Who Killed Alex Odeh? (2026) Movie Script

1
[traffic hums softly]
[contemplative music playing]
[man] Uh, I'm taking you
to the office...
-of Alex Odeh.
-[music subsides]
I haven't been there
in 36 years.
I haven't even
driven next to it.
This wall was not here.
This is new.
The whole parking lot
has changed.
It was a Friday,
and I promised him
to show up
for coffee on that day.
He said, "Yeah, come in
in the morning."
So, I arrived here before 10am,
and, as usual,
I entered this parking lot
and found huge commotion,
policemen, firemen, ambulances.
All signs that show...
a catastrophe.
[unnerving music playing]
[newsreader 1] An Arab-American
organization was the target
of a deadly terror bombing
today in Southern California.
[newsreader 2] Police believe
it was a powerful bomb
which shattered
the Santa Ana office
of the American-Arab
Anti-Discrimination Committee.
Just all of a sudden,
it went off.
There was smoke everywhere.
Plaster and debris,
and the lights and wires.
[newsreader 3] Indications are,
the bomb was planted here,
just inside the door.
[newsreader 4] The bomb
was sophisticated and large,
and it was meant to kill.
[newsreader 5] Alex Odeh,
the committee's
West Coast Regional Director,
was killed.
About eight other people
were injured in the bombing.
No-one has yet claimed
responsibility for the attack.
[man] The friends of Alex
who came over to the hospital
were all gathered
and asking the same question,
"What happened? What happened?"
[newsreader 6]
So far, no-one has
claimed responsibility
for the explosion.
This reprehensible crime
threatens the security of all
Americans everywhere
and must not go unsolved.
[newsreader 7] Police still
don't know who's responsible.
I have no tears for Mr Odeh.
He got exactly
what he deserves.
[newsreader 8]
The FBI's Assistant Director
told a congressional committee
that four bombings are the work
of Jewish extremists.
-[all shout]
-[man] Lock and load.
[man] And we were told
we could not go arrest them.
The Arab is a cancer
in our midst.
[woman squeals]
[Kahane] And you don't coexist
with a cancer.
[explosive boom]
[David 2] I was able
to actually track him down.
If I'm able to figure it out,
why can't the government?
You can run, but you can't hide.
[woman] It's a struggle
to not have answers.
People only hear one side
of the story.
They don't hear all the truth.
Maybe now they will.
[music continues]
[music concludes
and low buzz, crackling]
[siren wails, in distance]
[contemplative music playing]
[music concludes]
[woman] It's a lot of stuff
from the ADC.
[Norma] Yeah.
I saved everything.
-[woman] That me?
-[Norma] Yeah.
When Helena was born.
[woman] Here's your wedding day.
[Norma] That one is not good.
[woman] Your wedding day.
Who is this one?
That's you.
Poor babies. How do you
hold their hands like that?
What day...? This was October?
I mean, it's on the back.
That's the baptism itself.
-[Norma] Susie's?
-[Helena] Yeah.
Susie's baptism.
[photographs rustle]
[Norma groans]
All these pictures make me sad.
Especially the wedding ones
and all that stuff.
Makes me so sad.
Hm.
[contemplative music playing]
[man] Alex Odeh was born
in Jifna, Palestine, in 1944.
During the '67 war,
my brother Alex was in Cairo
finishing his degree.
He could not go back home
because the Israeli occupation
of the West Bank took place
in 1967.
[indistinct radio chatter]
[man] And when the hope
was gone,
he came to the United States
in pursuit of a better life
and more education.
Well, from the first day
that Alex came,
he came with great love
and motivation.
Naturally,
number one to his family
and to the larger family
of the Palestinians.
He always identified with the
cause of the Palestinians.
[Ellen] Alex wanted very much
to improve
on the image of the Arabs,
and worked very peacefully
towards improving their image
in a very quiet
and calm and peaceful way.
[man] The night he was killed,
there was an event
at the Jewish Community Center.
He was going to be
a speaker there.
He was a very gentle guy.
[reporter] In 1982,
Alex Odeh lit a Hanukkah candle
to show his willingness
to open dialogue with Jews.
He had tried hard to bring
about people of all faiths,
and for that, I'm grateful.
[man] One man's tragedy,
one woman's tragedy
is everyone's tragedy.
What has damaged so terribly
this particular community
has also had its
reverberations upon us.
Who now do we speak to,
we who are so familiar with Alex
and could speak with him,
as I spoke with him,
and as we worked together.
Now, who do we turn to?
Our whole community
has suffered a great loss.
[man] ...and media
productions...
to engage in
the music business, recording.
And we are equipping
a video studio.
My name is Alex Odeh,
and I'm the Regional Coordinator
of the American-Arab
Anti-Discrimination Committee.
Our focus is...
basically,
fighting discrimination
against Arab-Americans
and combating the negative
stereotypes in the media.
[reporter] A growing number of
Arab-Americans
feel they are the victims
of discrimination,
charging they are stereotyped
as either terrorists...
Holy shit!
[frenzied barking]
[reporter] ...or greedy,
oil-rich sheikhs.
Give me 12 suites.
Better yet, the entire floor!
Now a group of
Arab-Americans is engaged
in improving its image.
[reporter] The American-Arab
Anti-Discrimination Committee.
We intend to show the media
in this country
that people of Arab descent
are much more
than just one-dimensional
characters,
useful only as villains
or heavyweights
in their phony stories.
[newsreader] Odeh's widow
told Channel Four
that she agrees
with the critics
who claim not enough
is being done
to find her husband's
assassins.
Because we're Arabs,
and they've always
discriminated against Arabs.
[reporter] Do you believe
that is a reason, in your mind,
that you feel that
not enough is being done?
Yeah.
[Norma] Almost every day,
I'm thinking about it.
How it happened,
what my kids had
gone through...
not to have a dad.
People have been killed
for over 20 years,
and they're opening their cases
and they're finding
who killed them.
And I keep wondering
why nothing like this
had happened to Alex.
I just wonder, why not?
[tense music playing]
[reporter] The evidence shows
and the experts all agree,
the bomb was definitely
inside the office,
on this table in this corner.
Odeh arrived to work
just after 9:00 that Friday.
The door opens inward.
Odeh stepped in first
with his right leg,
and that's when the bomb
went off.
This is the impact right here.
