Yaga (2026) s01e06 Episode Script
Mother Witch
1
Catherine Hargrove
made a podcast, with Henry,
about Baba Yaga, and look,
who does that look like to you?
We need to be searching
for this fucking cabin!
I think we should be
chasing the mask in the video.
Oh, yeah.
She's one of mine.
- Who was the buyer?
- Henry Park.
- Have you seen this guy?
- I wasn't here.
My mom was,
but she's off-island today.
He often hires me to cater
his wacko theme parties.
The video was posted
from Sandeson's.
- Was Pam working?
- Yeah.
Shitty guys should be dead.
I think
that Henry killed Logan.
- Have you seen this boy?
- He's in the chicken house.
- Don't let a work crush get in the way.
- Worry about your own love life, okay?
You know, I am going on a date.
You angry about something?
Women?
We're angry about everything.
What the fuck?
What are you doing?
I have a question.
When was the last time
you heard of a mother witch…
a witch with a baby?
Never.
We just get pushed into ovens,
stabbed with swords,
drowned in the sea.
Knock knock.
So, why not pop out
a bun or two,
if only to delay the cross,
the rack,
the stake?
When we make our deal
with the devil,
does she take our uterus?
No, of course not.
But it seems to me,
to us, to witches
that it's safer for you to say
we eat children,
rather than that we have them.
Rapp! Dammit, you're not supposed
to be within a mile of Olena Yaha.
Morning to you, too.
Jesus.
I've been having insane dreams.
Also, I'm now certain that Katherine
was sleeping with Henry,
because somebody delivered the Baba Yaga
podcast to my rental car,
on Henry's phone.
You have Henry's phone?
How did it get into your rental car?
- I don't know.
- Why didn't you tell me about any of this?
Maybe because your boss
benched me,
and I still managed to come up
with more than Whittock PD?
And what were you doing at
Katherine Hargrove's all night?
Investigating. You should try it.
You called me, like, seven times.
Yeah, 'cause I was trying
to communicate with my partner,
who was fucking a suspect
all night.
I'd say foreplay took up
most of our evening.
Do either of you have change?
This doesn't take cards.
- Yeah.
- She's waking up.
I really,
I just wanna take her home,
but they're saying that
they need to run more tests.
It's gonna be fine, Geena.
She's gonna be fine.
Do you mind if I…
I'd really love
to check in with Lily.
Oh, now
you want to talk to her?
- Sorry, I…
- We have nothing to say to you!
- But I just need a…
- Did you hear what she said?
Just leave her alone, yeah?
I can try my best with Geena,
but she might be immune to my charms.
- It's okay.
- Hey, Sarge! Rapp!
He asked to come.
He wanted to "take initiative".
- Great.
- Hi! So, I…
That's a lot of blood.
- It's technically vomit.
- Oh, good!
Yeah, that's…
That's fine.
Okay, so I talked to my cousin, and…
You have to promise not to tell.
Marge could get in a lot of trouble.
Cross our hearts and hope to die.
Right, Carson?
Pinky swear.
Come on, over here.
They said that they don't wanna release
Lily into Geena's custody
until they know
she's safe at home.
- They don't think she's safe with Geena?
- Hold on.
Okay, so, Marge said Lily had clearly been
through some kind of a trauma,
and hallucinogens
were in her system.
And the blood she vomited
was from a chicken.
Oh, good. Fun.
She also threw up
a tooth.
- A tooth?
- Yeah. And, oh…
She was eight weeks pregnant.
But she isn't anymore.
She miscarried?
She's a minor, so they asked her
if she has a boyfriend,
if he maybe…
but Lily just stared
straight ahead, Marge said.
Because she's a minor, they have to send
the fetal tissue to pathology,
but they won't have
results back for a bit.
Marge also said there was something drawn
in chicken blood on Lily's stomach.
She drew a picture for me.
It looks like
the one under Henry's bed.
That's some good
police work, buddy.
- Thanks.
- Yeah.
Eckert needs me back at the station.
The Parks are coming.
- Yeah, go. Thank you.
- Yeah.
So, Lily knows about the symbol
or Geena does
and didn't Geena say that Henry lost
a tooth that night when Pam punched him?
