Are You My First? (2025) s01e03 Episode Script

1
Right where we belong, ooh! ♪
With all of the magic, yeah, yeah ♪
[Kaitlyn Bristowe]
Welcome back to Are You My First?
where the virginity count remains
16 out of 16.
But that could change
if our virgins make things a little saucy.
Which, by the way, is what you say
when you're a virgin
and you're still working your way up
to saying the word "sexy."
[gentle, upbeat music playing]
[Katya] Are you nervous?
-Um, I mean--
-Or excited? Are you excited?
Sometimes he makes me, like, nervous
'cause he's really good at flirting.
So then it's like, "Ooh, like, saucy."
[Kaitlyn] See?
I told you there'd be sauciness.
[Madi] I'm so shocked
Noah picked me to go on the date.
I know he was also talking to Carissa,
and I, I, like, thought
he liked her more, honestly.
[Kaitlyn] So did we, Madi.
I actually had 50 bucks riding on it.
Let's go on a date, Madi.
-[group clapping and cheering]
-[Kaitlyn] By choosing Madi,
Noah betrayed Carissa
and lost me 50 bucks.
But now I've made a super safe bet.
Fifty bucks on Carissa being super pissed.
[gentle music playing]
Madi is one of my top girls.
[Andrew] Yeah. Yeah.
There are other top girls, though.
[chuckles]
I wanted to take out Carissa,
but I just kind of thought,
"You know what,
she just went on a date with Mike,
and I do like Madi."
So, I think I need to, like,
keep them on equal pace
until, like, my heart actually starts
leaning one way or the other.
Would you try to kiss her, you think?
Yeah, if the vibe is there.
-It's like, I need to see a green--
-Yeah.
I need to see the green light, though.
This is, like, a romantic date.
Like, it's a nighttime date,
so the mood will be set.
You get some, like--
Moves happen once--
[chuckling] "You get some."
I'm just saying, like,
getting some is getting some.
-[Noah] I hate you.
-[all laughing]
[Madi] I'm like a horse.
Like, I spook a little easy.
[gasps]
I haven't been on a date with someone
I'm actually interested in in four years.
Like, it's been, it's been a minute.
On the outside of this experience,
my dating life is pretty
abysmal, honestly.
Like [chuckles]
A lot of people, I think, living in Texas
are already married or in relationships.
So, I feel like all the good ones
are kind of taken.
[" I've Been Dreaming Of You"
by HEIGHTS playing]
Bittersweet taste of summer ♪
Is this is a new phase? ♪
Do you think I should
wear a bra with this?
[Jade] No.
[Madi] I'm not necessarily waiting
'til I'm married to have sex.
But I do think I definitely
wanna be with someone
that is, like, loving and caring.
I feel like Noah's like that.
What are you doing here?
-You got glammed up.
-Glammed up. Hi.
-Yeah, you look good.
-How are you feeling?
I feel good.
[Madi]
I would like to kiss Noah,
but I don't know if
he's gonna wanna kiss me,
or how he's feeling.
So I'm nervous about that.
Oh, I've been dreamin' of you ♪
[Carissa]
Last night, Noah told me
that he was gonna pick me on the date
if he gets this next V card.
[Noah]
It's gonna be so romantic.
[Carissa] There was connection
growing with Noah.
And Mike and I, we haven't
talked really after the date,
so I don't know how he feels about me.
This is what I keep running into
when I'm dating these men,
is that their actions are not
lining up with their words.
When men lie, it puts me
into my man-hating era.
[sighs]
-[sparkling flourish]
-[ocean waves crashing]
["Come See Me" by HEIGHTS playing]
[Kaitlyn] First dates provide
a good chance of romance,
but can also be stressful.
Noah and Madi not only have
a virgin sacrifice on their minds,
but they also have exposed flames
in a wicker birdcage
hanging over their heads.
Is this a dream? ♪
[Madi]
Oh wow, this is so fancy.
[Kaitlyn] They say actions
speak louder than words,
and this particular action
speaks loudest of all.
-[cork pops]
-[Noah laughs]
[Madi] Oh! That went far!
-That was a good first time.
-That was great.
-Poppin'.
-Popping cherries? [laughs]
[gentle guitar music playing]
[Colton Underwood]
While Madi and Noah settle into their date
and get comfortable,
the other virgins are ready to make things
uncomfortable.
I think we should play a game
to get the night started.
-[group exclaims]
-Is that a bad idea,
-or is that a good idea?
-No, I like that. I like that.
The classic good-old, Truth or Dare.
-Yeah!
-[excited chatter]
Wow.
Truth or Dare with
a bunch of virgins who are like--
have been pent up their whole lives,
is like my Super Bowl.
Like, let's go.
-[Andrew] Let's work our way around.
-Let's go.
-Godwin.
-[Deya] Yeah, Godwin.
-[crosstalk]
-Oh, man!
[Deya] Truth or dare, Godwin?
-Yo, truth, bro. We goin' with truth, bro.
-[laughter]
-Conversation.
-Who was the best conversation? Boom.
[Godwin] I'm not wasting time,
'cause Kaitlyn and Colton
just dropped this news
that people are gonna be eliminated
if you don't make a connection.
You know what I'm saying?
I gotta seize the opportunity.
