Elsbeth (2024) s04e05 Episode Script
All About Eats
1
- (CHEERS AND APPLAUSE)
- KEEN: Ladies and gentlemen,
by golly, he's done it again.
The incomparable, the indomitable,
- the one and only Desi Orr
- Yeah! Come on!
has become the Northeast's
cherry pie eating champion,
his 22nd title.
And by the looks of it,
he's not giving up that crown
anytime soon.
Yeah!
Who's the champ?
I am!
- (CHEERING)
- (WHISTLING)
(INDISTINCT CHATTER)
Mr. Orr?
Hey, how's it going, bud?
- You got something for me to sign?
- Oh.
Uh, no, no, nothing like that.
I just I just wanted to say
what a thrill it was
seeing you compete today.
Incredible stuff.
Hey, thanks a lot.
Glad you enjoyed it. Have a good one.
Oh, you know,
I've been following your career
ever since the Flamers Hot Wings
finals back in 2006.
You know, the way
you shucked those bones
- so masterful.
- (CHUCKLES)
Now, please. Let-let me.
You know, let me get that.
You shouldn't be doing
any heavy lifting,
you know, on a full stomach.
Thanks.
You know, I'm from Coney Island,
you know, born and raised.
You know, I've seen every, uh,
New York Coalition of
Competitive Eating championship
since I could say "New York
Coalition of Competitive Eating."
(CHUCKLES) You are a legend.
Well, flattery will get you everywhere.
- (BOTH CHUCKLE)
- Uh, yeah, you've even
inspired me to enter
some competitions myself.
Yeah, you know, small-time stuff.
- Pickles. Deviled eggs.
- Pickles?
Soon you'll be sucking down ribs
like they're nothing.
Hey, man, you know, maybe
could I maybe get your email?
I mean, I'd love to pick your brain.
- Uh, listen, Kevin
- Cody. Cody Baxter.
I start training for
the championship on Tuesday.
- This is my busiest time of year.
- Yeah. Yeah.
No, I-I I get it. For sure. But,
you know, you ever need a helping hand,
- I'm-I'm your guy.
- I-I don't I don't really
You wouldn't even have
to pay me, really.
I'd just love to have a front-row seat
in the life of a champion.
Well
DESI: The first thing you need to
know about competitive eating
is that 99% of the game happens
before you take your first bite.
And go!
ORR: You're training your body
and your mind to do the unthinkable.
Strengthening your jaw muscles,
suppressing your gag reflex,
and most importantly
stretching your stomach.
The human stomach can only hold between
one to two liters of food.
But with regular water cleanses
and practice eats, I'm now capable
of eating seven liters' worth.
That's why I'm the best.
And winning is only the beginning.
It opens doors to brand deals,
sponsorships, national commercials.
That's where the big money is.
And that money goes right back
into the grind.
Concierge doctors, publicists,
and a superstar image.
Well, no, no!
Desi doesn't do crab cakes.
DESI: But at the end of the day,
being a winner comes down to one thing:
mindset.
- No blue pens.
- Mm-hmm. Come on.
DESI: Because the life of a champion
doesn't stop after the eating is done.
You need to stay hungry to win
whatever it takes.
And stop!
Whew.
That was your best one yet.
(GROANS)
Eh. There you go.
I'm back!
Uh, good news.
They finally got the mustard
stain out of your chinos.
And, uh, Dingo's Donuts needs
that final friends and family
list, uh, you know,
for that promotional event
tomorrow, so if we could, uh
You got some explaining to do, Baxter.
Uh so
- about the chinos?
- You know,
I haven't been feeling
quite myself lately.
It happens sometimes during
training, as your body adjusts.
But this time
it felt different.
Found these in your backpack
while you were out.
I'm surprised it took me
as long as it did
to notice the bitter aftertaste
of my water cleanses.
I
I can explain.
You little worm!
I know exactly
what you're trying to do.
I should have you arrested.
- I should kill you!
- No, please.
Please.
(CODY PANTING)
You don't understand.
You know? You
you don't know what it's been like.
You know, ever since my parents
I mean, now that they're gone, it's
it's just been me and my,
and my poor old grandma,
you know, and I've just been
And I just thought if I could
maybe just
make something of myself.
You know? Like, if I could just
like, be be, like,
a real winner, you know?
I mean like you.
No. You're never gonna be like me.
Because if you so much as enter
a gum-chewing contest,
I will report you
to every league, every state fair,
and the authorities. You got it?
Now get the hell out of here.
(BACKPACK ZIPS)
(INDISTINCT CHATTER)
(EXCITED CHATTER)
KEEN: Ladies and gentlemen!
Put your hands together
for the Dynamo of Donuts,
the Count of Crullers,
the crème de la creme filling
Desi Orr!
- (CHEERING)
- Come on! Come on!
- (CHEERING)
- (WHOOPING)
KEEN: The undisputed king of
eating has been challenged
by Dingo's Donuts
the proud sponsor of
the New York Coalition
for Competitive Eating
to eat 50 donuts in under five minutes!
- Do we think he can do it, folks?
- (CHEERING)
KEEN: Let's find out.
Five minutes on the clock, please.
Desi, are you ready?
- You donut!
- (CHUCKLES)
- (CHEERING)
- (CHANTING): Eat! Eat! Eat! Eat!
Eat! Eat! Eat! Eat!
Eat! Eat! Eat! Eat! Eat! Eat!
(CHANTING): Desi! Desi!
Desi! Desi! Desi!
(CHEERING)
Well, folks, he's donut again.
There is no challenge too great
for the unconquerable Desi Orr!
(CHEERING)
CROWD (CHANTING): Desi! Desi!
Desi! Desi! Desi!
(CHEERING AND CHANTING CONTINUE)
(CHEERING FADES)
(CROWD GASPS)
(PANICKED CHATTER)
Hey, uh, is there a doctor?
Do we have a doctor here?
FLEMING: Damn shame.
Desi Orr was at the top of his game.
- You knew the guy?
- Oh, yeah.
He's the biggest name
in pro eating.
My pops used to bring us here every year
to watch the NYCCE championships.
There's nothing like eating a
funnel cake while watching a guy
eat a few dozen hot dogs
in the blazing hot sun.
Oh. Hi. Sorry I'm late.
I got distracted by an aquarium
and then then a freak show
and then a cotton candy cart.
- Can't have that here.
- Oh. Okay.
(INDISTINCT CROWD CHATTER)
Can you believe
I've never been to Coney Island?
I was supposed to take Teddy here
when he first came to visit,
but then I got selected for jury duty
and that became a whole thing.
Do you think I have time
for a quick ride on the Wonder Wheel?
- No. Summerville
- (GROANS)
According to the EMT, Desmond Orr, 45,
went into cardiac arrest
after a promotional event.
The donut saw the whole thing.
He's pretty messed up.
ELSBETH: Aw.
Poor donut.
It's sad, but it's not exactly
a big surprise.
The guy pushed his heart to the limit.
Turns out the limit was
50 donuts in just under five minutes.
ELSBETH: 51 donuts.
Maybe it was the last one
that pushed him over the edge.
(MAN SOBBING)
Oh. Sir?
Are you okay?
Aw.
You're even sadder than the donut.
Did you know the deceased?
He was my patient.
I'm Dr. Lester Grosse.
I was Desi's sports doctor.
I-I cleared him to compete.
Oh, God, the litany of lawsuits
I'm looking at.
I'm ruined.
You cleared him.
Is that required?
At the level Desi worked,
we had to monitor his health for each
of his corporate sponsors.
So it sounds like you paid
pretty close attention to his heart.
Yes. That man was
the six-million-dollar stomach.
(SOBBING)
According to the autopsy,
that six-million-dollar stomach
was full of jelly donuts
and about a bottle's worth
of Vascilipine
Desi's prescribed
blood pressure medication.
How does someone unknowingly
take a whole bottle of pills?
