The One That Got Away (2022) s01e08 Episode Script

1
♪♪
[Ashley]
That was embarrassing.
Like, I feel like
I feel awful.
The portal has been
spitting out some duds.
[Ashley] First, Kyle definitely
treated me like crap.
[Ashley] I'm sorry to break
this up, but
[Kyle] I'm leaving. Don't worry.
No, no, no, come
Okay.
Mm-hmm.
[Ashley]
The way Taylor acted
[Taylor] So I was embarrassed for you.
I was embarrassed for myself.
With all due respect,
it's not for me
and I'm going to have
to walk away.
That was not
that was not cool.
[Ashley] But it took the portal
sending me these other guys
to realize what I want.
I've been stressing
on the fact
that I need
somebody who sees me.
-[Ashley] Hey.
-[Quinn] Hi.
-Hello.
-Hey.
I need to speak to Quinn.
[Alex] What?
I'm I have anxiety,
and I'm not even Quinn.
I was really a little
bit nervous,
a little bit anxious, think
I'm in a difficult position.
All right, I'm like shaking.
You all right?
Yeah, I'm just nervous.
All right, it's okay.
You know, you put a lot on
hold to come out here for me,
and I do appreciate that.
Tonight,
I have to ask you to leave.
But I want to come with you.
-[Quinn] Really? What?
-[Ashley] Really.
I feel like
I've taken you for granted
and you came here really ready
to prove things to me
that you're willing to change.
But like, there's things
that I need to change, too.
[Ashley] Sometimes I really just
need to shut up and listen.
But guess what?
Quinn still loves me.
He sees my flaws, and
he still loves me for them.
And you're a great guy.
I don't want to see what else
the portal has to offer.
Leaving here is hard
because I have made friends,
but I don't
I don't need to see anymore.
Come here.
I was not expecting this.
I need someone kind.
I need somebody compassionate.
[Ashley] It's it's
it all makes sense.
He gives me everything,
he truly does.
Quinn's, like, made for me.
Quinn is the one.
You told me at the portal last
time that, you know,
you loved me,
and I felt bad that
I couldn't reciprocate that.
And you know, there was someone
else that I had my eye on.
But, you know,
I don't have that anymore.
And I love you.
I love you, too.
Maybe you can even move
in with me.
Did just buy a new house,
you know?
Oh, I know.
Come here.
Quinn has made sacrifices
for me.
He continues
to make sacrifices for me.
Quinn gives so much to me
and I need
to reverse those roles.
I want to tackle the future
with somebody
and that somebody is Quinn.
-[Ashley] Can we get out of here?
-[Quinn] Yeah.
♪♪
[Ashley] This experience has
been really hard for me,
but I am here to tell
you the portal works.
I think the portal has taught
me lessons that will grow
mine and Quinn's relationship
outside of here
and make it even stronger
and make it long lasting
and help me fix the problems
that I did have.
-[Ashley] Let's get out of here.
-[Quinn] All right. Let's do it.
I found my future
and it was in my past.
♪♪
[Adam] Today has been a
very weird day.
[Vinny] Whatever he's doing
down there, I honestly
-hope it's for the best and healthy.
-Yeah.
I'm nervous
for Quinn right now.
-[Alicia] I can't take this.
-[Adam] What's next?
-What?
-Oh hey.
What?
Hi, Alex.
-Oh my God!
-What's up, what's up, what's up.
How's it going?
[Yurika]
Are you guys new to the house?
We're new.
-Yeah, we're new people.
-This is my friend.
All right,
come over here.
Seeing a familiar face
from back in New York
is just so exciting,
but I don't know
who else Mark could be
here for, if not Jeff.
-[Dezi] Who's here for Nigel?
-[Alicia] Me.
-I'm Alicia.
-Okay.
Nice to meet you,
nice to meet you.
I don't really care
about Alicia.
I'm concerned about how Nigel
makes me feel. That's it.
[Mark] How was your portal?
I'm pretty
I floated, actually.
-I didn't even walk through,
I floated.
-Oh, she floated.
-In those stilettos? Please.
I don't see Dezi
as competition but, you know
I just feel like our last
date really, really, really
like, broke down
a bunch of, like, walls.
-You're strong.
-Yeah?
You're strong.
And thank you for opening
up to me and just like
Thank you for
letting me feel safe.
So I feel like it's going
to be hard for the next girl
that comes in and Dezi happens
to be the next girl, but
judging from our last date,
I don't think nobody can top me.
Period.
[Isabel] Who are you guys here for?
[Yurika]
Who are you guys here for, yeah?
I'm here for Allyssa.
You feel me?
I met her in college.
What's up with y'all?
Who are y'all here for?
I'm Adam. I'm here for Allyssa.
-Okay.
-Okay bet.
[Adam] Jeff Me and him are here
for the same girl.
I think Allyssa has sparked
something in me.
I definitely could see us
being in a relationship.
It's not easy to do it
in a setting where
other people are also vying
for the same person.
[Alex] What happened with you?
-[Mark] What do you mean?
-[Alex] Like, how was the portal?
What happened? Like
-Was he shocked to see you?
-Yeah, well I mean like
I certainly am.
We need the tea.
Mark being here
for Jeff is news to me,
so we'll have to catch up.
Ooh!
To me, I had never known that
there was anything between them,
so it's kind of surreal
to see someone who I didn't
necessarily think had that
kind of connection with him.
[Alicia] How are you guys
feeling being here?
