The One That Got Away (2022) s01e06 Episode Script

1
♪♪
Honey. Hi.
What happened?
[Allyssa]
I stepped through the portal,
I see some dude
I don't even recognize him,
his hair is like gray.
And I was like,
"Who are you?
How do I know you?"
[Daniel] I actually follow you
on Instagram.
You follow me on Instagram?
It's been a hard week.
I'm running out of hope.
I'm going to need you to go
back to where you came from.
-Okay.
-Right now.
This is a waste of time.
[Producer]: Do you know his name?
I think his name was Paul.
-I'm Daniel
-Craig.
-I'm Daniel.
-Chris.
I'm Daniel.
-Steve.
-I'm Daniel.
Something very basic.
He's like, literally gone.
Oh, he's he went back
to where he came from.
-He went back to Instagram.
-Woah.
You know, my hopes
were really high.
And I just feel
like it's just hopeless.
I know you've had some bad luck,
and I'm really sorry.
♪♪
There is another man waiting to
come through the portal for you.
I'm confident.
Like, Betty, I'm over
the portal. I don't know.
Will you trust me?
Can we try this one more time?
[Allyssa] I'm over this portal,
I'm over this whole experience.
My feet hurt.
I'm tired.
I want to just kind of
forget this night ever happened.
But I still walk because
some small part of me
is still hoping that
somebody is here for me,
and somebody that I could
have a connection with.
So I think that the next person
that walks in,
if they don't
give me butterflies,
then I might as well
just go home
because it's a
waste of time here.
Oh, my God.
-Hey.
-Hey.
Adam is a friend of families,
but we did also go
to the same high school.
I always thought
he was really attractive.
I never thought that
he ever noticed me.
-[Adam] You look amazing.
-[Allyssa] Thank you.
Oh my God, you look so good.
Oh my gosh. The last time I saw
you was ten years ago,
in high school.
Oh my God,
you remembered me?
[Allyssa] His dad wanted
to set his brother up
with my big sister and like,
nobody was trying
to set him up with me.
I never would have expected him
to do something like this.
At that time,
I was so locked in
on pursuing
professional basketball
that I didn't make any
time for anything else,
and I ended up
closing a lot of doors
and I missed out
on a lot of connections.
And that's why
I'm so grateful tonight
to kind of have a chance
to revisit that connection
and hopefully
open up that closed door.
[Adam] With Allyssa, I'm most
attracted to
this almost unspoken
knowledge that she has.
There's something about her,
and it seems to be
something marvelous.
Oh my God, I'm shocked.
I always wanted
to get to know you.
-Thanks, come here.
-Oh my gosh.
[Allyssa] Let's go inside
and meet the others.
[Adam] Yeah.
-[Allyssa] We're walking through time.
-[Adam] Yeah.
♪♪
[Ashley] Kyle said all the right things,
but every time I asked him
a question,
he was trying to figure out
the best answer that
he thought I would like,
but then portal gave me Taylor
and he gives me butterflies.
He can naturally, like,
let his guard down with me,
and I feel like we are really
like, growing a connection.
♪♪
-[Betty Who] Hi, honey.
-[Ashley] Hey!
-[Ashley] Come on in, how are you?
-[Betty Who] You look gorg.
[Ashley] Thank you, you do too.
Oh man. I have so many questions.
[Betty Who]
How was the party last night?
[Ashley]
It was an absolute train wreck.
I had to take Kyle back
to the portal last night,
and that really upset
the other people in the house.
But I will say,
Taylor like, defended me.
[Ashley] I was trying to
nicely escort him out,
and he turned it down.
[Taylor] Let's calm down.
He did turn her down.
And just like the fact
that he was willing
to kind of put his
friendships
on the line to
defend me, like
He's like,
"Whoa, whoa, whoa, hold up.
That's my girl."
You're like
[Allyssa] Yeah, I'm very excited
to see him again.
Well
Ashley, are you ready
for a change?
Yes.
I'm nervous now, but yes.
When you're ready,
I want you to meet me
at the portal.
-Okay.
-Okay?
-All right.
-All right.
Oh my goodness.
[Ashley] I'm definitely worried
about who's going
to come through the
portal this time.
Because I really like Taylor,
it's hard to even picture
someone better than Taylor
because he's been nothing
but great to me,
like very kind
hearted and genuine.
So I am scared
I'm going to have to make
some hard decisions
in the future.
Wait a second, portal,
you're giving me
an ex-boyfriend?
Like, don't you know,
I tried this before?
I never expected this
to actually happen.
This is the first
ex-boyfriend here.
He's the guy
I told everyone about.
I expected more encounters
of people
who didn't have
a chance with me.
You never know what the
portal is going to do.
-How are you?
-Good to see you.
Oh, my God.
I met Quinn when I was a kid.
He kind of popped back into
my life when I moved back
to my hometown.
We dated for about six months.
I had to break up with him
because Quinn's 27
and still living
with his parents.
It's not the fact
that he has to live at home.
He chooses to live at home.
I know we've dated in the past
and you know, the last time
I saw you was at one of my races.