ME says that,
judging from the time of death,
Desi likely ingested the drugs
about a half-hour earlier.
Right around the time
he ate a wheelbarrow of donuts.
- So someone poisoned the donuts?
- ELSBETH: Mm.
- God, what has the world come to?
- ELSBETH: Weird.
The report also shows
that Desi had trace amounts
of oral semaglutide in his system.
But he wasn't prescribed a GLP-1.
FLEMING: That's what's weird?
GLP-1s aren't exactly
hard to get your hands on.
My sister ordered a baggie full online.
Now she's no fun to have dinner with.
Yeah, but why would a competitive eater
take a drug that suppresses
his drive to eat?
I think the better question is
what kind of psychopath
murders by donut?
Every year, the city holds
the Midtown Melee Softball Tournament,
where all the city services
go head-to-head.
And every year,
our precinct loses
to Ladder 44.
But this year is going to be different.
This year, I'm coaching us to victory.
I'm putting together
the best team this league has ever seen.
Ooh! Are we playing a game?
What are we playing? Can I play?
(CHUCKLES) Elsbeth.
Uh, I didn't see you there.
Oh, it's just a, you know,
silly rec softball game.
You're probably not interested.
I love games. Especially silly ones.
But, uh, have you ever played
softball before?
No, but how hard could it be?
The ball's soft.
- (WEAK CHUCKLE)
- Count me in.
WAGNER: I
See you on the field, Coach.
(WEAK CHUCKLING): Oh, yeah, yeah.
Ugh. (GROANS SOFTLY)
Uh, Elsbeth, am I interrupting?
I've been, uh, combing through
some of the videos from the event.
I think we should talk to this guy.
The donut?
Oh, no, not the donut.
Um
Look. That guy.
- With the fun hat.
- That's Earl Keen.
The NYCCE founder.
Doesn't seem all that nice to me.
Sure! Desi could be a cocky hothead
with a bad attitude,
but he had a fire
in that elastic belly of his.
It's what made him a star.
ELSBETH: And what exactly did your star
have a problem with
at the Dingo's event?
He shoved you pretty hard.
He accused me of sneaking
day-old donuts into the bunch.
Said he could taste the difference.
But NYCCE takes
food quality very seriously.
Dingo's made all 50 donuts
fresh that morning.
What about the 51st?
According to the scoreboard at Dingo's,
Desi ate 51 donuts.
Unless the scoreboard was wrong
Ma'am, I can't explain that extra donut,
but I can guarantee that
in all my years running NYCCE,
I have never never miscounted.
Mr. Keen, besides the kitchen staff,
did anyone else have access
to the plate of donuts
ahead of the event?
The only people who could
have been close enough
would have been in the VIP section.
Desi dropped off his friend
and family list that morning.
There's a VIP section
to watch a guy eat donuts?
There's a VIP section for everything.
I just can't believe he's gone.
At least he died
doing what he loved most.
Eating an extraordinary amount of food.
Miss Sullivan, did you happen
to speak with Desi that morning
before his death?
The last I heard from him was
a text from the night before.
Three words every girl wants to hear.
"I love you"?
"You were right."
Any idea what you were right about?
It could have been anything.
Desi was sort of helpless
and I know everything.
Do you know what he was doing
that evening when he texted you?
Or maybe where he was? Who he was with?
Okay, so I don't know some things.
Sue me!
You know who might know?
His little mentee, Cody.
Yeah, super helpful guy.
We don't have a Cody on
the friends and family list.
It's a funny name for it,
considering half the people on that list
are not friends or family of Desi.
NYCCE insisted
that all the contestants
of the championship be there.
And they were all jealous of Desi.
Especially Ben Tanaka.
Desi beat Tanaka
in the 2019 championship
and has won ever since.
He's Desi's biggest rival.
And my ex.
It's messy.
Desi hated him.
A-And he hated Desi right back.
He Uh, he posted something
last week. I'll show you.
Mark my words, Orr.
Your ass is going down.
Watch your back.
I meant his ass was going down
in the championship.
It was just a little smack talk.
I would never go through the trouble
of actually killing the guy.
Not even after he stole your girlfriend?
Candy? (LAUGHS)
No. Candy is a Chow Chaser.
A FrankFlirter?
A HornDog?
She only dates competitive eaters.
She and Desi deserve each other.
And he ruined the fun
of the sport for a lot of us.
And that was before the rumors.
What kind of rumors?
A few years back, word got out
that Desi spiked one of
the competitors' water cups
with gelatin.
You know, to slow things down.
Ick.
I didn't want the guy dead,
but I'm also not sad to see him go.
These new competitors need
better role models to look up to.
Someone with morals.
Someone like me.
Candy Sullivan said you might be able
to fill in some gaps for us,
particularly around
the night before Desi's death.
She said you're very helpful.
Candy said that? Aw.
That's awfully nice of her.
Love that top, by the way.
Such a fun, funky pattern.
Oh. Aren't you sweet?
Yeah, I was with Desi that night.
Yeah, I just dropped off
some some groceries
and some some dry cleaning
and some-some mail.
And then he sent me home.
Didn't see him again, till
he was on stage, before
Ah, I'm sorry. Yeah.
Desi was more than
just a mentor, you know?
He was a he was a friend.
Yeah. He taught me everything I know.
It was one of
the great honors of my life.
If you were Desi's
right-hand man and mentee,
why didn't he put you in
the friends and family section,
up front?
Oh, you mean the splash zone?
No, I was, I was in the way, way back.
By the kitchen?
Detective please.
For me.
Find out who did this.
If there's anything I can do to help
We'll let you know.
There will never be
another one like Desi Orr.
I only hope that I can honor his memory
by winning this year's
NYCCE championship.
You're competing?
Oh, yeah. Just joined.
Yeah, I, uh, I've only ever won
small-time contests before. You know.
Deviled eggs, pickles
But who knows?
Maybe this is my year.
(ELSBETH CHUCKLES)
Ladies and gentlemen, cats and kittens.
Welcome to the stage
your New York Coalition
of Competitive Eating
championship eaters!
- (WHISTLING)
- (WHOOPING)
Now, let's kick off the festivities
with the ceremonial first dog.
(SCATTERED CHEERS, WHOOPS)
KEEN: Tasty.
Uh, sorry to interrupt,
uh, but I just wanted
to take this moment
to dedicate this hot dog
to my dearly departed
mentor and my friend.
To Desi Orr.
I-I know that he
as well as my-my parents, who are
uh, now in a better place
would just be so proud
to see me standing up here on this stage
alongside so many amazing competitors.
So touching!
Now, let's all count down
from three together. Ready?
Three!
Two! One!
(CHEERS AND APPLAUSE)
That Cody guy seems nice.
He's awfully chummy with everybody.
Something tells me
he's more shark than chum.
WAGNER: I've been meaning to talk to you
about this for some time.
It's not easy.
Uh, I wanted you to know
this decision isn't personal.
It's based solely on performance.
And frankly, Officer Summerville
is better suited for your position.
Summerville?
- Mm-hmm.
- But
Now, we need someone a little more
spry at shortstop this year
if we're going to have a chance
- to win the Melee.
- (CHUCKLING): Oh. Thank God.
Wait. Hold on. A little more spry?
- Mm-hmm.
- I'm plenty spry!
I've been playing shortstop
since the first Melee.
And there have been a hell of
a lot more Melees since then.
- But Cap
- Sorry to interrupt, sir.
Ben Tanaka is in the conference room.
WAGNER: Mm-hmm.
Hello, Summerville.
Hey, Buzz.
Hi, Ben. Uh, can we get you anything?
- Coffee? Croissant?
- I'm off the clock.
Oh, right. Sorry. (CHUCKLES)
Uh so.
Yesterday, you mentioned
being a role model for new eaters.
You wouldn't happen to have been talking
specifically about Cody Baxter,
would you?
Oh, you know Cody? God, he's the best.
He's been showing me
and the other contestants
around Coney Island.
