."
So she said, um,
"I'm gonna go on over
and I'm gonna see--
go see your co-defendants,
and I'm gonna let them know."
She came in there and said, "Oh,
after 36 years,
we heard your cries."
She said,
"I'm gonna answer them today.
You'll be going home Monday."
I don't know what happened
after that.
[Ransom]
[Carolyn]
[Ransom]
[Carolyn]
[Ransom]
[Carolyn]
[Ransom]
[Carolyn]
[Ransom]
[Carolyn]
[Ransom]
It don't really register to me
until the judge said, "Stop."
He told the state's attorneys,
"Stop.
Do you mean to tell me
they did all this to these men
for all these years?"
He said...
"Mr. Watkins,
Mr. Chestnut, Mr. Stewart,
I'm sorry.
I apologize."
It was mind-blowing,
not only the fact that he said
we was going home,
but he had the integrity
to apologize to us
for something he had no part in.
[Andrew] Hey, baby!
[Ann] What's up, baby?
[Andrew] Monday!
[Ann] What is Monday?
[Andrew] Monday,
I come home Monday.
[Ann] Baby, what home?
[Andrew] Home, to you!
[Ann] Are you coming home
to me?
[Andrew] Yeah!
-[Ann] Yes!
-[man] Man, stop playing.
[Ann] Yes, he is coming
home Monday.
-[Andrew] Monday!
-[man] No, stop playing.
[Andrew] Monday!
[both laughing]
-[Ann] Yeah!
-[man] Oh, man.
[Andrew] I need you...
I need somebody
to pick me up Monday.
[Ann] Here's what's
gonna happen,
I may not come
because I'm gonna try--
I want to get the room,
get your room straightened out
and everything.
[Ann chuckles]
[Andrew] Ma, listen to me, Ma.
-[Ann] What?
-Please,
please listen to me, Ma.
I want you to be there Monday.
The room will wait for itself.
You are the first person
I want to wrap
my arms around Monday
when they release me.
[Ann] I'll get there,
just put it that way.
I'll be there.
-[Ann laughs]
-[Andrew cheering on phone]
[Ann] What happened? Tell me--
Tell me a little bit
about what happened.
[Andrew] They say they have
enough evidence to prove
that we didn't participate
in the crime.
They found, uh,
prosecutorial misconduct.
They found that they was
tampering with the witness,
they found that they was
withholding evidence.
They found more stuff
than we could ever find.
They said, "Mr. Stewart,
we want to get you home
to your mother
before Thanksgiving.
So Monday,
when you go to court,
you'll be walking out
the door with your mother."
And I started crying.
I just busted out crying.
I-I-I cried so much
and so hard
that they stopped everything
and everybody in the room
started crying.
[Ann] They want you to get
home before Thanksgiving?
[Andrew] Yes.
I went and got my ID,
my release ID today.
He gonna sign the papers
and, at two o'clock,
we can walk out the door.
[Ann] And you ain't owe
nothing, no parole or nowhere.
You can go anywhere
you want to go?
[Andrew] I'm totally free.
[Ann] Oh, God.
Oh, God!
-[Andrew laughs]
-[uplifting music playing]
-[Ann sniffles]
-Ooh, boy,
that's a tough one
right there, boy.
-Mm-hmm.
-Yeah, that's a tough--
-[woman] Look at that.
-That's a pretty-- [laughs]
That's a pretty tough one
there, boy. [sniffles]
Yeah, that's wanting to make
your heart melt,
-I promise you that.
-[Ann cries]
-Mmm-mmm.
-Mmm-mmm.
[indistinct chatter]
Hey there, Andrew.
[Andrew] When I walked out
and I seen my mother,
and my sister,
and my cousin, Tracy,
I just looked up at the sky
and was like,
are you kidding me?
This is real.
[Ann] The only way
I knew it was true,
when I seen him walk
through that door
and he hugged me.
That was the best feeling
in the world.
This is the first time I have
been able to hug my son
in about 20-some years.
This is wonderful.
And I ain't danced
in a long time,
I might do a little dance too.
[laughs]
[Marilyn] It's a tragedy
that these men had 36 years
of their life stolen from them.
There's no way to ever repair
the damage done or the trauma
imposed upon these men
for almost four decades.
So, on behalf of this system,
in an attempt to right
the wrongs of the past,
I apologize to you
and your family
for the pain that you
and they have had to endure
because of this
wrongful conviction.
I'm looking forward, man,
to living the rest of my life
being humble,
as peaceful as I am,
praising God,
looking out for my family.
Oh man, I'm telling you,
I-I... It's out of this world.
This journey here for us
has been rough.
We outside the walls,
but on the inside,
I hate to put it like this,
we went through hell.
I sat on my bunk
when I got the information
and I cried.
I didn't know how to stop crying
until a friend of mine came
to me, hugged me and said,
"Man, your journey
is coming to an end."
But it's not.
My journey just beginning.
[solemn music playing]
[Ta-Nehisi] You know,
you feel a lot of things.
It was just this kind of mix
of, like, rage
about the story
as it had been told,
feeling like a sucker,
deep sympathy
for the brothers themselves
who had gone through it.
Yeah, it's devastating.
[birds chirping]
[music fades]
[grunting] There you go.
Well, I'm all good.
This is what happens
when you come home
after all these years, you got
to take care of peoples.
You got to take care of peoples.
This is my grandmother,
my aunt Gertrude,
my aunt Mott
and my mother right there.
Grandma, boy, we would have
ate a feast and a half...
[woman]
Oh, she'd be cooking for days.
...Grandma would have had
a spread that wouldn't quit.
She probably would cry
every time she see you.
-She probably would.
-Yeah, she would cry
-every time she see him.
-Grandma would be so happy
-to see her grandson.
-Yeah.
[Andrew]
I think it was like '98,
I was about ready to give up.
I was, I was like, "I'm tired.
I'm tired of fighting. I just
wanna bust somebody head
and go in lock-up forever."
Grandma said,
"No, don't you do that.
You ain't gonna be in there
all your life.
You gonna--
You gonna make it home.
You gonna make it home,
just be patient. Hold on."
That's the last thing
I heard from Grandma.
That's the last thing
I heard from Grandma.
But... then we made it home.
Still we got a lot
to celebrate, though.
[Andrew] We do.
[Ann] We got a lot to be
thankful for, God knows.
[Andrew]
One thing we can celebrate,
we ain't got nobody
in our family incarcerated.
-That's true. That is true.
-We sure don't.
[Andrew] Nobody in our family
incarcerated.
-We sure don't, do we?
-No.
[Andrew]
Sure can celebrate that.
-Hadn't even thought of that.
-Me either.
I didn't even think
about that either
-till he just said it.
-No, I sure didn't.
[gentle piano music playing]
[Andrew] You never realize
how many dreams
was taken away from you
until you sit back and...
you rewind your life.
Because I haven't
accomplished nothing.
I-I-I ain't became--
I haven't become a father.
I never got to tell my father
I love him.
I never got to see none
of my grandparents,
they all died
before I came home.
[choking up]
I never got to do none of that.
None of it,
and it kills me to this day.
I wanted so bad
to tell my father I love him,
and he passed away in 1996
without even giving me a hug,
during my whole incarceration.
How is that fair to me?
Should be minding your mother,
your mother running.
-[woman] Where she going?
-Don't ask me,
you gotta ask your mother that.
I met him while I was working
at the Maryland Penitentiary.
He was, uh, incarcerated there
and I was
a correctional officer.
So it wasn't until after
I was let go from the jail
that I contacted him,
but then I fell for him,
and life just went on
from there.
Oh, yeah, did I tell you?
Phillips--
[Ransom]
Physically, I'm out here,
but mentally,
my mind be in prison.
Like, I depend
on Carolyn 100%,
because I'm only used
to knowing
from everything
men done for me.
[Carolyn] He never had
to make a decision
and so coming home,
having to decide
the smallest thing, like,
"What do you want to eat?"
"I don't know,
whatever you cook."
And I'm like, "Well,
what do you want to eat?"
[Ransom] You don't want
to keep asking people
for things at this age.
I mean, I'm a grown man.
I gotta ask you how to pay
a phone bill or a mortgage?
I should know how to do
all that.
[solemn orchestral music
playing]
I always think back at what
they have taken from us.
Like, it's hard for me now
because my family connection
is not there.
Like, my sister is sick
and I don't--
Mm, excuse me.
I don't have that feeling.
Right? Like, I love her,
but I don't have no connection.
I don't know her.
It's-it's-it's like a,
she's like a...
she my sister but she like
a stranger at the same time.
"I'm sorry for all the pain
I've caused them
and their families.
It was torture to sit
in the courtroom,
look in their faces
and lie on the stand.
What saddens me the most is
we were all students
at Harlem Park
Elementary School.
Knowing who you guys were
made it so difficult
to be on the witness stand,
especially knowing
you were all innocent.
But one day, I hope
to sit down with you guys,
apologize in person,
and if you guys
really want to know the truth,
I'm willing to tell."
[music fades]
-[laughs]
-Looking like...
Oh, man. You always been strong.
Yeah. Ain't no question.
You already know that.
What's up, baby?
What's happening? Huh?
-Old Drewsky back in town.
-What's happening?
Yeah.
[Andrew]
I can empathize and sympathize
with the fact
that we were all kids.
-[Alfred] Yeah.
-Yeah, I can do that.
-But once you turn 35, 40...
-Yeah.
-...and you have your voice...
-Yeah.
...and you ain't scared
of Kincaid no more,
it's different ways
you can help people.
I don't think you had to go
out there and say,
"Michael Willis
committed the crime."
Everybody already knew that,
but to say Kincaid
is the architecture
of this fallacy...
-Yeah.
-...is what needed to be done.
Man, that's going to be
kind of emotional, man.
[Ransom] Yeah,
this gonna be kind of hard.
-[Andrew] Kind of rough, man.
-Yeah.
But it's something
that may help us get over
a... a few hurdles
in our lives, man.
[Andrew sighs]
What's happening?
[indistinct chatter]
Camera, lights.
Gotta get it, boy.
[Andrew groans]
[Andrew] That's him right there.
[Ransom]
There he go right there.
[Alfred] Wow.
Yeah.
Alright, man.
-Shake your hand first.
-Yes, sir. Yes, sir.
-Love you, man.
-Yes, sir.
-Love you.
-Love you too.
-Love you, big Drew.
-Love you. [laughs]
-How you been, man?
-Oh, man. I've been good, man.
-You sure, man?
-Yeah, yeah.
-You good?
-Mm-hmm. Yeah.
As long as you all are good,
I'm good. I'm good.
[director] Uh...
I think, um... [clears throat]
...for the first time
I might be without words.
You know, um, to actually be
in the presence of somebody
that helped me regain my life.
But also,
you know, and I know
you was a kid,
was a part of them
taking my life.
It's mixed emotions, right?
And...
I'm sitting here, and as much
as I want to be happy
and I want to have this moment
be a defining moment for me,
at this present time,
it's eluding me.
It's painful for me
because I lost a lot.
Lost a lot of family members
in that prison,
and in the process
of losing them,
I lost a lot
that was even living.
Yeah, I'm thankful that
you did what you did, but...
that pain, I can't...
I can't shake it
no matter how much I try.
Hmm.
I always wondered,
you know, every time
we sat in the courtroom
and you looked
in our face, like...
like, how you felt
and-and-and I always wondered
why... why were you-- why...
were you doing that to us?
And what did I do to you
to deserve what I was getting?
Um...
I think the pain
and everything that
we're going through right now
is the battle, um,
that make us better.
I just want to say
I thank you all
for, you know,
accepting my apology.
I thank you all
for meeting me here.
When I sat in that courtroom,
was it 41 years ago?
And I had to look you all
in your face,
that was the worst thing,
the worst thing ever.
And then when the, you know,
they set it up in such a way
where I had to go in
and I had to say
what I didn't want to say,
and, you know,
you got to live in prison
for the rest of your life
up until when you were out,
or exonerated,
thinking why did we do this?