It just got me thinking,
you know, like how much
I valued your love
and your support.
I don't I don't want you
to be the one that got away.
I love you.
And that's why I'm here.
I do feel like the portal
is kind of screwing with me
a little bit and I'm like,
just so thrown off with Quinn.
[Ashley] So, do you want
to come to my room?
We could just like chat
for a little bit.
I can tell you a little bit
about what's going on.
[Quinn] Yeah. Let's do it.
I came here to reconnect with
Ashley because when we broke up,
I don't think we were both
on the same page
with where we wanted
to go in life.
And you know, now
circumstances have changed
and I'm excited to hopefully see
if that will spark something.
[Quinn] This place is crazy.
He came in and
confessed his love for me,
and it hit me how much
he cares about me.
I realize that
he now is going to
go stay in a house
with Taylor, who I also now
care a lot about, and I really
wanted Quinn to hear it from me.
So I really felt
the need to be honest with him
because I feel like
I have to protect his heart.
-You okay?
-Yeah.
It's just a little
nervous still, shaken up.
[Ashley] Yeah.
There's like,
there is another guy here
that I actually do like.
Okay.
[Ashley] You know what I mean? Like, I'm
still going into this with an open mind,
but given our history like,
I don't want you to have
to hear that from someone else.
This is a wild
like, experiment.
[Quinn] Yeah, this is different.
And, you know, I don't
want to make a bad decision.
Like, you're going
to meet Taylor.
He's a good guy,
and he reminds me of you,
like because he seems
like a really good guy.
[Quinn] Yeah. I mean, I could care
less about anybody else. So
It's definitely a little
bit of a tough pill to swallow.
[Quinn] I just don't want you to like,
hate me if it doesn't go
your way.
[Quinn] Yeah.
I mean, you do know me
and, you know
I'd do anything for you,
-and I just would ask
-No, I agree.
that you would
look inside yourself and
give me another real shot.
[Ashley] This is a very weird situation.
Quinn and I dated already,
but I wouldn't immediately
say there's another chance,
but I am going to say that
I definitely am open to it.
-I'll send you on your way.
-All right.
-Good night.
-Good night.
[Quinn] Hopefully, I'll see you soon.
-[Ashley] Yeah.
-[Quinn] All right. Night.
[Ashley] Bye.
♪♪
[Kasey] Vinny and I were neighbors,
so that's how we met.
And one day when we finally did
have solid plans to hang out,
I had a last minute
work thing come up.
And the way he responded,
it just seemed like he wasn't
supportive of my career
and he didn't really follow up
with another day to hang out.
So I kind of just like,
let it die.
I personally am just a little
bit confused as to why he's here
and if he's actually
truly interested in me.
Going on a date with your
neighbor could be super awkward,
or it could be super good
and convenient.
So, we'll see where
it goes tonight.
♪♪
-[Vinny] Sit?
-[Kasey] Yeah.
[Vinny] For me, it's been two years
in the making to go on this date
with Kasey
and finally able to do it,
you know, like when you're a kid
and you save up your money
to buy something,
then you finally get it.
It's like the best thing ever.
[Kasey] So why me?
Why did you come here?
Like, I'm just so curious.
I'm here because
I want you to get to know me.
I want to know what I do.
I want to know more about you.
I want to know
what makes you smile.
-I want to get to know you.
-Okay.
I want to show you
like, what I do more
to give you a better
idea of how
-Oh, how fun.
-how I help restaurants.
-You like cheese?
-I love cheese.
Oh, then you're in for a treat.
[Vinny] I needed to get away
from that fireplace.
I was starting to
break a sweat.
I'm really excited to do
a cheese tasting with Kasey
because she doesn't
know me that well.
I wanted to show her a good time
and let her know part of me.
I work with many
Italian restaurants
and my favorite thing to do
is dealing with all
the imported goods.
Here is our board, so we're
going to start with the best.
I like to refer
to it as a family.
-Mm-hmm.
-This is the best one.
-The most expensive.
-Can I use my fingers?
Or do we need a fork?
-Okay.
-Bang, bang.
-All right.
-Bang. Bang. Bang, bang, bang.
Okay.
Yum!
Now, a true Reggiano is going
to say d.o.p on it,
d.o.p. translated, it's
roughly it's designation
origin protected.
So it's coming from
the same region, the same area.
[sighs]
You ever go
into a supermarket
and you see Parmesan,
P-A-R-M-E-S-A-N. And it's like
Milk is both whole milk
and parts.
So when you make cheese,
you get it from curd.
-Yeah.
-It's all clumpy.
That's two months.
Oh.
-That's like
-I like to microwave my food.
-So yeah
-Yeah, no.
Two months is fast.
He actually cuts me off
every single time
I try to say something else
besides cheese.
I have gorgonzola, burrata.
-I love burrata.
-Burrata is the best.
Burrata. Do you
know how burrata is made?
You know what burrata is?
He's like burrata. Pecorino Romano,
do you know what I'm saying?
[Vinny] This is actually
the best on a cracker.
[Kasey] Tell me if I'm doing it right.
