Bull (2016) s05e15 Episode Script
Snatchback
1
Irina? Irina?
Irina? Hello.
Don't be scared.
I'm Hank.
I'm a friend of your mom's.
She wanted me to give you this.
Albert! See? Rinie, it's Mommy.
Mommy? I miss you so much.
Every second of every day since your dad took you, you're all I think about.
Now listen to me, lovebug.
I need you to go with Hank.
He's a nice man, and he's gonna bring you home to me.
So just do what he says, and everything will be fine.
I promise.
Be safe.
I love you.
So what do you say, Irina? You want to go home? - Yeah? - Yeah.
- Okay then.
- But wait.
It's almost 3:00.
That means my dad's already waiting out front with his scary driver.
They're never gonna let you take me.
Who said anything about going out the front? Okay, come on.
Okay.
Hop in.
There you go.
Good job.
Buckle up, kiddo.
Damn.
It's my dad! All right, come on.
Irina! You got to go with your dad now, okay? You're gonna be okay, I promise.
It's okay.
- Good Morning, Dr.
Bull.
- No.
No? I'm sorry.
It's not a good morning? No.
It may well be a good morning.
That was just a preemptive "no.
" Preemptive "no"? I like to start some conversations by setting expectations as low as possible.
And beginning with a "no" usually gets that done.
See? I can tell by the look on your face, it's working.
Okay, the thing is, I need a favor.
No.
See? That wasn't bad, was it? The first one kind of softened you up, took the sting out of it.
You took it like a champ.
Okay, so, it's not really a favor.
- I have a friend.
- Oh, lucky you.
And he could really use your help.
He's not looking for a freebie.
He's willing to pay.
He was just worried that if he cold-called you, you wouldn't agree to meet with him.
And why would he think that? Well, given what he does for a living.
And what's that? No.
No? "No" what? No, I'm not gonna tell you what he does for a living because you're gonna go over to the conference room where he's waiting, and you're gonna ask him yourself.
Are you saying "no" to me? Well, it's more of a preemptive "no.
" See, you took it like a champ.
You're gonna want to bring Chunk with you.
Name's Hank.
Hank Alston.
Danny tell you about me? Uh, well, not very much.
Former Army Ranger? Former a lot of things.
But what I am right now is a child recovery agent.
A child recovery agent? Not familiar with that line of work.
Well, I wasn't either till I got into it.
Turns out, abduction by a family member is the single most common type of child abduction worldwide.
That I did know.
The way it works in the United States One parent abducts a child, takes 'em overseas, there's really very little legal recourse for the other parent to do anything stateside.
And that's when, I'm guessing, a guy like you steps in.
- There you go.
- This problem that Danny mentioned you were having It's related to recovering children? So what'd they get you on? Kidnapping? Nope.
No, they're coming after me for fraud.
This woman Heather Shaughnessy she hired me about a year ago.
Got custody of her daughter in the divorce, but agreed to let her ex have visitation.
The guy grew up in Moscow.
So on one of his visits, he just up and flew back to Russia, took the little girl with him.
And the State Department couldn't do anything, because Russia's not one of our Hague Convention treaty partners.
So I got on a plane, figured I'd spend a couple weeks in-country, come up with an extraction plan, reunite the girl with her mom, that would be that.
Just like I've done a dozen other times.
In Russia? Never in Russia.
Anyway, second I got boots on the ground I realized this wasn't gonna be business as usual.
Turned out the dad has ties to organized crime.
He was always surrounded by muscle, and rarely left the girl alone.
Seemed like the chances of getting her out were slim to none.
Then why not call the whole thing off? Tell Heather Shaughnessy you couldn't do it? Now you're staring at 15 years.
Not an easy call to make.
You ever met a parent whose child has been taken? Whose kid is out there, but they can't get to 'em? Besides, I'm a Ranger.
I was trained to do the impossible.
Or at least trained to believe I could do the impossible.
So what exactly went wrong? They caught up with us on a public street.
Dad's goon brandished a firearm.
At that point, situation became unsafe for the child.
Had no choice but to let her go.
Plus, Dad got a good look at me, so there was no coming back and trying again.
So I came home.
And that's when Ms.