He reminds me that
we don't have to be enemies
just because we're competitors
- you know?
- Mm.
Right. Yes, you all seemed so friendly
at the opening ceremony.
Oh, speaking of
Why didn't you eat
your ceremonial first hot dog?
I'll be honest. I haven't been feeling
too interested in eating lately.
Not great for your line of work.
Yeah, I've been working on it
with my therapist.
You know, this sport
is as much mental as it is physical.
And sometimes, especially under
the pressure of competition,
eaters will lose their hunger to win.
So they choke?
We don't like to use
the C-word around here.
For obvious reasons.
We like to call it
- The Gaggies!
- The what now?
It's sort of like when
you're eating eggs
and the eggs start tasting
too much like egg.
And it's more common in
competitive eating than you would think.
Take Federica Ricketts, for example.
She was the top pickle eater
in the greater Boston area
five years running,
until a few months ago,
when she was hardly able to
stomach half her usual score.
And then there's
Greg "The Gut" Hyde.
Now, he won gold every year
in the Hudson Valley
deviled egg contest,
until this past June,
when he couldn't even finish
a single egg.
Now, what do these eaters
have in common?
The Gaggies?
Exactly.
They suddenly lost their drive to eat.
But these two have
something else in common.
They also lost
to Cody Baxter.
I called to Miss Ricketts
and, uh The Gut.
They had nothing but the nicest
things to say about Cody.
Just like Ben Tanaka.
But why did these champion eaters
suddenly lose their hunger
come crunch time?
- I'm guessing you have a theory.
- Sure do.
I think Cody sabotaged his competition,
not unlike his hero, Desi, did.
But with a GLP-1.
Just like the one found
in Desi's system.
Let's say Cody was sabotaging Desi.
Why jump to murder?
I'm not sure just yet.
But I do know
with Desi out of the way,
Cody is a lot closer to
gold and glory.
CODY: This this is proof
that with enough dedication,
discipline,
and a an alarming
capacity for carbs
anything is possible.
What the hell are you doing?
Oh, Candy! Uh, yeah.
Uh, hmm. Uh
I didn't even hear you come in.
Ew.
Take that off.
Oh, yeah. Yeah, yeah.
Yes, yes. Yes. Absolutely.
Sorry, sorry.
I just, uh, you know, I just
wanted to know how it felt.
You know. Just
Being Like, being a winner.
CANDY: I know what I was right about.
So when Cody first started
shadowing Desi, I was like,
"Okay. Who the heck is this guy?"
And I told Desi that
I was getting weird vibes.
But he just said
I was being territorial.
- What kind of "weird vibes"?
- (CANDY EXHALES)
It was like Cody was studying him.
Like he wanted to be him.
And he even insisted on
making all of Desi's
meal replacement shakes
and electrolyte waters.
Well, if that text was about Cody,
that would explain why
he wasn't on the friends and family list
that Desi sent to NYCCE
the next morning.
You think he found out Cody
was slipping him GLP-1s?
CANDY: I don't know about the GLP-1s,
but I found a bottle of Desi's
blood pressure meds when I was
sorting through his stuff for eBay.
- SUMMERVILLE: We'll run it for prints.
- Yeah.
Meanwhile, I think we should
pay Cody a little visit.
I'm afraid you just missed Cody.
He's off to work.
I do hope he's not in any trouble.
Um, no, no, we just have
to ask him a few questions.
- (DOG YAPPING)
- Wilford! Wilford,
will you knock it off,
you little lunatic?
Mm! I love your outfit.
- Oh.
- I didn't realize
it was the Mermaid Parade today.
(CHUCKLES)
Aw.
Oh. That's little Cody-ody in his
- fifth grade spelling bee.
- Mm.
Sixth place
out of nine.
Hmm.
Oh, are these Cody's parents?
Yes. It's been so hard without them.
- (DOG CONTINUES YAPPING)
- Wilford!
Put a cork in it! You're being rude
- to our guests.
- (LAUGHS)
I do not know what's happened
to him this week.
He's normally a nice little guy.
Oh, no, that's okay.
My Gonzo is a yapper, too.
(CHUCKLES)
Uh, if you don't mind me asking,
how did Cody's parents die?
Die? No, no.
They moved to Myrtle Beach.
And the new place didn't have
enough room for Cody,
so he moved into my basement.
And he's been so helpful.
- (KETTLE WHISTLING)
- Oh! Coffee's ready.
Looks like someone made
a stop at Dingo's.
Ah, you caught me.
I been snacking. (CHUCKLES)
Cody was so nice
to bring me a box,
even if he did take my favorite one
before I could get my hands on 'em.
Let me guess.
- Jelly-filled?
- How did you know?
Oh, just a lucky guess.
Ooh, I can't quit 'em.
They're not the same the next day,
but I can eat right through
that dang GLP-1 anyway.
You're on a GLP-1?
It's a lot of hoo-ha, if you ask me.
I've been on it for months
and I haven't lost a pound.
But I do admit
I like them new minty ones.
(DOG YAPPING)
I've had
just about enough of you, mister!
You want me to come up there?
Now, you mentioned that Cody is at work.
- (LOUD CHATTER)
- (CARNIVAL MUSIC PLAYING)
(CHILDREN SCREAMING HAPPILY)
All right.
Hiya!
Elsbeth!
Funny seeing you here.
You work on the boardwalk?
That must be so fun.
Well, technically, I'm an,
uh, independent contractor.
I make deliveries
to different fairs and carnivals
- and such.
- Oh. Like a carny.
That word has such
a negative connotation.
You know, people think of
carnies as being weird,
but look at me.
Uh, what brings you here?
Oh. Um, we just had
the loveliest visit
with your grandma Mimi.
It was very informative, actually.
Really?
Informative how?
Oh, well, she told us about
how wonderful and helpful you are.
Feeding the dog.
Giving Mimi her pills.
Buying donuts for her to snack on.
- (BELL BUZZES)
- (CARNIVAL MUSIC PLAYS)
RECORDED VOICE:
Step right up! Step right up!
Care to play?
Would I? (LAUGHS)
Who could say no to all this?
Um
But I have to warn you
I have surprisingly good accuracy.
Huh. Well, I love games.
Game on.
ELSBETH: You know, Cody, we also learned
that some of the things you told us
didn't turn out to be true.
I don't lie, Elsbeth.
Well, you said your parents
are in a better place.
But they're in Myrtle Beach.
Arguably, a better place.
And you said your grandma Mimi is sick.
Well, her osteoarthritis has
had a toll on all of us.
And you said Desi taught you
everything you know.
- He did.
- Like how he sabotaged his competitors?
Ah!
RECORDED VOICE: We have a winner!
Oh! That's me! I'm the winner!
(CHUCKLES)
(CHILD SCREAMS)
(CHILDREN SCREAMING)
- (LAUGHS)
- Congratulations.
What else do you think you know?
I know that you've been stealing
your grandma Mimi's GLP-1s.
And they're a match for
the kind found in Desi's system.
Do you love games enough to cheat
and sabotage your way
into the championship?
If you think I cheated, prove it.
But if I had to guess,
I'd say you can't prove anything.
Except for the fact
that I bought a box of donuts.
And last time I checked,
that's not a crime. (CHUCKLES)
Sorry.
I know how excited you were.
But if you'll excuse me,
I have more deliveries to make.
Careful what games you play, Elsbeth.
Some aren't quite as fun.
Oh. Are the new vending machines
broken already?
I wanted a Twinkie.
Just until after the big game.
We don't need any unnecessary
snacking slowing us down.
Um
Do you think maybe you're taking
this silly softball game
your words, not mine
a little too seriously?
I mean, some of our teammates
are regretting signing up.
What? Like who?
Like all of them.
I think you hurt Buzz's feelings.
Detective Taylor missed drop-off
at her kid's school
thanks to your
mandatory pre-duty workouts.
And I'm pretty sure I heard Rivers
crying in here earlier.