And my whole reason
for coming here
and doing all these things
to get to this point,
to tell you all
and for you all to ask me
anything you want to ask me,
and a lot of things
you all don't know.
Y'all don't know about all
these little weird situations
that played a part in why
you all were convicted.
Being in that
interrogation room,
struggling with Kincaid
and all that stuff,
it was horrific.
And watching you all
and, you know,
we're making eye contact,
and I'm sitting there,
like, I'm hurting inside,
but y'all didn't know
who was behind all of this.
I mean, it's just crazy.
Why would a person put,
knowing Alfred is innocent,
but you want to put the gun in
his hand, make him the killer,
and he could care less if
you were sentenced to death,
this who this person is.
Because I'm saying to myself,
these fucking white cops,
racist cops, they're forcing me,
I'm a slave, and now I know
what slavery feels like,
I'm a slave.
You're forcing me
against my will
and I'm telling you no.
Then you're coming in the room
when you're thinking,
you're leaving the room
and coming back
when you can't get me
to go along with this program.
Now you got a gun,
and that's when that
whole coercion stuff started.
But Eddie and I,
we fought for you all.
All that stuff I testified to,
it was hurting, it was.
But I knew they either
were going to try to put me...
put charges on me,
all this stuff,
and not knowing at the time,
I didn't know Michael Willis
was right there
in the courtroom with you.
I'm not sure if you knew,
he was right
in the courtroom with you.
He was... [chuckles]
He was out there
with your family,
I was sitting next
to all of your families.
And one thing I have to say,
they were upset,
yeah, I think your aunt
or your cousin
rolled her eyes at me,
but she never once cursed.
Kincaid would sit back
like the devil
and he was eating that stuff up.
He was watching every
little individual family,
like, kind of say things
in which he thought were
bad things against each other,
but your family, yeah,
they kept their dignity.
They knew we were lying,
but the jury didn't know
we were lying.
The judge for whatever reason,
he didn't know we were lying.
I was expecting him to pull me
in his chambers so I can say,
"Hey, Judge Bell,
these white officers,
they-they threaten me
with jail time
if I didn't tell them
the story."
Had I went in that courtroom
and said Michael Willis did it,
no one would believe me.
No one would believe me.
Because what they did was,
I'm the main witness,
and that's why I'm here,
I'm the--
basically, I'm
the only witness, really.
That's why I'm here.
What they did was they
shuffled the deck on you all.
They put those two phony
witnesses that weren't there.
They made Yvette,
who wasn't there,
they made her case,
I mean, her testimony,
the main test-- they made her
the main witness.
They made John Caldwell
the second main witness,
Eddie, and then myself last.
That's what they did.
So by the time I got in there,
the whole deal was already
sewed up for you all.
I was going to go
in that courtroom and say,
"Hell no, they didn't do it."
But I needed the judge,
Robert Bell, to see that.
He saw the BS,
but he never acted on it.
It was painful.
My plan was to still...
still stick to that one,
that's what it was.
That's what it was,
but they got these witnesses,
Yvette Thomas and John Caldwell,
these witnesses, they came
from out of nowhere.
So they just left me out there.
I'm the only person that said
you all didn't do it.
And believe me,
when you all were in prison,
I thought about you all a lot.
And for me, you know,
I graduated from high school,
I graduated from college,
and I want you all to know
that I was proud of myself,
but at the same time,
I was thinking about you all
and what you all had to endure
in, um, in prison.
You're talking about
the Maryland State Penitentiary,
we know what that was like
back in the--
No one has to say it,
what it was like.
You all went in at 16 or 17
and experienced 36 years
until they split you all up.
That was a horror show.
So when that verdict came down
and y'all got those sentences,
that, I mean, I felt so bad.
But at the same time,
I tried my best
and there's nothing I--
there was nothing else
I could do.
And to know that, you know,
you had to go against
these evil people,
a state's attorney,
a district attorney,
a-a-a-a sergeant in homicide,
and why they picked you all?
I don't know, but to me,
it's still a mystery.
I don't know why
they chose you all.
How did they get
these witnesses?
I mean, like,
how did Michael Willis
avoid all of this?
You know, it's just one
weird thing after the next.
So, you know, I came here.
I came here just to apologize
and to hear your stories.
Yeah. You know what, man?
I was sitting here
listening to you talk
and everything,
and I want you to know this
about me.
[sighs]
Twenty years ago,
I could have been home
from the parole board.
Twenty years of my life,
I could have lived,
I could have been home.
I could have had kids,
possibly, could have whatever.
But I chose not to do that.
I chose to stand my ground.
And like I told them, like,
we've been telling the world
we was innocent,
and I was willing to die
in prison for that.
So is it hard for me
to forgive you all for not?
Yeah. For me it is,
because the same thing
that happened to y'all,
the police played
with them two with me.
"Well, you know, Chestnut
and Andrew just said you did it,
you was the shooter."
It didn't make a difference.
I would've died before I
would've put them two people
in prison for something
I know they didn't do.
I would've died, man,
and even now.
So for everybody
that testified against me,
no, it ain't good with me
because I don't care
what them police is saying,
if you said that we was
innocent from the jump,
you should have stood on that
no matter what the cost was,
that's what I believe.
And then forget the Black
and the white stuff, man.
Because guess what?
We had jurors on there
that was Black too
that convicted us.
So damn with the cop
being white,
damn with the prosecutor
being whoever.
Because guess what?
When you told them people
we did it, you was Black.
That don't change,
so we can throw that race card
out of this.
"Well, take the focus off of me
and if you say
it's the white cop,
he ain't gonna worry about me,
he gonna focus
on the white cop."
I'll be damned
if I'm gonna do that.
I'm gonna keep the focus
where it's supposed to be,
on everybody that convicted us.
And right now, I ain't ready
to forgive nobody.
Maybe one day, man,
hopefully God will allow me
to come to that point
in my life.
But right now, bruh,
for what I lost,
man, I ain't forgiving nobody
for what happened to me
for 36 years.
And that's just me being honest.
Man, we done lost too damn much
for something
we didn't do in life.
[Andrew] Let me say this.
This is what you did.
"Kincaid made me.
Told us.
Did this."
You never said, "Man, I'm sorry.
From the bottom of my heart,
man."
I'm not a father.
I deserve to be a father.
He's not a father.
He deserves to be a father, man.
And you sit in my fucking face
and tell me that it's
somebody else's fault,
when you got on the stand,
and you said
Alfred killed the man,
and Ransom held him,
and I participated in it,
and you want us
to forgive you for that?
How is that possible?
How can you be
that dense of a person
that you don't see
that you're making yourself
the centerpiece
of our conviction,
and we not supposed to feel
a certain way about it?
You talking about
Yvette Thomas this,
Edward Capers this,
this person that, fuck them!
Excuse my language.
We absolutely ain't getting
no closure from you, man.
All we wanted to hear you say
was you're sorry,
but you came in here and made
every excuse under the sun.
Yeah, I wanted to forgive you.
I sat here and listened to you,
but you didn't even apologize,
like, wholeheartedly, really.
It's impossible for you
to... to sit here and...
and act as
that 14-year-old, man.
That's immature.
And no growth, man,
from then to now, man.
That's what I see, man.
Don't no real men do that.
Like, I would never...
do that to somebody
in my whole li--
I would never do that.
[Ransom] You came in here
with your, "I graduated,
went to college."
You an intelligent person,
right?
But you came here talking
to us with some bullshit.
Because, like Andrew said,
you came in here
not necessarily to tell us
that you were sorry, but you
came to clear your name
among all the others
who convicted us.
You wanted to clear your name
because everything that
you said to us sitting here
revolved around you.
I don't even know if we could
ever get back to normalcy
in our life.
We-we-we-- I-I don't even know
if it's possible for us,
because we have been through
so much
and come out here
in this messed up society
and still trying to function
among people like you
who can't give us what we need.
Man, this right here
could have been a thing
that could have probably
brought us back
if you would have just came
in this room
and looked us in our face
and said, "Listen, man,
I have no excuse
for what I done.
I know y'all suffered.
I know your family
have suffered,
but I apologize
from the bottom of my heart."
And that's all the three of us
was looking for in this room
and we couldn't even get that.
And I'm ready when y'all ready.
[somber music playing]
[director]
It's over. I'm relieved.
I am definitely sad
that they feel this way,
but I respect it.
And I can sit back
and I can say, "Well,
the cops, the cops, the cops."
No, it's me.
I'm sorry.
When they left out
of that room, I felt so bad,
but I understand
where that anger came from.
Myself, I'm in prison here
because I can't speak to no one,
I can't talk to anyone.
I can't share
what really happened
until they broke this case.
You can hate me,
you can say whatever you want
about me, whatever.
My mission was to make sure
you would come home and enjoy
the rest of your life.
Whether I'm forgiven or not,
I completed a mission,
and I'm at peace.
[music fades]
[soft, cheerful music playing]
Yeah. How you doing?
-How you feeling?
-On its way.
Okay, okay.
-[Ransom] Well, hello.
-[Alfred] Look at her.
-[grunts]
-[Ransom] She is cute, man.
Look at her.
[Alfred] My whole incarceration,
my nieces and all of them,
they done had kids,
my brother and them.
I was the only one
without no kids, so...
it's unbelievable
that I have one. [laughs]
I want to tell her when she'd
be able to understand, right,
and I'm gonna tell her, say,
"Your dad was in prison."
And let her know
what happened to me.
And then I'll let her know,
like, if you have a dream,
don't let nobody stop you from
making your dream come true,
not no man, not even me.
[laughs]
I'ma let her know
that she's my blessing,
and a lot of things
I may go through,
I just look at her
and it'll go away.
[inaudible]
[Ta-Nehisi]
What are our responsibilities
to each other?
The community was outraged
that somebody
had come into a school
and killed a kid.
We are still supposed
to protect each other.
The rage just became louder
than any of that.
You know, I'm part
of that community.
I was a child
when it happened,
but I'm part
of that community.
And we as a community...
[exhales sharply]
We're part of why this happened.
You know? Um,
and the least you can do
is allow these brothers
their story.
I just want them to know
that they're heard,
that we hear them.
I want them to know
that we're very, very sorry
and that they are believed.
[music fades]
[spirited music playing]
[singers vocalizing]
[music fades]
[director]
Tell me about Baltimore
in the early '80s.
-Hmm.
-Like, if you closed your eyes
and what images
come to your mind
when you think about Baltimore?
I loved Baltimore, I loved it.
[upbeat music playing]
Baltimore was home, you know,
it's Rhythm Skate,
it's Shake & Bake,
it's shooting basketball
on a crate
nailed to a telephone pole,
summer and the sun setting
really, really late.
These are just
incredible memories.
[music fades]
But in my mind,
this case is the break.
[suspenseful music playing]
That was, like, the moment
for me where, you know,
part of maturation
is you just realize
horrible things happen
in the world
and children seeing things
that they probably
shouldn't have saw.
I talked about that case
all the time.
And my wife was up one night
and could not sleep,
and picked up The New Yorker.
And I woke up the next morning
and I had a text message
from her and it said,
"Is this the case
you always talk about?"
I looked at, I said,
"It can't be."
I said, "It can't be."
And I started reading,
I said, "My God."
[man] In my neighborhood,
we call it Sandtown.
This is West Baltimore.
We call it Sandtown.
But it was
the most lively place ever.
Feelin'
Happy feelin'
In the music
That we're givin'
Feel the power
Of the hour
Every moment
That you're livin'
[Ransom] Like in my mind,
if I close my eyes,
I see the recreation center,
the football field,
the skating rink that
they had built for the kids.
But most of all, how we used
to sit on the steps.
The whole neighborhood,
everybody be out
in the summertime.
Everybody was just friendly.
[Andrew] Me, Ransom, Alfred.
We loved to be
around each other.
The best friends in the world.
We would just play sports.
[Alfred] We played basketball,
football, baseball,
jumping alleys,
climbing fences and trees.
[Andrew] We thought
we was the best at everything.