[Alex] I think it's cool to finally,
like, put it out there
because I don't think
that like
Like without this
opportunity, like,
I don't think I would have
pushed myself necessarily,
you know what I mean?
You're throwing yourself
out there.
Yeah, like
Jeff and I, I think look
better as a couple
and Alex is just
a really great friend
that is just there.
A friend with both of us,
but not anyone that I think
that I need to be
worried about.
♪♪
[Jeff] For Ashley,
the Portal worked for her,
so she did not need
to stay here any longer.
And I think it worked
for her, so maybe
it could work for me.
Ashley found love.
I hope my friends,
my roommates and myself
can walk out of here,
hopefully find the one.
[Producer]: Are we rolling?
[Producer]: How was last night?
[sighs]
[Kasey] Well
The date went really well,
for sure.
You know,
I invited him to come back
so we could have a nightcap
and what I thought
was the most beautiful,
romantic night
in which Dylan and
I professed that we were
starting to fall in love
with each other
ended up in a night where as
soon as the cameras were off,
he was a completely
different person.
Dylan confessed that all of
those feelings were fake.
[Producer]: Are you serious?
[Producer]: What did he do?
It's like he didn't
want anything to do with me.
It felt like he had no physical
attraction to me,
like all of a sudden.
He might consider me
as a friend.
[Producer]: Did he kiss you?
He didn't kiss me,
he didn't hug me.
For me, it's over.
[Producer]: Is there
any way that it's salvageable?
I could try to hear him out,
maybe when this is all over,
a connection could happen
in the future.
But it definitely
like, the way he talked to me,
it wasn't there.
The last thing I want to do
is date a selfish
and narcissistic person.
It really hurt.
Because my feelings for
Dylan were real.
♪♪
I have two amazing women,
and this is a great problem
for any man to have.
Alicia's
representing my outgoing side.
Alicia is representing a lot
of smiles, a lot of laughter
and I'm really excited
to see where this can go.
But at the same time, Dezi
and I were business partners.
There is no one like Dezi,
for sure.
I just don't know
if our relationship was one
that we're supposed to date
or if we're really supposed
to just be friends.
And it's easy to say
that a person checks
a box or, you know,
she does this and she is that.
But what's most important is
having that feeling
that they are the one.
It'll be very apparent
this time
where Dezi
is supposed to be in my life.
[Dezi] We pretty much just had a
connection, more so as friends.
Like he didn't really
pursue me off top.
I met him 2019 in March,
and we didn't go
out on our first date
until a year,
maybe about
a week off to the date.
Dezi, Dezi, Dezi.
About to start twerking the
way you jumped
on that couch, you know?
All right.
Okay, all right. It's on.
So you miss Big
Mama a little bit?
Put your butt down.
Why did you put
your butt in the air?
This opportunity
is very unique.
I'm not waking up
thinking about business.
I'm not waking up,
thinking about family.
I'm thinking about
what's important to
make me happy
with someone else.
So when I saw you last night,
obviously we are friends.
Obviously, we've been
through some things
that have been
pleasant and unpleasant.
But it's a comfort level.
We got the business.
If I tell you
I want something in any way,
you don't question
how it can be done.
You get it done.
If I say I'm sore, you like,
okay, you need a massage.
If I say my head hurt,
you are aspirin.
So our friendship
is outstanding.
If there's was one person
in my life who loves me
unconditional, that can
just really understand me,
that's been you.
I'm always going
to be attracted to you.
But you're my friend.
I'm always going to think
you have the fullest beard.
I don't even know
how you have all this.
Gonna get a little bit
of oil on your hand.
I got that Jesus juice
in my beard.
I'm just saying as a friend,
we talked about
everything, Nigel.
We talked about
fake ass people.
We talked about real shit.
-Yeah.
-Right?
I thought you was
like my best friend.
The loss of that
we went through,
I would have never thought
you would have done.
The main reason I say I broke up
with Nigel was loyalty.
He was pillow talking.
And pillow talking,
if people don't know that is,
that's whatever him and I
were going through,
he was sharing that
emotion or that feeling
with somebody else,
and I found out about it.
And when I asked him about it,
rather than own up to it,
he denied it.
And, you know,
seeing that he was talking
to a couple of people.
It doesn't mean anything.
I'm with you every day.
Who has time for that?
At the moment
you was being selfish
and I would think that
you just would have
shielded me a little bit better.
Right.
For sure was not ready
for a commitment
when I first met Dezi.
Felt like our relationship
just allowed me to understand
how I need to grow as a man.
I think timing is everything.
I'm really excited to see
if now's the right time.
You scare me like in a lot
of ways, you know,
that the love, the love
is what has me here.
I genuinely love you, and I
think you know this about me.
-Of course I know this. You taught me
-I never want nothing bad to happen
-what unconditional love is.
-to you.
I just miss you as my friend.
If I happen to fall
on your pogo stick,
and bounce all over
you because I love you.
Don't show my mom that.
[laughing]
My mom's going
to see that.
I can go on and on and on
about how special you are.
But what scares me is,
I don't want to hurt you.
You know that.
Coming into today,
I'm so nervous.
-I'm so nervous.
-Why?
Because you're too
important to me.
That scares me.
I'm nervous because
I don't deserve Dezi today.
Because the Dezi that's
in my life today loves me.
She's ready to be with me.
And that's just dangerous.
And there's a responsibility
that comes with
someone who
just really prioritizes you
and loves you
the way that Dezi loves me.
I think we know how we feel
about each other.
I think you just as fine
as when I first met you.
And I don't
I don't question you.