This spot right here.
[reporter 2] That's where
the bomb was?
[Joe] Where the bomb was,
right here.
[man] We were just trying
to figure out what happened
and why did this happen
and who would do this,
and a discussion came up
about Alex having been
on television the night before.
[newsreader]
Eyewitness News interviewed
41-year-old Alex Odeh
just last night.
He was reacting in an interview
to the coverage
of the hijacking
of the Achille Lauro.
[music continues]
[newsreader 2] Somewhere
in the Mediterranean tonight,
more than 400 people
onboard an Italian luxury liner
faced an uncertain destiny.
[newsreader 3] Commandos
reportedly
threatened to blow up
the vessel
unless Israel releases
50 jailed Palestinians.
Odeh said that he could
understand the emotions
that led to the violence.
They can do desperate acts.
And I can understand this,
because they are very frustrated
with the whole situation.
After they have been
denied their rights...
...in the United Nations,
as well as everywhere else,
some of them are very desperate,
and desperation could lead to...
acts of terror.
[newsreader 2]
Before that nightmare was over,
an elderly American was dead.
[newsreader 4] Leon Klinghoffer,
a Jewish man in a wheelchair,
was murdered by
Palestinian terrorists.
He gave a 45-minute interview,
and they cut it down to,
like, you know,
three or four
or five-second sound bites.
Alex made extensive statements
in that interview
before he died
condemning the hijacking
of the Achille Lauro.
They presented something
that was really out of context
with the man
and what he stood for.
Odeh, a Palestinian,
came to the United States
five years ago,
and he was not shy
with the media.
And perhaps remarks
he made last night
on at least two different news
broadcasts
triggered today's bomb attack.
I think the time is right
for the American administration,
as well as
the American people...
to understand...
the Palestinian side
of the story.
The Achille Lauro was a great
opportunity for demagoguery
on the part of President Reagan
and other politicians,
all of whom played it
to the hilt.
[stirring music playing]
On the floor!
Captain, we are taking this ship
in the name of Arafat's PLO.
[Abourezk] The object of their
demagoguery was, of course,
to make themselves more popular.
And the target was
Arab terrorists,
and, in short, Arabs,
read the code word "Arabs",
all over the United States
and all over the world.
[tense music playing]
[Abourezk] There was
an atmosphere
of permissiveness,
that it's okay to hate Arabs...
-[gunshot]
-...it's okay to do something
to them.
Four Palestinians
who hijacked a ship
and murdered an American
are now in Italian custody.
[reporter] Planes scrambled
from the carrier Saratoga.
The Israelis were
in the air as well.
The mission was at once
a brilliant escapade
in intelligence
and mid-air acrobatics.
We have finally, finally
got some of the bastards.
Are you absolutely thrilled
to be an American today?
-Yes, I am. I think it's...
-We got 'em right here.
-[applause]
-[host] Finally!
[Newsreader] President Reagan
lost no time today
in celebrating it
and complimenting
the US servicemen
who achieved it.
These young Americans
sent a message
to terrorists everywhere.
The message,
you can run, but you can't hide.
[tense music playing]
[Ellen] I was afraid
that something might happen,
because I had had
conversations with Alex,
and I verbalized to him my fear
about having some harm done.
Alex told me,
"Ellen, you're crazy.
"This is precisely
what they would like me to do,
is be quiet."
My brother has been receiving
continuous threats from...
individuals that will call
and identify themselves
that they are from the JDL,
demanding that he shut up
or will be killed.
And he received these calls
both at home and at his office.
[cassette clacks
and music continues]
[Alex]
[machine beeps]
[man]
[machine beeps]
[Alex]
[man 2]
[machine beeps]
[click]
[sirens blare]
[newsreader] The organization's
Washington, DC office
was gutted by fire.
In Boston, a bomb found outside
its office injured a policeman.
[tense music playing]
[explosive boom]
[newsreader] Each office
belonged to the American-Arab
Anti-Discrimination Committee.
[woman] ADC has been the target.
Did they ever find out
where the bomb came from
in Boston?
At your headquarters in Boston?
[woman] Um...
An anonymous caller
to two different newspapers
claimed responsibility
for the JDL.
[newsreader] Oliver Revell,
the FBI'S assistant director,
today told
a congressional committee
that four bombings
are the work of
Jewish extremists.
At this point,
we have insufficient
credible evidence
to bring charges.
So, these individuals
remain as suspects.
So, we are unable
to name these individuals.
We have characterized them
as members of
a Jewish extremist element.
[music continues and clamor]
[reporter]
An intriguing organization
called the Jewish
Defense League
has been attracting
hundreds of youngsters
to Jewish militancy.
They are led by an unknown
Orthodox rabbi
from a small community
in Queens, Rabbi Meir Kahane.
It's time for an unrespectable
Jewish group to come into being.
We're trying to change an image,
the image of the Jew as a patsy.
And this is what we mean
by our slogan, "Never again."
[man] I affirm
my total allegiance.
[all] I affirm
my total allegiance.
[man] To Jewish Defense League.
[all] To Jewish Defense League.
The time has come
for the Jew to understand...
that his roots
are in his people.
And that, for him,
the priorities
start with Jewishness.
Jews always wait
until the Holocaust is upon them
to suddenly realise
that they must fight back.
And that's what JDL is trying
to get across to the Jews,
get very angry and indignant.
-[man] What are we?
-[all] Jews!
[reporter] Right now,
you are preaching
that every Jew
should have a gun.
Every Jew, a .22.
[man] Lock and load.
[gunfire]
Kill!
Kill!
Kill!
Kill!
[music subsides]
[man] Hell, no, PLO!
Hell, no, PLO!
Hell, no, PLO!
[man 2] Stop killing
our children in the West Bank!
[clamor and chanting]
Stop killing our youth
in the West Bank!
Stop killing our youth
in the West Bank!
Stop killing our youth
in the West Bank!
-[chanting continues]
-[indistinct dialogue]
[clamor and shouting]
Get out! Get out of Israel now!
[car horns]
-You don't belong here!
-Go back where you came from!
[furious clamor]
[newsreader]
One FBI source said the
bombing was probably the work
of the militant
Jewish Defense League.
The Jewish Defense League,
a militant
anti-Arab organization,
has denied any connection
with the bombing,
but its local leader, Irv Rubin,
said the JDL wouldn't cry
over the event.