Every second matters here,
every second counts.
And that's what I gotta do.
I felt like I had a great conversation,
great chat with two people.
These two beautiful ladies
right here, one and two.
-[upbeat percussive music playing]
-[group exclaiming]
Realistically, Jade have the upper hand.
She's beautiful.
We have a great connection.
I think Deya is cool, great convo,
but Deya's also not my usual type,
so I'm just trying to figure it out.
Jake, truth or dare?
[group] Ooh!
[cheering and chanting]
Truth.
What do you want the most
out of this experience?
I'm, I'm trying to find a wife.
[dramatic music playing]
Who do you most wanna take on a date next?
Rachael.
[Godwin] Truth or dare, Mike?
-[Mike] I'll go with truth.
-Truth?
So lame! Oh, my God, I can't! [laughs]
I feel like everybody's
playing it so safe right now.
-We're virgins.
-Okay.
I wanna see people lap dancing.
I wanna see people getting
into sex positions.
I wanna see people, you know,
kissing each other's necks
and licking their ear lobes
and, and stuff.
Like, we're here to date.
Is it true that your conversation,
or connection with Carissa,
is the best one in the villa by far?
-[Carissa] Whoa!
-Oh, good one!
♪♪
Yeah, I feel like that
was an easy one, right?
[group laughing]
[Carissa] Knowing now that Mike
might have a little crush on me,
it obviously feels good,
and I think it, um,
gave me a lot of clarity.
I'm feeling, like, a lot better
about, like, where we stand
and, like, my interest in him
and our interest in each other.
Ty, truth or dare?
Dare.
You have to pick a girl
to demonstrate maybe
a little sexy position
when marriage comes around.
-[upbeat music playing]
-[group] Ooh!
[overlapping chatter and laughter]
[Carissa]
They laughed. He already knows.
Bubba, you got a little,
like, hand back here.
[group exclaims]
Pull her down, your hand around the waist.
[Colton] Whoa, Ty!
Too much more of that kind of action,
and you'll push our rating right up to
PG-13.
Thank goodness everyone
kept their shirt on.
Bro, man, you goin'
for the same girl I'm picking?
I'm like, "Yeah, this
a competition right here."
But basically, at the end of the day,
may the best man win.
And that is going to be me.
[Jake] Alright.
Andrew.
Dare.
Of course. If there's one person
that's gonna dare it.
The girl that you're most interested in
in this exact moment,
kiss her big toe.
-[snarky music playing]
-[group groans]
[Katya] What? Men are weird.
I cannot explain
the Y chromosome, personally.
Or maybe the ankle.
Like, feet stuff? People like that?
-The hand feels safe.
-Yeah. And sanitary.
Sanitary.
I didn't say suck, just a peck.
[Andrew] Okay.
[group cheers and claps]
-[upbeat music playing]
-[Andrew] My eyes are set on Katya,
but I can't tell what she wants,
because she hasn't made that very clear.
During the paint night,
she, like, painted everyone,
so I-I d-- I don't know.
-Literally, frickin' tornado up in here.
-Truly.
♪♪
-I knew it. [chuckles]
-[group cheering]
-Dare.
-[Ty] Yeah.
Okay, you know what?
Just walk up and go to the connection
that's your number one connection.
Goddammit, why did I get this question?
Why did I look Mike in the eyeball?
-[Michael] Okay.
-[Godwin] Yeah.
[Jade]
I am feeling very good with Ty.
I'm happy with where we're at.
On the other hand, with Godwin,
to hear from other women that he's kind of
articulating similar things to them,
that's a huge red flag.
But then, at the same time,
he is stunning.
Like, he is handsome.
Fuck.
And then come back and sit down.
[group exclaiming]
[group cheering]
So let the games begin ♪
Yo, seriously?
-You're number one out of the six.
-Yeah, I told you. I told you.
[Godwin] Is shawty even
that interested in me,
like, she making it seem?
Or is she just playing this whole time?
Let the games begin ♪
["Let The Games Begin"
by The Everlove playing]
[Jade] How did you feel
about the game?
Wait, you and Ty?
[Jade]
I know, right? [chuckles]
-I feel like Godwin's like, "This bitch."
-[all chuckling]
Like, I don't want him to think
I'm, like, fucking with his head,
but, like, I'm still, like,
so unsure with him.
But, like, with Ty,
it's like, it's just so easy.
-It's just so easy.
-[Carissa] And he solidified it.
[Deya] It was so shocking
when Jade chose Ty
as her number one connection.
Now, it's clear she made her choice.
And I'm happy because that also
makes it easier for me too,
because me and, and Godwin
can continue our connection.
Like, this game brings clarity
for you to know, like, where you stand
and what's really going on.
Let the games begin ♪
I just wanna give you ♪
[Kaitlyn] With a virgin sacrifice
and any number of reality show
twists on the horizon,
Noah and Madi's date feels
kind of like a romantic Wordle,
where every word could be their last.
Do you have any icks?
-[laughing]
-You know, like--
I have one, and you've done it. [laughing]
No, I don't like guys
that wear flip-flops.
I don't wear flip-flops.
Genuinely, I don't.
What do you wear when
you're, like, at the beach?
-Flip-flops. It's the beach!
-That's-- No,
I don't like guys that
wear flip-flops at the beach.