[Vinny] You just got a baish!
Baish, baish, get in there.
[Kasey] Oh my God.
And he was like
-Baish, and then that's it.
-Oh my God.
-Bajoom, bajoom!
-Baish, baish!
[laughing]
[Vinny] Baish, baish!
Do I feel like Kasey's
feeling me?
Yeah, I think she is feeling me.
When I first came
through the portal,
she was so excited, so shocked.
So I think I'm
in a good position.
-Cheers.
-Are you enjoying so far?
Yeah, I'm like, I'm so happy
because of the cheese. So
Okay.
The awkwardest date
I've ever had.
I have a parting gift for you.
-Oh?
-Yes.
What do you mean?
Oh my God.
-Wow.
-This is a wheel of asiago.
Oh my God.
What is this like ten pounds?
This is probably
about 20 pounds.
-Okay.
-22 pounds.
And you just thought I was
strong enough to carry it.
[Kasey] Okay, I give up.
Can you carry it now?
-[Vinny] Yeah.
-[Kasey] Thank you.
And the date
went a little stinky.
♪♪
[Alicia] Would you rather never
be able to shower again?
Or are you had
to crawl everywhere you go?
[laughing]
[Yurika] Oh oh gosh.
-[Anthony] I think I'm crawling.
-[Micah] My I would crawl.
[Yurika] Crawling, yeah.
[Micah] My knees would be busted,
but I would crawl.
[footsteps]
[Alicia]
So, when someone is walking up
the steps in the house,
we all get anxious
because that means other
people are coming in.
And somebody is about
to go home,
but we just don't know who.
[Dylan] Uh-oh.
-[Adam] Hey, everybody.
-[All] Hello.
What's up, what's up?
How's it going?
[Anthony] We got a new friend.
I'm Adam.
You can call me Dregs.
-What's up? Nice to meet you.
-What's going, bro?
-[Travis] Oh, I know this guy.
-[Yurika] Really?
[Taylor] Nice to meet you, man.
-I remember you, man.
-What's up, dude?
[Yurika] Wait, how do you guys
know each other?
We went to
high school together.
-No way.
-Yeah.
Man, in walks in this guy.
Go sit down.
Just sit down,
just have a seat.
So I mean, I already know
you're here for Allyssa.
-You know, I am, too.
-Right on, right on.
[Alicia] Okay.
[Anthony] Did she seem excited
to see you?
Yeah, yeah.
I mean, if I'm judging it,
like, then yeah.
I feel like Adam
has some ground to cover
before he gets to send me home.
But you know,
it's Allyssa's decision,
but him being here,
that changes the game.
What was your impression
of Allyssa back in high school?
To me, it was forbidden.
I legitimately thought that
if I did anything
besides basketball,
that I was just
not going to make it.
[Dylan] Hello.
-What's up, what's up.
-How's it going?
Hi.
I'm Dylan,
nice to meet you?
Quinn, nice to meet you.
-Alicia.
-Hello, Quinn.
-Taylor, man. Nice to meet you.
-Nice to meet you.
Obviously, in
the back of my mind
I'm a little concerned
about Ashley and Taylor,
but I'm in it to win it.
-[Dylan] Who'd you came for?
-Ashley.
She was super happy.
[Anthony] How do you know her?
[Quinn] We actually dated, so
-[All] Oh!
-[Yurika] For how long?
[Quinn] Probably not quite a year,
like eight, nine months.
[Yurika] That's a long time, though.
[Anthony] In gay years,
that's a lifetime, so
What did you say to her
when you came through?
-Told her I loved her still so
-[All] Whoa.
But yeah, that was
[Taylor]
I honestly, I don't understand
the relationship
with Quinn and Ashley.
He's definitely more
reserved and quiet
and more shy,
and I can see that.
And Ashley told me
that they are not how we were,
they don't click like we did.
And if I'm going to be honest,
I'm not too worried.
I mean,
exes are exes for a reason.
[Travis] This is the first time
with a full house.
[Dylan] And that means that everyone's
got their own competition here.
But it just is reminding us to
shoot our shot,
don't hold anything back,
and really just go for it.
[Anthony] I feel like we've been like
kind of sitting pretty
not having the house full,
but like,
this is already
a tense place and
having more people is going
to make it even more tense.
So
[Travis] I've been chilling
for a while, you know,
without like, too much of
a threat of being sent home.
[Anthony] Not anymore.
[laughing]
[Anthony] A bit of advice from someone
who's been here for so long.
I'm kidding.
But like shoot
your shot, because
you never know
when you're like,
you're going to be out of here.
[Micah] Anthony, just start
packing your bags already.
[Anthony]
Too bad. I ain't going nowhere, bitch.
♪♪
[Vinny] So what you guys think
about Quinn?
[Anthony] It seems like
it's just interesting
seeing like the difference
between Quinn and Taylor.
[Isabel] I feel like he's so much more
reserved and so much more shy.
Quinn is definitely
an introvert.
They're very different.
Yeah.
-Complete polar opposites.
-Uh-oh.
-[Anthony] Uh-oh.