All right. All right, you have a point.
If this Desi Orr thing has
taught me anything,
it's that the line
between friendly competition
and death by donut
is pretty thin.
Hey. What's that?
Donut?
I gotta say, maybe we were
wrong about that guy.
He seems really nice.
"Thanks for all your great
work! Good luck! Cody B."
Spit that out! Spit that out!
Bad news.
Forensics ran the bottle of
Vascilipine for Cody's prints.
It's clean.
And any other prints
would have been eaten
- along with the murder weapon.
- ELSBETH: Wait a minute.
This prescription was filled
the first of the month.
A 30-day supply with instructions
to take one pill a day.
But there are only
two pills left in the bottle.
This feels like math class.
What day of the month
was Desi murdered?
The 28th. What's 30 minus 28?
Two?
Two! Why drug him
with all but two of the pills?
I think Desi was
taking this as prescribed.
I don't think he was killed
with his own pills.
WAGNER: And how does this
first-grade math problem help us?
If Desi and Cody had their falling-out
late the day before,
then how did Cody get
his hands on Vascilipine
before the event the next morning?
He had to get it close to home.
Or maybe at home.
Uh, let's take five.
Elsbeth.
You've got a lot of nerve, coming here.
Well, I wanted to thank you for those
tasty treats you sent our way.
I made you these.
They look wet.
Yeah, I'm not sure what that's about.
Well, I can't eat these
before tomorrow's competition.
Besides, I have to watch my figure.
You're looking at
the new face of Dingo's Donuts.
ELSBETH: Mm.
Well, you can share them
with your grandma Mimi.
You know, she's pretty steamed at me
since you told her that she
hasn't been getting her GLP-1s.
She had a right to know.
She is a sick old lady.
All right? All she does
is sit around with her sick, old dog.
All right? Food is one of the last
remaining pleasures she has in life.
And now she wants back on her GLP-1s.
What is she supposed to do for joy
now that you've taken
snacking away from her?
Breathe?
Speaking of old, sick Mimi
she wouldn't happen to have
high blood pressure, would she?
Fortunately, no.
Her blood pressure is perfect.
Mine, on the other hand,
is getting higher by the minute.
Goodbye, Elsbeth.
Hope you can come see me win tomorrow.
(INDISTINCT CHATTER)
(SIGHS)
WAGNER: Come on.
Yeah! Attaboy.
Summerville, good catch.
ELSBETH: Good catch!
(BOTH CHUCKLE)
I really thought I had that last one.
- Yeah?
- Turns out
- didn't have it.
- Well,
next time, keep your feet on the ground.
No need to do a somersault.
Yes, Coach. (SNEEZES)
- Ah!
- Oh! I'm so sorry.
(SIGHS) My allergies have been
kicking my butt this year.
Gonzo and I were rolling around
in the grass the other day.
We were both up all night,
itchy and sneezy.
You know, Elsbeth
you can sit the game out
(GASPS) Oh, no. No.
Then we both took a little bit
of antihistamine
in a little bit of cheese
and we were good as new.
(GASPS)
I got it!
- (LAUGHS)
- Eh?
- Hey, now, Elsbeth.
- Oh.
(DOG YAPPING INSIDE)
Oh. You're back.
- And we brought your favorite.
- (DOG YAPPING)
KEEN: This is it!
It's never been so close.
- CROWD: Six!
- Tanaka and Baxter are
- neck and neck.
- Five!
- Four! Three!
- Who will pull ahead?
- It's
- Two! One!
Oh, heavens to Betsy!
Baxter takes it!
- He does it! He really does it!
- (CHEERING)
This is a Cinderella story
if I've ever heard one, folks.
Your newcomer, Cody Baxter,
has won the NYCCE championship!
(CHEERING CONTINUES)
(LAUGHING)
Yeah! (LAUGHS)
Mwah! Ha, ha! Loser!
Ooh, you're a loser!
You loser.
You lo
- Oh! He's making a run for it!
- Stop!
Unit 419 to Central! Suspect is fleeing
on foot! Male, 30s,
carrying a large hot dog trophy!
(SEAGULLS CALLING)
Move. Get out
Move! Out! Yes!
Get out of the way!
(GRUNTS)
(SHOUTS)
CODY: Oh. Oh, my God.
Oh. Too many hot dogs.
(PANTING)
(GRUNTS)
- (PANTING)
- (CODY GROANS)
Cody Baxter, you are under arrest
for the murder of Desi Orr.
How's that for spry?
SUMMERVILLE: That was my first chase!
I thought there'd be more in this job.
Whew. (EXHALES)
I have got to give you credit, Cody.
You told me yourself, you don't lie.
So yesterday, when you mentioned
your grandma's sick, old dog
(GROANS) I should have listened.
Grandma Mimi said
that Wilford had been
acting strange all week.
Because he wasn't getting his medicine.
The Vascilipine used to kill Desi
belonged to the dog.
Grandma Mimi was more than willing
to share with us
just how helpful you've been,
giving Wilford his medication
with this little syringe here.
CODY: That doesn't prove anything.
I'm the one that gives
that dumb dog his medication.
Mm-hmm. Who's gonna tell
you otherwise, huh?
The dog?
Oh, no. The dog wouldn't
tell us anything.
But the traces of raspberry jelly
found on the tip of the syringe
sure did.
It's the same raspberry jelly
from the donut
that you used to kill Desi.
You injected those meds
(IMITATES JELLY WHOOSHING)
right into the 51st donut.
I think I'm gonna be sick.
I hope you saved room for just desserts.
That's good.
(CHEERING)
(SHOUTS) Go!
Go! Go!
WAGNER: All right, listen up. Listen up.
We've played a good game.
Some might even say a great game.
But it all comes down to this.
This moment, right now.
Last licks.
Bases loaded. Two outs.
- We're on the razor's edge.
- Captain Wagner?
We don't need a home run.
We don't need a miracle.
We just need one run,
and it's ours for the taking.
- Captain Wagner!
- Uh, Elsbeth, I'm sort of
- in the middle of something here.
- I know,
but I haven't gotten to play yet.
And I really think I can do it.
(STAMMERS) She's
All right, Tascioni. You're up.
Yes!
Ay, battah battah.
Sa-wing battah!
Uh are you sure about this, Captain?
But I'm up to bat.
I've got this in the bag.
We're a team.
It's only fair that
Elsbeth gets a shot.
If we lose,
drinks are on me.
Elsbeth?
- Oh!
- Is that you?
(LAUGHS) Fire Marshal Jake.
What a small world!
How, uh, how-how you been?
- ELSBETH: Good!
- I-I never heard back from you
about going to dinner. I thought
You look, uh, good.
Oh. Why, thank you.
(GIGGLES)
- UMPIRE: Ball!
- WAGNER: All right.
TEAMMATE: Good eye. Good eye.
Ball two!
Oh, my God.
I don't believe it.
Yes.
Huh.
- UMPIRE: Ball three!
- (LAUGHS)
What is it with her and firemen?
BOTH: It's the hair.
This is it. Final pitch.
- Ball four! Take your base!
- Yes!
- (CHEERING)
- (WHISTLING)
(SHOUTING INDISTINCTLY)
I'm serious.
I haven't seen someone choke
so badly in my whole life.
That was awfully
clever thinking, Elsbeth.
Oh, I didn't do anything.
You guys did all the work. (CHUCKLES)
Besides, I think this is
my last softball game.
- What? Why?
- No.
But you won us the game.
Well, I'm not really an athlete.
I'm more of an arts-and-crafts gal.
And I don't think that my feminine wiles
will work the same on the team
from the sanitation department.
- (LAUGHTER)
- Well, Elsbeth,
I, too, want to commend you
on your quick thinking today.
And I would also personally
like to thank you
for helping me see that
winning is not the most
important thing in the world.
But it's damn nice when you do.
(LAUGHTER)
WAGNER: Elsbeth on three.
One, two, three!