I just questioned
your actions in the past.
-I love you too.
-I'm serious.
-I'm serious.
-I love you, too.
Dezi has proven that she's in
my life for the right reasons.
Come on.
This date really
has me confused,
and I'm not sure if it's
going to be Alicia or Dezi.
♪♪
I'm just happy
and I'm happy I came here
and I'm happy
I had this experience
and I feel confident
I made a good impression.
If she gets to know me and she
likes me, then that's great.
She gets to know Dylan
and she likes Dylan.
That's great.
Who knows what happens next?
My grandfather used to do it
With a little basil?
We used to have the pot
like this high.
And his whole arm
would be in there like stirring.
Vinny's a good dude.
But it's hard seeing
a Kasey date other dudes.
And at first,
I was fine with it.
But now this is the second guy
and it's going to be even harder
and I'm not going to like it.
Like, I'm really
not going to like it
because I'm
so invested in this.
-You just
-You want to help?
Mashing in
I'm making the
Paladino's proud, bro.
My goodness.
We got Vinny at the house
cooking up a storm.
We're ready to chow down
as a family.
[Alicia] You normally have this
many people in the kitchen?
I know, look at all
these out here.
[Mark] Well, we usually have people
talking smack.
The vibe is pretty
much still the same,
even with the new people
coming in.
Everyone kind of
welcomed them with open arms
and let them be themselves and
just, you don't want drama.
How was that date that you
went out with my friend?
Was it a nice date?
A nice time, huh?
Yeah. Well, we had
a real good time.
You had-a really nice-a time.
Talked about you
the entire time.
Mr. Bigga-Shot, huh?
Talked about you.
Mr. Bigga-Shot.
Talked about your cheese,
you know.
I've spoken to Dylan many times
about him and Kasey.
I, you know, I'm always
going to bust his chops.
I'm always going to break it,
break his eggs a little bit,
and I'll let him
be on his toes.
You know, I'm going
to let him be on his toes
because he should be
on his toes.
Dinner was nice.
I did go back to her spot,
but still, like we had this
like nice candlelit dinner
with just us two.
We had wine, kind of talked
about how we've been feeling.
We really just like,
turned it up.
Yeah, and we had
like sparklers and shit.
Yeah, yeah, right.
You'll get some sparklers, bro.
I turned up the romance.
I'm not usually like that
but I turned it up.
The guy needs
to turn up the heat.
I was born hot and ready.
Oh, okay.
I remember when she asked
what your name was.
Oh!
After last night,
she won't forget it.
Oh, big player.
♪♪
[Alex] I am obsessed!
No, we're going we're sitting
down like civilized people.
I think the dynamic of
the household has been that
we're all in this together
and we're a family
and we have
this shared experience.
And I learned
so much about myself
by, like, you know, hearing
different perspectives.
Oh my God. So tell me all
about your date with Nigel.
Like what happened?
Like, what did you guys do?
[Dezi] It started off
like when you really
love somebody,
you're okay with not
[Alex] Wait, whoa. Back up. Love?
[Mark] Yeah, we're saying
love right here?
[Alex] I want to like back
up just a little.
Yeah, trip.
I feel like Dezi
is loud and extra,
I feel like
that's her first of all.
And secondly, I just feel
like she's threatened by me.
But it's like, girl, relax.
[Alex] And you broke up with him.
-Yeah.
-Okay.
-I ended it.
-Why?
Because I realized that even
though we have a connection,
even though we enjoy
each other's company,
starting businesses together
Starting businesses Oh, so
you all have money involved?
I helped Nigel
open up a barbershop.
And then I opened up
a braid bar.
-Wow.
-That's dope.
All right.
I just saw that
he was not really ready
to be committed
because Nigel
was talking to other people
and he when I asked him
about it
[Alex] Yeah.
He didn't deny it,
but didn't admit it.
[Alex] While you guys were together?
Yes, like toward the end.
[Yurika]
Was it emotional cheating or
What do you mean
by talking to other people?
Whether a guy is given
a girl communication,
whether a guy is being
intimate with a girl
Nobody that is that
you come to me for that.
The relationship ended because
Nigel wasn't loyal in about,
you know, talking
to other women.
And when I asked him about it,
he would get mute.
I don't want nobody
that don't want me.
Why are we spending
time together?
Why am I
Why are we doing businesses?
Why are we
Okay, so you want to have
your cake and eat it, too.
You need to go on over
and chill with whoever else?
[Yurika] But what was your intention
coming back 'cause
you broke up with him, right?
So why are you here today?
Because I wanted to see
if I still had the same vibe.
-Okay.
-I wanted to know if
[Yurika]
But did you think like he was
like in this time
that you were apart
like he might have,
like grown up or like,
you know, changed
like mind or
I don't think anybody is going
to just grow up
-within six months.
-Okay.
My thing is really Nigel
was my friend first.
-Okay.
-So for me to even come here
is because he was
my friend first
so I can look past the hurt.
I'm a strong believer that
sometimes people need to go
do what they need to do.
I had to cut it off.
Even when somebody hurts you,
even when somebody
disappoints you,
you still
I still loved him.
That shit was not easy.
That shit was not easy,
it wasn't easy at all,
but I missed him.
I miss his friendship first.
I missed his friendship. Like I say,
it was bigger than sex,
it was bigger
than the money we got.
My soul missed this person.
My soul missed them.
I feel better with knowing
I don't have any expectations.
-Okay.
-She's not a threat to me.
Oh, okay.
-I think the same thing.
-Exactly.