And remember, Angel told us
that one of her little Yaga cult friends
wanted to "manifest a baby,"
and Olena told her to drink
a bunch of chicken blood,
and eat her husband's fingernails, and
then she got, like, magically pregnant?
This could be like
a fertility manifestation thing.
Why would a 14-year-old want to manifest
a baby from a 22-year-old?
A 22-year-old billionaire.
My dad saw this all the time
with Mr. Park. I've seen it with Henry.
Girls wanna get pregnant with Park babies
and then angle for the money.
That's what Dora Park did
back when she was Doreen!
She got him to marry her.
I'm not saying that's what this is,
I'm just saying…
This is a completely insane theory
that hinges on all women being liars.
Okay. Well then, why don't we
just talk to Lily then?
- No, you are not talking to Lily.
- Great, then I don't need to be here.
My job is to find Henry.
He's still fucking missing. Here.
Dad always said,
"Carry change, just in case."
What?
Dr. Hargrove, she was trying
to get coffee earlier.
- I found some change.
- Well, she's left.
Oh, okay. Well, I thought
you might want one?
- Thank you.
- How is she?
Look, Geena,
I know you don't like me,
and I'm so sorry you and Lily
are going through this,
but I want to help her,
I swear to God,
but I can't do that without asking
questions. I wish I could.
I know what it's like
to be young,
and to be manipulated
by someone older,
by systems that…
In high school, I was…
I had an incident.
If something like that
happened to Lily,
I will do everything
in my power to…
Geena, I swear,
I just want the truth.
Is this a test?
What? No.
Do you have any idea what this is
doing to Lily, all this bullshit?
I got the message,
loud and clear,
from your boss
at the diner yesterday.
What message?
You really don't know, do you?
- Hi.
- Hi.
Did you by any chance leave this
in my rental car yesterday?
Or was somebody else
working here?
No.
Would you mind terribly
if I had a peek at the registry?
- No. You obviously can't do that.
- Right. It's just…
This is embarrassing, but I…
I have a, like, a stalker situation.
- A stalker?
- See, I'm a detective.
I'm here from the mainland
for work, and…
this is my name.
And it's just…
It's very perturbing to me
that somebody could track me down and…
and leave this in my rental car.
Well, why do you think
they're stalking you?
Probably because I gave her
her first orgasm.
Click on that third one,
Sandeson.
You gave Geena Sandeson
her first orgasm?
First few, actually.
That's my number.
Maybe… you can try your luck
with me sometime?
Maybe.
Take your time, Lily.
He talked to me about books.
That's how it started.
And then movies, history…
I mean, he was with Pam,
I never…
It's so fucking embarrassing.
He made me feel like…
I dunno, like a grownup,
I guess.
- I'm so dumb.
- No, you're not.
He invited me
to his New Year's party.
He said it would be insane,
and it really was.
The theme was "Floral".
There were fresh flowers
everywhere,
whole rooms and hallways
just filled with them.
I think… somebody maybe
gave me something,
because everything
was so beautiful.
He wanted to show me
something in his room.
It was a chicken.
He said he was keeping it
in his bathtub.
It was supposed to be
for a ceremony, or something.
He said it was…
a secret…
just for us.
After that,
we were on the bed.
And I remember,
there was this thing on the bedpost…
And I remember wondering
if there had ever been
a chicken in the bathroom,
or if I had imagined it, or…
Or maybe I secretly wanted to go up to his
room and I just needed an excuse or…
No, baby.
No.
Logan Casey was there, too.
In the corner.
Watching?
No.
He was just listening, I think…
which is a lot worse, somehow.
I'm so sorry, Lily.
Afterwards,
Henry said I was drunk,
and that I had remembered
it wrong.
He said he showed me
the chicken,
and then I passed out.
He said he tucked me
into his bed
and just let me sleep it off.
Lily, what he did to you…
is not your fault.
You didn't do
anything wrong, okay?
Do you want to report
what happened?
We tried.
I'm scared if we…
He's gonna do something else.
- Henry?
- No, Eckert!
Lily told me what happened
at the party.
I called the police,
spoke to Eckert,
and he came to my house
to make a report, he said.
He offered us $50,000
to stay quiet,
or else.
Of course, I ignored him.
I brought Lily here
to do a rape kit,
but before we could do it,
he's all of a sudden here
and he's offering to drive us back home
to make another goddamn report.