ALL: Elsbeth!
- (CHEERS AND APPLAUSE)
- KEEN: Ladies and gentlemen,
by golly, he's done it again.
The incomparable, the indomitable,
- the one and only Desi Orr
- Yeah! Come on!
has become the Northeast's
cherry pie eating champion,
his 22nd title.
And by the looks of it,
he's not giving up that crown
anytime soon.
Yeah!
Who's the champ?
I am!
- (CHEERING)
- (WHISTLING)
(INDISTINCT CHATTER)
Mr. Orr?
Hey, how's it going, bud?
- You got something for me to sign?
- Oh.
Uh, no, no, nothing like that.
I just I just wanted to say
what a thrill it was
seeing you compete today.
Incredible stuff.
Hey, thanks a lot.
Glad you enjoyed it. Have a good one.
Oh, you know,
I've been following your career
ever since the Flamers Hot Wings
finals back in 2006.
You know, the way
you shucked those bones
- so masterful.
- (CHUCKLES)
Now, please. Let-let me.
You know, let me get that.
You shouldn't be doing
any heavy lifting,
you know, on a full stomach.
Thanks.
You know, I'm from Coney Island,
you know, born and raised.
You know, I've seen every, uh,
New York Coalition of
Competitive Eating championship
since I could say "New York
Coalition of Competitive Eating."
(CHUCKLES) You are a legend.
Well, flattery will get you everywhere.
- (BOTH CHUCKLE)
- Uh, yeah, you've even
inspired me to enter
some competitions myself.
Yeah, you know, small-time stuff.
- Pickles. Deviled eggs.
- Pickles?
Soon you'll be sucking down ribs
like they're nothing.
Hey, man, you know, maybe
could I maybe get your email?
I mean, I'd love to pick your brain.
- Uh, listen, Kevin
- Cody. Cody Baxter.
I start training for
the championship on Tuesday.
- This is my busiest time of year.
- Yeah. Yeah.
No, I-I I get it. For sure. But,
you know, you ever need a helping hand,
- I'm-I'm your guy.
- I-I don't I don't really
You wouldn't even have
to pay me, really.
I'd just love to have a front-row seat
in the life of a champion.
Well
DESI: The first thing you need to
know about competitive eating
is that 99% of the game happens
before you take your first bite.
And go!
ORR: You're training your body
and your mind to do the unthinkable.
Strengthening your jaw muscles,
suppressing your gag reflex,
and most importantly
stretching your stomach.
The human stomach can only hold between
one to two liters of food.
But with regular water cleanses
and practice eats, I'm now capable
of eating seven liters' worth.
That's why I'm the best.
And winning is only the beginning.
It opens doors to brand deals,
sponsorships, national commercials.
That's where the big money is.
And that money goes right back
into the grind.
Concierge doctors, publicists,
and a superstar image.
Well, no, no!
Desi doesn't do crab cakes.
DESI: But at the end of the day,
being a winner comes down to one thing:
mindset.
- No blue pens.
- Mm-hmm. Come on.
DESI: Because the life of a champion
doesn't stop after the eating is done.
You need to stay hungry to win
whatever it takes.
And stop!
Whew.
That was your best one yet.
(GROANS)
Eh. There you go.
I'm back!
Uh, good news.
They finally got the mustard
stain out of your chinos.
And, uh, Dingo's Donuts needs
that final friends and family
list, uh, you know,
for that promotional event
tomorrow, so if we could, uh
You got some explaining to do, Baxter.
Uh so
- about the chinos?
- You know,
I haven't been feeling
quite myself lately.
It happens sometimes during
training, as your body adjusts.
But this time
it felt different.
Found these in your backpack
while you were out.
I'm surprised it took me
as long as it did
to notice the bitter aftertaste
of my water cleanses.
I
I can explain.
You little worm!
I know exactly
what you're trying to do.
I should have you arrested.
- I should kill you!
- No, please.
Please.
(CODY PANTING)
You don't understand.
You know? You
you don't know what it's been like.
You know, ever since my parents
I mean, now that they're gone, it's
it's just been me and my,
and my poor old grandma,
you know, and I've just been
And I just thought if I could
maybe just
make something of myself.
You know? Like, if I could just
like, be be, like,
a real winner, you know?
I mean like you.
No. You're never gonna be like me.
Because if you so much as enter
a gum-chewing contest,
I will report you
to every league, every state fair,
and the authorities. You got it?
Now get the hell out of here.
(BACKPACK ZIPS)
(INDISTINCT CHATTER)
(EXCITED CHATTER)
KEEN: Ladies and gentlemen!
Put your hands together
for the Dynamo of Donuts,
the Count of Crullers,
the crème de la creme filling
Desi Orr!
- (CHEERING)
- Come on! Come on!
- (CHEERING)
- (WHOOPING)
KEEN: The undisputed king of
eating has been challenged
by Dingo's Donuts
the proud sponsor of
the New York Coalition
for Competitive Eating
to eat 50 donuts in under five minutes!
- Do we think he can do it, folks?
- (CHEERING)
KEEN: Let's find out.
Five minutes on the clock, please.
Desi, are you ready?
- You donut!
- (CHUCKLES)
- (CHEERING)
- (CHANTING): Eat! Eat! Eat! Eat!
Eat! Eat! Eat! Eat!
Eat! Eat! Eat! Eat! Eat! Eat!
(CHANTING): Desi! Desi!
Desi! Desi! Desi!
(CHEERING)
Well, folks, he's donut again.
There is no challenge too great
for the unconquerable Desi Orr!
(CHEERING)
CROWD (CHANTING): Desi! Desi!
Desi! Desi! Desi!
(CHEERING AND CHANTING CONTINUE)
(CHEERING FADES)
(CROWD GASPS)
(PANICKED CHATTER)
Hey, uh, is there a doctor?
Do we have a doctor here?
FLEMING: Damn shame.
Desi Orr was at the top of his game.
- You knew the guy?
- Oh, yeah.
He's the biggest name
in pro eating.
My pops used to bring us here every year
to watch the NYCCE championships.
There's nothing like eating a
funnel cake while watching a guy
eat a few dozen hot dogs
in the blazing hot sun.
Oh. Hi. Sorry I'm late.
I got distracted by an aquarium
and then then a freak show
and then a cotton candy cart.
- Can't have that here.
- Oh. Okay.
(INDISTINCT CROWD CHATTER)
Can you believe
I've never been to Coney Island?
I was supposed to take Teddy here
when he first came to visit,
but then I got selected for jury duty
and that became a whole thing.
Do you think I have time
for a quick ride on the Wonder Wheel?
- No. Summerville
- (GROANS)
According to the EMT, Desmond Orr, 45,
went into cardiac arrest
after a promotional event.
The donut saw the whole thing.
He's pretty messed up.
ELSBETH: Aw.
Poor donut.
It's sad, but it's not exactly
a big surprise.
The guy pushed his heart to the limit.
Turns out the limit was
50 donuts in just under five minutes.
ELSBETH: 51 donuts.
Maybe it was the last one
that pushed him over the edge.
(MAN SOBBING)
Oh. Sir?
Are you okay?
Aw.
You're even sadder than the donut.
Did you know the deceased?
He was my patient.
I'm Dr. Lester Grosse.
I was Desi's sports doctor.
I-I cleared him to compete.
Oh, God, the litany of lawsuits
I'm looking at.
I'm ruined.
You cleared him.
Is that required?
At the level Desi worked,
we had to monitor his health for each
of his corporate sponsors.
So it sounds like you paid
pretty close attention to his heart.
Yes. That man was
the six-million-dollar stomach.
(SOBBING)
According to the autopsy,
that six-million-dollar stomach
was full of jelly donuts
and about a bottle's worth
of Vascilipine
Desi's prescribed
blood pressure medication.
How does someone unknowingly
take a whole bottle of pills?
ME says that,
judging from the time of death,
Desi likely ingested the drugs
about a half-hour earlier.