Shaughnessy went to the FBI? Look, I get it.
200 grand's a lot to pay for nothing.
Except it isn't nothing.
Even in failure.
I had to cover my expenses, I had to hire fixers, bribe a couple bureaucrats to make sure I had a way out of the country.
None of that comes cheap.
Thank you for stopping by, Mr.
Alston.
Mr.
Palmer and I are gonna discuss a few things.
We'll be in touch.
Look, I get why you're skeptical.
I know it all sounds pretty shady.
Well, Mr.
Alston, we're not implying I'm no saint.
When I left the service, I struggled.
Drank too much, got in some fights.
I was so used to having a mission that working mall security back in Georgia just kind of I was lost.
And one night, I'm having beers with a high school buddy.
He starts talking about how his crazy ex up and left, took their boy to Mexico.
Do I know anyone who could help bring him back? And I realized I could help.
And I did help.
And something clicked.
I had a purpose again.
Please.
I don't have a family.
I only have my work, and I'm good at it.
Thanks for your time.
I'll I'll be waiting for your call.
It's open.
Boy, are you hard to get a hold of all of a sudden.
Why aren't you answering your phone? Debate prep, debate prep, debate prep.
Got to write an opening statement.
No more than 90 seconds, no less than 75.
Two more weeks, thank goodness.
So, did you hear? Your opponent finally acknowledged you today.
A.
D.
A.
Messina, is this finally turning into a two-man race? I'm sorry.
Who-who would the other man be? I'm kidding.
I'm kidding.
Look, Benjamin Colón and I go way back.
All right, he's a fantastic person, he's a nice man.
The question is, is he really someone you would want to be the district attorney of the greatest city on earth? I mean, based on his record, I wouldn't think so.
All right? The man walked away from the D.
A.
's office eight years ago to go into private practice with a firm that all but guarantees, "You know, if you pay us enough money, "we can pick a jury that will give you the verdict you want.
" I mean, come on.
Is that what we really want in a D.
A.
? Someone who's happy to sell justice to the highest bidder? Doesn't sound right to me.
I would think that voters have to Ah.
Okay.
Isn't he the one that you told me about that everyone said withheld evidence when you two were working as A.
D.
A.
s? Well, that's what I heard.
But it doesn't make it true.
Look, I'd much rather tell them about me, okay? Me I can talk about, me I can vouch for.
Well, he didn't hesitate to talk about you at that press conference this morning.
Look, I'm just saying that maybe this debate is a good time to level the playing field.
Benny, I just want you to win.
Listen, it will be what it will be, okay? I got to run my race, and Messina's got to run his.
Now, why don't you get out of here so that way I can write this opening statement.
Well, you still got my vote.
So our new client travels to foreign countries, bribes officials, goes onto private property and kidnaps children? When he's successful at what he sets out to do, yes.
And that doesn't make him a criminal? No.
Sometimes you have to fight fire with fire.
If one parent steals a child from the rightful custodial parent, then flees to a country where the rightful custodial parent has no legal standing, what else is there to do? Just give up? And Hank's not answerable for what he does in a foreign country.
Not in our courts anyway.
He's only answerable for what he does in this country.
Beg to differ.
He sold his services in this country to a citizen of this country.
Marissa's right, and that is precisely why the government is charging him with fraud and not bribery, not kidnapping, or any other crime that would be considered illegal in this country.
That's why we have to build our case around intent.
Intent? If we can prove Hank genuinely intended to rescue that little girl, then there is no fraud.
And if there is no fraud, there is no case.
How the hell are we gonna prove intent? As far as I can tell, there's not a shred of evidence that the man did anything but take that woman's money, fly to Russia and have himself a nice little vacay.
We are obviously gonna need our client's help with that.
And we know he's done this kind of work before, and for lots of different people, so all we have to do is demonstrate that fact, show his track record of success.
And that is gonna go a long way with the jury.
What do you mean, "no"? I mean no.
I can't give you a list of the names of satisfied customers.
First thing I tell a parent once they get their child back is to disappear.
Vanish.
Do anything they have to to avoid retaliation, and they do.
A lot of them change their names, walk away from good jobs and friends and family.
I can't very well track 'em down, ask 'em to compromise themselves because I'm in a bad situation.