You want me to wear
my Converse to the beach?
No, Birken-- Birkenstocks.
Those are so like,
"I'm a troll from the woods."
[chuckles] I feel like you actually
have really good style.
What else do you like about me?
[chuckles] Your hair, your face.
I like your little eye wrinkles,
actually, a lot.
I like your face.
-You like my face?
-I like your face.
-Yeah--
-Is there something in my eyelash?
There's a fuzz.
-Is it gone? Can you get it?
-No, you still have a little bit of fuzz.
-Do you, like, trust me?
-Mm-hm.
Thanks.
-I'm like, "Got it." [chuckles]
-[Madi gags and chuckles]
Wait, have you seen those where it's like
the face they make before a kiss?
-Girls-- Girls--
-Oh, go
Girls go like this. They go
[both laugh]
So, so, what's your kiss face?
Mm
[Noah chuckles]
-That was good.
-Is that icky?
That was awesome. [chuckles]
Yeah, I bet you want
more of that. [laughs]
Yeah, lemme see it again. [laughs]
-Stop.
-[both laughing]
-I'm just gonna look at you.
-Okay.
["Close To You"
by Gracie Abrams playing]
Pull the trigger on the gun ♪
I gave you when we met ♪
I wanna be close to you ♪
Break my heart and start a fire ♪
You got me overnight ♪
You're like a princess kisser.
-What do you mean? What's my kiss face?
-Like
-[laughs] Like that.
-What does it look like?
[both chuckle]
-Yours was like this. Ahh!
-I can't reciprocate.
-Yeah. What was mine like?
-Ahh!
Close to you ♪
[Noah]
I am seriously looking for love
and really trying to find someone
that I could lose my virginity to.
I totally think the one could be Madi.
Ah! [chuckles]
You're cute.
Thanks.
[Noah] Kissing a girl that I actually
have, like, budding feelings for
and interest in
just kind of left me, like, fuzzy
and, like, a little love-drunk, I think.
You have soft lips.
[clicks tongue] Oh.
Yeah.
-That was a good kiss.
-Yeah, that was cute. I liked it.
Noah definitely makes me feel
like he understands me and my humor,
and we're on the same page,
and I feel like I can be myself,
which I don't really feel like that
around a lot of people.
I can be as weird as I wanna be,
and like somehow, he's weirder,
[laughing]
which is, like, kind of crazy.
So, that's always a plus.
And so, I think I'm like,
"Oh wow, like, I could
actually have a boyfriend."
Like, that's great. Like, I--
It just makes me excited.
Burn for you ♪
Mm ♪
[Noah] That was so fun.
To be close to you ♪
Pull the trigger on the gun ♪
[Noah] You're cute.
You look very, very pretty tonight.
Thank you.
Close to you ♪
[Kaitlyn] As Madi and Noah get closer,
we're about to find out
if Andrew is a closer.
[Katya] First of all, hi.
[Andrew] We're twinning.
Katya, she's always been
someone I've been interested in,
and she's an independent, like,
confident woman, which I love.
She's holding her cards
close to her chest.
I felt she was interested in me,
but she was a, a question mark.
And tonight, I want that
question to be resolved.
What does romantic love look like to you?
Like, literally, I want
my marriage and my love
to be like my best life
with my best friend.
For me, romantic love is
friendship set on fire.
-Oh, my gosh, let's set some fire.
-I want--
Yeah, let's add some fire. Turn it up!
-[Andrew] I've been so nervous-- Yeah.
-Really?
[Andrew] And I wanna make it known
that, like, you're my number one.
I'm pretty reserved about like--
[Andrew] I can tell.
But I feel super, super secure
in what we have,
and you are always and forever
gonna be, like, in my top.
[Andrew] I'm glad. I was--
I've been so nervous, 'cause--
-About me?
-Yeah.
Let me clear that up for you,
'cause I didn't feel insecure at all ever.
-This is like
-Not one second.
everything I needed to hear.
-Good, I'm glad.
-You have no idea.
I feel secure with Katya.
The fact that she just confessed her
feelings that she has towards me,
it really solidified the fact that
this is where I wanna invest my time.
She went from a question mark
to an exclamation point.
-I know what I want.
-Okay.
-Like, you're my one
-Good.
-and, like, I know that.
-Good, I'm glad.
Fortune favors the bold.
-Fortune favors the bold.
-Yeah.
[Andrew] For sure, for sure.
Like, I guess on the note
of being bold, can I?
-No.
-No?
-Mm-mm.
-Okay. Why is that?
-You gotta earn it.
-Okay.
-Mm-hm.
-Meaning?
You'll figure it out.
You don't just get to kiss me.
Absolutely not.
You wanna kiss me? Prove it.
I wanna see it in your actions.
Can I get some hints?
Everyone's different, so
I don't know. I guess that,
that'll take time then for you to learn.
I mean, I was just gonna give you a peck,
but damn, I gotta work for that, huh?
Mm-hm. Yeah, duh.
♪♪
[Kaitlyn] Strike! Swing and a miss.
But Andrew has balls to spare
and is determined to get to first base.
-Hey, guys.
-Hi.
-Hey, What's up?
-Hi.
-Yay!
-You look so cute.
Should we do, like, a girl chat, boy chat?