Right around the time
he ate a wheelbarrow of donuts.
- So someone poisoned the donuts?
- ELSBETH: Mm.
- God, what has the world come to?
- ELSBETH: Weird.
The report also shows
that Desi had trace amounts
of oral semaglutide in his system.
But he wasn't prescribed a GLP-1.
FLEMING: That's what's weird?
GLP-1s aren't exactly
hard to get your hands on.
My sister ordered a baggie full online.
Now she's no fun to have dinner with.
Yeah, but why would a competitive eater
take a drug that suppresses
his drive to eat?
I think the better question is
what kind of psychopath
murders by donut?
Every year, the city holds
the Midtown Melee Softball Tournament,
where all the city services
go head-to-head.
And every year,
our precinct loses
to Ladder 44.
But this year is going to be different.
This year, I'm coaching us to victory.
I'm putting together
the best team this league has ever seen.
Ooh! Are we playing a game?
What are we playing? Can I play?
(CHUCKLES) Elsbeth.
Uh, I didn't see you there.
Oh, it's just a, you know,
silly rec softball game.
You're probably not interested.
I love games. Especially silly ones.
But, uh, have you ever played
softball before?
No, but how hard could it be?
The ball's soft.
- (WEAK CHUCKLE)
- Count me in.
WAGNER: I
See you on the field, Coach.
(WEAK CHUCKLING): Oh, yeah, yeah.
Ugh. (GROANS SOFTLY)
Uh, Elsbeth, am I interrupting?
I've been, uh, combing through
some of the videos from the event.
I think we should talk to this guy.
The donut?
Oh, no, not the donut.
Um
Look. That guy.
- With the fun hat.
- That's Earl Keen.
The NYCCE founder.
Doesn't seem all that nice to me.
Sure! Desi could be a cocky hothead
with a bad attitude,
but he had a fire
in that elastic belly of his.
It's what made him a star.
ELSBETH: And what exactly did your star
have a problem with
at the Dingo's event?
He shoved you pretty hard.
He accused me of sneaking
day-old donuts into the bunch.
Said he could taste the difference.
But NYCCE takes
food quality very seriously.
Dingo's made all 50 donuts
fresh that morning.
What about the 51st?
According to the scoreboard at Dingo's,
Desi ate 51 donuts.
Unless the scoreboard was wrong
Ma'am, I can't explain that extra donut,
but I can guarantee that
in all my years running NYCCE,
I have never never miscounted.
Mr. Keen, besides the kitchen staff,
did anyone else have access
to the plate of donuts
ahead of the event?
The only people who could
have been close enough
would have been in the VIP section.
Desi dropped off his friend
and family list that morning.
There's a VIP section
to watch a guy eat donuts?
There's a VIP section for everything.
I just can't believe he's gone.
At least he died
doing what he loved most.
Eating an extraordinary amount of food.
Miss Sullivan, did you happen
to speak with Desi that morning
before his death?
The last I heard from him was
a text from the night before.
Three words every girl wants to hear.
"I love you"?
"You were right."
Any idea what you were right about?
It could have been anything.
Desi was sort of helpless
and I know everything.
Do you know what he was doing
that evening when he texted you?
Or maybe where he was? Who he was with?
Okay, so I don't know some things.
Sue me!
You know who might know?
His little mentee, Cody.
Yeah, super helpful guy.
We don't have a Cody on
the friends and family list.
It's a funny name for it,
considering half the people on that list
are not friends or family of Desi.
NYCCE insisted
that all the contestants
of the championship be there.
And they were all jealous of Desi.
Especially Ben Tanaka.
Desi beat Tanaka
in the 2019 championship
and has won ever since.
He's Desi's biggest rival.
And my ex.
It's messy.
Desi hated him.
A-And he hated Desi right back.
He Uh, he posted something
last week. I'll show you.
Mark my words, Orr.
Your ass is going down.
Watch your back.
I meant his ass was going down
in the championship.
It was just a little smack talk.
I would never go through the trouble
of actually killing the guy.
Not even after he stole your girlfriend?
Candy? (LAUGHS)
No. Candy is a Chow Chaser.
A FrankFlirter?
A HornDog?
She only dates competitive eaters.
She and Desi deserve each other.
And he ruined the fun
of the sport for a lot of us.
And that was before the rumors.
What kind of rumors?
A few years back, word got out
that Desi spiked one of
the competitors' water cups
with gelatin.
You know, to slow things down.
Ick.
I didn't want the guy dead,
but I'm also not sad to see him go.
These new competitors need
better role models to look up to.
Someone with morals.
Someone like me.
Candy Sullivan said you might be able
to fill in some gaps for us,
particularly around
the night before Desi's death.
She said you're very helpful.
Candy said that? Aw.
That's awfully nice of her.
Love that top, by the way.
Such a fun, funky pattern.
Oh. Aren't you sweet?
Yeah, I was with Desi that night.
Yeah, I just dropped off
some some groceries
and some some dry cleaning
and some-some mail.
And then he sent me home.
Didn't see him again, till
he was on stage, before
Ah, I'm sorry. Yeah.
Desi was more than
just a mentor, you know?
He was a he was a friend.
Yeah. He taught me everything I know.
It was one of
the great honors of my life.
If you were Desi's
right-hand man and mentee,
why didn't he put you in
the friends and family section,
up front?
Oh, you mean the splash zone?
No, I was, I was in the way, way back.
By the kitchen?
Detective please.
For me.
Find out who did this.
If there's anything I can do to help
We'll let you know.
There will never be
another one like Desi Orr.
I only hope that I can honor his memory
by winning this year's
NYCCE championship.
You're competing?
Oh, yeah. Just joined.
Yeah, I, uh, I've only ever won
small-time contests before. You know.
Deviled eggs, pickles
But who knows?
Maybe this is my year.
(ELSBETH CHUCKLES)
Ladies and gentlemen, cats and kittens.
Welcome to the stage
your New York Coalition
of Competitive Eating
championship eaters!
- (WHISTLING)
- (WHOOPING)
Now, let's kick off the festivities
with the ceremonial first dog.
(SCATTERED CHEERS, WHOOPS)
KEEN: Tasty.
Uh, sorry to interrupt,
uh, but I just wanted
to take this moment
to dedicate this hot dog
to my dearly departed
mentor and my friend.
To Desi Orr.
I-I know that he
as well as my-my parents, who are
uh, now in a better place
would just be so proud
to see me standing up here on this stage
alongside so many amazing competitors.
So touching!
Now, let's all count down
from three together. Ready?
Three!
Two! One!
(CHEERS AND APPLAUSE)
That Cody guy seems nice.
He's awfully chummy with everybody.
Something tells me
he's more shark than chum.
WAGNER: I've been meaning to talk to you
about this for some time.
It's not easy.
Uh, I wanted you to know
this decision isn't personal.
It's based solely on performance.
And frankly, Officer Summerville
is better suited for your position.
Summerville?
- Mm-hmm.
- But
Now, we need someone a little more
spry at shortstop this year
if we're going to have a chance
- to win the Melee.
- (CHUCKLING): Oh. Thank God.
Wait. Hold on. A little more spry?
- Mm-hmm.
- I'm plenty spry!
I've been playing shortstop
since the first Melee.
And there have been a hell of
a lot more Melees since then.
- But Cap
- Sorry to interrupt, sir.
Ben Tanaka is in the conference room.
WAGNER: Mm-hmm.
Hello, Summerville.
Hey, Buzz.
Hi, Ben. Uh, can we get you anything?
- Coffee? Croissant?
- I'm off the clock.
Oh, right. Sorry. (CHUCKLES)
Uh so.
Yesterday, you mentioned
being a role model for new eaters.
You wouldn't happen to have been talking
specifically about Cody Baxter,
would you?
Oh, you know Cody? God, he's the best.
He's been showing me
and the other contestants
around Coney Island.