You two guys okay? - I'm good.
- We're good.
I mean, I know our client didn't promise up front that he could guarantee that he could bring the child home, but still, she took out a second mortgage - to pay that man.
- That's very compelling, but we need a jury who understands it's irrelevant.
How is that irrelevant? And why didn't the man just give her back her money when things fell apart? For the same reason we don't give our fee back whenever we lose a case.
I mean, just because we lose every once in a while doesn't mean it wasn't our intent to win.
And the same goes for Hank.
Sometimes you pay for the process, and the outcome is not guaranteed.
For its first witness, the prosecution would like to call Ms.
Heather Shaughnessy.
Nothing like starting off with a bang.
And at this point you'd paid him Almost $150,000, which was everything I had.
And the thing was, every time I would talk to Hank, he would ask for more money.
The mission was going on longer than expected.
He had to bribe this one, he had to pay off this one.
I had to go to the bank, get a loan on my house.
I-I have to ask, Ms.
Shaughnessy, if Hank Alston never gave you proof of his progress locating or retrieving Irina, why on earth did you keep giving him money? What choice did I have? He said he could bring my baby back.
I had to have my baby back.
And I was a fool.
I can see that now.
My husband stole my child, the bank took my house.
And that fraud stole any hope I had! And now my child is sick, and there is nothing that I can do to help her.
Did she just say her daughter is sick? That's what it sounded like.
Did you just testify that your daughter is ill? Is this new information? I got a call at 3:00 a.
m.
this morning.
It was a doctor in Moscow in a hospital.
He had my daughter, but he didn't have any vaccination records.
No records at all.
She has a fever, and they can't figure out why.
And they need my help, but I can't help them.
Objection.
Your Honor, we all feel for Ms.
Shaughnessy, but everything that she's testifying as it relates to her daughter's possible illness is both hearsay and irrelevant.
We have no idea of knowing whether or not the phone call actually happened.
We don't know who the man on the other end of the phone was, if he was a doctor or not.
We don't even know if her daughter is truly sick.
And none of this has anything to do with my client or the matter at hand.
I can't help her! I can't find the vaccination records because they're in a box, and I had to leave my house, and I can't find it.
- Your Honor - And I don't have the money to go - to Moscow because he took it from me.
- Ms.
Shaughnessy.
- And now - Your Honor, objection! - Ms.
Shaughnessy.
- instead of being there, where I'd actually be useful, which is with her! Ms.
Shaughnessy.
And now the judge is gonna tell us we won the point, but they won the game.
Mr.
Palmer, your objection is sustained.
The jury will disregard everything having to do with the possible illness of Ms.
Shaughnessy's daughter.
Right.
And they're gonna forget their cell phone numbers and the first time they had sex.
I'm warning the witness to limit her testimony to direct answers to the questions put to her.
Is that understood? Yes, Your Honor.
I apologize, Your Honor.
Do you have any more questions for this witness? Not at this time, Your Honor.
Then let's take a 30-minute recess.
On a scale from one to ten, how do you guys think we're doing? We're talking fractions.
Fractions of fractions.
About the only thing my team at the FBI could verify is Mr.
Alston's military record.
He was, in fact, an Army Ranger.
And what about the other claims the defendant made to convince Ms.
Shaughnessy to purchase his so-called services; The dozen or so families he allegedly helped, for example? Well, there's no record of any of that.
As far as we can tell, Mr.
Alston knew that Ms.
Shaughnessy was desperate, and he told her what she wanted to hear.
And his trip to Russia, did he make that up, too? No.
Mr.
Alston did travel to Russia.
His name can be found on airline passenger manifests.
But there's no indication that he attempted to locate Irina Belov while he was over there.
None of the government agencies he claimed to have had contact with have any record of him.
There's no attainable surveillance that puts him near the music school that he claims to have staked out.
So if Mr.
Alston wasn't trying to rescue a little girl, do you have any evidence indicating what he was doing in Russia? Well, uh, he certainly appeared to be enjoying himself.
And what makes you say that? His credit card transactions have him staying at some nice hotels in the best parts of town, eating at some fancy restaurants.
And on what I can only imagine was one particularly wild night, Mr.