-[Travis] What's up, Jeff?
-Jeffrey.
-[Isabel] Hi!
[Anthony] Jeff walks in my heart,
literally just busts open.
I was like, oh my God,
I have to play it cool for Jeff,
to like, let him know
that I mean business.
But bitch, I was juiced.
Ah!
-Hi.
-Tie-dye fantasy.
-[Isabel] Good to see you.
-[Jeff] Nice to see you.
-I love the outfit,
-Thank you.
-You smell like sunscreen.
-In this house
[Jeff] As I'm watching
certain relationships grow
and people are talking
so highly about the people
they're going on dates with.
I have Micah,
I have Anthony.
But why am I not
feeling like this?
And I feel like it's time
to switch something up.
I just need to follow my
gut at this point.
Well, Micah and Anthony,
I feel like
I wanted to invite you guys both
to come out with me tonight,
so I figure get changed
and meet me at the barn tonight.
-Okay.
-Lovely.
[Jeff] All right. Well, I will see you
guys in a little bit.
All right, see you soon.
Guys, thanks for having me.
-Nice to meet you.
-Cheers.
[Vinny] It's like a triple date.
[Vinny] Hey, how would
you describe that?
[Anthony] Are you kidding me?
I am so angry because
I've spent so much time here
waiting and waiting and
waiting and waiting
and waiting for an opportunity
to get a second date with Jeff.
What the fuck?
And now I have to get more
intimate getting to know you
while someone else is also
trying to do the same thing?
I'm just gonna say you should
pack your bags before you go.
Oh!
Sharing is caring, but not here.
[Vinny] This is Clash of the Titans.
♪♪
[Ashley] Going into the date,
I really want to grow
a new connection with Quinn.
It's going to be hard to kind
of like, relight that fire
that was put out,
but the one change
that's going to be key
to my heart for Quinn
is the fact that he needs
to move out and grow up.
♪♪
[Quinn] Definitely really excited
to go on a date with Ashley.
I think there's just a couple
small things
that we need to get past,
and all I can ask for is
that she gives me
a legitimate chance.
[Quinn] Is there wine out there?
[Ashley] I don't know, but like
this looks like a, you know, winery.
[Quinn] Yeah.
-Wow.
-Wow.
[Quinn] This is a great.
Look at the pickles.
[Ashley] Oh, and the little
wildflowers, so pretty.
And beer.
My favorite.
Yeah, it wouldn't be
a picnic without that.
Wow.
-How are you?
-I'm good, how are you.
You just got here last night, like
Thought it'd be
a good chance to come back
and try to rekindle
that spark used to have and
I don't think there's
too many puzzle pieces
out of place
with our relationship.
I mean, like the problems
that I had like
the problems don't
go away with time.
[Ashley] What makes you think that
it'll be different this time?
Well, because I'm ready
to take the steps
that need to be taken and
do the hard decisions, and
Move out from home?
[Quinn] I kind of have like
the little devil angel situation
right now
where I'm just like,
well, he says he's
going to make all this change
and he really wants you
to help him.
But I'm also like
But you already vocalized
the change you want,
and he hasn't done it yet.
You know, you're 27.
You know, I think like,
it's time to fly the coop.
Yeah, I mean, that's
that's what I want to do.
And that's my goal.
Like, what's your game plan?
Well, my game plan is
to figure it out and solve it.
I mean, it's not something
I can do right now today,
like I got to get back home and
take it from there, you know.
Like, what are
you looking forward to
in the future with us then?
Like, it's really hard
to not hang out with you
and want to talk
to you all the time.
And like, it's just
it's tough being
doing the friend role
and everything.
[Quinn]
And basically, in a nutshell,
I just want to hopefully try
to move on
and grow with you, basically.
[Quinn] Do anything for you.
[Ashley] I know.
[Quinn] Feels awesome, I feel
almost like a sense of relief
after getting to talk to her,
and I'd definitely like to prove
to Ashley that
she's a priority in my life
and I think
I can definitely see myself,
you know, marrying Ashley
and having a future with her.
[Quinn] Come here.
♪♪
[Ashley] After our date,
I really feel like
I need more time with Quinn.
I'm very torn
because I have another man
in the house who I am
starting to grow feelings for,
but I know Quinn and I know
that he is a wonderful guy,
so I'm really
like, split right now.
♪♪
[Jeff] I came into this journey
with like zero expectations,
but by surrounding
myself around people
who are thriving
in this journey,
it makes you want to experience
what they're experiencing.
And I think the thing
with Anthony and Micah,
you have two great people who
you want to feel something for.
They have all these
great qualities about them.
But that brought me
to this dark place
that was kind of like,
what is wrong with me?
Like, why can I not get
there with these people?
And so I think I really am
pushing myself to explore more
and find my right person
from the portal
that I don't know
if it's here yet.
[Micah] Going into tonight,
I'm a little nervous.
I am actually interested
in like,
not just here to like, play
games like, this is like real.
Worst case scenario,
Anthony goes home and
I lose a friend in Anthony.
Best case scenario,
Anthony goes home
and I am still with Jeff.