Alicia, how does it
kind of make you feel
hearing that, you know,
in the past
when he dated her, he was
talking to other girls?
I mean, it's a red flag.
I mean
Don't ever look at what
my problem with Nigel,
whether it be communication
or whether I feel
like maybe
Well, no because cheating
is a red flag.
Whether, like
-Cheating is cheating.
-Cheating is cheating.
[Alicia] Cheating is a red flag,
period.
And this is recent,
you just said that
he couldn't change
in six months.
So that is a red flag.
Whether it's your situation
or not, it's a red flag.
[Alicia] In order to even
build a foundation,
I have to be able
to trust you.
So if there's no trust there,
then why even
take that next step, you know?
So I'm just a little torn.
I'm in the middle.
If I don't get the answers
that I want
or I feel him stumbling,
and I feel like he's
not telling the truth
because I pick up
really good on energy.
I'm going to have to walk away
from this
because I'm not going
to embarrass myself.
I deserve better.
And it's not Nigel,
if that's the case
and I will walk away.
♪♪
What started out
as a beautiful date
with Dylan and I
I feel like I'm, like, starting
to fall for you, I don't know.
Turned into Dylan
saying that
he was just playing along
this whole time.
I feel super betrayed by him.
How could you let someone
else fall for you,
lie about it that you feel
the same way too,
and that it was all fake.
What a shitty thing to do.
Tonight, I really want to tell
him honestly how I felt.
I don't really know who
Dylan is at this point.
I don't know how
he's going to respond.
[Alicia] Okay, cutie.
-Hi, Kasey.
-Hello, Kasey.
[Yurika] I like your black dress.
-Dylan?
-Yeah?
-Can we talk?
-Yeah.
Me and Dylan are the last
two OGs, man.
You don't know
when your time is.
The portal is always open.
I can't take this no more.
I was not expecting that.
How did you feel about
last night?
I had an amazing
time with you.
And I mean,
I woke up this morning,
I was thinking about it and
you look amazing right now
and I'd like to do it again.
It was great.
How did you feel about
you opening up to me
and saying that
you were falling for me?
I felt so comfortable doing it.
It was like
a lot easier than
I thought it would be.
You know, last night,
Dylan turned into
such a just weird friend
instead of someone who we
had shared so many romantic
kisses and dinners,
and Dylan wasn't
affectionate at all.
There's a lot of red flags,
especially with the whole
situation with Allyssa.
When you came back
to talk to me
Mm-Hmm.
I just felt lied to.
What do you mean?
You told me that
this was all a game.
We opened up about
what we were feeling
and we were having
a great time,
but we had to figure out
how we felt.
You're literally
lying to me right now.
-I'm not lying to you.
-Yes, you are.
We had this conversation.
We had a conversation
off camera
Okay.
That this is all a joke.
As soon as the cameras
were off
-Not at all.
-you did not hold my hand once.
You did not kiss me.
You didn't even hug me goodbye.
Yes, I did.
Kasey, I hugged you goodbye.
You sat across from me
and like, fucking
bro-ed it out with me.
I was having a really nice
time with you, I don't
Yeah, it was all a show.
I think you interpreted
what happened last night
in maybe a way that I did not
mean for it to come across.
This is like
coming out of nowhere.
We talked about how
we like to take things slow.
-I mean.
-Wow.
Like fucking wow,
I've dated a guy like you.
-I'm not fucking stupid.
-Kasey
I'm really sorry
I made you feel like this.
I never intended to do that.
I never wanted to see
you like this.
I mean it.
I don't want this
to end this way.
I have a real hard time
in the beginning
being affectionate
because of things
that have happened in my past.
I don't want to screw
things up.
I just want realness.
Even when the cameras are off.
If you think it's too fast,
like, don't ghost me, you know.
Never. I think it was
maybe a misunderstanding.
I think maybe she wanted me
to open up more,
which I didn't expect to do.
I got to work on that.
Don't act like
we don't have anything.
I won't.
And I want to believe him.
I just hope that, you know,
he's not tugging on my heart
and toying with it.
I'm going to sleep on it.
I'm going to give it
like a day or two.
It's a whirlwind of
emotions right now.
I feel like should
I stay with him,
you know, should I not?
It's hard to trust someone
once they have deceived you.
But I've been in
situations like this
in my past relationship
where I have given them a
chance and it was worth it.
So I'm hoping
it's one of those moments.
When I cool down, when
I can make a clear decision.
I can let you know how
I feel again.
Thank you.
Thank you for even the chance
at a second chance.
I think the portal finally gave
me everything I was looking for.
It's definitely
interesting timing
to see Alex and Mark
both be here.
With Alex, It's very
like emotionally driven where
where with Mark,
it's more physically driven.
Mark and I have known each
other for three years.
Yes, we've gone on trips.
We've gone out with friends.
We've done the Fire Island
anything else,
but we've never been in a
one on one moment like,
why don't we just go to dinner
or talk about life.
It's always like
tequila, tequila, tequila
But Mark's hot.
We've had that lust experience
while always
remaining good friends,
so I think it'll be
interesting to see
is this just a lust moment
that we've had going for
like, three years.
[Mark] After seeing Jeff yesterday,
I'm really excited to go
on this date with him.
He's a great person,
he's a great guy and like,
but he always has that
like block like right here.
It's like
you can only get so far.
And like tonight,
getting to finally know him
on a deeper level is something
that I'm definitely
really looking forward to.
[Mark] What's going on?
[Jeff] Oh my God.
I think I have that
-This kind of
-Hold on.