["I Got Whatchu Want"
by The Everlove playing]
I got what you want ♪
-Okay, just tell us. Just tell us.
-Okay.
-Date.
-[Rachael] Yay!
So, it was a really sweet, cute date.
[gentle, upbeat music playing]
It was super fun.
I discovered more about her
that was really attractive to me.
And then at one point, we said,
"Okay, well, I'm just gonna sit here."
And then
[Krash] That's a sign, bro.
-And then that was the sign.
-That was the sign!
-Smooch. [laughs]
-Ah!
-[group cheer and clap]
-Yo!
[Colton]
To many, a peck is no big deal.
-It was good. It was cute.
-[Andrew] Yes, sir!
[Colton] But to most virgins,
it's a white-knuckle thrill ride
with the potential to slingshot them
into a boundary-breaking future
of love, connection, and sex.
To others, it's just a peck.
But he was like--
He said something like--
like, "What do you-- What's like--
What do you think your kiss face is?"
-[laughing] Okay.
-So, then we were-- Then we were like
-Like, joking, you know?
-Uh-huh.
Madi is very excited
about her kiss with Noah,
and this sucks, because
I thought he liked me,
and I guess he wants to explore Madi.
No one likes feeling like a second choice.
But it was good.
Yeah, so it was a good date.
I'm interested in
maybe, like, a few girls,
and she's, like, my main girl,
I'd say, right now.
-Yeah.
-[group cheering and clapping]
[Ty] Uh-oh, we got hosts.
[Kaitlyn] I love how they
say "uh-oh" when they see us.
[Rachael] Uh-oh.
[Colton] We're gonna
talk to you guys up here.
[contestants] Oh!
Oh no, Colton's over there.
[Rachael] I'm a little worried.
All of a sudden,
Kaitlyn and Colton walk up.
We don't know what they have planned
or what they're gonna say.
So, we're a little uneasy
because they know how
to keep us on our toes,
and I think they're here
to shake things up.
Alright, there's obviously a reason
why we are here tonight.
[tense, suspenseful music playing]
We told you to use your time wisely.
[Colton] Because if you weren't able
to find that genuine connection,
you would be sent home.
♪♪
Unfortunately, that time
is right around the corner.
♪♪
[Kaitlyn] Tomorrow night
is the very first virgin sacrifice
where some of you will be going home.
[dramatic sting]
[contestants] "Some"?!
-[Madi] Tomorrow?
-More than one?
[shocked chatter]
[Kaitlyn] That's right, there won't be
just one virgin sacrificed.
Kaitlyn and Colton come in
and drop a bomb on us
and say there will be
multiple people going home.
I think that's when everything
kind of hit the fan and reality hits,
and everybody now goes,
"I need to figure this out."
-They really said "some."
-[Godwin] That's crazy.
No one's safe.
Oh, shit.
I was just having fun. I was on a date.
Like, it was all flirty and fun,
and now it's, like, serious
and people are going home.
And, you know, kind of like a reminder
that we are here to meet someone
and not just, like, have fun.
So I think, definitely puts
the pressure on a little bit.
Tomorrow, you're gonna need
to make some very difficult decisions.
It is crucial that you start focusing in
on the people that you
can see a future with.
-[tense, suspenseful music continues]
-Whew.
Have a good night.
-[Rachael sighs]
-[Deya] That is crazy.
I'm not goin' down without a fight ♪
[Godwin] I'm very worried
about going home.
I'm trying to leave here
with the love of my life.
I'm not leaving here empty-handed.
[Jade] I'm 28 years,
here I am, still a virgin.
I came here hoping
to get something different
from what I wasn't
getting in the real world.
If I can't find it here
♪♪
I would be emotionally devastated.
♪♪
-[birds chirping]
-[ocean waves crashing]
[Kaitlyn] Welcome back
to Are You My First?,
a place where a bunch of virgins
are now panicking
about whether they will find "the one."
-[Krash] Yeah, let's go talk.
-[Rachael] Let's go talk.
[Krash] Let's talk right here.
[Kaitlyn]
That's right. After tonight,
these virgins may find themselves
one step closer to the pleasure zone
and for others, the friend zone.
-[Deya] Godwin, this got so freaking real.
-[Godwin] Yeah.
[gentle, upbeat music playing]
What'd you think about, like,
that bomb that they just dropped?
Yeah, it's pretty nerve-racking.
Some people, two people,
whoever's going home tomorrow, like--
Maybe, or even more.
[sighs] How you feeling?
Um Oh, I forgot we actually have to,
you know, do that whole thing.
Virgin sacrifice sounds scary.
Like, what are we gonna do?
Throw a virgin in the fire?
-[lava bursting]
-[Kaitlyn] Yes!
Wait, I'm being told
the answer is in fact, "No."
[Carissa] But I am probably saved
because Noah did say that
he doesn't think I'm gonna go home.
If I go home tomorrow, I'm so okay
because it was still
such a great experience.
-I just went on a date.
-You're--
You are not going home tomorrow.
-Like
-[Carissa laughing]
I don't know if I necessarily trust Noah.
I mean, he did say that he
would take me on the date,
and then, changed his mind.
But, no matter what,
I'm excited about continuing
my connection with Mike,
and I'm having fun.