[Jeff] How are you?
[Micah] Well.
[Jeff] Oh my God.
[Micah] Outside of the waiting.
-I know, I'm sorry.
-You're fine.
[Jeff] I mean, obviously, you know
Anthony from New York, right?
Like he's obviously
supported your shows.
-Yes.
-We've seen each other.
We run in a similar circle,
if you will, and I think to like
have to like, look at both
of you and say, like
Who's more deserving, right?
Or who has showed more,
it's tough to like, compare
the two situations,
and I think, where do you see
like, you and I going from here?
[Micah] And there's, I think,
enough of a spark
that we could
it could work.
[Jeff] I feel like with the amount of
time we have
and the way I'm going,
the way I'm feeling,
it's tough for me to like,
look at somebody who
I appreciate so much,
but I don't know if you and
I will ever get to a point
that we can look at each
other and say, like,
-you're the one for me.
-Yeah.
And I think for that reason,
I need to say goodbye
to you tonight.
Got it.
-I'm sorry.
-You're fine.
What I want most
for you is for you to be
true to yourself and
true to who you are and like,
I want to see you thrive
and be the best you can be.
You know, I'll still be there
for you in New York,
1000%, you know?
[Jeff] Micah is a beautiful person,
so to say goodbye,
it's kind of difficult for me.
-Thank you.
-Thanks for having me.
-You know I love you
-Always.
All of a sudden,
it's like the rug is
kind of pulled
out from under you
and you fall on
your ass, and
I feel a little played,
like, it hurts a little bit.
Onto bigger
and better, and by bigger,
I mean taller.
Kidding, kind of.
♪♪
[Anthony] I came here because I want to
make a connection with Jeff.
You know, I have to make sure
that my intentions are pure,
that I am leading with love
and that my feelings are clear
and that he gets that.
And I'm going to bring it
'cause I'm a badass bitch.
I'm going to bring,
I'm a badass bitch.
I'm going to bring it
I'm going to bring,
because I'm a badass bitch.
My new hit single.
♪♪
Child.
I can only predict so much
that's going to happen.
I am doing my best
to stay true to who Anthony is
because this is what you get.
Either you want it or you don't.
Hopefully, you want it.
But yeah, it's a
little nerve wracking.
[Anthony] I haven't seen Micah yet.
But in the end,
it doesn't come down to Micah.
It's me and Jeff.
And if Jeff isn't feeling
that I wish Jeff the best.
I just hope even more
that I'm the one thing
that makes him happy.
It's
it's a stressful situation.
[Jeff] When I saw you like, walk
through the portal,
I'll be honest with you,
-I never looked at you in that way.
-Sure.
[Jeff] And then after our first date,
I was like,
"Damn, like, this kid
has gone through a lot."
And I saw so many
good qualities in you.
And like, it's tough to
go through this situation
and like, look at you
and say, like,
are we compatible?
[Anthony] While I don't know who
romantic Jeff is that much,
all I want
is to figure that out.
And it feels so weird
to say that
because I don't let myself
feel for anyone,
and especially after one date,
like the fact that all I was
thinking about was like,
I just want to see him, I want
to see him, I want to see him,
makes me know that like,
I'm willing to, like,
make something happen
after this.
I don't know that
we'll ever know until we try.
[Jeff] You are the most like,
beautiful person
I've probably met on this
whole experience thus far.
And I'm like, looking
at myself like
what's wrong with me
that you told me everything
I could have ever
asked for, but like,
I'm not there?
At the end of the day, like,
you're not the person for me.
And unfortunately,
I have to send you back
to the portal tonight.
♪♪
-Okay.
-I'm sorry.
Don't be sorry.
We both came here
for a reason.
And
when it comes down to it,
I want you to be as happy
as you possibly can.
I just hope that you find
someone that that will do
and be whatever I know that
I could have been
and done for you.
And I just
While this sucks,
I wish you the best.
I'm finding my night to be
a little more difficult
than I was expecting.
Once I go back to New York,
Anthony and Micah,
they're not not
in my life, right?
But I have to follow my heart.
It just sucks.
I appreciate you
though, so much.
[Jeff]
This is so hard to say bye to you.
So, on today's episode of
Anthony Spills the Tea,
I guess we can say that
the show is getting canceled
because I am going home.
And it fucking sucks.
I am still a bad bitch,
but bad bitches can be sad,
and bad bitches can be hurt.
[Jeff] You okay?
[Anthony] Mm-hmm.
And
I just
Thank you.
Um
It's hard to do this,
and I understand that.
I just wish you the best.
-Good luck.
-I appreciate you. Thank you.
No worries.
I just can't wait
to find my person.
I'm still fucking riding
for that rocking chair
on the porch, eating our frickin'
applesauce and oatmeal
because we have no teeth and
our dentures are too expensive.
I'm hoping for that and
that's gonna happen for me.
And if that's not aligning
with what you have, Jeff,
then your loss.
♪♪
[Allyssa] I'm excited for my date
with Adam,
and I'm excited
to get to see
the man that he's become.