Chicken tenders right here?
-Chicken wings
-Shut up.
-Now I am excited.
-I am dead.
So with our friends,
like back home
instead of Thanksgiving,
or friendsgiving
what we have done in
the past is wigsgiving.
Basically,
you're just drinking,
you know, drinking your drink
with your own new hair
and having fun
with your friends.
Should we do
a montage of just a
Whipping our hair?
[Jeff] I feel like we almost need
to like rename ourselves.
Like we can't be
Mark and Jeff right now.
I do like the fact
that he escalates me
in that like free
spirited of like,
let's just go, who cares?
I think you're giving me
like, maybe like Trish.
Trish?
Oh my God, stop.
Yeah, like she's
a hairdresser in Nashville.
-I really like that
-I see that for you. Okay.
Yeah, I'm into it.
See, you're giving me
very much like single mom
who works too hard with the
heart of a fighter, you know?
-Oh, wow.
-Because you're a survivor.
-New wine, new wig?
-I'm into that.
I'm not as nervous
as I thought.
I feel okay.
I feel like, okay,
you know what?
I feel this and it's time to,
like, shoot my shot.
I do you really care
about you.
And I, like, love
our friendship and like
I think
it would be fun to like,
see what could happen.
I think we're already
seeing what could happen and
-I'm into it.
-Yeah, I like it.
♪♪
Oh.
I forgot how soft
these lips are.
Have we kissed before?
Yeah.
I was so confused.
I was like
Tell me more.
It's like, to my knowledge,
like, I never kissed him.
Maybe once upon a drunk time,
I coincidentally
passed an ice cube in a club
through his mouth.
I don't remember.
[Producer]: How many guys have
you done that with?
A lot.
Like, to me, you
are someone who is like,
very outgoing and like,
you're very much going to do
what you want to do.
And I find that like,
so attractive.
I also have never seen you
in a relationship
or even like hearing
about, like, you dating.
I'm really good at working,
but when it comes
to relationships,
I fail every single time,
like it does not work for me.
So instead of putting
so much energy and hope
into one person, I was like,
let me put that into a career.
And I think I'm finally
confident and comfortable like,
I don't need to, like, put on
a show for other people.
I'm trying to prove
something like, I did it.
-It's great.
-Yeah.
And now I want
to find somebody
who I can live that with.
Honestly, I'm not surprised
it went so well.
Mark and I, as we've
always known, have had like
a great connection.
To finally be in a position
that we both can
just let it all go
and talk about things,
it was nice.
I would say this
is probably the best date
I've had so far,
and I'm excited
to see where
this goes with Mark.
♪♪
Hey, Vinny.
Hi, Kasey.
What's up?
Come on in.
How are you?
It's been a night.
I don't know if you overheard
me and Dylan at all, but
I saw you come in.
I saw him go out
with you, obviously.
But I just came here
to tell you
-that I'm going to be going.
-What?
I know you had a
great date with him.
He said that
he was falling for you
and he said that
you were falling for him
and you had like
the best time ever.
I just wish you
the best of luck.
Kasey had such a time
with Dylan and
stayed with Dylan and told Dylan
that she was falling for him
and kissed Dylan, and if
she was interested in me,
she wouldn't have done
all of that with Dylan.
Vinny does not like that.
What do you mean
you're going?
I mean, why do you want
me to stay
and videotape you
hanging out with him?
I'll stay and videotape you
and take pictures for you,
if you want.
What the hell
is he talking about?
You know, not everything
is what it looks like.
Okay, what does it look like?
You kissed him.
If you was thinking
of being with me,
you was thinking of
being with me.
You wouldn't have kissed
someone else.
You wouldn't have said, you're
falling for someone else.
You chose the other guy.
You had your chance with me.
Okay. Clearly, this
process is not for you.
No, it's not a process.
No, it is a process.
-That's your opinion.
-It's really not my opinion.
-No, it's your choice.
-Okay.
All right. So clearly,
this is not going to work out.
No, it's not because
I'm going to go home.
-Yeah, definitely go home.
-Yeah.
So there's no point in
dragging this out any longer.
I appreciate that.
-Okay.
-Okay.
Vinny Vinny, Vinny,
Vinny, Vinny.
-Bye.
-Bye.
Vinny came over
and kicked himself out
Wow.
And that was freaking awkward.
What the fuck?
♪♪
Coming here, Vinny
was looking to
see if there was
something with Kasey
because we've been trying
to hang out and we hung out
and she still chose
to hang out with other people,
and that's it, she chose
someone else over me.
Vinny deserves a person
who respects him,
and Kasey does
not deserve Vinny.
She had her chance and she
wanted to be with other people.
I may be a cheese guy,
but Kasey is not going
to string me along.
I believe I will find love.
This is not the end for Vinny.
What are we going to do with
this fucking cheese, though?
Oh my God.
It's smelly.
It's messy.
I'm going to roll it
out of my life.
You can walk yourself out.
Oh, wait, you already did.
I've had three crazy
relationships, I feel like.
And now I'm like,
I think I need a fresh start.
♪♪
-Hi, Miss Kasey.
-Hi, Betty.
How are you doing?
Tonight was such a
whirlwind of emotions.
You had a tough convo
with Dylan.
Yeah, it's crazy.
Like Vinny walked
himself out,
Dylan somehow convinced
me to let him stay.
Love is worth fighting for.
It is.
And I'm glad you are
and I'm proud of you.
So Vinny just left, which
means the portal is open.
-Mmm!
-Mmm?