Boys being boys.
[Ta-Nehisi]
I have memories that are
really beautiful to me,
and then I laugh,
and I realize
that people thought Baltimore
was a really,
really dangerous place.
[solemn music playing]
[reporter 1] Downtown Baltimore
is surrounded still
by urban decay.
[man] About the last six weeks,
we've had 15 burglaries
in the neighborhood.
[reporter 2]
Baltimore City cab driver
was fatally shot
once in the neck
on the steps of his home
in the 1400 block
of Myrtle Avenue.
[reporter 1] Maryland State
Police have jailed five people
in a major drug bust
involving more than
$3 million worth of cocaine
and several hundred thousand
dollars worth of Quaaludes.
[Ta-Nehisi] But the violence
doesn't quite capture it,
because there's things
that are happening
underneath the violence
as a culture.
I felt very much loved.
[gentle music playing]
[Andrew] We belonged to
a community of kids our age.
Alfred mother would call you,
"Come here,
you sit right here
until your mother come."
Ransom mother and father,
"Come here, boy.
You hungry?" "Yes, sir."
"Okay, come on up here
and get something to eat."
It was the village raising us
and loving us
the way you're supposed to.
And we grew up
with all of that love.
You was precious cargo.
Like, we never felt so safe
in our lives.
Until we were 16.
-[music fades]
-[clicks]
[somber music playing]
That day was just
a different day.
-[children shouting]
-[basketball bouncing]
[Andrew] We all met
down the basketball court
and we all
just played basketball.
So we got so sweaty
and played basketball
that we said, "Well, look,
we gonna meet up later,
everybody got to go home
and get changed."
I said, "Well, I got to go get
the key from my sister,
she in Harlem Park."
[Alfred] I used to go
to Harlem Park School.
I liked my teachers back then,
and I would go in there
and visit them
and stuff like that.
[Ransom] So we just go in the
building, laughing, joking.
We went to some classes,
talked to the teachers.
[Alfred] And then Mr. Kelly,
the security guard,
came out then,
he know every last one of us.
So he was like, "Can't be
out here around this time."
[Ransom] "Alright, Mr. Kelly,
ain't no big thing."
-We just leave.
-[Andrew] The security guard
escorted us
off the school premises.
We all going home, we took
showers, we meet up again.
We meet this girl that grew up
with us named Duchess.
She's like, "You know somebody
got killed in Harlem Park?"
"Killed?
No, we was up there early,
ain't nobody got killed
while we was up there." So...
She said, "Yeah,
somebody killed DeWitt."
I said, "DeWitt?"
Now, DeWitt is a friend
that live in my neighborhood.
I know his mother, I've been
in his house, all of us had.
So to hear that he got killed
was, like, crazy.
I went home
and watched it on the news.
[reporter] Harlem Park
ninth grader DeWitt Duckett
was shot here
as he stood in the hallway
of the junior high school.
Whoever shot him fled.
Duckett made his way
downstairs,
heading for the cafeteria.
The teenager collapsed
before he got there.
[soft, somber music playing]
-[director] You ready?
-Yes.
[director]
Mm-hmm.
[pensive music playing]
I remember specifically,
I was the one
that didn't complete
my work on time,
so DeWitt and Eddie,
they were waiting
for me to finish.
Once I finish,
we walked out of class,
and we were just
walking down the hallway,
just laughing at each other,
telling jokes, nothing,
and, um, I think we were
the last to leave class.
[boys laughing]
When we got close to the end
of the hallway,
that's when someone
came up on us.
When I turned around,
someone had a gun in my face,
and then the gun went
from my face
to the back of DeWitt's neck.
And then when he said,
"Take off your jacket,"
that's when I realized
this person is serious.
I just took a few steps back,
and I got the attention
of Eddie and he turned around.
There's a guy standing there
behind him,
holding him by his neck
with a gun to his head.
We couldn't hear him talking
at first,
but then when we focused
on it, you can hear him
clearly telling him
to take his jacket off.
As all this is going on,
we still walking backwards.
We get close
to the stairwell...
[panting]
...we rush down the stairwell
to go get help,
and that's when
we hear the gunshot.
-[gunshot blasts, echoes]
-[solemn music playing]
-[running footsteps]
-[panting]
[Ron] We go into the cafeteria
and that's when we see
Mr. English,
the unit D's principal.
So we run to him
and we tell him
that DeWitt just got shot.
That is when DeWitt came
into the cafeteria,
and he saw us standing
in the middle of the cafeteria
and he was running to us,
holding his neck,
and that's when we really knew
he got shot.
[labored breathing]
He was struggling
to get to us.
He just dove
in Mr. English arms.
[Mr. English] I picked him up
and took him
out of the cafeteria
and took him
to the main office,
and I laid him on the floor
where we could be in seclusion
from everybody else
in the school.
At that point, I had someone
call the ambulance.
You know, right now
even talking about it,
it just sends chills
through me right now.
-[siren wailing]
-[indistinct radio chatter]
Good evening, everybody.
Tonight, an intensive search
is on for the killers
of 14-year-old DeWitt Duckett.
He was shot in the hallway of
Harlem Park Junior High School
this afternoon after he
refused to give up his jacket.
[reporter 1]
The Harlem Park principal says
before DeWitt died,
he told him about the attack.
It was labored, but he talked.
I was able to find out
and piece things together.
[reporter 1] DeWitt Duckett
said his attacker stole
his blue satin
Georgetown jacket.
[Ta-Nehisi] The jacket he had
was a statement piece.
It had that, you know,
beautiful royal blue
and the silver and everything,
so this was a coveted item.
It didn't occur to me
that people would kill
each other over them
until this happened.
[reporter 2] DeWitt Duckett
died at University Hospital
at 2:35 this afternoon.
What I want now is that person
caught, that's what I want.
Now, police are really
concentrating on that,
and I want that person
apprehended.
[reporter 2] Police say the
investigation is continuing.
They are working on leads
supplied by eyewitnesses,
but so far, no word as to when
an arrest could be made.
First time I was contacted
by a patrol officer at home,
and he said, well, he has
to take me down to homicide.
As a kid growing up
in Baltimore,
I learned a lot of the
negative stuff about cops.
So my father taught me
if, you know,
if a cop ever pull you over,
you keep your calm,
you be cool about situations.
I remember going up
this elevator,
and we step out in the lobby
and that's when
Donald Kincaid comes out.
He individually pulled us
into a room, and he said,
"I'm sorry,
DeWitt didn't make it."
And I just sat in the chair
in the homicide office, like,
I just cannot believe this,
like, this is a bad dream.
[solemn music playing]
[door slams]
[reporter] Duckett was
the first student ever murdered
inside a Baltimore school.
It was not normal for kids
to have guns, it just wasn't.
Like, like, the world
was really changing.
What I have
is this kind of haze of memory
of everyone being
really, really bothered
and disturbed, like, everyone.
It felt like a change,
you know?
It felt like childhood
ain't childhood no more.
He was in my class.
[reporter] 14-year-old
Richard Williams,
a ninth grader,
is among the students
who believe security
should be tightened
in the 87-door school.
They letting outsiders in.
Anybody can come in.
Well, we mostly scared
and worried about the security
and what's been happening.
I feel that it should--
it should have been prevented.
I don't know how, but that's
what we're working on finding.
[reporter] The fire department
is already reassessing
the necessity to keep
all of the school's
87 doors unlocked,
and the possibility
of installing
a TV monitoring system
is being investigated.
The safety of our children
is what we want
and we intend to get it,
and we don't care
what the system costs,
we want it in the school.
[man] I'm afraid
if we don't do anything,
and Mr. Duckett is buried,
and six months pass,
that another child
will be murdered
and we will find ourselves back
in essentially
the same position.
[solemn organ music playing]
[reporter]
About 200 people came
to St. Peter Claver's
Catholic Church
in West Baltimore today
to say goodbye
for the last time
to DeWitt Duckett.
DeWitt's family members,
city and school officials,
and some of his classmates
from Harlem Park Junior High
all find it hard to accept
the sudden loss
of this young man
who's been described
as studious,
hardworking, and quiet.
He was a very good friend
of mine, but...
I just feel so sad
that he's gone, right,
that I really can't express
what I want to say.
I just hope they catch
the people who shot him.
[Ta-Nehisi] The community
was deeply traumatized
and wanted something done.
Had you interviewed me
at eight years old
and you asked me
what I thought about that,
I would have told you,
"This makes me feel unsafe,"
or however I would have said,
you know, in that vocabulary
at the time,
and "I hope they get who did it.
And I hope whoever did it
is not anywhere near
any other child."
That's what I would have felt,
because I'm sure
that's what the adults felt.
[lawyer 1] Mr. Kincaid,
can you please state
and spell your full name
for the record, sir?
First name is Donald,
D-O-N-A-L-D,
Kincaid, K-I-N-C-A-I-D.
[lawyer 1] When did you work for
the Baltimore Police Department?
[Donald] From 1966 to 1990.
[lawyer 2] Can you please state
and spell your name
for the record?
Name, Ron Bishop, R-O-N,
Bishop, B-I-S-H-O-P.
Edward Capers.
E-D-W-A-R-D, C-A-P-E-R-S.
[lawyer 2] When Detective
Kincaid came in the room,
what, if anything,
did he say to you?
He seemed concerned, um,
and just asked me
a few questions,
like, how am I feeling?
[lawyer 2] What, if anything,
did you say in response?
I said I was-- I was--
I told him I was okay,
just nervous, anxious...
shocked.
They gave me the impression
they was truly concerned,
they was trying to get
this case over with,
they was trying to figure out
who did this and who did that.
I told him that the person
that came up behind us,
myself, Edward Capers,
and DeWitt Duckett,
dark-skinned guy,
light colored pants, um,
a white or grayish hoodie
and, um, slight mustache.
How many people did you say
were involved in the shooting?
I told Mr. Kincaid
only one person.
[lawyer 2]
How many people did you say
were involved in the shooting?
One person.
[lawyer 1]
Mr. Kincaid, do you see
that first paragraph?
"According to Detective
Donald L. Kincaid,
the victim's two friends said
they were walking in the hall
when a teenage boy," singular,
"walked up behind them
and grabbed the collar
of DeWitt Duckett's jacket."
Did I read that correctly?
-Mm-hmm. Yes, sir.
-[lawyer 1] Okay. All right.
How did you get
to three suspects?
-How did I get three suspects?
-[lawyer 1] Yeah.
I was teaching a class,
three young men came to my door,
and one of them came in the room
to talk to somebody he knew,
and I was trying to get him
to leave, you know,
asked him nicely to leave.
And then the other ones
was out in the hallway,
hollering in the room, trying
to talk to other people.
So they was disrupting my class.
So then I was getting
very annoyed,
so I went to the door
and nicely pushed, pushed
one of them out the door,
and then I locked the door
and I went on with my quiz.
[lawyer 2] Did those boys, um,
two of which you identified
as Alfred Chestnut
and Ransom Watkins,
did they make any threats
to other students
in the classroom?
No.
[lawyer 2] Did you see
any of those boys
carrying any weapons?
No.
[lawyer 2]
You described the boys as,
quote, "real polite," quote,
"They were just, you know,
really silly and immature"?
Yes.
According to a security guard,
that they were in the school
without permission.
So they-they actually,
although this speaks
to one-one defendant,
they actually became possible
suspects in the investigation.
[soft, tense music playing]
[Alfred] From that day
when it happened
and then come questioning us
on a Saturday,
they told us that, um,
we weren't being arrested,
we were just being questioned.
They said that they had
witnesses saying
that they saw us
inside that school that day
and which I said, "Yeah.
Yeah, we were inside
the school. Yes, we were."
I had my Georgetown jacket on
that day.
I didn't hide from the police.
We walked right
in front of them,
and I was in the car
with my Georgetown jacket on.
And then you're going to joke
with me in the car about it,
like-- like, "Did you kill
that boy for that jacket?"
And I'll tell you, I said,
"No, this is my jacket.
No, no, we didn't."