[Allyssa]
I think that Adam is someone
that I always
really wondered about.
And I think Adam
is the type of person
I could potentially
see myself with.
You know, it's honestly
an indescribable feeling
that somebody was looking
at me in a way
that I couldn't even come close
to looking at myself.
I definitely had a crush
on Allyssa back then.
I just never thought it would
become anything tangible.
And now I have the chance
and I'm ready to find out
what's behind that door.
Hopefully,
it takes me somewhere beautiful.
-[Adam] Oh, wow.
-[Allyssa] Welcome to prom?
-[Allyssa] 2014?
-[Adam] Welcome to prom.
-Oh!
-Amazing.
[Allyssa]
Took me to my first prom.
I didn't get to go to prom.
So this feels like
an opportunity
that we get to actually go
back in time and redo.
So prom 101, we got to have
our accessories.
[Allyssa] Okay.
It's beautiful.
I'm very, very afraid
of this boutonniere.
There's a there's a pin.
Aim for the heart.
[shriek]
[Adam] Are you all right?
No, I'm not bleeding,
I'm okay. I'm okay.
Okay.
♪♪
[Allyssa] Oh my God.
Are these our photos already?
[Adam] Look at us.
Being able to be the one
to put the corsage on her
and truly give her
that prom experience
made everything feel
special to me.
[Adam] We get the chance
to have a proper prom.
I love this prom.
This is my favorite prom.
-This is your favorite?
-Yes.
I'm honored to be
your prom date.
[Adam] She allowed me the
chance to get to know her
as an individual,
and that means everything to me
because now I have a moment
that I'll never forget.
This is one of those
special moments in my life
where this is an opportunity
that I've had to finally
get closer to that person
I've always wanted to know.
I've admired you
from afar for so long,
and I always thought that you
were amazing and out of reach.
I thought you were
out of reach.
For me, it was all about
trying to play basketball
and make everyone else around me
proud and see who I am
as what they wanted me to be.
And I think I was just
in my own world.
And now looking back
While I don't fully regret
my decision to pursue my dream,
I think I missed out on so much
and now I'm ready to let
other people into my world.
This is what I came for,
that connection.
This is definitely
what I came here for.
[Allyssa] Me too. Me too.
-Well, cheers to that.
-Cheers for sharing.
Feels like ♪
[gasps]
I'm standing in
a timeless mist ♪
[Allyssa]
Oh my God! Betty!
Of light mist ♪
Of pale amber rose ♪
Most of what
I put on my manifestation list,
he immediately is
checking the boxes.
Touching ♪
Discovering you ♪
I love you
always forever ♪
[Adam] Dancing with Allyssa is
such a magical moment to me.
I think this is something
that I've been waiting for.
And it just felt natural to me.
[Adam] How do you think your
prom is going so far?
[Allyssa] I'm loving this.
This is the best prom
I've ever been to.
[Adam] Me too.
[Allyssa]
Should we do like a spin?
[Adam] Oh yeah, got to spin
you one time.
[Adam] Oh yeah, maybe
maybe another. Two spins.
[Allyssa] Yeah, I'm not
mad at it.
[Adam] I'm loving this.
[Allyssa] Me too.
As we lay there ♪
[Adam] I'm over the moon
right now, and Adam,
he keeps telling me how he's
admired me this whole time,
and that's all
I ever really wanted was
somebody who saw me when
I thought I was invisible.
Magical time ♪
This night could not
have gone any better,
I would say this is the best
night of my life so far.
We'll
we'll wait for the wedding,
but right now
it's definitely number one.
You think we're going
to keep this?
Near and far,
close and together ♪
-You got no choice
-Yeah, no choice.
Everything I will do for you ♪
♪♪
[sniffles]
Hi, honey.
-Hi.
-Oh my God.
Hi.
Oh my God, Betty.
Honey
Hi, how are you doing?
Are you okay?
[Jeff] Dude, this sucks.
What happened?
It's like, so difficult to like
watch like, two amazing guys,
and I have to look
at both of them and say, like,
as great as you are, like,
I don't see a future with you.
[Jeff] You know what I mean?
And so I feel like
I'm sitting here like,
what the fuck is wrong with me
that like, I can't
get to this point?
It's like,
what am I doing here?
You know, like,
it's so difficult.
Honestly, I just need a minute.
Hold on.
[sobs]
[Betty Who]
Honey, oh, honey.
[Betty Who]
Oh, honey.
[Jeff] Oh.
This sucks, dude.
[Betty Who]
Oh my God, I'm so sorry.
[Jeff] It's like, every single
person that comes in here
feels like, it's like
a fail.
You know what I mean,
like, it's like,
what is wrong with me
that every time I try,
it does not happen for me,
like, every single time?
And that's like here,
that's in New York.
There's this wall
that like, I can't get past.
I think what you're supposed
to do is keep trying, right?
I mean, I guess
that's what they say, but
[Betty Who] You did something
so hard today, seriously.
And I know it's hard and I can't
imagine how you feel, like
You had two guys
and now you have none.
All of you must remember
the clock is ticking.