I have no tears for Mr Odeh.
He got exactly, apparently,
what he deserves.
He stated that, apparently,
Alex got
what he deserved, and...
to me, probably,
this is the most cruel thing
that anybody can say.
Anybody can say.
Nobody deserves to die that way.
We, as a family,
are extremely distressed
over the fact
that nine months have gone by
and his widow and daughters
and all of us...
are still waiting
for some results.
[contemplative music playing]
[man] I have promised the ADC...
and I have promised Mrs Odeh...
that we will not rest,
we will not conclude
our duties...
until the murder of
Alex Odeh is solved
and those individuals
pay the full penalty of law.
[music continues]
[applause subsides]
[Norma] For a while
after his death,
they would go to Washington...
meet with the FBI.
They said not to worry,
that the case is still open.
"It's top priority,"
always is the same answer.
[music continues]
[Norma] Every morning
when I take them to school,
I'm scared to come back.
I say, "What if I end up dead?
Who's going to take care
of them?"
When I picked him up,
I would leave the girls
in the car.
And I... I'm sorry.
You tell them.
Um...
She would tell us
to get in the back seat,
on the floor.
She just said,
"Keep holding your sisters."
And, one day,
I decided to look,
and I see her picking up
a newspaper
and throwing it at the door.
Of course, years later,
I figured it out,
that she was afraid to open the
front door to her own home...
because it might explode.
[Helena] As a kid, you know,
my mom really didn't explain
too much to us,
just because
she wanted us to be protected.
But, as I got older,
I just want to know more
about my dad's case
and hopefully find justice
for him and my family
and the community.
[ruminative music playing]
[Abourezk] There seemed to be
this kind of false
understanding
that the ADC was
somehow suspect.
So, the community
started feeling victimized,
like, "Hey, we have
to be on the defensive here."
We are outraged at this
contemptible act of cowardice
and brutality...
directed against
a gentle, compassionate...
and peace-loving
American citizen
right here in
Southern California.
This reprehensible crime
threatens the security
of all Americans everywhere
and must not go unsolved.
[newsreader] James Abourezk
called for
a stepped-up investigation
of the murder
and charged the press
with ignoring Odeh's killing
while devoting broad coverage
on the murder of
Leon Klinghoffer.
It seems that everybody
in the government,
from the president on down,
just doesn't seem to care
that we don't
fit into their political
point of view.
So, therefore, they kiss off
this kind of an assassination.
The ADC think that not enough
was made of Alex Odeh's death,
that there was not
enough notice,
there was not enough outcry,
and not enough
politicians saying,
"This is terrible,
what has just happened."
Yes, I agree. Um...
For example,
President Reagan has not sent
a letter of condolence
to Mrs Odeh.
[applause]
[applause subsides]
Well, who did it?
Any clues? Any leads?
Our information is certainly
that the FBI is...
relatively comfortable
they have suspects in the case.
The House Judiciary hearings
this past summer...
made it pretty plain that
there's a foreign connection,
an Israeli connection, at least
a possible Israeli connection.
[uneasy music playing]
[bustling chatter]
[music subsides]
I report from the ground
in Israel-Palestine,
focused on the core
of the ultra-racists in Israel.
I've been doing that
for about a decade.
So, I'd set out here,
really, to document.
I decided to investigate,
to research,
trying to find
where the suspects might be.
His widow and his children
were denied a father
for their entire childhood.
Not only denied their father,
but denied the right
to even know
what really happened to him.
I remember when we spoke
on the phone really briefly,
I could tell by
your silence, like,
this isn't enjoyable.
I will say, not many people
contact us saying,
"I'm from Israel,
I'm a journalist,
I need to speak to you
about your father."
Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Fair enough, fair enough.
What interested you in...
finding out more
about my father?
I've spent a good deal of time
studying the Israeli
far right in general, so...
That's what I report on.
Before it came to this,
I've been physically
threatened,
you know,
while covering race riots.
I've been physically attacked,
you know, in the streets.
[in Hebrew]
[in English] But then
there's a worry of targeting me,
finding out where I live
and attacking me in my home.
That's... That's a fear.
So, I said, "Okay...
"people need to know about this,
and they need to understand
"the roots
of this racist group."
I had been studying them
on the streets
for ten years, but I didn't
know the backstory.
I didn't know what happened
in the '60s and '70s
and '80s.
So...
I started by reading
the biography of Kahane
called The False Prophet ,
by the American
investigative journalist
Robert Friedman.
[contemplative music playing]
According to the writings
of Robert Friedman...
a cell of Kahane's
top lieutenants,
Robert Manning,
Keith Fuchs,
and Andy Green,
commit a string of
bombing attacks.
And, after the last one,
Alex Odeh,
they quickly returned
to Israel at first opportunity.
But, in the years
that followed, eventually,
one of them
was actually indicted
on a completely
different charge.
[newsreader] Guarded by
federal agents, Robert Manning,
a former member
of the Jewish Defense League,
returned from Israel
to Los Angeles
to answer to a series
of murders
and bombings in the 1980s.
Manning will be tried first
for the 1980 mail-bomb murder
of California Secretary
Patricia Wilkerson.
Wilkerson died when she opened
a package at her office.
[newsreader 2]
Robert and Rochelle Manning
were arrested after living
nearly ten years
in the Israeli-occupied
West Bank.
After the murder,
the Mannings fled to Israel.
They became citizens.
He joined
the military reserves.
By living on the West Bank,
they avoided capture.
[newsreader] When ABC News
approached their house,
a civilian guard opened fire.
[gunfire]
[David S] Robert
and Rochelle Manning
were extradited.
She died mysteriously,
right before she was about
to be extradited,
but Robert Manning
was extradited back to the US.
Until this day,
he's actually serving time
in an Arizona penitentiary.
[brooding music playing]
[man] Robert Stephen Manning.
9-8-5-0-0-0-1-2.
He was a known terrorist.
He is still a terrorist.
He was convicted,
in another bombing in 1972,
targeting people
of Arabic descent.
[Helena]
The Justice Department feels...
and we feel, my family and I
are victims of that as well,
because Robert Manning...
is a person of interest
in my dad's case.
[man] Now is the time for you
to go ahead
and make a statement
if you wish.