-Are you ready?
-I am.
Let's see if this is the one
that got away, all right?
All right.
Sounds good.
-MiLady.
-Thank you.
♪♪
I feel like I've been through
it all already,
and I was fully prepared
for whoever would
come through the portal.
Please give me a good person.
Oh
Oh, my God, who's this
going to be?
-Simon?
-What's up?
Are you serious? Oh my God.
Lo and behold.
This adorable man
comes through the portal,
and it's my friend
Simon from college
and I always had
a crush on him.
I thought he was so cute.
He looks even better now.
-Oh my God!
-What's up? How are you doing?
-You look so fucking good!
-You look fucking great.
Oh my God, I cannot believe
you came out
all the way here for me.
Oh hell yeah, hell yeah,
it's good to see you.
Oh my God, it's
good to see you, too.
-What's up?
-It's been so long.
-It's like ten years at least.
-Oh my God.
You know, I'm really happy that
we both get to be here right now.
I'm happy that you're here,
I'm happy that I'm here.
And I feel like ever since
back in the day,
I always thought, you know,
maybe you and I
could have been something.
That was always
in the back of my mind.
I'm here right now to try
to rekindle a lost connection,
When it comes to getting back
into a serious relationship.
I think I'm definitely ready.
Granted, I meet the right girl
and you know,
we'll see maybe Casey's
that next right girl for me.
I actually felt the same way,
too, like meeting you.
I always had like
a tiny crush on you.
I just maybe I was shy
and I was always
in like relationships.
I was hard for me to like
-Same for me.
-flirt and whatever.
I learned how to flirt
like I don't even know,
later in college.
-So catch me at the right time.
-Oh my God.
I'm like, so, so, so
happy that you're here.
-Me, too.
-You have no idea.
Thank you, portal.
It was such
a roller coaster of emotions.
I went from angry
to sad to questioning
to confusing with Vinny
and then
happy with Simon, like, I have
never had
so many emotions
in just one freaking night.
Wow. Let me show you
the rest of the place.
Oh, yeah, let's do it.
All right, let's go.
♪♪
[Vince] The weird thing
about being here
is that I have the power
to decide between two women
and at the end of the day,
that's not the real world.
For me, I think I'm ultimately
a very one woman type of person.
I've had Isabel, you know, who
brought like the fun loving side
of Vince, like the side
that, you know,
likes to go out
and have a drink, right?
And then I have Yurika,
who really brings me into
my feelings
and like that comfort of home.
You know,
I'm happy with my options.
And then at the
same time, I know
I need to keep moving forward
and I'm going to have
a tough decision to make.
We can grab a drink and,
you know, just catch up.
-I know it's been a little while.
-It's been a while, yeah.
Yeah, yeah.
I want to give Isabel
time to just
just talk and, you know,
have a one hour conversation
with her grabbing a drink.
-Cheers.
-Cheers.
Good to be back.
-Good to see you again.
-Nice to see you.
I am so excited
to go on this date tonight.
I feel like
I can't stop smiling.
I keep thinking about
situations in my head.
I feel like we're looking
for the same things.
Yeah.
This date is so important to me
tonight, and I'm happy
to even get the date
in the first place with him.
And yeah, I just
feel nervous, excited,
but it still feels
really good.
How did you feel
about our first date?
-I had a great time.
-Yeah.
I left in the most,
that, most giant smile.
I had a great time.
-Yeah?
-Yeah, I did. Did you?
I did. Yeah, I thought
it was super fun.
I can definitely
like, see us like, you know,
having a lot of fun like that.
Is it weird for
you to date two girls at once?
It's a learning
experience for me.
Like, I've never
really done that before.
-Definitely strange.
-Yeah.
I know it's tough
because at the end of the day,
you know someone's going to
have to go home through the portal.
And it's like, for me,
I mean, you could,
you know me, like,
I don't really want
to like hurt anybody.
I want to just kind of
put that all aside
and just focus on you
while I'm here.
And, you know, like,
get to know you more.
I know we talked at the pool
and like,
I feel like whenever we talk,
it's so like easy, right?
-It's like, it's so fun.
-It is. It's natural.
-It feels right.
-It feels really lighthearted.
It does, yeah.
That maybe it's partly
because we only met
a few months ago, right?
I know with like, me and Yurika,
it was like a decade ago.
So you have a lot more,
you know,
time to bridge and,
you know, catch up.
For us we're kind of just going
straight into it, you know?
Yeah, I didn't expect to like
you this much, to be honest.
I feel like
when we first hung out,
it was with friends
and we were kind of having like
a lighthearted conversation
and it was very playful.
And our first date kind of
solidified that feeling for me.
I was like, this is someone
I can see myself with.
The best case
scenario is that there
is that spark
and we end up dating
and in a perfect world
would be completely compatible
and end up married.
And I feel like we talked and
shared things and opened up,
and I felt like there
was even more of a connection.
And that's how it should be,
I think.
After our first date,
like I really thought about,
you know, what
I wanted in my life long term.
Mm-hmm.
And trying to figure out
where my head was at
with you and seeing you,
I was like,
"Oh, like, we had so much fun
the first time we met."
Like, it's just going
to kind of carry over.
Me and Isabel
have a very like, you know,
flirtatious relationship,
and it's really fun.
It's really casual.
We did try to explore
a little bit more
to see if it could go
a little bit deeper than that.
But I keep thinking about
Yurika.
But I feel like for me,
like on this journey
what I'm looking for is
that deeper connection, right?