You did not think that
you came all this way
to send some boys home
and have nobody waiting
for you, did you?
I can't do this right now.
Do you need a second?
You don't have to.
I think we definitely
need a moment.
You can take a moment.
You're opening the portal
right now.
Jeff is fucked.
Oh.
I want you to take a couple
of minutes, collect yourself.
I will be right here
waiting for you.
Okay. I appreciate it.
-I love you.
-I love you.
[Betty Who]
My beautiful tiny friends.
[Jeff] Not all of us can be
6'2," bitch. Okay, I get it.
I feel like this experience has
been very eye-opening to me
as to how much I need
to figure out for myself
and that it's difficult
to just be open.
And I think that's something
I'm trying to work on.
I hope this process will put
me in the right direction,
but like, it's so hard.
♪♪
Shut up right now.
[Jeff]
Alex is one of my best friends.
We met on a dating app.
We were hooking up,
going on dates
like it was super intense
for like three months.
Then I was like, I can't do this.
Like, I was like,
this is like, scary.
Let's just be friends.
[Jeff] Oh my God.
I'm trying not to cry.
I know. I think this is
the longest it's ever been
since I've spoken to you.
[Jeff] Alex and I are so close,
I think my biggest fear is
that if we do cross that line
and it gets too far,
if he doesn't come back,
it's like you're
losing your best friend
because you took a risk
and it failed.
How are you?
This has been a lot.
I got it.
-Oh
-Well
I'm sure you know why I'm here.
Not too surprising, I imagine.
Not not surprising
at the same time.
I know.
You know
I just feel like ever since, you know,
I met you a couple of years ago,
you and I have always kind of
blurred the line between,
you know, friends,
more than friends.
You know, not really knowing.
And, you know,
I think this would be
the perfect time to kind of,
you know, explore those feelings
or kind of explore,
you know what we could be
if we unblurred those lines
and kind of, you know,
built on the foundation
that we already have together.
For a long time,
you know, me and Jeff
have kind of had one side
that's feelings
and one side that is intimacy,
and we've kind of kept
those two separate.
What I want for me
and Jeff is to see
if we can blend
those two together.
We might be in a position
that we can have it all.
[Alex] It's crazy to be here.
-I'll give you the tour.
-Oh, please.
[sighs]
♪♪
[Nigel] I'm definitely looking forward
to spending time with Alicia.
At the pool party, there was
a lot of things going on.
We didn't really have a lot of
time to sit down and talk.
I want to see where
we pick things up at.
[Alicia] I am super excited.
I feel like our first date
kind of took it there
the first step,
so I was starting to feel him.
I'm like, okay,
I can see this.
So brace yourself, Nigel,
because I'm coming in hot.
♪♪
[Nigel] Three years ago,
when I met Alicia,
I would have never thought we
would be at this moment today.
I was a party boy, right?
But now I'm looking
forward to being able
to go through life and grow
through life with someone.
I'm happy you
let me make it this far.
I really appreciate it.
Well, I'm happy
you let me make it this far.
-This was in the plans, right?
-Okay.
I have to bring this up because
it has been bothering me.
So at the pool party,
I did feel a little way.
I felt like you wasn't
really happy to see me.
You like it wasn't giving,
the vibes wasn't there.
Well, I apologize.
I didn't mean it that way.
-Okay.
-But I admire that about you.
Thank you.
Because if something
makes you uncomfortable,
I think it's important for
you to discuss it.
And that's very tough for me, too.
I don't know if I've ever
been in an environment
like that myself, or if
maybe some of the others have
been in that environment, right?
-Like, everyone was edgy anyway.
-Yeah, I accept your apology.
-You accept my apology?
-I do.
Where do we go from here,
now that we have
all of the messes?
Where do we go from here?
[Nigel] You know, what
I'm getting myself into.
Just talk to me.
You, you know.
Talk to me like I know nothing,
okay?
Like, I have no idea.
I think that when we met,
I was still in my dark
like, in my dark space, so that's
probably why I was like,
-you feel like I was mean to you.
-That's why you were mean?
Yeah, I wasn't happy
with myself,
like my
my boyfriend at the time
was the first person
I actually like, loved.
And once we broke up,
I realized
I depended on him
too much for like, love.
I depended on him to, like,
tell me I'm beautiful,
to do those things.
And once we broke up,
I just felt empty.
I realized that I'd never
loved myself.
-Right.
-If you could tell like,
how dark I was, then
[sobs]
it just like, really made me
pull myself up
because I really was like
-You're strong.
-Yeah.
You're strong.
-You're special
-Thank you.
I know this isn't easy.
And thank you for opening
it up to me and just like
Thank you
for letting me feel safe.
It was the popcorn.
I feel like when you do connect
with people, you're transparent,
you are vulnerable, so him
asking me personal questions,
I was like, all right,
I can sprinkle a little bit of,
you know, whatever
I'ma tell you on you.
How can I potentially
fit into your life?
We working towards it now.
-Yeah?
-Yeah.
Obviously, I feel safe with you
enough to say that because
it's hard for me
to open up sometimes.