And of course, I know he was lying.
What am I supposed to do?
He's the police.
And then he breaks my wrist.
- Eckert did?
- Yeah. He says if…
If we tell anybody, the next person
who's gonna get hurt is Lily.
He reminded me of that
at Sandeson's yesterday.
I just don't…
- I don't believe…
- Believe it.
He's working for them.
He's on the payroll.
I thought you were, too.
I'm telling ya, sometimes I think
the whole fucking town is on the payroll.
When did you realize
you were pregnant?
A week ago.
I missed my period
two months in a row.
I asked my friend to get me
a pregnancy test. It was positive.
What friend?
Pam Russell?
Lily, was it Pam Russell?
I'd never…
been with anyone else,
so I knew it was his.
I was too scared
to get an abortion.
I thought it would
get back to the Parks somehow.
You told Pam everything
that night at Sandeson's?
Is Pam in trouble?
Look, all she did was punch him,
I swear to God. She was so pissed.
And then he lost that tooth.
She looked so strong,
it was fucking awesome.
Later, Pam texted me and said her roommate
knew this, like, naturopath, Laney,
who helps girls
with stuff like this.
So, I called the number and a voice told
me to come to the woods with…
What?
She said I needed
to bring a piece of…
the father's body.
So, I took the tooth out of the garbage,
and I showed up at the edge of the woods.
Someone in one of those creepy masks
from the video was there.
They took me to this kind of,
like, clearing.
There was a weird symbol
on the ground and…
You won't believe me.
I promise I will.
They chanted
in this other language,
and then there were
all these chickens,
and we were at this, like, hut
in the middle of the woods.
There were candles
and bones everywhere.
I think there was a bloody mattress
on the floor.
They made me eat the tooth,
kill a chicken
and drink its blood.
And then they left me alone.
I waited, but I started feeling so sick
that I walked back to town.
I only made it
as far as Katherine's.
- Did you know about this?
- No!
Lily, why didn't you tell
your mom about any of this?
The pregnancy?
I'm really tired.
Okay, you lie down.
That's enough questions for now.
You rest.
I'll be back.
- So, do you think Lily will…
- We are done talking!
Geena.
Geena, wait, please?
If I'm gonna find a way to help you,
you need to be honest with me.
- We are being honest!
- Geena!
When I was assaulted in high school,
my mom went to the house of the guy
and kicked the shit out of him
with a metal doorstop, okay?
She said she always regretted
she didn't kill him.
- Leave me alone.
- What are these scratches from, Geena?
My hens.
They get testy when I'm collecting.
Don't touch me ever again!
I'm saying your rage is valid.
I'm saying if you did take matters
into your own hands,
I can still help you,
especially if it's not too late.
You know…
I wish I had killed them.
Both of them.
But you can be sure when I heard
that Logan had been killed,
I was happy.
Happy.
And I hope to God
that wherever Henry is,
he's fucking dead.
- Yeah?
- Henry raped Lily Sandeson.
What?
And Logan was there.
Oh, my god,
there's probably a tape.
Holy shit.
Lily did some kind of
abortion in the woods,
and someone wearing
one of those fucking cult masks
made her drink chicken blood
and eat Henry's tooth.
Wait, where in the woods?
Like, a cabin, like Angel said?
And Eckert tried to cover it all up.
He broke Geena's wrist to keep them quiet.
So Geena knew
about Henry and Lily?
That's why Pam wanted us
to keep listening to the tapes.
Henry assaulted Lily
in his bedroom.
Logan recorded everything,
so he would have…
He would have known
and did nothing.
- Maybe Geena figured that out.
- Well, she was there, right?
She catered the party!
And I know that she returned a van
to the rental place yesterday.
She could have put the phone
in my car .
Rapp, Geena has scratches
all down her left arm.
They look a few days old. And she was
the last person to see Henry alive.
- Are you still at the hospital?
- No.
- Is Geena still there?
- No, she left.
- What? When?
- Like, 15 minutes ago. Why?
- 'Cause I'm in her fucking house!
- You're in Geena's house?
- Get out of there!
- Oh, yeah, you think so?
Shit!
Rapp? Rapp!
Shit!
First one's a warning!
It doesn't make
any fucking sense.
Geena didn't do this.
I know she didn't kill Henry, okay?