Like, you know, that
deeper connection
where I know
it's going to last
and it's going to go
the distance.
Ultimately, I just I don't
think you're the one for me.
I didn't see that coming.
I didn't expect to get sent
home tonight, and I thought
Vince and I had a connection
and I felt that and
I feel heartbroken.
-[Isabel] No.
-[Vince] No?
[Isabel] That's not cool.
[Vince] You're mad?
You're mad at me?
[Isabel] Don't waste my time.
I opened up to you,
I deserve better than that.
I know that. And that's not
that's not cool of you.
I don't appreciate that
at all.
Okay.
I think I deserve a lot
better than that.
[Vince] I wasn't trying to
waste your time.
[Isabel] Don't call me on a date
to send me home.
Come to the house and call me
out and say it's not working.
Don't have everybody
in the house
come and say,
you look great.
Go do your hair and makeup
and call me here to look all
good and then send me home.
Don't do that.
[Vince] I feel like this has
Don't put on
the whole good guy thing
and paint a perfect scenario
and everything
before you send me home.
Don't do that.
It makes me feel angry.
I feel like it's messed up
to call me on a date
to send me home
and break up with me.
You could have had the chance
to tell me after our first date
that you weren't feeling it
and you didn't.
I really enjoyed our first date.
I was being honest about that.
But I'm going home,
so you really didn't.
No, just because
you're going home
doesn't mean I didn't enjoy it.
I mean, ultimately, I told
you it's a tough decision.
You know, at the
end of the day, like,
I don't want to waste any of
your time
and like you've gone
through great lengths
just to be here for me,
and I'm so grateful for that.
All right.
Ultimately, you know, I couldn't
get past the casualness
of our relationship.
At the end of the day.
I'm here for something more
and I don't have
any time to waste.
♪♪
I was vulnerable,
I was trusting, and maybe
I feel a little bit naive now.
Maybe that feeling that
I shouldn't be quite as open
so soon was maybe
right in the first place.
I said what I said,
and I'm glad that I said
to Vince what I did,
because I know now that maybe
he's not the right person
to accept that about me.
It's not just like sending
a stranger home, right?
Like you can send
a stranger home
and not shed a tear
and it'd be fine,
you don't have
to second guess yourself
and no one takes
things personally.
But in this experience,
like it's not the case at all.
I don't want to hurt
these people.
I don't want to,
you know, like,
make them feel like
they did anything wrong
I want to protect them and
You know, it's hard.
Hi.
-Hi.
-Hey.
But at the same time,
you know,
I don't want to waste time.
The person that
I'm supposed to be with
might be on the
other side of that portal.
And if I don't cycle through
and figure out
what's going on here,
I may never even get to them.
Even though
they're hard decisions,
I have to make them.
-I just hate this part.
-Yeah.
After this,
I still have to go back home
and live my life and
I don't know if my life
is going to be
the same after all this.
I just I don't think
I don't think she expected it.
You know, I think
she was really hopeful for us.
And as much, you know,
fun that we have together,
I think she's an awesome
person, you know,
just wasn't
the right fit for me.
She wasn't the one.
But she'll make someone else
really happy.
Of course.
That's all anybody
wants in their life is
for someone to be completely
ready and honest, to be like,
I know you.
I know your spirit.
I know your heart.
I want you.
Let's see if this will work.
That's what's
amazing about being here.
That's what's really hard
about being here as well.
You want big reward,
you have to take a big risk.
You deserve someone
who knows how special
and wonderful you are.
And speaking of people
who want to date you?
I know I'm throwing a lot
at you right now.
I feel like at this point,
I don't know why I'm surprised.
Yeah, I know you shouldn't
have been surprised.
You know me.
You know, I'm here to just
I know you.
Oh my God.
-Let's do it.
-Yeah?
Let's do it.
Come on. Let's ride.
Just meet me at the portal,
okay?
-Okay.
-Okay.
♪♪
Betty gives me this news
that there's someone new.
And my heart
is still recovering
from sending Isabel back
through the portal
But in my mind
I know I'm here on a journey
and I don't want to waste
any time.
To go to the portal,
it's something that I dread.
But at the same time,
it could be something that
changes my life completely.
Hey, Vincent.
-Hey, how are you doing?
-How are you?
-Long time.
-Yeah, a long time.
It's been a minute.
I think the last time I saw
you, we were in law school.
Yeah.
Seeing Andrea
walk through the portal,
I'm just completely shook
because I know that
she could easily
sweep me off of my feet.
-Your law school graduation.
-That's right.
-We gave each other that look.
-Yeah.
You know the look, you know
the look I'm talking about.
Comparing Yurika to
Andrea is going to be so hard.
You know, they both appeal
to me in different ways.
I'm not sure ultimately
what my heart is
going to call to
because they're
just so different.
I'm trying to find out whether
that look meant something
and we could see
where it could go?
I'm at the point in my life,
my career,
where I'm looking for that
person, that best friend,
that, you know,
potential soul mate
and I think it could be you.
I think what I'm attracted to
the most when it comes
to Vincent is
his body, his body. I'm most
attracted into the body.
I mean, he's fit,
like, he works out.
And I love that
because I work out, too.
I mean, he's a really fit guy.
Who doesn't like muscles?
So I'm ready to see where
that could go.
Okay, let's go.
Oh boy.
[Dylan] If we have to like, get happy
when someone comes up
the stairs,
we're going to be like,
Hey
I'm feeling grateful,
I'm still here, but also like
I could be sent home.