[Manning] If you look at
all of the actions
that JDL ever did,
you would find out
that they were never anything
meant to kill or hurt anybody.
[sirens wail]
[Manning] It was always
a political thing.
[Parole Officer] So, you're
denying any involvement
with the death of Mr Odeh?
[Manning] Absolutely.
-[music subsides]
-He never admitted his role...
in the Odeh murders,
or any of the other ones...
that the JDL
was responsible for.
But Keith Fuchs
and Andy Green...
have never been heard
from since, allegedly.
Understood to continue
living in Israel,
in the occupied territory
since that time.
[brooding music playing]
[indistinct radio chatter]
[David S] The second suspect,
I knew that he had two names,
both Keith and Israel.
Another American-born Kahanist
with a criminal record
for spraying Palestinian people
with bullets.
[newsreader] Police had arrested
followers of Rabbi Kahane
in connection with the ambush.
First of all, they are innocent
until proven guilty.
Secondly...
in general terms, I see nothing
wrong with what they did.
Thirdly, there should be
no need for it.
If I were the prime minister,
not one Arab would be touched.
He wouldn't be here.
Tonight, in the confines
of Israel's Tel Mond Prison,
in the cells I once occupied...
29 members
of the Jewish Underground,
they sit for the crime
of avenging Arab terror.
They felt the blood
of their murdered
martyred brothers cry out,
"Avenge our deaths!
"Let our Yishmael cousins know
that Jewish blood is not cheap."
[music continues]
[music subsides]
[David S] There was hardly
any footprint of him online.
I did find a LinkedIn profile.
He goes by Izzy Fuchs,
but I couldn't be 100% sure
that this was him.
You know, I knew,
according to Robert Friedman,
that he was ginger,
that he had red hair.
Going through the
Facebook profiles
of different members
of the Kahanist movement,
Kahane Mama,
I was able to find references
to Israel Fuchs.
"Our identity is no longer
a secret.
"We decide to operate
in the open.
"My partners in the
mosque-busting business
with Izzy Fuchs."
"Israel Fuchs."
And it's got his name,
his phone number, his address...
to be able to confirm
that this is the guy.
If I'm able to figure it out
without too much trouble,
why can't the
Israeli government?
If I go to that address,
will I find him there?
If I can have an excuse
to be on his street,
maybe I can see him.
[ruminative music playing]
[David S] We're going to go
to the village
with the pretense that we're
looking for a house there.
So, we need to look the part.
We need to look like
the type of people
that would want to move
into this neighborhood,
into this community.
And so, we need to look
like religious Jews
of a very specific type.
[music subsides]
[indistinct conversation]
It's this one.
[woman] You want to ask
if you can just go over?
Yeah.
[knocking]
[dog barks]
[David S] Hey...
[in Hebrew]
[somber music playing]
[Fuchs in English]
[David S]
[Fuchs]
-[David S]
-[Fuchs]
[David S]
[Fuchs]
[chuckling]
-[David S]
-[Fuchs]
[music continues]
[David S] We did
what no-one else
has done up until now.
We confirmed
that he lives there.
We confirmed what he looks like.
We've got audio of his voice.
He unabashedly explained
that he, himself,
was a follower of Meir Kahane,
that he was active in the JDL,
that he hasn't changed
his politics, of course.
No big shocker there.
I've literally done,
you know, what the police
should have done,
what the government
should have done
years and years and years ago.
[tense music playing]
Meir Kahane,
an American-born rabbi,
is now in Israel,
where he was recently elected
to that country's parliament.
[David S] After about a decade
of Kahane's militant activities
in the United States,
he then branches out
into activities
on Israeli soil.
He's trying to build
a political base there.
[reporter] His aim?
To make two million Arabs
leave Israel
and the occupied territories.
I come and I say,
" Aravim hutzah - Arabs out."
That's what they want.
[interviewer]
But you don't expect them to go.
Of course not.
I expect to throw them out.
[furious clamor]
[David S] He preaches
ethnic cleansing openly,
straightforward, without trying
to hide it in euphemisms,
and says that
there's only one choice -
kick them all out, or kill them.
The Arab is a cancer
in our midst.
And you don't coexist
with a cancer.
A cancer, you either cut out
and throw out, or you die.
[David S] Up until that point,
people couldn't speak
those words out loud.
It would have been
behind closed doors.
So, he speaks openly
about this,
and that breaks the taboo
in Israeli society.
[newsreader]
Opinion polls today show
Kahane would win
10% of the vote
and form Israel's
third-largest party.
[David S] And Kahane himself
took frequent trips
back to the US
to drum up support
and to raise funds.
[newsreader 2]
Kahane's message is clear,
he wants to be the next
Prime Minister of Israel.
I come here to get
the support of the American Jew.
And get funding, too.
Because the American Jew
has a stake in Israel.
[newsreader 2]
The crowd was so large,
hundreds had to be turned away.
[Kahane] For 37 years, we waited
for someone to reach the Knesset
and say these things,
and give to them
as they have given
all these years.
Well, I've arrived.
[newsreader 3] 400 people,
Arabs and Jews alike,
protested outside
Francis Hotel.
[reporter] Protesters held
a candlelight vigil.
It was to remember the leader
of the Arab-American
Anti-Discrimination Committee,
Alex Odeh,
killed earlier this month
in a bombing
at his Santa Ana office.
Several Jewish organizations
joined Arabs and others
to attack what they called
"Kahane hysteria."
I think we have...
not only the right,
but the obligation
to protest a man
who is spewing forth...
vehement... racism.
[tense music playing]
[upbeat theme music plays]
Tonight, we'll meet a man
who thinks he has the answer,
expel all the Arabs from Israel.
[applause, booing]
This person here and the JDL,
the Jewish Defense League,
three years ago,
collaborated in killing
a Palestinian-American
on the West Coast!
[cheering]
Has that ever been proven?
I want to tell you
something, that...
tomorrow morning...
tomorrow morning,
you are going to be served
with a libel suit.
-And believe me...
-[Bishara] I have lawyers.
Thank you.
But I mean it.
You are going to be served
with a criminal libel suit
-for what you just said.
-Talk to the FBI about it!
It's not me! It's the FBI!
[crosstalk and clamor]
[Kahane] Yes?
[Kahane]
[Kahane]
I want him to fund my campaign.
[Scattered applause, laughter]
[Man] What did he say?