I think my problem is
is I've been playing it almost like,
I guess, safe.
Like, trying to keep my cards
close to my chest, in a way.
-Yeah.
-Kind of, like, not sharing too much.
So, I just wanted to say, like,
I think I'm definitely interested in,
in seeing maybe where this goes.
I wanted to see how you
felt about that, though.
Yeah. No, that's how I feel too.
Time's limited, and if you
squander opportunity, then it passes.
I'm 34, I know what I want.
So, my focus stays on one girl,
that girl's Carissa.
That's who I want.
It's that plain and simple.
Just hoping for more time with that.
I have to be just focused on one.
Yeah, okay.
-Maybe my brain's small, I don't know.
-[Carissa laughs]
Maybe you're much more capable.
-I've got a bigger head.
-Yeah.
[Carissa laughing]
[Colton] Regardless of their brain sizes,
it's clear that the threat
of the upcoming virgin sacrifice
has our virgins throwing up Hail Marys
to secure their strongest connections.
Dear Heavenly Father,
protect me, cover me--
-Yes. Please protect, Godwin.
-[both laughing]
Protect-- Protect me.
Yes, and also, with this connection
that I also, you know,
I also have built, dear Father Lord,
my prayers is let it be great.
-Amen.
-Amen. Whew!
-[Godwin] You-You were in tears?
-Yeah!
Yo-- Dang. Nah, it's cool.
[both laughing]
[Colton] But for some of our virgins,
honing in on just one connection
hasn't been easy.
My tops have always been,
like, you and Godwin.
-[Ty] Right.
-[Jade] With, like, Godwin,
this, like, like, uncertainty
that I just can't, like, articulate.
-Yeah.
-I'm vibing with it,
-I'm getting it, and then other times
-Yeah.
I'm like, "You're losing me."
So, like, going into, like, tomorrow,
that's what I'm thinking about.
I'm thinking about, like, you and him.
[Ty] Jade was super transparent
about how she also has
a little something with Godwin.
But still, I'm crushing on Jade.
Her personality, her humor, her beauty,
there's so much about her
that is very intriguing.
She's someone I potentially see myself
losing my virginity to.
The biggest thing that
-I like about you
-[Jade] Mm-hm.
is just kind of all the qualities
you conduct in, like, one package.
You do, like, conduct a room
with, like, your beauty.
And, like, I know, like,
there are differences between us,
but, like, I have a high stake
in, like, figuring those out
and seeing if it does go somewhere.
[Jade] You, like, always, like,
validating me, I just
-It feels nice.
-Yeah.
Ty makes me feel so safe.
Obviously,
my dating experience is limited,
but just out of all
the conversations I've ever had,
I've never felt so seen
by, like, another man before.
I love to hear that, like,
you're feeling what I'm feeling like--
-[Ty] Yeah.
-[laughs] You know?
Emotionally, the connection is there.
But, like, physically,
I am attracted to Godwin.
Am I torn between the two guys,
Godwin and Ty? Absolutely.
-My little skippy.
-[Jade] Mm!
[gentle, upbeat music playing]
I'm glad that we both agree
we're just, like, solid,
-that kind of thing. Like, yeah.
-Solid, yeah. It's good.
Like, we don't have to worry about it.
When I'm with Michael,
my guards are completely down,
and my walls are down.
Like, he's really genuine.
He makes me laugh.
I feel like I could just,
literally, tell him anything.
So, at this point,
like, Michael's kind of
just running away with it, so--
And "it" would be my heart.
And-- [clears throat] I'm-- [coughs]
Okay, are you alright?
I have a frog in my throat. I--
Oh, I have a phobia of frogs.
-Really? It wasn't a--
-Yeah, like big time.
No, it wasn't a literal frog,
it was just a little bit of--
[laughing] It's like a figure of speech.
Just needed to grease the pipes.
I'm feeling really good about Rachael.
Things are going well.
She's into me, I'm into her.
I think we, by far, have, like,
the strongest connection.
Let's go to the beach real quick
before anyone else goes.
-Oh, my God! We've never hammocked it.
-I don't think anyone's hammocked it.
[Rachael] Oh, my God! Okay.
I've just been loomed with,
uh, my virginity,
and it's time to part those clouds
and let some sun in.
And who knows?
Maybe Rachael's that sunshine.
Of all the girls, she's,
like, the whole package.
-Are you flexible? I'm not flexible.
-No.
-That-- Like, that's pulling me.
-That's pretty good.
-That's pulling me.
-Yeah, like--
Alright, so when we have sex,
just don't go farther than here.
[both laughing]
I'm joking. I'm joking, okay?
-Okay.
-No pressure.
[both chuckling]
[Michael] I've never been, like,
this close with someone this fast.
The fact that we're already,
like, crossing bridges
that I didn't think I would cross
maybe my whole time here.
And it's, you know, just the beginning,
so I think we're on a good path.
Do you think your parents would like me?
Yeah, I don't see why not.
My dad treats me like a princess.
Like, that's partly why
my standards are high
'cause, like, the way he, like, treats me.
Um, but he, like, just--
I ain't doing that shit.
[both laughing]
I gotta put effort into this?
Yeah, fuck.
And you literally just throw me off.
[both chuckling]
Um, but he just, like, wants me
to be with, like, a good guy
-that I, like, deserve.