So, time for you
to be vulnerable.
I'm more than open.
What do you want to know?
Who is Nigel?
Who are you?
I'm a mama's boy.
To the core, is
a true mama's boy.
I've just I've been blessed enough
to have some of the most
amazing people in my life.
That's been the hardest part
about dating, right?
When you have amazing people
in your life
and great people just like,
keep coming into your life
and coming into your life
it's like, at what point do you
figuratively shut the portal?
-Yeah, ooh!
-Right?
You know what I mean, it's just
like, when do you know
what's for you?
When do I feel
the most like myself?
I appreciate you
for opening up with me.
Like, that's not
easy for anyone to do.
It is not.
I just think this was like
a really special moment.
I know, I had such a good time.
You know, I don't know.
I don't know what I did
to deserve
this moment with you, but
Like, I don't know. So
I want to see where it goes.
I'm open to seeing
where it goes.
It's safe to say my feelings
for Alicia are really growing.
Come on, let's get out of here.
It's getting late.
She's almost like,
you know, giving me her heart
on a silver platter
and saying, I trust you.
And I think that's the type
of memory that lasts a lifetime.
♪♪
[chattering]
[shouting]
-Oh, man.
-How was your date?
-[Travis] Looking good, looking happy.
-[Yurika] You're glowing.
[Travis] That's the biggest smile
I done seen on you all day.
[Vinny] How'd it go?
My date was great.
You know, I cried a little bit,
got a little vulnerable
and we looked at the moonlight.
We kissed a few times, you know?
But overall,
I had a great time.
-It was awesome.
-[Dylan] That's awesome.
-[Yurika] Romantic, wow.
-Yeah, it was super romantic.
[Travis] You're here glowing
like this.
[Yurika] I know, you look so happy.
Yeah. Where's Anthony?
And where the fuck
[Vinny] They're not back yet.
They haven't come back yet.
[Vinny] We don't know.
You're all like, I know I'm trying to
talk about my date,
but where the fucking
is Anthony?
We just been up here
sipping, tipping, and tripping.
[Dylan] Yeah.
-[Dylan] Oh, hello.
-[Alex] Hey.
[Travis] What's up, sir?
-[Alex] What's going on?
-[Travis] How are you doing?
I'm Alex.
I'm here for Jeff.
Nice to meet you guys.
-Hello, Alex.
-How's it going?
-Hi, Alicia. Nice to meet you.
-Hi, nice to meet you.
-[Alex] How's it going?
-[Quinn] How's it going?
[Yurika] Tell me how your
portal experience was.
[Alex] It was cute.
It was fun, you know?
Me and Jeff are like,
really close friends.
[Travis] What happened when
you came through the portal?
It was really good to see him.
He actually told me he sent
a couple of people home.
[Yurika] A couple people?
Like, just one, or two?
-A couple, like two.
-Okay.
-Oh my God.
-Wow.
[Taylor] That's why we're all
[Vinny] We're trying to
figure shit out.
[Taylor] We had two people in the house,
which is Anthony and Micah.
They left a couple of hours ago.
[Alex] Oh, damn.
[Alicia] On a date with Jeff.
It was Yeah.
[Alex] Oh damn, really?
Yeah, we've been waiting
for them to come back.
And then when you came
in, we were kind of like
[sobs]
[Dylan] It's okay.
[Alex] How'd that go?
I actually know Micah.
[Travis] Well apparently
it didn't go that well
because you're here.
So they got sent home,
probably before
-Damn.
-you came through the portal.
Sorry, I'm happy you're here.
But me and Anthony were like,
really close.
[Alex] Yeah.
[Travis]
We definitely are taken aback.
You know, we didn't expect,
you know, for two of our homies
to go home like that.
Anthony
He told me
I was like a brother to him
and he really liked Jeff.
I can't help but wonder if
like, I'ma go out the same way.
I'm really sad, you know,
I don't want you to feel like,
-you know
-Oh, no, not at all.
I'm not going to welcome
you or anything like
Anthony was like my
best friend in the house, so
Didn't even say bye.
Like, bam.
[Taylor] That's never happened
before, like two people have
never left at the exact same
time for the same person.
What the fuck
is going to happen?
♪♪
On the next episode
of "The One That Got Away."
[Jeff] I'm obviously scared
to fully dive in,
but I want to try with Alex.
[Dylan] I'm like, starting to fall
for you, I don't know.
[Kasey] Stop.
[Dylan] I do feel like we're
on the same page
in terms of our feelings.
[Kasey] Maybe.
I can't do this.
We have an arrival.
This is almost going to be
coming to an end
and I'm just standing
there with nothing
but a wig and a dream.
Are you kidding me?
What do you like most about her?
It just resonates with me.
I declare war.
[Taylor] You know more
about Ashley than I do.
Is this how
it's always been or
The way you acted was insane.
I went back to the house.
I talked to Quinn.
It's just a lot.
[Ashley] I have to suck it up
and do what needs to be done.
-[Vinny] Hello.
-[Ashley] I need to speak to Quinn.
[Alex] What?
♪♪