What did he say?
He said that, uh...
I and the JDL killed Alex Odeh,
the Arab who was
killed by a bomb in 1982.
And that is, of course,
criminal libel.
[man] Let me say something.
Kach got $38,000.
-[applause and cheering]
-For many years,
we've been backing a man
we knew was a winner.
And it took all these years
for the rest of the world
to find out that he really
was a winner.
The next member of the Knesset,
the power base of the Knesset,
and the following election,
the Prime Minister of Israel,
Rabbi Meir Kahane.
[applause and cheering]
[brooding music]
[newsreader 1] The controversial
Israeli rabbi Meir Kahane
barged into two Boston-area
Hillel houses uninvited.
[newsreader 2] Kahane is
considered an outcast
by American-Jewish leaders,
primarily because of his
hardline position
that Israel should become
a true Jewish state
governed strictly
by the scriptures.
[reporter] Why isn't he invited
or welcome here?
Because of the views he holds.
Because of the positions
he fosters.
I said...
I called him a two-bit fascist.
Isn't it clear
what I think of him?
[music continues]
Living standards.
Their problem is not
living standards.
Their problem is not education.
[man] This is the blood
of all the...
[woman squeals]
I would rather be
a winner than a loser.
And I would rather have
the entire world
hates the state of Israel...
which is a winner,
than love the state of Israel,
which is dead.
[announcer]
This is a Channel seven
Eyewitness News brief.
Rabbi Meir Kahane,
founder of the militant
Jewish Defense League,
was shot to death last night
in Manhattan.
[reporter] A lone gunman
walked up to the rabbi,
smiled, and fired.
The suspect is 37-year-old
El Sayyid Nosair.
The gunman got into
a shoot-out
with a Postal Service
police officer,
leaving both men wounded.
[newsreader 1] Kahane died
at Bellevue Hospital
shortly before 10pm.
[unnerving music playing]
[newsreader 2]
Word of Kahane's murder
adds to escalating tension
in the Middle East.
Angry and grieving followers
wait for his
Jerusalem burial tomorrow.
Today, his followers
were calling for revenge blood.
[newsreader 3] Two elderly
West Bank Arabs
were killed in an
apparent revenge attack.
[reporter] The signs they
carried called for blood,
for vengeance,
for a war against the Arabs.
Again and again, the crowd
shouted, "Kill the Arabs."
[music continues]
[music continues]
[music subsides
and bustling chatter]
[newsreader]
Californians are paying tribute
to a man who gained
a reputation as a peacemaker.
[gentle flute music playing]
[reporter] Odeh's widow
and three daughters
were overcome with emotion
as several hundred people
gathered
for a first look
at the sculpture.
[man] Three, two, one...
[reporter] Now,
nearly nine years later,
a statue in his honor
was unveiled
at the city's main library.
We memorialized this man who was
a bridge-builder, a philosopher,
a poet, a teacher.
But, today,
as we look at this statue,
we know that he's here with us.
Just because he was killed
does not mean
that his voice
has been silenced.
And this is the best
proof of it.
He continues to inspire
the whole community,
and he will always live
forever in our hearts.
[unnerving music playing]
You know the statue
was vandalized?
[Khalil] Yes.
How...? What were your thoughts
when you first heard
about the vandalism?
[Khalil] Well, my first thought
was for you guys,
that, you know,
how do you react to this?
For the fanatics
who are doing this,
you know, what kind of...
mental process
would bring them to do this?
It was not enough
they killed Alex already.
They want to kill
even the symbol?
I think it's a tribute
to the power of his work
and his spirit.
I felt almost sorry
for how unwell they must be
to feel so compelled
to express the hate.
[Norma] At the unveiling
of the statue,
the JDL was across
the street from us.
[Helena] Irv Rubin was there.
He stood up,
and the minute he stood up,
he looked me straight
in the face.
He told me...
he sheds no tears,
that my dad deserved to die.
That's what I'll never forget.
But then,
once the statue came out
and it was there for him
to see forever...
[music subsides]
[newsreader 1] Federal agents
under cover of darkness
moved in late Tuesday night
in the home
of a high-ranking official
of the militant
Jewish Defense League.
JDL head Irving Rubin
and JDL official Earl Krugel...
[newsreader 2] . ..have been
charged with attempting to bomb
a Southern California mosque
and the Office of
California Arab-American
congressman Darrell Issa.
Krugel said that
Arabs needed a wake-up call...
and Rubin said that the JDL
needed to let people know
that they are alive
in a militant way.
[newsreader 2]
A former JDL-member-turned-
government-informant
had several meetings
with Krugel and Rubin.
When they were planning
the King Fahd Mosque,
they wanted to make sure
that those children died.
They wanted to make sure
what time those children
were out at the playground.
[bustling chatter]
[Osder] The men
who were directly accused
of the Odeh bombing,
you know their names,
but you never met them.
[Daniel] I never met them, no.
Before my time.
While I was in the JDL,
their names would be
brought up all the time, though.
It was just a lot of things
that kind of added up.
There's no reason to have...
news footage
of a guy being killed...
and shown over and over
to certain people.
But, yes, he had multiple VHSes
on multiple situations, and...
um... the bomb.
[tense music playing]
[newsreader]
A two-foot pipe bomb
was found at Krugel's home.
[Daniel] The bomb was something
that they trained me in
and that they did.
Yeah, I guess
I can say that he...
unfortunately, was proud of some
of those things.
What's going to be
in your future?
I think you ought to get
your will together.
-Are you threatening me?
-[cheering and clamor]
You can accept that
any way you want to...
He's violently
opposed to violence.
I'm violently
opposed to violence.
I suppose Alex Odeh...
You see, there's a fellow named
Alex Odeh, ladies and gentlemen.
He was blown up. He was blown...
-You should be there with him.
-Blown up?
-Well I'm sure he'll greet you.
-[interviewer] It wouldn't have
happened to have been
by a terrorist, would it?
[indistinct arguing
and voices fade]
[music continues
and distorted buzzing]
[brooding music playing]
[David S] The last suspect,
Andy Green,
upon moving to Israel,
changed his name
to Baruch Ben Yosef.
And I was shocked to find
that there are no shortage
of references
to Baruch Ben Yosef.
He's not hiding
in some back alley somewhere.