I was there. I saw her face.
She was genuinely fucking shocked.
So, even if that DNA
under the fingernails is hers…
No, I'm telling you, I was there!
She didn't fucking do this.
And think about the cabin.
When I went to that clearing,
there's no fucking cabin there.
Okay, hey!
- You hungry?
- Not really.
You should eat. Come in.
This one's mine.
- You live on a boat?
- Full of surprises.
And Eckert, what the fuck?
Why would he do that?
- Money.
- Yeah, but like…
Okay, I get that he can
come on a bit strong and…
and maybe he isn't so great
at boundaries.
But breaking Geena's wrist?
Covering an assault?
- He has a daughter.
- I mean, what the… I just…
I don't think he could do it.
What do you mean
he's "bad at boundaries"?
Nothing, just a… misunderstanding
the other night.
But I'm a big girl.
I handled it.
Look, I know we're, like,
new friends or whatever,
but I want you to know you could have
called me if you needed someone to…
I did. You were at Dr. Hargrove's,
"investigating".
Sorry.
I'm sorry about Henry.
I'm sorry your friend wasn't
who you thought he was.
I mean, I think, deep down,
I kinda knew, you know?
There have been… allegations,
similar situations.
That's why we had to move
him here for 4th year.
But… never with a minor.
What happened
in those situations?
Well, the Parks are
very powerful people, you know?
They can make things…
disappear.
My dad worked for TJ,
like, my whole life.
Doing… stuff like this.
He was some kind of fixer?
Well, he preferred
the term "helper".
One time, when I was, like, 14,
he took me out for this,
like, fancy steak dinner
and he sat me down,
and he said, "Charlie,
everybody gets
their hands dirty.
You might as well
be getting paid for it."
Good stuff.
What'd your mom think of that?
She left when I was, like, six.
Damn.
So, I grew up
around the Parks, you know?
And when Henry was born,
it was like I had a little brother,
and they took care of me.
And what happened
with your dad?
He died on the job.
- Fuck. Jesus.
- Yeah, heart attack.
They gave him a big funeral,
and pulled me out of the army,
and told me I could come and work for them
doing, like, security for Henry.
Yeah, I don't know.
Part of me thought it would be nice
to carry on his legacy, or something.
Is that why you became a cop?
Is that your dad?
My dad…
I mean, I guess
that's probably part of it.
But, oh, wait.
Wait.
So, you're not even a real P.I.?
I mean, what's a real P.I.?
Like, I've seen a lot of movies.
Oh, okay.
No, I'm not a real detective.
Thank you for being honest.
You want another honest?
Okay.
The best part…
the only good part
of this whole fucking mess…
has been meeting you.
- Shut up.
- No, you shut up. You're, like…
You're very good.
You're a good cop.
You're a good person.
You might be the best person
I've ever met, you know?
You make me
wanna be a better person.
Like, you're…
You're real, you know?
Like, being here,
it's like you're… you're real.
This is you.
You live on a boat, and…
and your dad is a cop,
and you have…
weird toast art.
I ordered that
when I was drunk.
See? That's the fucking most
adorable thing I've ever heard.
- Your dad must be so proud.
- Never got to meet him.
- Oh, I'm sorry.
- It's okay.
You know I don't think
you're a bad person just because…
your dad did bad things.
You ever think about
having kids?
- Why?
- I don't know.
I think you'd be a good mom.
Well…
I would love to have a kid,
but every guy I meet is a disaster.
Maybe you just have
very bad taste in men.
Well, at least I don't have a crush
on every woman in Whittock.
Well, I only have a crush
on one.
You don't have a crush on me.
Yeah? How do you know?
You're very crushable.
- Stop it.
- No, you stop it.
I'm gonna let you in
on some hints, okay?
In case this should happen
to you in the future, so you'll know.
Say I did have
a crush on you…
I might come up with some, like,
reverential pet names,
like "boss,"
"partner".
- Right.
- Let you know that I respect you.
I might…
no, I do…
want to kick the shit out of Eckert
the next time I see him,
even though
I know you handled it.
I might see…
if you like this
and this.
I might see
if I could…
You are so fucking beautiful.
You too.
So, could it be
that those who tell our story
don't mention children
for one very good reason…
a witch with a child
would never die.