Alston charged $20,000 to a high-end strip club called the Kitty Kat Kabaret.
No further questions for this witness.
Agent Camargo.
$20,000, that's a that's a lot of drinks.
A lot of dances.
Like I said, a wild night.
Maybe.
Maybe not.
You ever heard of a man named Dmitri Bulgakov? Um, sorry, I have not, no.
According to our research, he's the registered owner of the Kitty Kat Kabaret.
I guess I'll have to take your word for it.
Yeah.
Now, Agent Camargo, would it surprise you to learn that Interpol has identified Dmitri Bulgakov, the owner of said strip club, as a suspected money launderer for the very same crime syndicate that Irina's father has been associated with? The witness will answer the question.
I did not know that, no.
But now that you do, wouldn't you agree that it's just as likely that, rather than spending all that money on dances and champagne, that in all probability, it was a bribe to get information on the location of Irina Belov and her father? Objection.
This calls for speculation.
Your Honor, Agent Camargo has an extensive background investigating transnational organized crime in the Bureau.
She knows how information is gathered in a place like Russia, in a city like Moscow.
I'm simply asking for her professional opinion.
Overruled.
Ask your question again, Mr.
Palmer, and the witness will answer it.
Again, isn't it possible that Hank Alston paid $20,000 to Dmitri Bulgakov as a bribe in exchange for information on the whereabouts of Irina Belov so that he could craft a plan to get her out of Moscow, and deliver her to her mother, Heather Shaughnessy? Sure, it's possible.
And one other thing.
You mentioned that you could find no evidence to support my client's claim that he had done this kind of work successfully for other families.
Not a shred of evidence, no.
And did you find any evidence - to the contrary? - Excuse me? I would think that disgruntled ex-clients would be easy to find if he had any.
So my question for you is were you able to find any? No, we were not.
No further questions, Your Honor.
It's open.
- Sorry to intrude.
- Hey Twice in one week.
What's the occasion? I know last time we spoke you said that you would run your race and Messina would run his.
Mm-hmm.
That's all I know how to do.
But Messina's dragging your name through the mud every chance he gets.
Whether it's you leaving the D.
A.
's office to come work for TAC, or how you worked for a corrupt boss all those years, like David Sherman.
I never saw an ounce of corruption the whole time I was there.
He doesn't miss an opportunity to let the voters know that you're unfit to be New York's district attorney.
Like I said, I cannot control what he says.
I can't control how he runs his campaign.
The only campaign I can control is my own.
What's this? Our friend Mr.
Kiehl wanted you to see it.
He thought you would find it useful.
Okay, so two years ago Right before he was promoted to head of the trial division.
Messina completed a stint in an outpatient alcohol rehabilitation program.
Good for him.
So you know what that means.
He was an outpatient.
He was still handling cases.
So? So it strongly suggests that he may have very well been impaired while doing the job.
And Kiehl thinks that maybe we might be able to get some people in the D.
A.
's office to go on the record about it.
Who are you? And what have you done to my sister? Izzy This sounds like Messina had a personal problem and he took care of it.
It's to be applauded, not used as a billy club against him.
And I'd agree with you, except Kiehl doesn't think he actually did take care of it.
Apparently, a few weeks ago, Messina's campaign had a big fundraiser event.
Messina left before he was scheduled to speak.
And his staff told everyone that it was an asthma attack.
Something about the flowers at the venue.
He was actually rushed to the hospital for alcohol poisoning.
They had to pump his stomach.
Well, uh He still didn't break any laws.
No, but he got so out of control that he nearly killed himself.
Plus, he had his staff lie about it.
I'm sorry, I don't think that's the person most New Yorkers want to be their top prosecutor.
What would you have me do? Huh? Would you have me call a press conference and announce that the man has a drinking problem? That's not me.
I'm not that guy.
Kiehl says we can leak it anonymously.
And he swears it will never be traced back to you, he just wants your blessing.
Oh.
O-Okay.
Well, uh, thank him for me.
Tell him I get it.
And also tell him, "Not until hell freezes over.
" I knew from doing my homework that the father's driver was his bodyguard, his enforcer.
I also knew he carried a Yarygin, MP-443 Grach.