He asked us,
what time did we leave?
I had a watch on. I knew
exactly what time we left.
From leaving there
from the security guard
talking to us
was like 12:45 maybe.
It took 15 minutes to get
from Harlem Park
to Mount Street for walking,
compared to when my friend
got killed in Harlem Park.
We never lied to the police
about nothing that we did
that day inside that school.
Nothing.
[soft, gentle music playing]
[Ron] I remember Donald Kincaid
coming by the house
with pictures
and showing me, like,
several pictures of guys,
Alfred, Ransom, Andrew,
asked me, "Does anyone look
familiar in the pictures?"
I'm like,
"No, no, I do recognize them,
but no one
in the set of pictures
that I recognize
as the shooter."
[indistinct radio chatter]
There was a time
when an officer came by
and asked, "Can you come down
to homicide with us?"
And, you know, I'm thinking,
"Oh, they got good news."
When we get there,
Donald Kincaid,
he doesn't really have
eye contact with me,
and he said,
"Can you have a seat?"
[lawyer 2] Did you have
any adult relatives
with you at that time?
No adult relatives.
[lawyer 2] Were you accompanied
by any adult relative of yours?
No, ma'am.
[lawyer 1] Were Mr. Bishop's
parents present?
-No, sir.
-Did you tell Mr. Bishop
he could have
his parents present?
No, sir.
[lawyer 1]
Did you tell Mr. Capers
that if he wanted to have
his parents present,
he could have
his parents present?
No, I did not.
He says, um...
"We have someone of interest,
and, um, and we think
you know who the person is."
I'm like,
"Well, the only person I know
is the description I gave you."
And he said, "No,
we have someone and, um,
you haven't been-- you haven't
been honest to us."
They said they had,
uh, new evidence
that it was more
than one person involved
and, uh, I wasn't
totally truthful with them.
I'm like, "What, what?
What do you mean?"
Like, "No, no, I told you,
it was only one person."
Then he said,
"Well, I believe you've been
holding back information."
I'm like, "No,
I've been honest with you."
So it went back and forth
and back and forth,
and then he said,
"Well, the person or persons
that committed this crime
or killed DeWitt,
they're in this photo."
I'm like, "No, no, no way."
He already told me
he had a witness,
and the witness
was this young girl,
and the witness
told him everything,
so therefore I'm lying to him.
That's when, uh, I first heard
about Yvette Thomas,
and, um, he was telling me
how her statement
don't coincide
with mine's or Ron's.
I'm like,
"Why would they?
Where were she? Who is she?"
[lawyer 2] Did he tell you
that he had spoken
to Yvette Thomas?
Yes. Actually,
he said she came to him.
[lawyer 2]
And what did he tell you
about his meeting with Yvette?
He said, uh, Yvette witnessed
the whole thing,
she was standing
in the side corridor,
and she witnessed
the whole thing.
She saw three people
approach, uh, DeWitt,
uh, grab him, hold him,
one was pointing a gun to him,
another one standing
to the side,
and, uh...
then, um, the guy shot him,
and they all ran back
the other way.
I told him,
"There's no way in the world
any of this
could have been true because
it was only four of us
in the corridor."
There's no way possible
she could place herself
in this hallway
because there is a gate.
There's no way.
[Edward] It's a gate there
that's locked.
[lawyer 2]
And from your memory,
were you standing
in front of that gate
at the time the shooter
approached Mr. Duckett?
[Edward] No, ma'am.
We haven't reached it yet.
[lawyer 2] So if someone
were standing in that hallway,
would it have been possible
for that person
to see anything?
No.
[lawyer 1] Let me ask you
about, um, uh, Yvette Thomas
and when she gives you
this information
on November the 23rd.
What did you do to corroborate
whether her statement
was truthful or not?
Nothing that I recall,
just that we had
the other three witnesses
come down and showed them
the photograph.
[lawyer 1] Right. You didn't do
any follow-up
to corroborate the veracity
of Miss Yvette Thomas's
statement or identification
of Mr. Stewart, Mr. Chestnut,
and Mr. Watkins, correct?
No. Correct.
[lawyer 1] You took
Yvette Thomas's statement,
um, as credible,
even though you didn't get
that statement
until five days after the murder
on November the 23rd, correct?
Correct.
[solemn music playing]
[Edward] He just kept repeating
what she said happened.
I-I even explained to him
the layout of the place.
I explained all that
and he just got infuriated,
he started yelling
and screaming. I was like,
the more truth I bring out,
the worse it got,
so I just shut down.
And then he starts
threatening me,
"I'll put your head
through a goddamn wall,
you fucking whatever."
He say, "You know what?
Your goddamn ass
is not leaving here.
You're going to be here
all night."
I said, uh, "Can we, uh...
Can we get my mother to come
get me so I can go home?"
He say, "You ain't going home."
I'm not going back home.
[Ron] He yells,
he bangs on the table.
-[table thuds]
-He said,
"I can charge your ass
with accessory to murder."
You know, I felt like
I want to cry.
Kincaid told me that, uh,
if I'm going to continue
to, um, disagree with it,
then that means
I'm a part of it,
and he's going to charge me.
If we don't get on board,
me and Ron will be charged
with accessories,
and we'll be taken away
from our families.
That mean they going
to lock me up
and, um, put the blame on me.
[lawyer 2] And how did that
make you feel?
I was terrified.
I'm 16 years old, you going
to put me in a prison
with grown freak-ball men?
Man.
You know,
I'm starting to realize
he just wants me to lie.
He's going to frame me
to say someone did it,
I didn't know at the time,
like, who is he talking about?
He's going to frame me
to say someone did it,
and now he's going to make me
a snitch, a lying snitch.
And not only that,
if I don't do what he says,
I'm going to prison.
I'm 14, so I'm like,
are you going to put me
in a Maryland state
penitentiary at 14?
I ain't never been nowhere
without my family.
I ain't never been separated
from my family.
I was 16 years old, I ain't
never been in no trouble,
nothing.
When he told me
that he would charge me,
have me put in prison,
separated from my family,
he became-- he became
a god right there.
I know I am not leaving alive
if I don't tell him
that Alfred shot DeWitt,
Alfred had the gun,
Andrew and Ransom were pulling
the jacket off of him.
[lawyer 1] You tell Mr. Bishop
that if he didn't cooperate
with you,
that he could be charged
as an accessory
to this murder-robbery?
I don't recall saying that,
no, sir.
[lawyer 1] You recall, um,
being physical with Mr. Bishop,
-putting your hands on him?
-Physical?
-[lawyer 1] Yes.
-No, sir.
[lawyer 1] Did you make
any threatening gestures
toward Mr. Bishop?
No, sir. None that I recall.
[lawyer 1] When Mr. Bishop
changed his story
on November 23, 1983,
and all of a sudden was able
to select Mr. Chestnut,
Mr. Watkins, and Mr. Stewart,
why did you believe him?
I believed him because of what
Yvette Thomas had told me.
I think they were at a point
where they were ready
to tell the truth.
[light music playing]
[Ron] When I got home,
I just kept it to myself.
I never told my parents
because I knew my parents
would confront them,
and I was afraid that somehow
they would kill my parents
because I'm like,
if you're willing to do this
to those three guys,
then you're willing to kill,
and that's what I was afraid of.
I didn't want my parents
to get killed,
or hurt, or go to jail.
You know, I felt
so ashamed of myself.
I couldn't even talk
to my mother about it.
I was scared
to say something to her
because my mother
ain't going to bite her tongue,
and I didn't want her
to get in trouble.
You're living
in this nightmare, a dream.
Just nightmares all over.
[reporter] Police believe
they have in custody
all of those involved
in the Harlem Park
Junior High murder.
They have yet to recover
the weapon.
All these polices just start
coming in the house.
They say, "We want
to search your house."
I said, "For what?"
They bust in the door,
they searched the living room,
they flipped my bed over
upstairs.
They was just
all over the house.
[Alfred] They taken me
out of my bed
one o'clock in the morning
on Thanksgiving,
arrest us and taken me
to Western District.
[reporter] Police spokesman
Dennis Hill says
information from witnesses
led to these arrests.
[Dennis] They were able to get
enough concurring information
to begin writing warrants
about nine o'clock last night,
and at about midnight
they began arresting, uh,
the boys at home.
[reporter] These are two
of the suspects,
16-year-old Alfred Chestnut,
a student at Harlem Park
Junior High,
the school where
the murder took place.
Police allege that Chestnut
was the trigger man.
The second suspect here is
16-year-old Ransom Watkins,
a student
at Walbrook Senior High.
The third suspect is
16-year-old Andrew Stewart,
a student at Douglass High.
[Alfred] I remember
what was going in my mind
and the expression on my face
when I was in the paddy wagon.
I just did like this, and I
turned around and I looked,
because I was in my head like,
"What? What is going on?"
I can't believe
what's going on with me.
"What's-what's happening?"
[Dennis] At the home
of one of them,
the jacket, believed
to have been taken
from, uh, the victim,
was recovered.
[reporter]
But Alfred Chestnut's mother
says the jacket belonged
to her son
and she has a receipt
to prove it.
After they had searched
the house,
you know, and everything,
I showed them the receipt
for the jacket.
[reporter] And the store
receipt confirmed the date
of the purchase was two weeks
before the murder.
Sarah Chestnut also claims
DeWitt Duckett and her son
were friends.
Whoever did this, you know,
I wish they would come forward
and give theirself up
because my son didn't have
anything to do with this.
[reporter] But police
are looking for a gun,
which they say Alfred Chestnut
used to shoot Duckett.
Last night, the police
just going to come
busting in the house
searching for it.
They said they searching
for a .22 gun.
[interviewer]
Did your brother have a gun?
No, my brother
don't have no gun.
The three young suspects
will appear
before a district court judge
tomorrow
for their bail review.
[Andrew] It was horrible
how you tried to tear me apart
from my friends.
[clock ticking]
"Ransom said this,"
"Alfred said that."
"They was doing this for you
or they was doing that
for this reason,"
this, that, and another.
What?
"If you don't tell us,
you're gonna spend
the rest of your life in prison.
Your mother gonna die
before you get out of prison."
The worst stuff
you could tell somebody.
It was terrible.
Finally, they let me go in
and see him,
and, oh, he was a mess.
He was crying, he was like,
"Ma, you know
I ain't kill nobody.
They said we killed
the-the boy."
I said, "What boy, Andrew?"
He said, "Ma, you know DeWitt,
don't you?" I said, "Yeah."
He said, "They said
we killed him over a jacket."
He said, "You know
I wouldn't do that,
I didn't kill him
and they keep--
they keep badgering us
and badgering us."
[Alfred] That was like
a nightmare, like,
and they gonna say
something like,
Ransom and them was saying
that I did this and did that.
And I said, "They couldn't
have said nothing like that
because all of us was together
and we ain't do nothing,
so I know you...
I know you lying.
I know you lying.
'Cause we ain't do nothing.
Neither one of us
ain't do nothing."
So, and they said
the same thing to them.
[Ransom] The officer
that had locked us up,
there's something
he told me as a kid
that no kid should hear.
And at 16 years old,
he told me, he said, "Listen,
you Black, I'm white,
I have a badge.
Who do you think
they're going to believe?"
[reporter] Alfred Chestnut
was brought back
to Western District
from city jail this morning.
Also spending the night
in jail, Ransom Watkins.
Andrew Stewart spent the night
at Western's lockup,
joining his co-defendants
in court,
where a large contingent
of family, friends,
and Harlem Park PTA members
were also.
Taking us to court
from city jail,
we're getting on a bus,
like, uh, getting shackled.
You get taken
to, uh, the courtroom,
then you sit in the bullpen,
the cold bullpen.
As a kid, we were scared, like,
I mean, yeah, I was scared.
When we went
in front of the judge,
they talked to us
like we was trash,
like we shouldn't be breathing.
And we looked at each other,
"Man, I love you.
You're my brother for life.
We didn't kill him.
We're not telling nobody
we killed this dude.