And wouldn't that
be fucking scary?
Catherine Hargrove
made a podcast, with Henry,
about Baba Yaga, and look,
who does that look like to you?
We need to be searching
for this fucking cabin!
I think we should be
chasing the mask in the video.
Oh, yeah.
She's one of mine.
- Who was the buyer?
- Henry Park.
- Have you seen this guy?
- I wasn't here.
My mom was,
but she's off-island today.
He often hires me to cater
his wacko theme parties.
The video was posted
from Sandeson's.
- Was Pam working?
- Yeah.
Shitty guys should be dead.
I think
that Henry killed Logan.
- Have you seen this boy?
- He's in the chicken house.
- Don't let a work crush get in the way.
- Worry about your own love life, okay?
You know, I am going on a date.
You angry about something?
Women?
We're angry about everything.
What the fuck?
What are you doing?
I have a question.
When was the last time
you heard of a mother witch…
a witch with a baby?
Never.
We just get pushed into ovens,
stabbed with swords,
drowned in the sea.
Knock knock.
So, why not pop out
a bun or two,
if only to delay the cross,
the rack,
the stake?
When we make our deal
with the devil,
does she take our uterus?
No, of course not.
But it seems to me,
to us, to witches
that it's safer for you to say
we eat children,
rather than that we have them.
Rapp! Dammit, you're not supposed
to be within a mile of Olena Yaha.
Morning to you, too.
Jesus.
I've been having insane dreams.
Also, I'm now certain that Katherine
was sleeping with Henry,
because somebody delivered the Baba Yaga
podcast to my rental car,
on Henry's phone.
You have Henry's phone?
How did it get into your rental car?
- I don't know.
- Why didn't you tell me about any of this?
Maybe because your boss
benched me,
and I still managed to come up
with more than Whittock PD?
And what were you doing at
Katherine Hargrove's all night?
Investigating. You should try it.
You called me, like, seven times.
Yeah, 'cause I was trying
to communicate with my partner,
who was fucking a suspect
all night.
I'd say foreplay took up
most of our evening.
Do either of you have change?
This doesn't take cards.
- Yeah.
- She's waking up.
I really,
I just wanna take her home,
but they're saying that
they need to run more tests.
It's gonna be fine, Geena.
She's gonna be fine.
Do you mind if I…
I'd really love
to check in with Lily.
Oh, now
you want to talk to her?
- Sorry, I…
- We have nothing to say to you!
- But I just need a…
- Did you hear what she said?
Just leave her alone, yeah?
I can try my best with Geena,
but she might be immune to my charms.
- It's okay.
- Hey, Sarge! Rapp!
He asked to come.
He wanted to "take initiative".
- Great.
- Hi! So, I…
That's a lot of blood.
- It's technically vomit.
- Oh, good!
Yeah, that's…
That's fine.
Okay, so I talked to my cousin, and…
You have to promise not to tell.
Marge could get in a lot of trouble.
Cross our hearts and hope to die.
Right, Carson?
Pinky swear.
Come on, over here.
They said that they don't wanna release
Lily into Geena's custody
until they know
she's safe at home.
- They don't think she's safe with Geena?
- Hold on.
Okay, so, Marge said Lily had clearly been
through some kind of a trauma,
and hallucinogens
were in her system.
And the blood she vomited
was from a chicken.
Oh, good. Fun.
She also threw up
a tooth.
- A tooth?
- Yeah. And, oh…
She was eight weeks pregnant.
But she isn't anymore.
She miscarried?
She's a minor, so they asked her
if she has a boyfriend,
if he maybe…
but Lily just stared
straight ahead, Marge said.
Because she's a minor, they have to send
the fetal tissue to pathology,
but they won't have
results back for a bit.
Marge also said there was something drawn
in chicken blood on Lily's stomach.
She drew a picture for me.
It looks like
the one under Henry's bed.
That's some good
police work, buddy.
- Thanks.
- Yeah.
Eckert needs me back at the station.
The Parks are coming.
- Yeah, go. Thank you.
- Yeah.
So, Lily knows about the symbol
or Geena does
and didn't Geena say that Henry lost
a tooth that night when Pam punched him?
And remember, Angel told us
that one of her little Yaga cult friends
wanted to "manifest a baby,"
and Olena told her to drink
a bunch of chicken blood,
and eat her husband's fingernails, and
then she got, like, magically pregnant?