He reminds me that
we don't have to be enemies
just because we're competitors
- you know?
- Mm.
Right. Yes, you all seemed so friendly
at the opening ceremony.
Oh, speaking of
Why didn't you eat
your ceremonial first hot dog?
I'll be honest. I haven't been feeling
too interested in eating lately.
Not great for your line of work.
Yeah, I've been working on it
with my therapist.
You know, this sport
is as much mental as it is physical.
And sometimes, especially under
the pressure of competition,
eaters will lose their hunger to win.
So they choke?
We don't like to use
the C-word around here.
For obvious reasons.
We like to call it
- The Gaggies!
- The what now?
It's sort of like when
you're eating eggs
and the eggs start tasting
too much like egg.
And it's more common in
competitive eating than you would think.
Take Federica Ricketts, for example.
She was the top pickle eater
in the greater Boston area
five years running,
until a few months ago,
when she was hardly able to
stomach half her usual score.
And then there's
Greg "The Gut" Hyde.
Now, he won gold every year
in the Hudson Valley
deviled egg contest,
until this past June,
when he couldn't even finish
a single egg.
Now, what do these eaters
have in common?
The Gaggies?
Exactly.
They suddenly lost their drive to eat.
But these two have
something else in common.
They also lost
to Cody Baxter.
I called to Miss Ricketts
and, uh The Gut.
They had nothing but the nicest
things to say about Cody.
Just like Ben Tanaka.
But why did these champion eaters
suddenly lose their hunger
come crunch time?
- I'm guessing you have a theory.
- Sure do.
I think Cody sabotaged his competition,
not unlike his hero, Desi, did.
But with a GLP-1.
Just like the one found
in Desi's system.
Let's say Cody was sabotaging Desi.
Why jump to murder?
I'm not sure just yet.
But I do know
with Desi out of the way,
Cody is a lot closer to
gold and glory.
CODY: This this is proof
that with enough dedication,
discipline,
and a an alarming
capacity for carbs
anything is possible.
What the hell are you doing?
Oh, Candy! Uh, yeah.
Uh, hmm. Uh
I didn't even hear you come in.
Ew.
Take that off.
Oh, yeah. Yeah, yeah.
Yes, yes. Yes. Absolutely.
Sorry, sorry.
I just, uh, you know, I just
wanted to know how it felt.
You know. Just
Being Like, being a winner.
CANDY: I know what I was right about.
So when Cody first started
shadowing Desi, I was like,
"Okay. Who the heck is this guy?"
And I told Desi that
I was getting weird vibes.
But he just said
I was being territorial.
- What kind of "weird vibes"?
- (CANDY EXHALES)
It was like Cody was studying him.
Like he wanted to be him.
And he even insisted on
making all of Desi's
meal replacement shakes
and electrolyte waters.
Well, if that text was about Cody,
that would explain why
he wasn't on the friends and family list
that Desi sent to NYCCE
the next morning.
You think he found out Cody
was slipping him GLP-1s?
CANDY: I don't know about the GLP-1s,
but I found a bottle of Desi's
blood pressure meds when I was
sorting through his stuff for eBay.
- SUMMERVILLE: We'll run it for prints.
- Yeah.
Meanwhile, I think we should
pay Cody a little visit.
I'm afraid you just missed Cody.
He's off to work.
I do hope he's not in any trouble.
Um, no, no, we just have
to ask him a few questions.
- (DOG YAPPING)
- Wilford! Wilford,
will you knock it off,
you little lunatic?
Mm! I love your outfit.
- Oh.
- I didn't realize
it was the Mermaid Parade today.
(CHUCKLES)
Aw.
Oh. That's little Cody-ody in his
- fifth grade spelling bee.
- Mm.
Sixth place
out of nine.
Hmm.
Oh, are these Cody's parents?
Yes. It's been so hard without them.
- (DOG CONTINUES YAPPING)
- Wilford!
Put a cork in it! You're being rude
- to our guests.
- (LAUGHS)
I do not know what's happened
to him this week.
He's normally a nice little guy.
Oh, no, that's okay.
My Gonzo is a yapper, too.
(CHUCKLES)
Uh, if you don't mind me asking,
how did Cody's parents die?
Die? No, no.
They moved to Myrtle Beach.
And the new place didn't have
enough room for Cody,
so he moved into my basement.
And he's been so helpful.
- (KETTLE WHISTLING)
- Oh! Coffee's ready.
Looks like someone made
a stop at Dingo's.
Ah, you caught me.
I been snacking. (CHUCKLES)
Cody was so nice
to bring me a box,
even if he did take my favorite one
before I could get my hands on 'em.
Let me guess.
- Jelly-filled?
- How did you know?
Oh, just a lucky guess.
Ooh, I can't quit 'em.
They're not the same the next day,
but I can eat right through
that dang GLP-1 anyway.
You're on a GLP-1?
It's a lot of hoo-ha, if you ask me.
I've been on it for months
and I haven't lost a pound.
But I do admit
I like them new minty ones.
(DOG YAPPING)
I've had
just about enough of you, mister!
You want me to come up there?
Now, you mentioned that Cody is at work.
- (LOUD CHATTER)
- (CARNIVAL MUSIC PLAYING)
(CHILDREN SCREAMING HAPPILY)
All right.
Hiya!
Elsbeth!
Funny seeing you here.
You work on the boardwalk?
That must be so fun.
Well, technically, I'm an,
uh, independent contractor.
I make deliveries
to different fairs and carnivals
- and such.
- Oh. Like a carny.
That word has such
a negative connotation.
You know, people think of
carnies as being weird,
but look at me.
Uh, what brings you here?
Oh. Um, we just had
the loveliest visit
with your grandma Mimi.
It was very informative, actually.
Really?
Informative how?
Oh, well, she told us about
how wonderful and helpful you are.
Feeding the dog.
Giving Mimi her pills.
Buying donuts for her to snack on.
- (BELL BUZZES)
- (CARNIVAL MUSIC PLAYS)
RECORDED VOICE:
Step right up! Step right up!
Care to play?
Would I? (LAUGHS)
Who could say no to all this?
Um
But I have to warn you
I have surprisingly good accuracy.
Huh. Well, I love games.
Game on.
ELSBETH: You know, Cody, we also learned
that some of the things you told us
didn't turn out to be true.
I don't lie, Elsbeth.
Well, you said your parents
are in a better place.
But they're in Myrtle Beach.
Arguably, a better place.
And you said your grandma Mimi is sick.
Well, her osteoarthritis has
had a toll on all of us.
And you said Desi taught you
everything you know.
- He did.
- Like how he sabotaged his competitors?
Ah!
RECORDED VOICE: We have a winner!
Oh! That's me! I'm the winner!
(CHUCKLES)
(CHILD SCREAMS)
(CHILDREN SCREAMING)
- (LAUGHS)
- Congratulations.
What else do you think you know?
I know that you've been stealing
your grandma Mimi's GLP-1s.
And they're a match for
the kind found in Desi's system.
Do you love games enough to cheat
and sabotage your way
into the championship?
If you think I cheated, prove it.
But if I had to guess,
I'd say you can't prove anything.
Except for the fact
that I bought a box of donuts.
And last time I checked,
that's not a crime. (CHUCKLES)
Sorry.
I know how excited you were.
But if you'll excuse me,
I have more deliveries to make.
Careful what games you play, Elsbeth.
Some aren't quite as fun.
Oh. Are the new vending machines
broken already?
I wanted a Twinkie.
Just until after the big game.
We don't need any unnecessary
snacking slowing us down.
Um
Do you think maybe you're taking
this silly softball game
your words, not mine
a little too seriously?
I mean, some of our teammates
are regretting signing up.
What? Like who?
Like all of them.
I think you hurt Buzz's feelings.
Detective Taylor missed drop-off
at her kid's school
thanks to your
mandatory pre-duty workouts.
And I'm pretty sure I heard Rivers
crying in here earlier.
All right. All right, you have a point.