-Yeah.
So I think he would really like you.
Oh, that's so sweet.
My grandfather was from New York
-[Rachael] Mm-hm.
-and he would climb a tree
and watch the Yankees
with a pair of binoculars.
Oh, you love baseball?
It's, like, the only sport,
like, I really watch.
-Me too.
-Really?
-Yeah.
-Oh, that's tight.
We're so perfect for each other.
[both chuckling]
[Michael] We have, like, one thing
in common. "Oh, this is destiny."
[Rachael] No, I know. [chuckles]
[insects chirring]
I guess we'll just, like,
cut a little bit to the chase.
-Yeah.
-And then I kinda wanna maybe just, like,
-hear about your night.
-[Carissa] Okay.
We just like-- I--
Me and Madi just, like, quickly--
The date went so well,
and we're both excited about it.
[Carissa] We talked last night.
You did mention, like,
if there was a date, you'd want to go.
[Noah] Yeah, how did you feel
about when I chose Madi?
I don't know if I, like, was super pumped.
Yeah.
With Noah, I don't know if there's,
like, a real, like, connection.
He did say that he would
take me on the date.
So that is a giant red flag.
So, at this point,
Mike is my top connection.
I did get to talk to Mike tonight,
and we did get some, like, good clarity.
So I think I am, like, feeling him
-[Noah] Okay.
-for sure.
Yeah. You wanna know what, actually?
I think I'm excited to get to know you
without the pressure of romance.
-Yeah.
-This is our time
to maybe actually be friends for a minute.
-Yeah. Right?
-If it never turns into romance,
like, I'll be really grateful
-that you and I are friends.
-Yeah.
Carissa's full of games, I think.
She's pissed she didn't get chosen,
so she's trying to tell me that
she's not interested anymore.
It was like, "Okay, 'just friend,'
see you around."
But I just felt like I
could read through it
'cause there was still
a good energy there.
[Carissa] Oh, we're gonna do the--
We're doing the side hug?
-No.
-We were doing [muffled] little side hug.
-Here you go.
-[both chuckle]
I was doing the side hug at first
'cause I was sweaty.
I'm, like, not feeling clean right now.
["You Got Me Dreaming" by Markus Hughes
and The Home Of Happy playing]
I still remember we were new ♪
Back when my heart was falling ♪
But you're still
the light of my morning ♪
[Colton] Up and at 'em.
The early virgin gets the worm.
[Madi] An ant fell in my coffee.
You got me dreaming of you ♪
[Colton]
It's the day of the virgin sacrifice.
And the virgins are employing
the same tactic I use
when facing imminent catastrophe:
distraction, moisturize, distraction.
Every time I hang out,
me and Michael are kissing
or, like, just touching,
my vagina tingles again, I'm like, "Damn!"
[Colton] Nothing starts the day
quite like a bit of tingle talk.
I haven't dyed my hair.
-Let's go!
-[both laughing]
-[Katya] Virgin all around.
-Virgin all around.
I feel like I'm one of the few
-Hasn't done anything.
-kids I know
that is, like, actually holding out.
So, you haven't done
anything with girls like that?
You haven't gotten head? That's crazy.
No.
No, I haven't done any of that stuff.
Good for you, bro.
-Thanks.
-It's better that way.
It's really dope,
but it's better that way.
-[Noah chuckling]
-Have you got to second base?
-Like hand job?
-[Andrew] Yeah.
-No.
-[Andrew chuckling]
[Noah] You gotta, like,
swat the hands away,
and be like,
"No, like, let's slow things down."
Like, "I'm done, I'm leaving."
It's good. It's admirable.
♪♪
[Kaitlyn] There's no telling
which virgins will be sacrificed first,
so we told them all
to pre-pack their bags.
What we didn't tell them
is whoever is sacrificed
has to settle everyone's
outstanding room service bill,
including mine.
Last night, there was
just a different energy.
I felt like me and Michael, like,
that push we've been needing
to get to that, like, couple energy.
I'm not worried about Michael
going home or me going home.
I think, like, I feel really solid,
but I don't know how solid
everybody else feels.
[Krash] It's gonna suck to see,
like, who leaves.
[Jake] Oh, man.
[Madi] I'm preparing myself for the worst.
[Noah] You're gonna be so
effing lonely if I leave.
[Andrew] Yeah.
We don't know how many
people will be going home.
Um, there's a lot of uncertainty.
And I'm definitely worried.
-[Ty] Where's Michael at?
-[Andrew] We don't know.
You woke up and he was gone, right?
Is that what--
-Yeah, I, like, woke up--
-[Jake] He's gone.
We're all kind of looking at each other.
We don't know if maybe
he has already been eliminated.
We really don't know what's happening.
There's a fire
and it's blazin' in my heart ♪
I got a lot of emotions that I'm feeling.
I'm very anxious to see
how this will play out.
Definitely not feeling, like,
100% confident going into this,
that's for sure.
["No Place to Hide"
by Luke Rowe playing]
-There's ♪
-There's just no place to hide ♪
Hide ♪
There's just no place to hide ♪
Hide ♪
There's just no place to hide ♪
[Katya] Ladies, you look beautiful.
Everyone looks gorgeous.
-[Jade] Stunning.