He was a friend of ours,
we gon' be brothers for life."
[reporter] Prosecutors
in court told the judge
they had witnesses
who saw Andrew Stewart
try to remove the jacket
from DeWitt Duckett that day.
The judge gave him $75,000 bond.
Those same witnesses saw
Ransom Watkins
hold the man about the neck.
They gave him $100,000 bail.
And those same witnesses saw
Alfred Chestnut
pull the trigger
and kill DeWitt Duckett,
the judge set his bail
at $150,000.
The boy's not guilty
and neither one of us
had money to, uh, to get bail
after the lawyer.
[reporter 1] Are you gonna make
bail, gonna try and make bail?
No, the money going
for a lawyer, not the bail.
[reporter 2] Are you going
to try and make bail?
Well, it's too high, really,
and I don't have the money,
you know, for the bail
because it's too high.
[reporter] We tried to talk
with Andrew Stewart's mother,
who was also in court,
but she had nothing
to say to us.
Please.
[Ann] Don Scott
was running behind me.
He said, "Miss Stewart,
do you have any comments?"
I said, "No, no comment.
No comment."
And I just went home.
I just went home, and I just
went in the living room,
and I just sit there,
and I just cried
and cried and cried.
I was like, "No,
this can't be happening.
This can't be true.
This is not true.
Why would they do this?"
After that,
they just stayed in jail.
I really couldn't afford
the lawyer,
so they told us that we
could get a public defender.
The lawyer,
Mr. Stewart said to me,
he said,
"This is going to be a hard--"
He said,
"This is going to be hard."
He said, "Because
they want to get somebody."
[solemn music playing]
[Alfred] In around that time,
Black youth was considered
as public enemy number one.
People saying they was afraid
of Black youth.
They walked down the street,
they'd be afraid,
you know what I'm saying?
So time was changing.
Wasn't nobody going to give us
justice on this case
because the media had it.
Three Baltimore teenagers
charged with a...
[overlapping reporting]
[Ransom]
And once the media got it,
everybody was just thinking
that we was guilty.
[Ta-Nehisi] There is
a tremendous amount
of narrative resource
that goes into establishing
police departments
as the institution
within the community
that was most worthy of trust.
A community like Baltimore,
that the Black community
so quickly jumped
to conclusions
about who was guilty
and who was not,
what happened was
that they trusted the cops,
they trusted the police,
they trusted the people
they were told to trust,
and those people
revealed themselves
to be the wrong people.
[director]
I meet Jonathan Shoup,
the district attorney,
and he's describing to us
what the situation is,
and it's the same narrative
that Kincaid
and these other two witnesses
who weren't there,
same exact narrative.
Kincaid, he was present
in the room
as we were rehearsing.
When Kincaid left,
I approached Jonathan Shoup,
I said, "Excuse me, Mr. Shoup,
the stuff that
you're going over,
it really didn't happen
this way.
It's not exactly that way."
And immediately he said,
"Oh, just go over there
and have a seat."
[reporter] Today,
three teenagers went on trial
at Baltimore Circuit Court
for Duckett's murder.
In his opening argument,
Assistant State's Attorney
Jonathan Shoup told the jury
the three had come
to the school that day
looking for someone to rob.
They found Duckett on his way
to the school cafeteria
for lunch.
Franzelle Duckett,
the victim's mother,
was in court today.
She cried when she heard
the description
of how her son died.
Afterwards, Prosecutor Shoup
outlined his case.
What we plan to show
is that there were
several eyewitnesses
to the crime,
and that the case was--
the evidence will demonstrate
that a robbery was committed.
And during the course of that
robbery, the three defendants
were responsible for the death
of DeWitt Duckett.
In their closing arguments,
defense attorneys
called Duckett's death
a hideous crime,
but they said they would be
able to refute testimony
from students and teachers
at Harlem Park
that it was their clients
who did the killing.
Yeah, I thought
I could win it, absolutely.
The jacket was not the jacket,
uh, from DeWitt Duckett.
I told my lawyer
about the receipt.
[Barry] Alfred's mother
produced the receipt.
The store manager, who did
end up being a witness,
proved that the jacket
that Alfred Chestnut had
was not the jacket that
was taken from the victim.
[Alfred] One of the jurors,
he said he saw on TV
that they seized evidence
out of my house,
the Georgetown jacket
out of my house.
He said he formulated his own
opinion that I was guilty.
He still wound up being
on the jury stand.
The judge, he just allowed
all this stuff.
The prosecutor acted
very suspiciously.
Remember, we didn't know
anything at the time
because we were given...
Well, we were given
really scant information.
We knew that there were
many other documents.
The defense tried
to force Shoup
to produce these documents.
Shoup told Judge Bell
that they don't have
anything to do with this case
and the judge just accepted
his answer.
And somehow they were sealed
in an envelope.
We weren't allowed
to look at them.
I've never heard
of anything like that
where they were sealed.
And Judge Bell himself
had apparently
no interest whatsoever,
even by himself in chambers
reading them.
They put a lot of effort
into hiding, uh, the evidence
and the material
they didn't turn over.
I was, like, losing my mind
with the judge after a while,
and I couldn't believe
that he would just accept
the things that, uh,
Shoup was saying.
One time we thought we was
going to have a mistrial.
The security guard said that,
"Ain't no way these boys
could have did this..."
He said,
"...because I found those boys
and I took them
out of the school.
I walked them
out of the school."
[reporter]
The three defendants decided
not to testify
in their own defense,
thus avoiding
cross-examination,
and Shoup said
four witnesses testified
they saw the three do it.
But the lawyers
for the defendant said
most of the same witnesses
had denied
that the three were involved
and only changed their stories
later under pressure.
But the jury was reminded
by the prosecutor
that the witnesses said
they were terrified
because the three defendants
allegedly threatened
to hurt anyone
who told what happened.
They had four witnesses
with completely inconsistent
statements
who could not describe
anything about the scene
or what any of the defendants
were wearing,
how far they were.
Any factual questions
of the situation
they could not answer.
[Ransom] They were saying that
they had four eyewitnesses,
that they looked down a hall
and saw us do a murder.
[Alfred] Ron Bishop,
Edward Capers,
John Caldwell
and Yvette Thomas.
[melancholy music playing]
[Barry] Yvette Thomas,
she was a small, young girl.
You don't want to beat her up
too much on cross-examination,
because then you just come off
as a bully
and take the chance
of losing the jury,
and I-I thought she was
going to be a problem
for-for us as the defense.
Edward Capers like,
I ain't never did nothing
to-- to ever to--
for him to want
to send me to prison
for something I ain't do.
[director]
No, he couldn't look at me.
And a guy named Ron Bishop
who been knowing me
my whole life.
The only thing you understand
is frustration,
anger that somebody's
getting up there and lying
and decimating your character.
People that you went
to school with,
that you knew
in the neighborhood,
sat up there and lie
like that on you,
your heart gonna drop.
In my mind,
I was saying to myself,
"Why would he do that?"
[gavel pounding]
-[whispering]
-[soft, somber music playing]
[Ron] I couldn't even sleep
the day before
and my heart was pounding.
I felt like crying
on the stand because
I'm looking at them
and they're looking at me,
and I'm telling lies.
And this is what I don't get,
the jury never picked up on...
me making
contradictory statements.
[somber music playing]
I was hoping
that Judge Robert Bell
will postpone,
pull me back in his chambers
or in his office,
and say, "Hey, young man,
what's really going on?"
He never did any of that.
[whispering in court]
So now I have to live
with this lie.
The more I think about it,
the more angry I get at Bell.
I mean, he-he bears...
more responsibility,
well, not more than Shoup
or Kincaid,
but he-he bears
a lot of responsibility.
He had to have had that
feeling in his gut, you know,
that it was just wrong,
and I don't know
how you-- how you couldn't.
[somber music playing]
I-I just, I can't tell you
how damaging this shit is.
You know, it's like
you've been violated,
and then you go for help
and the help violates you.
It-it destroys your ability
to trust the state.
I just, I-I can't begin
to express
the-the level of violation
that this is.
[melancholy music playing]
God just-just let me know
that that was it for us,
because it was sunny outside,
and we were sitting
in the courtroom,
big, big windows,
big windows like this
that you could see outside
and the windows was open.
All of a sudden
it just got dark.
[thunder rumbling softly]
It started raining
and thundering real loud.
-[thunder rumbling]
-[rain falling]
I just knew we was going
to get found guilty, that day.
Yep.
I knew it.
When they were found guilty,
I was-- I was pretty shocked.
I was angry and upset.
[reporter] The three
defendants sat emotionless
as Judge Robert Bell
announced the sentence,
first for 16-year-old
Alfred Chestnut.
Judge Bell to Alfred Chestnut,
"It was a useless crime,
a waste of a life,
and by my actions,
by this sentencing,
I'm participating
in the waste of another life,
but under the circumstances,
I think it's justified."
Alfred Chestnut received life
in prison plus 20 years.
Then the judge turned
to Ransom Watkins
and Andrew Stewart and asked
if they had anything to say.
Stewart summed it up,
"We know
we didn't kill DeWitt,
but the jury did what
they thought was best,
and we have to deal with it."
Judge Bell sentenced them
both to life in prison.
[Ta-Nehisi] Was what happened
to them fair?
Let's say they had done it,
let's say we had caught
the right person that did it,
should that person have been
put into an adult prison?
I-I don't think so.
They don't really care
about children.
They don't see children
as children.
I just hollered out,
"No, no, no.
This is not right.
No, it's not right!"
It wasn't right.
They had no right to do that,
because they know,
and they-they knew
that these kids did not do this.
My son, he looked at me,
he said, "Ma, I didn't do this."
I said, "I... I know
you didn't do this."
He said,
"Why I gotta go to jail?"
We couldn't do nothing.
It was over.
[grim, dramatic music playing]
[Alfred] When they found us
guilty and everything,
they sent me straight over
to the Maryland penitentiary.
I was 16, they didn't care,
they didn't care.
And when I first came in there
walking through the doors,
I got my shackles on
and all I saw was, like,
busted windows,
pigeons and stuff
flying all around.
[cooing, wings flapping]
I see a dude say, uh, said,
"Yeah, that's one
of them dudes right there
that killed that boy
for his Georgetown jacket."
Absolutely terrified.
Remember, I may be
the oldest in months,
but I'm absolutely the smallest.
About 5'1", 5'2".
About 112, 113 pounds
soaking wet.
Jail bait, as they say.
I seen men getting raped,
seen men getting stabbed
to death...
[prisoners chattering]
...about nothing,
about a basketball game,
a football game.
[Alfred] I saw people
getting stabbed in the yard,
knife fights in the yard.
You would think like,
"Am I gonna die here?"
I just cry all the time, like,
call my moms, like,
begging her
to try to get me a lawyer.
My moms know I ain't do that,
moms know I-I never did
nothing like that in my life,
never robbed anybody in my life.
Never thought about doing
nothing like that in my life.
[Ann] And you got to listen
to the horrifying stories
that you really don't want
to hear,
then you go home
and the phone rings
and you don't know
if that's somebody calling you
to tell you your son is dead
or he hurt.
[Ransom] No kids
should have to go through
what we went through.
You take a kid at 16,
you put him in an adult system,
and you don't think
that he's going to have
psychological problems
when he get out?
It's literally impossible.
See, at 16, I had to become a,
what I would consider
an animal,
because you put me
in a position
where if I don't act
like an animal,
then they're going to take
advantage of me,
where a place I don't belong.
It was either
you act like they act for now,
or you let them
take advantage of you,
and that I wasn't going to do.
[prisoners chattering]
[Andrew] How do you get over
that psychological hurdle?
[Ransom] Most people go crazy,
and the walls do talk to you,
and if they tell you
they don't, they lying.
[Andrew] Especially when
you had to do it for 36 years.
[dreary music playing]
Thirty-six years...
of trauma.
I made my own life in there,
started putting myself
around things
that I knew would keep
my mind occupied.
So I worked all day,
I drove a forklift
for probably around
about 13 or 14 years.