If this Desi Orr thing has
taught me anything,
it's that the line
between friendly competition
and death by donut
is pretty thin.
Hey. What's that?
Donut?
I gotta say, maybe we were
wrong about that guy.
He seems really nice.
"Thanks for all your great
work! Good luck! Cody B."
Spit that out! Spit that out!
Bad news.
Forensics ran the bottle of
Vascilipine for Cody's prints.
It's clean.
And any other prints
would have been eaten
- along with the murder weapon.
- ELSBETH: Wait a minute.
This prescription was filled
the first of the month.
A 30-day supply with instructions
to take one pill a day.
But there are only
two pills left in the bottle.
This feels like math class.
What day of the month
was Desi murdered?
The 28th. What's 30 minus 28?
Two?
Two! Why drug him
with all but two of the pills?
I think Desi was
taking this as prescribed.
I don't think he was killed
with his own pills.
WAGNER: And how does this
first-grade math problem help us?
If Desi and Cody had their falling-out
late the day before,
then how did Cody get
his hands on Vascilipine
before the event the next morning?
He had to get it close to home.
Or maybe at home.
Uh, let's take five.
Elsbeth.
You've got a lot of nerve, coming here.
Well, I wanted to thank you for those
tasty treats you sent our way.
I made you these.
They look wet.
Yeah, I'm not sure what that's about.
Well, I can't eat these
before tomorrow's competition.
Besides, I have to watch my figure.
You're looking at
the new face of Dingo's Donuts.
ELSBETH: Mm.
Well, you can share them
with your grandma Mimi.
You know, she's pretty steamed at me
since you told her that she
hasn't been getting her GLP-1s.
She had a right to know.
She is a sick old lady.
All right? All she does
is sit around with her sick, old dog.
All right? Food is one of the last
remaining pleasures she has in life.
And now she wants back on her GLP-1s.
What is she supposed to do for joy
now that you've taken
snacking away from her?
Breathe?
Speaking of old, sick Mimi
she wouldn't happen to have
high blood pressure, would she?
Fortunately, no.
Her blood pressure is perfect.
Mine, on the other hand,
is getting higher by the minute.
Goodbye, Elsbeth.
Hope you can come see me win tomorrow.
(INDISTINCT CHATTER)
(SIGHS)
WAGNER: Come on.
Yeah! Attaboy.
Summerville, good catch.
ELSBETH: Good catch!
(BOTH CHUCKLE)
I really thought I had that last one.
- Yeah?
- Turns out
- didn't have it.
- Well,
next time, keep your feet on the ground.
No need to do a somersault.
Yes, Coach. (SNEEZES)
- Ah!
- Oh! I'm so sorry.
(SIGHS) My allergies have been
kicking my butt this year.
Gonzo and I were rolling around
in the grass the other day.
We were both up all night,
itchy and sneezy.
You know, Elsbeth
you can sit the game out
(GASPS) Oh, no. No.
Then we both took a little bit
of antihistamine
in a little bit of cheese
and we were good as new.
(GASPS)
I got it!
- (LAUGHS)
- Eh?
- Hey, now, Elsbeth.
- Oh.
(DOG YAPPING INSIDE)
Oh. You're back.
- And we brought your favorite.
- (DOG YAPPING)
KEEN: This is it!
It's never been so close.
- CROWD: Six!
- Tanaka and Baxter are
- neck and neck.
- Five!
- Four! Three!
- Who will pull ahead?
- It's
- Two! One!
Oh, heavens to Betsy!
Baxter takes it!
- He does it! He really does it!
- (CHEERING)
This is a Cinderella story
if I've ever heard one, folks.
Your newcomer, Cody Baxter,
has won the NYCCE championship!
(CHEERING CONTINUES)
(LAUGHING)
Yeah! (LAUGHS)
Mwah! Ha, ha! Loser!
Ooh, you're a loser!
You loser.
You lo
- Oh! He's making a run for it!
- Stop!
Unit 419 to Central! Suspect is fleeing
on foot! Male, 30s,
carrying a large hot dog trophy!
(SEAGULLS CALLING)
Move. Get out
Move! Out! Yes!
Get out of the way!
(GRUNTS)
(SHOUTS)
CODY: Oh. Oh, my God.
Oh. Too many hot dogs.
(PANTING)
(GRUNTS)
- (PANTING)
- (CODY GROANS)
Cody Baxter, you are under arrest
for the murder of Desi Orr.
How's that for spry?
SUMMERVILLE: That was my first chase!
I thought there'd be more in this job.
Whew. (EXHALES)
I have got to give you credit, Cody.
You told me yourself, you don't lie.
So yesterday, when you mentioned
your grandma's sick, old dog
(GROANS) I should have listened.
Grandma Mimi said
that Wilford had been
acting strange all week.
Because he wasn't getting his medicine.
The Vascilipine used to kill Desi
belonged to the dog.
Grandma Mimi was more than willing
to share with us
just how helpful you've been,
giving Wilford his medication
with this little syringe here.
CODY: That doesn't prove anything.
I'm the one that gives
that dumb dog his medication.
Mm-hmm. Who's gonna tell
you otherwise, huh?
The dog?
Oh, no. The dog wouldn't
tell us anything.
But the traces of raspberry jelly
found on the tip of the syringe
sure did.
It's the same raspberry jelly
from the donut
that you used to kill Desi.
You injected those meds
(IMITATES JELLY WHOOSHING)
right into the 51st donut.
I think I'm gonna be sick.
I hope you saved room for just desserts.
That's good.
(CHEERING)
(SHOUTS) Go!
Go! Go!
WAGNER: All right, listen up. Listen up.
We've played a good game.
Some might even say a great game.
But it all comes down to this.
This moment, right now.
Last licks.
Bases loaded. Two outs.
- We're on the razor's edge.
- Captain Wagner?
We don't need a home run.
We don't need a miracle.
We just need one run,
and it's ours for the taking.
- Captain Wagner!
- Uh, Elsbeth, I'm sort of
- in the middle of something here.
- I know,
but I haven't gotten to play yet.
And I really think I can do it.
(STAMMERS) She's
All right, Tascioni. You're up.
Yes!
Ay, battah battah.
Sa-wing battah!
Uh are you sure about this, Captain?
But I'm up to bat.
I've got this in the bag.
We're a team.
It's only fair that
Elsbeth gets a shot.
If we lose,
drinks are on me.
Elsbeth?
- Oh!
- Is that you?
(LAUGHS) Fire Marshal Jake.
What a small world!
How, uh, how-how you been?
- ELSBETH: Good!
- I-I never heard back from you
about going to dinner. I thought
You look, uh, good.
Oh. Why, thank you.
(GIGGLES)
- UMPIRE: Ball!
- WAGNER: All right.
TEAMMATE: Good eye. Good eye.
Ball two!
Oh, my God.
I don't believe it.
Yes.
Huh.
- UMPIRE: Ball three!
- (LAUGHS)
What is it with her and firemen?
BOTH: It's the hair.
This is it. Final pitch.
- Ball four! Take your base!
- Yes!
- (CHEERING)
- (WHISTLING)
(SHOUTING INDISTINCTLY)
I'm serious.
I haven't seen someone choke
so badly in my whole life.
That was awfully
clever thinking, Elsbeth.
Oh, I didn't do anything.
You guys did all the work. (CHUCKLES)
Besides, I think this is
my last softball game.
- What? Why?
- No.
But you won us the game.
Well, I'm not really an athlete.
I'm more of an arts-and-crafts gal.
And I don't think that my feminine wiles
will work the same on the team
from the sanitation department.
- (LAUGHTER)
- Well, Elsbeth,
I, too, want to commend you
on your quick thinking today.
And I would also personally
like to thank you
for helping me see that
winning is not the most
important thing in the world.
But it's damn nice when you do.
(LAUGHTER)
WAGNER: Elsbeth on three.
One, two, three!
ALL: Elsbeth!