-Stunnin'.
-[Rachael] Amazing.
-[Katya] How are we feeling?
I'm literally, like, wiping
sweat off myself right now.
Palms are sweaty.
Guys are here.
-[Carissa] Oh, my God.
-[Rachael] Oh, my God. Oh, my God.
Guys, where's Michael?
[dramatic music playing]
[Jade] Hey!
[everyone greeting each other]
[overlapping chatter]
[Katya] How are the guys
feeling today? Like nervous,
or what's the vibe there?
Well, we don't know
where our boy Michael is.
That is one thing we have no idea--
Oh, y'all don't know where he is?
-[Deya] You don't know?
-[Krash] We don't know.
-[birds chirping]
-[ocean waves crashing]
["Reaching For The Scars"
by HVMANS ft. So Effective playing]
[Andrew] Look who's comin'.
Feel you gettin' closer ♪
Tryin' to keep composure ♪
Hopin' is all I can hold ♪
[Krash] Oh, my God,
and they're wearing black.
Literally, like funeral vibes.
[Kaitlyn] Good evening, everyone.
[contestants] Good evening.
Before we get started
with our very first virgin sacrifice,
we're gonna address
the elephant in the room.
[tense music playing]
[Colton] I'm sure you guys
have realized by now,
Michael is not here.
♪♪
Unfortunately, due to a family emergency,
Michael had to return home.
[dramatic sting]
[Rachael crying]
[gentle music playing]
[Rachael weeping]
God.
I can't breathe right now ♪
[Rachael whimpering]
Rachael, how are you feeling?
[sniffles] I'm really sad.
Yeah.
I just, I've been waiting
so long for that connection,
and then to have it,
and then have it ripped away,
I just don't even know
what to think right now.
[crying] I hope everything's okay.
I'm without you ♪
Ooh ♪
I think my soul just, like, left my body.
There's so many emotions,
because I can't talk to him,
I can't check in with him,
I can't see if he's okay.
[sniffles]
So, my heart's with him.
I hope he's okay,
and he's where he needs to be.
Love, for now, I'll be without you ♪
[Kaitlyn] We all will miss him terribly.
Now it's time to focus on
the people that are here.
By the end of tonight,
three of you will be heading home.
-Fuck.
-That's fucked up.
It is heart-wrenching, I know.
-[tense, suspenseful music playing]
-[Colton] Ladies,
you will need to decide which two men
you think should go home.
♪♪
And gentlemen, you will
need to choose one woman
who you've decided won't be your first.
That will leave just six women and six men
in the pursuit of finding
love here on Are You My First?
So, think carefully
about who you think is
the least likely to find love here.
[Kaitlyn] When you're ready, you will
head to the confessional one at a time.
You will declare the name
or names of who you think
should be going home.
♪♪
Ultimately, the two men and the one woman
who receive the most votes
will be going home.
[Colton]
We know you won't take this lightly,
but from our experience,
in order to get to
the destination you all want
real love
you will have to face
many difficult decisions.
And tonight is just the beginning.
["Keep The Fire Alive" by Palomar,
Murphy, Sanudo, & Prince playing]
Good luck, and we will see
you at the virgin sacrifice.
The fire that rages through the night ♪
[Krash] That's crazy.
Gonna keep the fire alive ♪
[Andrew]
They said least likely to find love?
[Rachael]
Yeah, that's probably
the worst-case scenario
we didn't even think of.
Bye, good luck.
[Noah] This is a crazy decision because
we're choosing to send home our friends
and people we care about,
and maybe end someone
else's genuine connection
to save our own.
That's a sacrifice,
and I didn't expect that at all.
[voice breaking]
I don't want any of us to go.
[tense music playing]
[Mike] What's unique about this
is everybody's on the chopping block.
[Godwin] It's just crazy to me.
Yeah.
Does anyone have a single name
that they can throw out?
With the whole Rachael situation,
is she emotionally prepared
to open up to the next person?
-[Noah] To somebody else?
-[Godwin] For somebody else,
with Michael being gone?
I'm on the same page with you.
If that reaction's true,
there's not gonna be really
a connection with anybody else.
[Rachael] Knowing that multiple people
are going home tonight,
and my connection's not here,
I pretty much just feel like
I should pack my bags,
and, you know, be on my way at this point.
I really came here to find somebody,
and I actually do think that
I found somebody really special.
But, you know, there's lots
of religious people here,
so, you know,
maybe I could get 'em
to pray for a miracle for me.
And what about Krash?
[Jade] I feel like he's an amazing man.
Like, I really--
-He is!
-[group agreeing]
You gotta take into account
if they have a connection,
or if they are wanting
to build a connection.
Like, for me, like, Katya has definitely
continued to be a hard one to read,
and I don't think that's gonna change.
[Andrew] I mean, I would love her to stay.
She did tell me very directly
that she's very secure with me,
she wants to continue to pursue me,
and she's the person I'm committed to
that I want to stay and I wanna pursue.
[Krash] From day one,
I don't think Katya has been forward.
The paint party was a cop-out
just painting everybody.
It was an easy way out.
I don't think she is being completely
transparent and upfront,
and I think she is playing it safe.
[Jade] How about Hakeem?
[Sara] Hakeem and Jake
are really good guys
and I feel like they're both
really deserving to be here.