Like, I was a workaholic.
Had I stopped, then I would
have been thinking about,
"Man, they got me here
for something I didn't do.
I don't deserve this."
And your mind can't take that.
I was offered parole,
only if I admit my guilt.
They was gonna give me
work release,
but I choose to die in prison
before I walk out that door.
If you're wrong, you say
you're wrong, you own up.
But if you're right,
you stand on it till you die.
[dramatic music playing]
[birds chirping]
[music fades]
[Ron] I've been painting
for about 15 years now,
and over time,
it has been therapy
for me, it has.
I never forgot...
I never forgot them.
I could only imagine
the punishment and the abuse
that they were going through
in jail.
You carry that guilt with you.
[dramatic, somber music playing]
Like, the pain
and the guilt of...
like, staying quiet and silent.
I don't know, I started off as
a pretty good student, I did.
I had really good grades.
And after the case,
I couldn't really concentrate
on my work.
You know, after that,
you don't trust people.
I spent a lot of time
to myself.
I think I was in my 20s...
[sighs] ...and I was thinking
about calling the FBI,
see if you could find help
to get those guys free.
But for me,
being Black in this country
and dealing with racist people,
they can set up any situation
they can and frame you,
so I had nowhere to turn to.
When I made it through school
and through college
and I started working,
I'm happy for myself.
But then I just remember
not to be too happy because
I remembered that, um,
that Alfred, Ransom, and Andrew
would never get
the opportunity that I got,
and that stuck with me.
I sent Black boys
who looked just like me,
from the same neighborhood,
to prison
that didn't kill my friend.
The only person I ever spoke to
about this was with Ron,
and we was basically comparing
how differently
things had turned out.
Whenever we got stressed out,
we, uh, found each other
and we just talked.
He was, uh, he was having
similar problems as me
as far as, uh, nightmares
and, um, headaches,
you know, migraines
and all that, but, um,
emotionally, he-he held--
he held on stronger than me
because he ain't get
into a whole lot of crap.
When all this happened,
it just sent my whole life
in a spiral.
I ain't care about nothing
after that.
I lost respect for the law,
I lost faith
in the justice system, period.
[lawyer 2] Did you stop going
to school after the murder,
or did you continue
for some point after that?
I never went back.
[indistinct chatter]
I just gave up on everything.
I started getting high,
using drugs, drinking.
Oh, man, I just,
I was just in a whirl,
a whirlwind spiral of trouble.
One thing after another.
[lawyer 2] Just looking
at that criminal history
beginning in 1989
through 2019, um,
it's obvious that you've been
in some trouble with the law.
So is it accurate
that you're serving
a 28-year sentence currently?
Yes, ma'am.
-[indistinct chatter]
-[music fades]
[Alfred] As years went by,
I was basically trying
to survive.
You can be doing
the bad stuff,
or you can be doing something
that's going to keep you
motivated.
[papers rustling]
All the older guys,
you know, they tell you,
you go to school, you work out,
and you work on your case.
I'm an innocent man,
and to prove it,
it's going to be hard.
We sat around
and, uh, studied our cases
and stuff like that together.
I just wrote everybody,
DC, New York, Virginia,
I wrote everywhere, right?
It took me, like, seven years
to get my transcript,
and I would sit down there
and read it.
And so I started writing
the police department,
asking them, "Can I get
my police reports?"
I would get denied
all the time. They told me,
"You got to pay for it,
it costs this much."
I ain't had that money
to get it.
Even under the Freedom
of Information Act,
they still denied me.
[mellow music playing]
[phone ringing]
[automated voice]
This call is from...
[Alfred] Alfred Chestnut.
...an inmate at a Maryland
correctional facility.
[phone beeps]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
[phone rings]
[Alfred]
[phone rings]
-[Alfred]
-[Angela]
[Alfred]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
Mmm-mmm.
[Angela]
[Alfred]
-Um...
-[Angela]
I mean, when I got
all the, um, police reports,
I got one police report.
I just-- I just knew,
then right there,
because I showed, um, some
of the guys that studied law.
They was like, "Man, that's,
that's all you need, Chestnut.
That's it, that's a done deal.
You out of here, man."
I sat down and I wrote, like,
a five-page letter.
[woman] May of 2019
is when this particular case
came to our attention,
and actually,
I was reviewing
all of the applications
that came in.
It was just
a handwritten letter,
um, from Mr. Chestnut.
[Alfred on phone] I said,
"Dear Ms. Marilyn Mosby,
I've been trying to get help
for a very long time
in my case.
I was trying to get
my police reports for years
and finally after 35 years
I got them.
The things I read
in my police report,
I've never seen before.
All of this is newly
discovered evidence."
[Lauren] At the time
of receiving that letter,
I did what I would normally do,
which is pull back
certain documents
to figure out exactly
whether or not this has merit.
I mean, it took me two minutes,
and I'm like,
"Okay, I don't see how
they got to these people."
Usually you are able
to clearly see
where they were headed.
This case however,
when you look at the timeline,
it's not clear.
While you had
these three individuals
and you actually had
additional individuals
who were in the school
at the time,
but then you almost have
this leap
in the police reports
to fast forward
to about a week later,
and all of a sudden, you've got
locked-in identifications
and these people
are under arrest.
But what you don't see
is any sort
of logical development
of how that occurred.
I realized that, no,
this needs to be investigated.
The Maryland
Public Information Act request
that Mr. Chestnut had filed
with the Attorney General's
office,
usually we don't tend
to have their file
yielding anything
that would be of use.
That's not the case here.
He got documents
that included police reports
that we actually did not have
at all in our file, period.
Those police reports
did not match
what I saw in the transcript
and what I saw
in the file documents
that we already had,
and that was a major problem.
[Alfred]
[Lauren]
They had anonymous tips,
they had people who called in,
they had people
who made statements,
and all of those individuals
were clearly identifying
another individual
named Michael Willis
as being the person
who had committed that murder,
by name.
[Alfred]
[Angela shouting]
One of the witnesses who
had actually called in said,
"I was at the Shake & Bake
that night
and Michael Willis came in
wearing the victim's jacket
and was bragging about
the fact that he was wearing
the victim's jacket."
That's in the police reports.
[Alfred]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
[Alfred laughs]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
There was no evidence
to suggest,
"Well, we... we ran down
that lead."
He should have been considered.
[lawyer 1] Do you recall,
um, Theresa Moody, uh, saying
that another person told her
that Michael Willis was at
Harlem Park Junior High School
on the day of the shooting,
had a gun,
he threw down the gun,
and he ran away
with some other boys?
You recall Miss Moody
giving you that information?
Yes, I think I recall that.
[lawyer 1]
And why did you go interview
Mr. Chestnut, Mr. Stewart,
and Mr. Watkins
before you created
the photo array
if you didn't interview
Mike Willis?
Well... [clears throat]
I think Michael Willis's name
came through,
like, two or three
different parties.
The names of, um, Ransom,
Alfred, and Andrew
came up from Mrs. Woodworth,
the school teacher.
[lawyer 1]
Regarding Michael Willis,
when, if ever,
did you interview him?
-Michael Willis?
-Yes.
I never interviewed
Michael Willis.
I-I can't recall whether
it was John Caldwell,
Bishop, or Mr. Capers,
but I went to show him
and he picked out,
he picked out his picture
and said, "Oh, I know him.
He lives down the street.
He's not involved in this."
So he was basically cleared
that way.
[director]
I knew of him because he was
from the neighborhood.
He lived, like,
a block and a half
from where I lived.
[lawyer 1] And when
Mr. Bishop, Mr. Caldwell, um,
did not pick out Mr. Watkins,
Mr. Chestnut, Mr. Stewart,
why didn't you at that time
determine that they, too,
were not involved in this?
I have no answer for that.
I don't recall why.
[lawyer 1] Help me understand,
why did you believe
John Caldwell or Ron Bishop
with respect to Michael Willis,
but you didn't believe them
with respect
to, um, their negative
photo identification
of the three suspects?
I don't have any--
I don't have any recollection
or have any recall
as to why I did either one.
[Alfred]
-[Angela]
-[Alfred]
[Angela]
[Alfred]
The trial transcript shed
some light on those documents.
We're a page into the transcript
when the defense
is standing up and saying,
"I have received nothing
from the State.
I've received
no police reports.
I don't know anything about
the police investigation.
I don't know how they arrived
at arresting my clients.
I have no information
whatsoever
that's been provided to me
about this investigation
and how my clients
are sitting here today."
And that was them starting
a murder trial
for Mr. Chestnut,
Mr. Watkins, and Mr. Stewart.
They had all kinds
of information
about this Michael Willis
and just plain ignored it
and hid it.
Uh...
If there's anything
more egregious
than what was done
with not turning that over,
not letting us explore it,
not even letting us know
that there could possibly be
another, uh, suspect...
I've never seen
Brady violations like this,
where somebody's just lying
directly to the judge.
[dramatic music playing]
[woman] So I was aware that
there was a case that came in
and that Lauren was concerned
because there had been
some exculpatory evidence
that had not been turned over.
The prosecutor misrepresented
facts to the court,
which is prosecutorial
misconduct.
You have to take
responsibility for that,
and even though it didn't happen
under my administration,
I was then the state's attorney,
and I have to recognize
that we messed up.
The four witnesses
who had direct evidence
that testified at trial,
their testimony
was incredibly vague.
That is extremely unusual
where you've got four kids
who can't answer
any basic questions
about a homicide they saw.
"What was the shooter
wearing?" "I don't know."
"Was the shooter tall?"
"I don't know."
"Where was the shooter
standing?" "I don't know."
So at that point,
it became urgent
to try to get a hold
of the witnesses in the case.
While it was not hard
to find Mr. Bishop,
as with anyone who gets
a letter out of the blue
from the state's attorney's
office,
it took us a few weeks to, um,
to convince Mr. Bishop,
uh, that it would be
a good idea to talk to us.
This is the same
state's attorney's office
that I told the truth
in the beginning,
and they framed those guys
and they were framing me
and threatening me as well,
so I don't trust anyone.
It changed
when I got the letter,
that et al. letter from
Conviction Integrity Unit.
So I said, "Well,
I'll give it one more shot."
Finally, Mr. Bishop did agree
to talk to us,
and, um, and he came in,
uh, and just,
it was a very long interview.
But he, uh,
he broke down at points, um,
and he-he said that he,
uh, had not been truthful.
And what really,
I will always remember
about that conversation was
that he thanked us at the end,
and he thanked us
for our resilience
in getting a hold of him
and for listening to him
and for, you know,
letting him kind of come clean
after all of these years.
It was fantastic to hear that
they were listening to me.
They believed me.
[lawyer 2] Why should
we believe you today?
First of all, I ain't
the same scared little kid
from '83 in November.
I don't have nothing to gain
or nothing to lose
by lying to you.
So why?
I just want everybody
to know what happened.
[soft, somber music playing]
I need closure for myself.
[lawyer 2] Do you have
any memory, Miss Thomas, of...
attending Harlem Park
Junior High School in 1983?
Yeah, I used to go there.
[lawyer 2] And do you remember
being at school
on the day that DeWitt Duckett
was murdered?
Yes. According to the
transcript, yes, I was there.
[lawyer 2] But you don't have
any independent memory
of being there
that day, is that right?
-Right.
-And so sitting here today,
is it your testimony that
you have no memory whatsoever
about seeing DeWitt Duckett
get murdered in 1983?
I have-- I haven't, no.
[somber music playing]
At the end
of this investigation,
what I had was four
of the eyewitnesses,
the only four individuals
who testified at trial
who said that they saw something
directly related
to the homicide,
now, every single one of them
has recanted.
Our main witness
upon whom was placed
the tremendous burden
of really being the foundation
of-- for the, um,
for all four of the kids,
she has said
she did not see a murder.
Every single one
of the witnesses
said the same thing,
they used the same language.
They were, in their words,
told what to say,
get with the program.
These kids were told
by someone, clearly,
that this was how the criminal
justice system works.