It's a great honor
to introduce Baruch Ben Yosef.
[David S] He continues to be
a prominent political activist.
In these YouTube videos
with his own name
and his own voice
and his own face,
I can see
what he looks like now,
and I can see him
from different angles.
I wanted to compare that
to what he looked like then.
All I had to go on, though,
was this one photograph
that I knew of he had
originally published in
The Village Voice.
But I noticed
there was a credit here.
[music continues]
In June '85, I took the picture.
I know it was on the
cover of one of the issues...
-Mm-hm.
-that picture was.
[David S] He still had
high-quality-resolution images.
Not only the one photograph,
but a whole series
of photographs
from different angles,
different vantage points.
So, I was able to
compare and contrast
what Andy Green looked like
in the 1980s
and what he looks like today
as Baruch Ben Yosef.
And, sure enough,
the likeness is uncanny.
It's the same man.
[music continues]
[man] I affirm
my total allegiance.
[all] I affirm
my total allegiance.
[man]
To the Jewish Defense League.
[all]
To the Jewish Defense League.
[in Hebrew]
[David S, in English]
He's been practicing law.
He has a law office
in downtown Jerusalem.
He's been arguing
in front of the Supreme Court
of Israel
again and again and again.
[music continues]
That is the ultimate goal
of the Jewish people,
to Institute a true Jewish state
and a true Jewish government.
That is our ultimate goal.
[in Hebrew]
[applause]
[tense music playing]
[reporter in English]
Every month,
radical Jewish groups
try to enter the Temple Mount
to worship.
The greatest fear
of the security forces
is that someone
will try to blow up the mosque.
[David S] Baruch Ben Yosef
wants to advance efforts
to destroy the Dome
of the Rock Al-Aqsa Mosque,
driving Palestinians out of
the last little bit
of territory
that they control,
and, on it,
to build a Jewish temple.
In 1980, Kahane planned,
with Baruch Ben Yosef,
to shoot an M72 LAW rocket
at the Dome of the Rock.
He hoped that,
in the wake of that,
all the Muslim states would
launch a war against Israel -
the war of Gog and Magog.
This was an actual plan that,
if they had not stopped it
in time,
would have been carried out.
[in Hebrew]
[clamor]
[in English] That's really
what's standing, in their mind,
between them
and the Kahanist vision,
descent into theocracy.
There is no golden calf
worse than democracy.
Democracy is the worst
possible idolatry.
[indistinct arguing]
[David S] We need an insider
from the JDL,
someone who witnessed
what they'd done.
I didn't expect to find that,
but I figured I'd chase down
the leads that I had,
just to do
my due diligence, and...
then I found someone.
A prisoner, V,
wrote to the FBI a decade ago,
telling them,
"I've got information
about Alex Odeh's murder."
But the FBI perceived him
to be a bit erratic.
The prisoner says that...
when he was an associate
of the Jewish Defense League's
National Chairman, Irv Rubin,
Irv introduced Baruch Ben Yosef
as the killer of Alex Odeh.
That's the gold nugget there.
Certainly,
it's worth checking out.
-[beeps]
-[automated voice]
[beeps]
[beeps]
Can we trust what this guy says?
I mean, is he using my dad
to get out of
his death-row sentence?
-[David S] Right.
-[Helena] It's a possibility.
I mean, he's a criminal, so...
Exactly. Exactly. It is...
That's what I'm saying.
It is still a possibility.
I think the possibility is low,
but certainly
I cannot rule it out yet.
The reason
why I can't rule it out yet
is because we don't have
any corroborating evidence yet.
So, the idea is to bring
this information
to the United States government
and say,
"Hey, we've got this one person
who claims to have witnessed.
"And he claims
that this other person
that you allegedly are...
"he's wanted in the US
for crimes,
is also another witness."
They can take this information,
go to these specific people,
find out what they know,
and then decide
whether it's actionable.
[contemplative music playing]
[David S] Did he really witness
the confession?
I wasn't there,
and there's no way to prove it.
But that's the job of the FBI -
to drive to the jail
where he's incarcerated
and to interview him
and to determine for themselves
if his testimony is valid.
[music continues]
[music subsides]
[David] So, this is from
Baruch Ben Yosef.
"Mr David Sheen.
"Without prejudice.
Notice of warning.
"I want to put you on notice
"that you and the periodicals
that publish your article
"are liable under law
for defamation of character.
"Should you defame me
or my character in any way,
shape or form,
"I reserve the right
to take legal action
against you
and said periodicals.
"In any event,
I categorically deny
any connection to the matters
mentioned in your letter.
"I request you do not
contact me again,
"and I suggest you
pass this information
on to the periodicals before
they publish your article.
"You have been warned,
"and there will be
no further warnings necessary.
"Sincerely, Baruch Ben Yosef,
attorney at law."
[ruminative music playing]
[Ben Yosef] Hello?
[woman] Uh, hello.
May I please speak to
Baruch Ben Yosef?
-[Ben Yosef] Yes.
-[woman] Yes, hi.
I'm a researcher in the States,
and I'm calling on behalf
of Professor Jason Osder
from George Washington
University.
He's currently working
on research in Israel
on the religious discrimination
on the Temple Mount,
and we'd love to film
an interview with you.
[Ben Yosef] An interview
about religious discrimination
-on the Temple Mount?
- [woman] That's right.
Would you be free on Thursday?
He's going to be in Jerusalem.
[music continues]
[woman] Option one,
he gets angry.
Option two is,
you get to ask him,
"Are you Andy Green?"
If he says,
"Yes, I am Andy Green"...
[Osder] I think, then,
we have to say,
"Well, Robert Friedman
essentially accused you
of committing the murder
of Alex Odeh.
"You're being accused
of a serious crime.
"Do you not want to give
your side of the story?
"We're here to get
your side of the story."
[music continues]
-Hey, how are you?
-Good.
-Thanks for coming.
-[clears throat]
How's your day so far?
Just started.
Uh, so, we got you here.
Yeah.
And... let's see...
[Lia] We're going to be
mic'd up and on camera.
And you're mic'd up.
Thank you.
...on the other camera.
Do you want a mic?
[Osder] One, two, three. We're
ready to start this interview...
[Lia] Yeah.
We're rolling.
We're rolling.
Perfect.
When did you first become
sort of impassioned
and engaged in these issues?