[voice breaking] You know,
and I'm, I'm worried about you guys,
so I-I-I'm just kind of flustered,
'cause I don't really
-know where to go with-- Yeah.
-It's a lot. It's overwhelming. Yeah.
I'm not ready to go home
this early at all.
I want my first date,
I want my first kiss.
That's why I decided to come here
and push myself out my comfort zone.
So, I-I don't wanna go home. I don't.
If I have to choose someone to go,
it might be Carissa.
She's the only person that I've had
no idea who she's actually pursuing.
All the guys have made
an effort to talk to us
except for Mike.
-[Katya] Mm-hm.
-[Jade] Yeah.
[Deya] Except for with Carissa.
Because he has been so intentional,
and that means that we have,
like, a good connection,
I wanna see where that goes.
-Yeah, I wanna keep that.
-Yeah, fight for that. Yeah, absolutely.
Do you think like Mike
would be fending for you?
-Or how do you feel?
-Yeah, I think for sure. Yeah.
I felt like I had a really
genuine spark with Carissa,
and I had a conversation with her
after the date with Madi.
She was almost, like,
shutting down our friendship
in addition to the spark, too.
It felt petty.
It didn't feel very genuine.
I think I'm leaning towards
putting Carissa down,
and I'm sorry, Mike. I'm sorry.
[dramatic music playing]
♪♪
Could this be the end? ♪
The people least likely
to find love here are
Could this be the end? ♪
♪♪
Oh, I'm like shaking.
The person that I don't think
is gonna find love here is Rachael.
The reason I'm voting for Hakeem
is he hasn't found
a deep enough connection
to stay.
If I have to send someone home,
I think, I think it must be Carissa.
My own personal experience with her
didn't feel totally genuine.
Krash
Katya.
and Mike.
♪♪
-[birds chirping]
-[ocean waves crashing]
Come with me, I'll lead the way ♪
[Kaitlyn] It is time for
the very first virgin sacrifice.
They face some very tough decisions,
and there's simply nothing harder.
Well, there is,
but it doesn't seem appropriate
to mention that at this dramatic time.
Wildest fires ♪
[Krash exhales sharply]
Come with me, I'll lead the way ♪
Welcome to your first virgin sacrifice.
[exhales sharply]
[crickets chirping]
I can feel the tension.
How's everyone feeling?
Worried.
Definitely was a tough decision.
[tense, suspenseful music playing]
Well, the time has come
to reveal who is getting sacrificed.
♪♪
Three of you will be going home.
[dramatic sting]
[Kaitlyn] You all named one person
you think should be leaving.
We've heard what you all had to say.
Let's start with the men.
The women have voted.
The two men with the most votes
and who will be going home are
Krash
and Hakeem.
[dramatic music playing]
I'm so sorry.
You have been sacrificed.
♪♪
[Krash and Noah chuckling]
Unfortunately, I think Krash and Hakeem
did not have a connection.
I think they're both great men,
but it's not about
finding great friendships,
it's about finding great love.
♪♪
Before we say goodbye
to Krash and Hakeem,
the men have voiced their opinions
on which woman should go home.
And it's between
Katya
[tense, suspenseful music playing]
and
Carissa.
♪♪
♪♪
However, we have a massive
problem on our hands.
[dramatic music playing]
We have a tie.
[dramatic music continues]
This sucks. I don't understand
who would've voted for me.
I literally have a connection here.
I mean, it's so shocking
that it might be cut short.
As we set into the great unknown ♪
[Katya] What the fuck?
Me right now being on the chopping block
to go home, with Carissa in a tie,
when I have a connection?
I really thought I was safe.
♪♪
[Colton] Next time,
on Are You My First?
Guys, time to man up.
You need to come to a decision right now.
[Colton] the tie is broken
[dramatic music playing]
-[Ty] Is there a girl?
-[Madi] Someone coming.
[Colton] and a pair of
new virgins rock the island.
You try to fuck anyone here yet?
-[Noah laughs]
-I'm a-- I'm an insecure little girly.
[new contestant] I'm gonna snatch you.
[Andrew] Have fun, Noah.
[Godwin clapping]
[Madi screaming]
["You'Re The Baddest" by Andrea
Christina Obeid and Chris Dececio playing]
Ooh ♪
You're the baddest, no doubt,
you're the baddest ♪
The baddest ♪
D-S-B like duck duck goose ♪
One, two, three, four, pick and choose ♪
You got angles, you got angles ♪
You so bad you make the rules ♪
You're the baddest ♪
You're the baddest around,
you're the baddest ♪
The baddest ♪
You're the baddest ♪
You're the baddest around,
you're the baddest ♪
You're the baddest ♪
Oof, look at you lookin' oh so fine ♪
Pull up to the crib
bustin' out that wine ♪
Lookin' in the mirror 'cause you know
you don't look regular ♪
Phone blowin' up,
ring, ring, I'm a sailor ♪
You're the baddest ♪
You're the baddest around,
you're the baddest ♪
-You're the baddest around ♪
-You're the baddest ♪
Let me hear you scream and shout
you're the baddest ♪
You're the baddest ♪
You're the baddest ♪
You're the baddest around ♪
You're the baddest ♪
[song ends]
[trilling]