I think it was probably a
bit of a misunderstanding
with Kasey, so I got to
step up and figure this out.
Here we go.
Game time.
-Hello.
-Hello.
-Hi. Hi, everyone.
-Hi.
-I'm Andrea.
-Hi, Andrea.
So I'm here for Vincent.
There's a new person
in and I know
I don't know, it's like
it's a mixture of emotions,
I would say.
I'm here for Vince.
-Okay.
-Yurika, yeah.
Nice to meet you all.
You look comfy.
Is this for me?
I'm just going to
-You look really pretty.
-Thank you.
That's a great dress.
How was your portal entrance?
Very good. Very cool.
He still looked good.
Very fit, you saw.
-So yeah.
-Yeah, he looks good.
Wait, how do you know him?
We went to law school
together.
-Oh.
-Yeah, yeah.
-So you're a lawyer?
-Yeah.
[Alicia] What was his reaction
when he saw you?
-Yeah, was he shocked?
-I think he was shocked.
Yeah, yeah. And I brought up
something like, that
he like, we have this weird
like eye contact we used to do.
Like, I reminded him of that.
He was hysterical.
-So, yeah, yeah.
-Oh my God, that's great.
So you felt the vibe?
Yeah, I did.
Yeah, I always did then.
-So here to see, you know.
-That's great.
Oh, that's exciting.
Welcome.
Wait, who's coming up now?
-Oh, hey.
-Hello.
-What's up guys.
-How's it going?
-How are you. Simon.
-Simon?
Good to meet you.
I'm here for Kasey.
-Okay.
-Of course you are.
Of course you are.
-Good to meet you.
-Nice to meet you. Andrea.
Oh, shit.
Here we go again.
So how do you know Kasey?
We knew each other
from college.
-NYU?
-NYU, yeah.
Me too, bro.
Not good news, okay?
Sorry, bro,
I'm not going to lie.
I don't want to see you
in the house.
It's not going to be good.
Okay.
♪♪
Guys, last night,
where do we even begin?
So much has changed
since last week, like
I don't know about you guys,
but this week has been
really, really stressful.
I feel like you have some new
people, you have some new people.
-Like
-I'm a little conflicted.
I don't know.
I think they're both really,
really great.
I mean, that's a good problem
to have, right?
[Jeff] That's the goal, right,
that's what we're doing here.
I guess the portal works
right, giving you gifts.
We'll see.
Yeah, I definitely
want you to meet my two.
I feel like I have two people
finally who
I like both of them and
[Vince] I have Yurika still.
And then Andrea
just arrived for me.
So I really want you
guys to all meet her, too.
She's super cool.
-Yeah.
-Not another pool party.
Maybe something else.
Yeah, no more pool parties for us.
So I had an idea
that I wanted to like,
relieve the tension
in the house,
and I thought it'd be awesome.
We could just have like a night
under the stars
tonight with our new arrivals
and the ones
we've made connections with.
-I'm down.
-Let's do it!
The portal's working.
[cheering]
♪♪
-Look at this!
-Wow!
It's so pretty!
There's actually stars out here.
This is crazy.
The fire
[Jeff] Guys, me and Allyssa built this
fire earlier today.
[Allyssa] Yeah.
It took a really long time,
so you better appreciate it.
[Nigel] Have you guys gone
camping before?
[Kasey] I literally hate camping,
but you know,
this is really beautiful.
You guys excited to get
some one on one time and
-Definitely.
-Yeah.
Hopefully get some clarity
out of tonight
and see what happens.
Tonight is different
because we're outside camping.
Usually, when I go on a date,
I'm going to be with just Dezi,
and I'm going to be
just with Alicia.
But tonight's unique,
in a sense,
where I'll be able to date
both Dezi and Alicia
and really just understand
what I'm looking for.
I'm really just curious
to see how my
arrivals can cook s'mores, so
If that doesn't go well
That's going to be
the true test of who I'm going
to be one on one
with first right here.
I'm excited to see two gays
go camping.
[laughing]
♪♪
[Betty Who] Hey, friends.
-Hey.
-Hi!
Betty Who!
We love your camping outfit.
Thank you.
Well, before
your guests arrive,
I have something to tell you.
-Uh-oh.
-Oh, no.
Your time here will soon
be coming to a close.
What?
What do you mean?
Each of you are currently
dating two people
and each of you
has one more arrival.
Oh shit.
Ready to come meet you
at the portal.
-When?
-Not now.
[laughing]
Nigel's stressed.
You will use tonight
to make your decision.
Oh.
Are you happy with the
two people you're dating?
Or do you want to say goodbye
to one of them?
Oh my God
And bring in
your last arrival.
You're kidding me.
So use tonight wisely.
Oh my God, I don't even know
who I would even send home.
That's insane.
On the next episode
of "The One That Got Away."
[Kasey] Simon, this new eye,
candy has his shit together,
it's like everything
I'm looking for.
What I have to do now is
going to be the hardest thing
I've had to do here yet.
[Yurika] Like, I live in San Francisco
and you live in L.A.
So like
So does that mean
like you wouldn't
want to be in a relationship?
[Jeff] You're nervous
to cross the line.
I'm nervous to cross the line.
And we both don't know
what it's going to look like
on the other side.
[Alicia] Your ex comes in
and she tells us
like how you cheated on her.
Are you still that same person?
Like, are you really looking
for something serious?
[Nigel] That's not what we're doing.
That's bullshit.
That's not what we're doing.
-Hey.
-Hi.
Why do you look so serious?
Uh
Yeah, so
♪♪