This could be like
a fertility manifestation thing.
Why would a 14-year-old want to manifest
a baby from a 22-year-old?
A 22-year-old billionaire.
My dad saw this all the time
with Mr. Park. I've seen it with Henry.
Girls wanna get pregnant with Park babies
and then angle for the money.
That's what Dora Park did
back when she was Doreen!
She got him to marry her.
I'm not saying that's what this is,
I'm just saying…
This is a completely insane theory
that hinges on all women being liars.
Okay. Well then, why don't we
just talk to Lily then?
- No, you are not talking to Lily.
- Great, then I don't need to be here.
My job is to find Henry.
He's still fucking missing. Here.
Dad always said,
"Carry change, just in case."
What?
Dr. Hargrove, she was trying
to get coffee earlier.
- I found some change.
- Well, she's left.
Oh, okay. Well, I thought
you might want one?
- Thank you.
- How is she?
Look, Geena,
I know you don't like me,
and I'm so sorry you and Lily
are going through this,
but I want to help her,
I swear to God,
but I can't do that without asking
questions. I wish I could.
I know what it's like
to be young,
and to be manipulated
by someone older,
by systems that…
In high school, I was…
I had an incident.
If something like that
happened to Lily,
I will do everything
in my power to…
Geena, I swear,
I just want the truth.
Is this a test?
What? No.
Do you have any idea what this is
doing to Lily, all this bullshit?
I got the message,
loud and clear,
from your boss
at the diner yesterday.
What message?
You really don't know, do you?
- Hi.
- Hi.
Did you by any chance leave this
in my rental car yesterday?
Or was somebody else
working here?
No.
Would you mind terribly
if I had a peek at the registry?
- No. You obviously can't do that.
- Right. It's just…
This is embarrassing, but I…
I have a, like, a stalker situation.
- A stalker?
- See, I'm a detective.
I'm here from the mainland
for work, and…
this is my name.
And it's just…
It's very perturbing to me
that somebody could track me down and…
and leave this in my rental car.
Well, why do you think
they're stalking you?
Probably because I gave her
her first orgasm.
Click on that third one,
Sandeson.
You gave Geena Sandeson
her first orgasm?
First few, actually.
That's my number.
Maybe… you can try your luck
with me sometime?
Maybe.
Take your time, Lily.
He talked to me about books.
That's how it started.
And then movies, history…
I mean, he was with Pam,
I never…
It's so fucking embarrassing.
He made me feel like…
I dunno, like a grownup,
I guess.
- I'm so dumb.
- No, you're not.
He invited me
to his New Year's party.
He said it would be insane,
and it really was.
The theme was "Floral".
There were fresh flowers
everywhere,
whole rooms and hallways
just filled with them.
I think… somebody maybe
gave me something,
because everything
was so beautiful.
He wanted to show me
something in his room.
It was a chicken.
He said he was keeping it
in his bathtub.
It was supposed to be
for a ceremony, or something.
He said it was…
a secret…
just for us.
After that,
we were on the bed.
And I remember,
there was this thing on the bedpost…
And I remember wondering
if there had ever been
a chicken in the bathroom,
or if I had imagined it, or…
Or maybe I secretly wanted to go up to his
room and I just needed an excuse or…
No, baby.
No.
Logan Casey was there, too.
In the corner.
Watching?
No.
He was just listening, I think…
which is a lot worse, somehow.
I'm so sorry, Lily.
Afterwards,
Henry said I was drunk,
and that I had remembered
it wrong.
He said he showed me
the chicken,
and then I passed out.
He said he tucked me
into his bed
and just let me sleep it off.
Lily, what he did to you…
is not your fault.
You didn't do
anything wrong, okay?
Do you want to report
what happened?
We tried.
I'm scared if we…
He's gonna do something else.
- Henry?
- No, Eckert!
Lily told me what happened
at the party.
I called the police,
spoke to Eckert,
and he came to my house
to make a report, he said.
He offered us $50,000
to stay quiet,
or else.
Of course, I ignored him.
I brought Lily here
to do a rape kit,
but before we could do it,
he's all of a sudden here
and he's offering to drive us back home
to make another goddamn report.
And of course, I know he was lying.