-The Temple Mount issues?
-[Osder] And Zionism
-more broadly.
-Oh, Zionism?
The first time
I heard Rabbi Kahane,
basically, was on, I think,
The David Frost Show .
And it was clear that he made...
I mean, just...
Again, I didn't have a religious
background or anything,
but just sense,
just common sense.
It was that he made sense
and they didn't make any sense.
[Osder] Well, I guess the...
I guess the knock in some of
the literature on Kahane
and Jewish Defense League
is that it was mobbed-up,
or was violent.
I mean, is that... accurate?
Look, Rabbi Kahane always said,
"It's better not to have
to use violence."
But sometimes
it's a necessary...
There's no avoiding it.
If you're going to be attacked,
you don't turn the other cheek.
You got to defend yourself.
What's your interest in
Rabbi Kahane?
Well, I'm sort of trying
to just trace
the threads of philosophy
and understand
how people come to the...
come to the beliefs.
Where I was going with it is...
some of the stuff
I found about Kahane
was by this American journalist,
Robert Friedman.
Are you familiar with his work?
I don't want to...
I don't want to even
deal with him and his...
his BS. I don't want to...
Yeah. So, we found this,
that I just have to ask you.
Is that a picture of you?
Are you going to start
with this? Then we're finished.
Anything to do with
Robert Friedman
and all that stuff,
if you want...
-Basically done.
-But I'm asking you for your...
You don't have to ask me
anything, 'cause it's over with.
Nice to meet you.
[somber music playing]
[music subsides]
[siren wails]
[reporter] The steady scream
of ambulance sirens
pierced the Israeli morning.
It was just after dawn
when the attack came.
The worshipers were
kneeling in prayer.
Suddenly, Dr Baruch Goldstein,
a Jewish settler
from New York City,
slipped in, blocked
the only exit, and opened fire.
And when it was all over,
Goldstein had killed
at least 29 worshipers.
" One million Arabs are not
worth a Jewish fingernail,"
said a rabbi eulogizing
Goldstein.
I wish I had
the guts to do it, too.
They deserved it,
and they got what they deserved.
[tense music playing]
[reporter] His hero
and good friend
was the late Rabbi Meir Kahane.
[no audible dialogue]
[David S] Following
the massacre,
the Israeli government
declared the Kahanist movement
to be illegal.
But that was not the end
of the Kahanist movement,
and it was far from the end
of the Kahanist idea.
[All chanting]
Two, four, six, eight,
Israel is a Jewish state!
Three, five, seven, nine,
no such thing as Palestine!
Two, four, six, eight,
Israel is a Jewish state!
[David S] When there are efforts
to create peace on the ground
between Israelis
and Palestinians,
that's when
the Kahanists strike.
[gunshots and clamor]
[newsreader] The architect
of the Middle East
peace process
has been assassinated.
[reporter] Shots rang out,
and Rabin collapsed
into the arms
of his security men.
[reporter 2] Rabin killed
not by a Palestinian,
but by a 24-year-old
Israeli extremist
who opposed the peace process.
[David S] Prime Minister
Rabin is assassinated.
Puts an end to the possibility
of a two-state solution,
of a territorial compromise
between Israelis
and Palestinians.
Netanyahu quickly
came to power,
and he made sure
that that possibility
would be squashed.
In the years that followed,
Kahane himself may have died,
but he came back stronger
than ever.
The movement renewed
its push to recruit
and turn more and more
young Israelis
onto its eliminationist ideas.
[reporter] These are the faces
of Israel's firebrand
ultra-nationalists,
young men stirred
by a messianic zeal
and now emboldened
by election success.
[newsreader] One of the most
right-wing governments
in that country's history
has now been sworn in.
[David S] In March 2021,
elections brought
into the Knesset
for the first time in 33 years
these open,
unabashed Kahanists.
Itamar Ben-Gvir
is the top Kahanist lawyer.
He only became a lawyer in 2012
after he articled
at the law firm of Ben Yosef.
So, Ben Yosef was able
to tutor Ben-Gvir,
and now Ben-Gvir
is the head of
the new Kahanist party
in Israel.
[reporter] Ben-Gvir came
to fame in Israel
as a mere 19-year-old,
back in 1995,
in the wake of the
Oslo Peace Accords,
when he appeared on television
holding a Cadillac emblem
that he claimed to have ripped
from then-Prime Minister
and Israeli peacemaker
Yitzhak Rabin's car.
"We got the car," he said,
"we'll get to Rabin, too."
[David S] The alleged assassins
of Alex Odeh
have proteges
in the Israeli parliament.
At first, these ideas
were considered extremist
and they weren't given
any credence
by Israeli governments.
But the Kahanists are now
the kingmakers
of Israeli politics.
[in Hebrew]
[applause]
[crowd chant]
[chanting continues]
[chanting and music fades]
[in English] According to
documents that I uncovered,
the Justice Department says
that the Israeli government
is obstructing
the FBI's investigation...
-[interviewer] How?
-that the FBI's requests
for information about
the suspect's telephone logs,
surveillance reports, everything
that police need to make a case
have been denied
by the government of Israel.
[David S] In 1996,
Benjamin Netanyahu
is elected Prime Minister
of Israel.
Early 1998,
he flies to the United States
for meetings
with President Bill Clinton,
and he gives a press conference
there in Washington, DC.
[ADC representative] There's
another case of Alex Odeh,
who was murdered in California.
Will the government of Israel
begin cooperating
to seek justice in this case?
I am not familiar
with extradition requests...
concerning the murder
of Alex Odeh,
but I'm sure if those
would be brought before me,
I would look into them.
Again, we have a problem
for lack of an instrument,
of a legal instrument.
[ADC representative] Um...
But Keith Fuchs and Andy Green
are apparently still
in Kiryat Arba.
And what we've been told -
since we're the organization
involved in this -
is that the Justice Department
has not received
full cooperation at all
from the Israeli government
on this matter.
I assure you
that our policy is to
cooperate fully
with the murderers...
We don't make
a distinction, sir,
between the murderers
of Arabs or Jews and...
Innocent blood is
innocent blood.
That is our policy.
[tense music playing]
[newsreader] In California,
a jailed leader
of the Jewish Defense League
is reported brain-dead tonight
after a suicide attempt.
[Osder] Do you accept
that Irv committed suicide?