[lawyer 1]
From your perspective,
all you did in this case
was proper, correct?
-To my knowledge, yes, sir.
-[lawyer 1] Right.
And as far as you're concerned,
this was a perfect
investigation, correct?
[laughs] Yes, sir.
If you had to do
this investigation over again,
Mr. Kincaid, what,
if anything, would you change?
Nothing.
[music fades]
I-I just-- I just don't
get it. I just don't get it.
I have to believe
there's something, you know,
there was or is
something going on
in the Baltimore City
Police Department
that would allow for that.
When the police do things
like this, they're fine.
Right, they just got away
with it. It was okay.
Um...
So they're kind of immunized
to do, like,
to come into our community
and do whatever they want,
you know, and taking advantage
of whatever, you know, pain,
you know, we're feeling
and use it however they want.
I mean, the law
is above the law.
In my career, certainly,
this is the most egregious
wrongful conviction case
that I have worked on.
Someone is in prison,
and the moment you believe
that that person
should not be in prison,
that becomes
a full-blown emergency,
and you move heaven and earth
to correct the situation.
[spirited music playing]
I was so outraged
by the injustice
that these men had gone through.
I knew that Alfred was the one
who wrote my office, um,
and Alfred
had not given up hope, right?
And so for me,
I wanted to deliver
that news to him myself,
because I wanted him
to know that he was heard.
When I seen her come
through the door, I was like,
"That's-that's Marilyn Mosby."
I was like, I sat down,
I was shaking,
my hands were shaking.
And I could just see,
like, relief.
It was kind of emotional
for the two of us.
We walked into a little room,
and I said,
"You know why I'm here?"
And he said, "I do."
[Alfred] I smiled,
and she smiled at me.
She said,
"You ain't going home today,
but you'll be going home
on Monday."
So she said, um,
"I'm gonna go on over
and I'm gonna see--
go see your co-defendants,
and I'm gonna let them know."
She came in there and said, "Oh,
after 36 years,
we heard your cries."
She said,
"I'm gonna answer them today.
You'll be going home Monday."
I don't know what happened
after that.
[Ransom]
[Carolyn]
[Ransom]
[Carolyn]
[Ransom]
[Carolyn]
[Ransom]
[Carolyn]
[Ransom]
[Carolyn]
[Ransom]
It don't really register to me
until the judge said, "Stop."
He told the state's attorneys,
"Stop.
Do you mean to tell me
they did all this to these men
for all these years?"
He said...
"Mr. Watkins,
Mr. Chestnut, Mr. Stewart,
I'm sorry.
I apologize."
It was mind-blowing,
not only the fact that he said
we was going home,
but he had the integrity
to apologize to us
for something he had no part in.
[Andrew] Hey, baby!
[Ann] What's up, baby?
[Andrew] Monday!
[Ann] What is Monday?
[Andrew] Monday,
I come home Monday.
[Ann] Baby, what home?
[Andrew] Home, to you!
[Ann] Are you coming home
to me?
[Andrew] Yeah!
-[Ann] Yes!
-[man] Man, stop playing.
[Ann] Yes, he is coming
home Monday.
-[Andrew] Monday!
-[man] No, stop playing.
[Andrew] Monday!
[both laughing]
-[Ann] Yeah!
-[man] Oh, man.
[Andrew] I need you...
I need somebody
to pick me up Monday.
[Ann] Here's what's
gonna happen,
I may not come
because I'm gonna try--
I want to get the room,
get your room straightened out
and everything.
[Ann chuckles]
[Andrew] Ma, listen to me, Ma.
-[Ann] What?
-Please,
please listen to me, Ma.
I want you to be there Monday.
The room will wait for itself.
You are the first person
I want to wrap
my arms around Monday
when they release me.
[Ann] I'll get there,
just put it that way.
I'll be there.
-[Ann laughs]
-[Andrew cheering on phone]
[Ann] What happened? Tell me--
Tell me a little bit
about what happened.
[Andrew] They say they have
enough evidence to prove
that we didn't participate
in the crime.
They found, uh,
prosecutorial misconduct.
They found that they was
tampering with the witness,
they found that they was
withholding evidence.
They found more stuff
than we could ever find.
They said, "Mr. Stewart,
we want to get you home
to your mother
before Thanksgiving.
So Monday,
when you go to court,
you'll be walking out
the door with your mother."
And I started crying.
I just busted out crying.
I-I-I cried so much
and so hard
that they stopped everything
and everybody in the room
started crying.
[Ann] They want you to get
home before Thanksgiving?
[Andrew] Yes.
I went and got my ID,
my release ID today.
He gonna sign the papers
and, at two o'clock,
we can walk out the door.
[Ann] And you ain't owe
nothing, no parole or nowhere.
You can go anywhere
you want to go?
[Andrew] I'm totally free.
[Ann] Oh, God.
Oh, God!
-[Andrew laughs]
-[uplifting music playing]
-[Ann sniffles]
-Ooh, boy,
that's a tough one
right there, boy.
-Mm-hmm.
-Yeah, that's a tough--
-[woman] Look at that.
-That's a pretty-- [laughs]
That's a pretty tough one
there, boy. [sniffles]
Yeah, that's wanting to make
your heart melt,
-I promise you that.
-[Ann cries]
-Mmm-mmm.
-Mmm-mmm.
[indistinct chatter]
Hey there, Andrew.
[Andrew] When I walked out
and I seen my mother,
and my sister,
and my cousin, Tracy,
I just looked up at the sky
and was like,
are you kidding me?
This is real.
[Ann] The only way
I knew it was true,
when I seen him walk
through that door
and he hugged me.
That was the best feeling
in the world.
This is the first time I have
been able to hug my son
in about 20-some years.
This is wonderful.
And I ain't danced
in a long time,
I might do a little dance too.
[laughs]
[Marilyn] It's a tragedy
that these men had 36 years
of their life stolen from them.
There's no way to ever repair
the damage done or the trauma
imposed upon these men
for almost four decades.
So, on behalf of this system,
in an attempt to right
the wrongs of the past,
I apologize to you
and your family
for the pain that you
and they have had to endure
because of this
wrongful conviction.
I'm looking forward, man,
to living the rest of my life
being humble,
as peaceful as I am,
praising God,
looking out for my family.
Oh man, I'm telling you,
I-I... It's out of this world.
This journey here for us
has been rough.
We outside the walls,
but on the inside,
I hate to put it like this,
we went through hell.
I sat on my bunk
when I got the information
and I cried.
I didn't know how to stop crying
until a friend of mine came
to me, hugged me and said,
"Man, your journey
is coming to an end."
But it's not.
My journey just beginning.
[solemn music playing]
[Ta-Nehisi] You know,
you feel a lot of things.
It was just this kind of mix
of, like, rage
about the story
as it had been told,
feeling like a sucker,
deep sympathy
for the brothers themselves
who had gone through it.
Yeah, it's devastating.
[birds chirping]
[music fades]
[grunting] There you go.
Well, I'm all good.
This is what happens
when you come home
after all these years, you got
to take care of peoples.
You got to take care of peoples.
This is my grandmother,
my aunt Gertrude,
my aunt Mott
and my mother right there.
Grandma, boy, we would have
ate a feast and a half...
[woman]
Oh, she'd be cooking for days.
...Grandma would have had
a spread that wouldn't quit.
She probably would cry
every time she see you.
-She probably would.
-Yeah, she would cry
-every time she see him.
-Grandma would be so happy
-to see her grandson.
-Yeah.
[Andrew]
I think it was like '98,
I was about ready to give up.
I was, I was like, "I'm tired.
I'm tired of fighting. I just
wanna bust somebody head
and go in lock-up forever."
Grandma said,
"No, don't you do that.
You ain't gonna be in there
all your life.
You gonna--
You gonna make it home.
You gonna make it home,
just be patient. Hold on."
That's the last thing
I heard from Grandma.
That's the last thing
I heard from Grandma.
But... then we made it home.
Still we got a lot
to celebrate, though.
[Andrew] We do.
[Ann] We got a lot to be
thankful for, God knows.
[Andrew]
One thing we can celebrate,
we ain't got nobody
in our family incarcerated.
-That's true. That is true.
-We sure don't.
[Andrew] Nobody in our family
incarcerated.
-We sure don't, do we?
-No.
[Andrew]
Sure can celebrate that.
-Hadn't even thought of that.
-Me either.
I didn't even think
about that either
-till he just said it.
-No, I sure didn't.
[gentle piano music playing]
[Andrew] You never realize
how many dreams
was taken away from you
until you sit back and...
you rewind your life.
Because I haven't
accomplished nothing.
I-I-I ain't became--
I haven't become a father.
I never got to tell my father
I love him.
I never got to see none
of my grandparents,
they all died
before I came home.
[choking up]
I never got to do none of that.
None of it,
and it kills me to this day.
I wanted so bad
to tell my father I love him,
and he passed away in 1996
without even giving me a hug,
during my whole incarceration.
How is that fair to me?
Should be minding your mother,
your mother running.
-[woman] Where she going?
-Don't ask me,
you gotta ask your mother that.
I met him while I was working
at the Maryland Penitentiary.
He was, uh, incarcerated there
and I was
a correctional officer.
So it wasn't until after
I was let go from the jail
that I contacted him,
but then I fell for him,
and life just went on
from there.
Oh, yeah, did I tell you?
Phillips--
[Ransom]
Physically, I'm out here,
but mentally,
my mind be in prison.
Like, I depend
on Carolyn 100%,
because I'm only used
to knowing
from everything
men done for me.
[Carolyn] He never had
to make a decision
and so coming home,
having to decide
the smallest thing, like,
"What do you want to eat?"
"I don't know,
whatever you cook."
And I'm like, "Well,
what do you want to eat?"
[Ransom] You don't want
to keep asking people
for things at this age.
I mean, I'm a grown man.
I gotta ask you how to pay
a phone bill or a mortgage?
I should know how to do
all that.
[solemn orchestral music
playing]
I always think back at what
they have taken from us.
Like, it's hard for me now
because my family connection
is not there.
Like, my sister is sick
and I don't--
Mm, excuse me.
I don't have that feeling.
Right? Like, I love her,
but I don't have no connection.
I don't know her.
It's-it's-it's like a,
she's like a...
she my sister but she like
a stranger at the same time.
"I'm sorry for all the pain
I've caused them
and their families.
It was torture to sit
in the courtroom,
look in their faces
and lie on the stand.
What saddens me the most is
we were all students
at Harlem Park
Elementary School.
Knowing who you guys were
made it so difficult
to be on the witness stand,
especially knowing
you were all innocent.
But one day, I hope
to sit down with you guys,
apologize in person,
and if you guys
really want to know the truth,
I'm willing to tell."
[music fades]
-[laughs]
-Looking like...
Oh, man. You always been strong.
Yeah. Ain't no question.
You already know that.
What's up, baby?
What's happening? Huh?
-Old Drewsky back in town.
-What's happening?
Yeah.
[Andrew]
I can empathize and sympathize
with the fact
that we were all kids.
-[Alfred] Yeah.
-Yeah, I can do that.
-But once you turn 35, 40...
-Yeah.
-...and you have your voice...
-Yeah.
...and you ain't scared
of Kincaid no more,
it's different ways
you can help people.
I don't think you had to go
out there and say,
"Michael Willis
committed the crime."
Everybody already knew that,
but to say Kincaid
is the architecture
of this fallacy...
-Yeah.
-...is what needed to be done.
Man, that's going to be
kind of emotional, man.
[Ransom] Yeah,
this gonna be kind of hard.
-[Andrew] Kind of rough, man.
-Yeah.
But it's something
that may help us get over
a... a few hurdles
in our lives, man.
[Andrew sighs]
What's happening?
[indistinct chatter]
Camera, lights.
Gotta get it, boy.
[Andrew groans]
[Andrew] That's him right there.
[Ransom]
There he go right there.
[Alfred] Wow.
Yeah.
Alright, man.
-Shake your hand first.
-Yes, sir. Yes, sir.