What am I supposed to do?
He's the police.
And then he breaks my wrist.
- Eckert did?
- Yeah. He says if…
If we tell anybody, the next person
who's gonna get hurt is Lily.
He reminded me of that
at Sandeson's yesterday.
I just don't…
- I don't believe…
- Believe it.
He's working for them.
He's on the payroll.
I thought you were, too.
I'm telling ya, sometimes I think
the whole fucking town is on the payroll.
When did you realize
you were pregnant?
A week ago.
I missed my period
two months in a row.
I asked my friend to get me
a pregnancy test. It was positive.
What friend?
Pam Russell?
Lily, was it Pam Russell?
I'd never…
been with anyone else,
so I knew it was his.
I was too scared
to get an abortion.
I thought it would
get back to the Parks somehow.
You told Pam everything
that night at Sandeson's?
Is Pam in trouble?
Look, all she did was punch him,
I swear to God. She was so pissed.
And then he lost that tooth.
She looked so strong,
it was fucking awesome.
Later, Pam texted me and said her roommate
knew this, like, naturopath, Laney,
who helps girls
with stuff like this.
So, I called the number and a voice told
me to come to the woods with…
What?
She said I needed
to bring a piece of…
the father's body.
So, I took the tooth out of the garbage,
and I showed up at the edge of the woods.
Someone in one of those creepy masks
from the video was there.
They took me to this kind of,
like, clearing.
There was a weird symbol
on the ground and…
You won't believe me.
I promise I will.
They chanted
in this other language,
and then there were
all these chickens,
and we were at this, like, hut
in the middle of the woods.
There were candles
and bones everywhere.
I think there was a bloody mattress
on the floor.
They made me eat the tooth,
kill a chicken
and drink its blood.
And then they left me alone.
I waited, but I started feeling so sick
that I walked back to town.
I only made it
as far as Katherine's.
- Did you know about this?
- No!
Lily, why didn't you tell
your mom about any of this?
The pregnancy?
I'm really tired.
Okay, you lie down.
That's enough questions for now.
You rest.
I'll be back.
- So, do you think Lily will…
- We are done talking!
Geena.
Geena, wait, please?
If I'm gonna find a way to help you,
you need to be honest with me.
- We are being honest!
- Geena!
When I was assaulted in high school,
my mom went to the house of the guy
and kicked the shit out of him
with a metal doorstop, okay?
She said she always regretted
she didn't kill him.
- Leave me alone.
- What are these scratches from, Geena?
My hens.
They get testy when I'm collecting.
Don't touch me ever again!
I'm saying your rage is valid.
I'm saying if you did take matters
into your own hands,
I can still help you,
especially if it's not too late.
You know…
I wish I had killed them.
Both of them.
But you can be sure when I heard
that Logan had been killed,
I was happy.
Happy.
And I hope to God
that wherever Henry is,
he's fucking dead.
- Yeah?
- Henry raped Lily Sandeson.
What?
And Logan was there.
Oh, my god,
there's probably a tape.
Holy shit.
Lily did some kind of
abortion in the woods,
and someone wearing
one of those fucking cult masks
made her drink chicken blood
and eat Henry's tooth.
Wait, where in the woods?
Like, a cabin, like Angel said?
And Eckert tried to cover it all up.
He broke Geena's wrist to keep them quiet.
So Geena knew
about Henry and Lily?
That's why Pam wanted us
to keep listening to the tapes.
Henry assaulted Lily
in his bedroom.
Logan recorded everything,
so he would have…
He would have known
and did nothing.
- Maybe Geena figured that out.
- Well, she was there, right?
She catered the party!
And I know that she returned a van
to the rental place yesterday.
She could have put the phone
in my car .
Rapp, Geena has scratches
all down her left arm.
They look a few days old. And she was
the last person to see Henry alive.
- Are you still at the hospital?
- No.
- Is Geena still there?
- No, she left.
- What? When?
- Like, 15 minutes ago. Why?
- 'Cause I'm in her fucking house!
- You're in Geena's house?
- Get out of there!
- Oh, yeah, you think so?
Shit!
Rapp? Rapp!
Shit!
First one's a warning!
It doesn't make
any fucking sense.
Geena didn't do this.
I know she didn't kill Henry, okay?
I was there. I saw her face.