No.
[Osder] What do you think?
My opinion doesn't matter.
[Osder] Who do you believe
was responsible for Irv's death?
I...
The government's responsible.
Irv did nothing wrong.
They wouldn't let him out
because they knew
they were going to...
he was going to die in prison.
He was going to die, and...
and that's what happened.
[Michel] And, also,
Kruger got killed in prison,
but after he said to the FBI,
he told the FBI
the name of the people
who assassinated Alex.
And nothing happened.
[music continues]
[Osder] Do you accept
the idea that...
not everyone
in the federal government
was doing the right thing here?
[Daniel] It's not
just a murder investigation
of Alex Odeh.
Obviously,
it's an ongoing investigation.
And there's a reason why
it's an ongoing investigation,
I'm sure.
I mean, why would it...
be just
an ongoing investigation?
You're hitting something,
and I understand
why you're asking that.
I understand. But we need
to not talk about that.
[music continues]
[music subsides]
[man on phone] Hello?
[David S] Hello.
May I please speak with
-Hugh Mooney?
-[Hugh] That's me.
We've never met before.
My name is David Sheen,
and I'm an Israeli journalist.
I understand that,
many, many years ago,
you were working on a case that
I'm currently investigating.
-[Hugh]
-Sure, sure.
So, my understanding is that,
when you were working with
the Santa Ana Police Department
many decades ago,
there was this incident,
a murder of a local man
named Alex Odeh.
[Hugh]
Yeah. Yeah, yeah.
[Hugh]
Well, no,
I wasn't aware of that.
[Hugh]
Wow.
Wow! Wow, wow.
[ruminative music playing]
[Hugh] When it first happened,
I was an Area Commander
in the city of Santa Ana.
So, I responded up there to
take partial command
of the scene.
And then, a helicopter landed
in a field next door,
which was highly unusual.
It turned out to be
the FBI and LAPD.
And they arrived
and told us that
they knew what happened
and who did it -
Manning and Fuchs and Green.
New York PD and New York FBI
were monitoring two of them,
and they lost them out
by the airport.
And then said
they're en route to LA.
They missed them at the airport,
so they were scrambling,
everybody looking for them,
and then, boom,
they knew what happened.
And we were told
we could not go arrest them.
They said,
"We knew it was them,"
and they wouldn't let us
arrest them.
Do you know why?
Why the US Attorney
instructed the agents not to...
Gee, why? Why, why, why?
No, it was very curious.
I mean,
that's not usual behaviour.
They were tailing them.
They knew
they did the bombings
in New York.
They knew they did them
in Los Angeles.
So, why would the US Attorney
not want them arrested?
It didn't make any sense.
We knew they arrived back
in New York,
and they stayed there
for another two weeks
before they flew out to Israel.
[music continues]
Contacts with Israel
first met with nothing.
They said, "No, we don't have
any such people here."
And so, then,
they called them back and said,
"Well, here's the address
and here's his birth date,
"and here's a photo of him.
"You might want to go
check out that house
and see if he's there,"
you know?
So, then, the Shin Bet
calls back and said,
"Well, yeah, he's here,
but we have political problems."
The FBI was saying,
"We know where they are."
You know,
"Why can't we get them?"
And the State Department says,
"Well, you understand,
it's real complicated.
"We're dealing
with these things,
and there are other irons
in the fire," blah, blah, blah.
The State Department says,
"No, you can't have 'em."
The FBI was very unhappy
about it, or the agents I knew.
But it came from Washington,
and they were just, you know,
"Choke it down
and do as you're told."
[clears throat]
You know, "It's going to be
an open case forever."
[David S] Yeah,
I constantly question
whether there's a purpose
to any of this.
On one hand, I have family
and agents who worked
on the case telling me,
"This is credible evidence.
This should be taken
into account.
"This should be investigated.
This should be pursued."
On the other hand,
this evidence I've uncovered
is just languishing
on my computer.
Either way, at least I know
it wasn't a waste of time.
I know that it was legitimate,
important work that I did,
and it'll stand on its own.
[contemplative music playing]
[Norma] They kept saying,
"We're committed.
"We're going to be
working on it.
It's not a cold case."
They have their names,
they know where they live.
[GPS] In 800 feet, turn right
onto South Sepulveda Boulevard.
I need to hear more.
I need to understand more.
I need more, more, more.
And I was given nothing.
And it's, like,
the same answer...
I had in '86,
they gave me today.
Same answer.
[music continues]
[LAPD]
[FBI]
[V]
[attorney]
[LAPD]
[Richard] Resolve.
It's a question of resolve.
When the US sent its airplanes
to bring down the airplane
that was carrying
the hijackers of
the Achille Lauro,
that's resolve.
And there's no resolve,
anything like that,
in the case of the Odeh case.
Nothing.
It's... The case is
30-some years old at this point.
The day that it happened,
they told me to my face,
"We know exactly
who did this. Period."
It's 30 years later,
30-plus years later,
as far as I'm concerned,
nothing palpable, or nothing...
nothing of consequence
has happened.
So, you kind of have to be...
skeptical...
at this point, you know...
that it's ever
going to be resolved, really.
[ruminative music playing]
[Ahmad] This is an activist
who paid dearly.
It was really brave in the '80s
to speak out and say,
"Yes, Palestine exists
and we want peace.
"We are people, too.
We deserve a better life."
It was courageous
to say that then.
It's courageous to say it now.
Losing my dad
was very hard on us.
But we are still strong.
Maybe I'm putting myself
in danger.
The same thing that happened
to my dad could happen to me.
[music subsides]
[Youmans] So, why take the risk?
For my dad.
I know he would be proud,
and I know it's something
that he would do.
If he was still here,
he'd still be fighting.
[contemplative music playing]
[man] How lucky we are
we had Alex Odeh.
What he has done in his lifetime
can never be erased
by the thug
who committed this awful crime
in the darkness of anonymity.
They have not stilled his voice.
They have amplified it
10,000 times.
[music continues and chanting]
[man] And thousands more
will take their strength
from the courage of Alex Odeh,
and from his brave family.
[music continues]
[Norma] Well, Alex,
happy birthday.
I just wish you were with us.
I'll be seeing you again.
I love you and miss you a lot.
[music continues]
[music continues]
[music continues]
[music subsides]
by Matchbox Cinesub