-Love you, man.
-Yes, sir.
-Love you.
-Love you too.
-Love you, big Drew.
-Love you. [laughs]
-How you been, man?
-Oh, man. I've been good, man.
-You sure, man?
-Yeah, yeah.
-You good?
-Mm-hmm. Yeah.
As long as you all are good,
I'm good. I'm good.
[director] Uh...
I think, um... [clears throat]
...for the first time
I might be without words.
You know, um, to actually be
in the presence of somebody
that helped me regain my life.
But also,
you know, and I know
you was a kid,
was a part of them
taking my life.
It's mixed emotions, right?
And...
I'm sitting here, and as much
as I want to be happy
and I want to have this moment
be a defining moment for me,
at this present time,
it's eluding me.
It's painful for me
because I lost a lot.
Lost a lot of family members
in that prison,
and in the process
of losing them,
I lost a lot
that was even living.
Yeah, I'm thankful that
you did what you did, but...
that pain, I can't...
I can't shake it
no matter how much I try.
Hmm.
I always wondered,
you know, every time
we sat in the courtroom
and you looked
in our face, like...
like, how you felt
and-and-and I always wondered
why... why were you-- why...
were you doing that to us?
And what did I do to you
to deserve what I was getting?
Um...
I think the pain
and everything that
we're going through right now
is the battle, um,
that make us better.
I just want to say
I thank you all
for, you know,
accepting my apology.
I thank you all
for meeting me here.
When I sat in that courtroom,
was it 41 years ago?
And I had to look you all
in your face,
that was the worst thing,
the worst thing ever.
And then when the, you know,
they set it up in such a way
where I had to go in
and I had to say
what I didn't want to say,
and, you know,
you got to live in prison
for the rest of your life
up until when you were out,
or exonerated,
thinking why did we do this?
And my whole reason
for coming here
and doing all these things
to get to this point,
to tell you all
and for you all to ask me
anything you want to ask me,
and a lot of things
you all don't know.
Y'all don't know about all
these little weird situations
that played a part in why
you all were convicted.
Being in that
interrogation room,
struggling with Kincaid
and all that stuff,
it was horrific.
And watching you all
and, you know,
we're making eye contact,
and I'm sitting there,
like, I'm hurting inside,
but y'all didn't know
who was behind all of this.
I mean, it's just crazy.
Why would a person put,
knowing Alfred is innocent,
but you want to put the gun in
his hand, make him the killer,
and he could care less if
you were sentenced to death,
this who this person is.
Because I'm saying to myself,
these fucking white cops,
racist cops, they're forcing me,
I'm a slave, and now I know
what slavery feels like,
I'm a slave.
You're forcing me
against my will
and I'm telling you no.
Then you're coming in the room
when you're thinking,
you're leaving the room
and coming back
when you can't get me
to go along with this program.
Now you got a gun,
and that's when that
whole coercion stuff started.
But Eddie and I,
we fought for you all.
All that stuff I testified to,
it was hurting, it was.
But I knew they either
were going to try to put me...
put charges on me,
all this stuff,
and not knowing at the time,
I didn't know Michael Willis
was right there
in the courtroom with you.
I'm not sure if you knew,
he was right
in the courtroom with you.
He was... [chuckles]
He was out there
with your family,
I was sitting next
to all of your families.
And one thing I have to say,
they were upset,
yeah, I think your aunt
or your cousin
rolled her eyes at me,
but she never once cursed.
Kincaid would sit back
like the devil
and he was eating that stuff up.
He was watching every
little individual family,
like, kind of say things
in which he thought were
bad things against each other,
but your family, yeah,
they kept their dignity.
They knew we were lying,
but the jury didn't know
we were lying.
The judge for whatever reason,
he didn't know we were lying.
I was expecting him to pull me
in his chambers so I can say,
"Hey, Judge Bell,
these white officers,
they-they threaten me
with jail time
if I didn't tell them
the story."
Had I went in that courtroom
and said Michael Willis did it,
no one would believe me.
No one would believe me.
Because what they did was,
I'm the main witness,
and that's why I'm here,
I'm the--
basically, I'm
the only witness, really.
That's why I'm here.
What they did was they
shuffled the deck on you all.
They put those two phony
witnesses that weren't there.
They made Yvette,
who wasn't there,
they made her case,
I mean, her testimony,
the main test-- they made her
the main witness.
They made John Caldwell
the second main witness,
Eddie, and then myself last.
That's what they did.
So by the time I got in there,
the whole deal was already
sewed up for you all.
I was going to go
in that courtroom and say,
"Hell no, they didn't do it."
But I needed the judge,
Robert Bell, to see that.
He saw the BS,
but he never acted on it.
It was painful.
My plan was to still...
still stick to that one,
that's what it was.
That's what it was,
but they got these witnesses,
Yvette Thomas and John Caldwell,
these witnesses, they came
from out of nowhere.
So they just left me out there.
I'm the only person that said
you all didn't do it.
And believe me,
when you all were in prison,
I thought about you all a lot.
And for me, you know,
I graduated from high school,
I graduated from college,
and I want you all to know
that I was proud of myself,
but at the same time,
I was thinking about you all
and what you all had to endure
in, um, in prison.
You're talking about
the Maryland State Penitentiary,
we know what that was like
back in the--
No one has to say it,
what it was like.
You all went in at 16 or 17
and experienced 36 years
until they split you all up.
That was a horror show.
So when that verdict came down
and y'all got those sentences,
that, I mean, I felt so bad.
But at the same time,
I tried my best
and there's nothing I--
there was nothing else
I could do.
And to know that, you know,
you had to go against
these evil people,
a state's attorney,
a district attorney,
a-a-a-a sergeant in homicide,
and why they picked you all?
I don't know, but to me,
it's still a mystery.
I don't know why
they chose you all.
How did they get
these witnesses?
I mean, like,
how did Michael Willis
avoid all of this?
You know, it's just one
weird thing after the next.
So, you know, I came here.
I came here just to apologize
and to hear your stories.
Yeah. You know what, man?
I was sitting here
listening to you talk
and everything,
and I want you to know this
about me.
[sighs]
Twenty years ago,
I could have been home
from the parole board.
Twenty years of my life,
I could have lived,
I could have been home.
I could have had kids,
possibly, could have whatever.
But I chose not to do that.
I chose to stand my ground.
And like I told them, like,
we've been telling the world
we was innocent,
and I was willing to die
in prison for that.
So is it hard for me
to forgive you all for not?
Yeah. For me it is,
because the same thing
that happened to y'all,
the police played
with them two with me.
"Well, you know, Chestnut
and Andrew just said you did it,
you was the shooter."
It didn't make a difference.
I would've died before I
would've put them two people
in prison for something
I know they didn't do.
I would've died, man,
and even now.
So for everybody
that testified against me,
no, it ain't good with me
because I don't care
what them police is saying,
if you said that we was
innocent from the jump,
you should have stood on that
no matter what the cost was,
that's what I believe.
And then forget the Black
and the white stuff, man.
Because guess what?
We had jurors on there
that was Black too
that convicted us.
So damn with the cop
being white,
damn with the prosecutor
being whoever.
Because guess what?
When you told them people
we did it, you was Black.
That don't change,
so we can throw that race card
out of this.
"Well, take the focus off of me
and if you say
it's the white cop,
he ain't gonna worry about me,
he gonna focus
on the white cop."
I'll be damned
if I'm gonna do that.
I'm gonna keep the focus
where it's supposed to be,
on everybody that convicted us.
And right now, I ain't ready
to forgive nobody.
Maybe one day, man,
hopefully God will allow me
to come to that point
in my life.
But right now, bruh,
for what I lost,
man, I ain't forgiving nobody
for what happened to me
for 36 years.
And that's just me being honest.
Man, we done lost too damn much
for something
we didn't do in life.
[Andrew] Let me say this.
This is what you did.
"Kincaid made me.
Told us.
Did this."
You never said, "Man, I'm sorry.
From the bottom of my heart,
man."
I'm not a father.
I deserve to be a father.
He's not a father.
He deserves to be a father, man.
And you sit in my fucking face
and tell me that it's
somebody else's fault,
when you got on the stand,
and you said
Alfred killed the man,
and Ransom held him,
and I participated in it,
and you want us
to forgive you for that?
How is that possible?
How can you be
that dense of a person
that you don't see
that you're making yourself
the centerpiece
of our conviction,
and we not supposed to feel
a certain way about it?
You talking about
Yvette Thomas this,
Edward Capers this,
this person that, fuck them!
Excuse my language.
We absolutely ain't getting
no closure from you, man.
All we wanted to hear you say
was you're sorry,
but you came in here and made
every excuse under the sun.
Yeah, I wanted to forgive you.
I sat here and listened to you,
but you didn't even apologize,
like, wholeheartedly, really.
It's impossible for you
to... to sit here and...
and act as
that 14-year-old, man.
That's immature.
And no growth, man,
from then to now, man.
That's what I see, man.
Don't no real men do that.
Like, I would never...
do that to somebody
in my whole li--
I would never do that.
[Ransom] You came in here
with your, "I graduated,
went to college."
You an intelligent person,
right?
But you came here talking
to us with some bullshit.
Because, like Andrew said,
you came in here
not necessarily to tell us
that you were sorry, but you
came to clear your name
among all the others
who convicted us.
You wanted to clear your name
because everything that
you said to us sitting here
revolved around you.
I don't even know if we could
ever get back to normalcy
in our life.
We-we-we-- I-I don't even know
if it's possible for us,
because we have been through
so much
and come out here
in this messed up society
and still trying to function
among people like you
who can't give us what we need.
Man, this right here
could have been a thing
that could have probably
brought us back
if you would have just came
in this room
and looked us in our face
and said, "Listen, man,
I have no excuse
for what I done.
I know y'all suffered.
I know your family
have suffered,
but I apologize
from the bottom of my heart."
And that's all the three of us
was looking for in this room
and we couldn't even get that.
And I'm ready when y'all ready.
[somber music playing]
[director]
It's over. I'm relieved.
I am definitely sad
that they feel this way,
but I respect it.
And I can sit back
and I can say, "Well,
the cops, the cops, the cops."
No, it's me.
I'm sorry.
When they left out
of that room, I felt so bad,
but I understand
where that anger came from.
Myself, I'm in prison here
because I can't speak to no one,
I can't talk to anyone.
I can't share
what really happened
until they broke this case.
You can hate me,
you can say whatever you want
about me, whatever.
My mission was to make sure
you would come home and enjoy
the rest of your life.
Whether I'm forgiven or not,
I completed a mission,
and I'm at peace.
[music fades]
[soft, cheerful music playing]
Yeah. How you doing?
-How you feeling?
-On its way.
Okay, okay.
-[Ransom] Well, hello.
-[Alfred] Look at her.
-[grunts]
-[Ransom] She is cute, man.
Look at her.
[Alfred] My whole incarceration,
my nieces and all of them,
they done had kids,
my brother and them.
I was the only one
without no kids, so...
it's unbelievable
that I have one. [laughs]
I want to tell her when she'd
be able to understand, right,
and I'm gonna tell her, say,
"Your dad was in prison."
And let her know
what happened to me.
And then I'll let her know,
like, if you have a dream,
don't let nobody stop you from
making your dream come true,
not no man, not even me.
[laughs]
I'ma let her know
that she's my blessing,
and a lot of things
I may go through,
I just look at her
and it'll go away.
[inaudible]
[Ta-Nehisi]
What are our responsibilities
to each other?
The community was outraged
that somebody
had come into a school
and killed a kid.
We are still supposed
to protect each other.
The rage just became louder
than any of that.
You know, I'm part
of that community.
I was a child
when it happened,
but I'm part
of that community.
And we as a community...
[exhales sharply]
We're part of why this happened.
You know? Um,
and the least you can do
is allow these brothers
their story.
I just want them to know
that they're heard,
that we hear them.
I want them to know
that we're very, very sorry
and that they are believed.
[music fades]
[spirited music playing]
[singers vocalizing]
[music fades]