She was genuinely fucking shocked.
So, even if that DNA
under the fingernails is hers…
No, I'm telling you, I was there!
She didn't fucking do this.
And think about the cabin.
When I went to that clearing,
there's no fucking cabin there.
Okay, hey!
- You hungry?
- Not really.
You should eat. Come in.
This one's mine.
- You live on a boat?
- Full of surprises.
And Eckert, what the fuck?
Why would he do that?
- Money.
- Yeah, but like…
Okay, I get that he can
come on a bit strong and…
and maybe he isn't so great
at boundaries.
But breaking Geena's wrist?
Covering an assault?
- He has a daughter.
- I mean, what the… I just…
I don't think he could do it.
What do you mean
he's "bad at boundaries"?
Nothing, just a… misunderstanding
the other night.
But I'm a big girl.
I handled it.
Look, I know we're, like,
new friends or whatever,
but I want you to know you could have
called me if you needed someone to…
I did. You were at Dr. Hargrove's,
"investigating".
Sorry.
I'm sorry about Henry.
I'm sorry your friend wasn't
who you thought he was.
I mean, I think, deep down,
I kinda knew, you know?
There have been… allegations,
similar situations.
That's why we had to move
him here for 4th year.
But… never with a minor.
What happened
in those situations?
Well, the Parks are
very powerful people, you know?
They can make things…
disappear.
My dad worked for TJ,
like, my whole life.
Doing… stuff like this.
He was some kind of fixer?
Well, he preferred
the term "helper".
One time, when I was, like, 14,
he took me out for this,
like, fancy steak dinner
and he sat me down,
and he said, "Charlie,
everybody gets
their hands dirty.
You might as well
be getting paid for it."
Good stuff.
What'd your mom think of that?
She left when I was, like, six.
Damn.
So, I grew up
around the Parks, you know?
And when Henry was born,
it was like I had a little brother,
and they took care of me.
And what happened
with your dad?
He died on the job.
- Fuck. Jesus.
- Yeah, heart attack.
They gave him a big funeral,
and pulled me out of the army,
and told me I could come and work for them
doing, like, security for Henry.
Yeah, I don't know.
Part of me thought it would be nice
to carry on his legacy, or something.
Is that why you became a cop?
Is that your dad?
My dad…
I mean, I guess
that's probably part of it.
But, oh, wait.
Wait.
So, you're not even a real P.I.?
I mean, what's a real P.I.?
Like, I've seen a lot of movies.
Oh, okay.
No, I'm not a real detective.
Thank you for being honest.
You want another honest?
Okay.
The best part…
the only good part
of this whole fucking mess…
has been meeting you.
- Shut up.
- No, you shut up. You're, like…
You're very good.
You're a good cop.
You're a good person.
You might be the best person
I've ever met, you know?
You make me
wanna be a better person.
Like, you're…
You're real, you know?
Like, being here,
it's like you're… you're real.
This is you.
You live on a boat, and…
and your dad is a cop,
and you have…
weird toast art.
I ordered that
when I was drunk.
See? That's the fucking most
adorable thing I've ever heard.
- Your dad must be so proud.
- Never got to meet him.
- Oh, I'm sorry.
- It's okay.
You know I don't think
you're a bad person just because…
your dad did bad things.
You ever think about
having kids?
- Why?
- I don't know.
I think you'd be a good mom.
Well…
I would love to have a kid,
but every guy I meet is a disaster.
Maybe you just have
very bad taste in men.
Well, at least I don't have a crush
on every woman in Whittock.
Well, I only have a crush
on one.
You don't have a crush on me.
Yeah? How do you know?
You're very crushable.
- Stop it.
- No, you stop it.
I'm gonna let you in
on some hints, okay?
In case this should happen
to you in the future, so you'll know.
Say I did have
a crush on you…
I might come up with some, like,
reverential pet names,
like "boss,"
"partner".
- Right.
- Let you know that I respect you.
I might…
no, I do…
want to kick the shit out of Eckert
the next time I see him,
even though
I know you handled it.
I might see…
if you like this
and this.
I might see
if I could…
You are so fucking beautiful.
You too.
So, could it be
that those who tell our story
don't mention children
for one very good reason…
a witch with a child
would never die.
And wouldn't that
be fucking scary?