That gun can fire 17 or 18 rounds, depending.
If I'd have made a run for it with little Irina, that's 17 or 18 chances for him to try to stop me.
More importantly, that's 17 or 18 chances he might have hit her.
And what about the government's assertion that you, you never really tried to rescue Irina, that you were on some sort of a vacation at your client's expense? Irina, the little girl, she rides horses at a school on Begovaya Street twice a week.
The Arabian is her favorite.
She loves practicing the piano but hates performing.
She makes her father take her to this restaurant called Marina's for breakfast every Sunday.
I think it's 'cause it's the only place in Moscow with decent American pancakes.
I know all this 'cause I did my job, did my homework.
I tried my damnedest to bring that little girl back to her mother, just like I try my damnedest for all my clients.
I don't deny that I failed.
But failing is very different than choosing not to do the work.
No further questions, Your Honor.
I know you can't see their faces, but I think they're starting to hear us.
For what it's worth, I found his explanation very reasonable.
Very credible.
I'm telling you, he's a good man.
Your Honor, the people would like to present a video that we believe proves the witness Hank Alston just perjured himself.
Objection, Your Honor.
This is the first that we're hearing about any video.
We've not had a chance to examine any supposed evidence, let alone attempt to authenticate the video.
The video is a recording of Mr.
Alston.
He can authenticate it, Your Honor.
Very well.
I'll allow it.
Yeah, man, I've been working on my tan, but I get red first.
I burn first thing.
Cheers.
Is that you in the video, Mr.
Alston? I actually don't know.
Excuse me? You're under oath, Mr.
Alston, and I must tell you, the man on that screen certainly looks like you.
Now I'm gonna ask you one more time, is that you in the video? You're right.
It certainly looks like me.
But I have no recollection of being in that place, I can't recall ever owning that shirt, and my hand to God, I'm well aware of the fact that I'm under oath.
Bull, do you have any idea what's actually on that video, what this is about? - Not a clue.
- Perhaps if we play a little more of it? With the court's permission? Perhaps that will refresh the witness's memory? I'm told it's, uh, at a bar in Bangkok.
- You've been to Bangkok? - I have.
Your Honor, just for the record, my client's admission that he has been to Bangkok in no way constitutes authentication of this video.
Duly noted.
The jury will keep in mind that the video has not been authenticated.
That notwithstanding, let's see a little more of it.
Perhaps it will refresh the witness's memory.
Obviously, if it doesn't, we'll react accordingly.
Thank you, Your Honor.
So why abduction recovery, man? Like, what do you dig so much about the gig? What's not to love, bro? Think about it.
Desperate people are stupid people.
Desperate parents? You just hit the jackpot.
They'll give you as much money as you want.
You take a little, buy a plane ticket, have yourself a nice vacay, and just bank the rest.
Spin some crap about the mission going south Blah, blah, blah what are they gonna do about it? To me.
That's definitely not me.
I never been in that place, I never wore those clothes, and I've never said those words, not to anyone, not ever.
Was that not your face? Was that not your voice? It appears to be my face, it sure sounded like my voice, but that doesn't make it me.
Well, why don't we leave that for the jury to decide? No further questions.
Chunk, ask where the tape came from.
Look at his face.
Trust me, he knows.
You have a theory about that video, don't you? I sure do.
You care to share it with all of us? Objection.
Counsel is inviting the witness to speculate.
On the contrary, Your Honor.
This witness is an expert at getting into and getting out of places that he has not been invited to or is he allowed.
Now, he is in many ways, a master of disguise, a master of illusion.
And in so many words, he has intimated to this court that what we have just seen is an illusion.
I would very much like the jury to have the benefit of his expert opinion as to how it might have come to be.
Well done.
Given that we played your tape despite the fact that it remains unauthenticated by the witness, it doesn't seem unreasonable to allow that same witness an opportunity to explain what he thinks we saw.
The witness will answer the question.
I believe it's what's known as a deepfake.
And would you please explain to the jury what a deepfake is? It's like Photoshop for video.
You take a person in an existing video and you replace them with someone else's likeness, someone else's voice.
They're becoming very easy, very inexpensive to make.
You see a lot of them on social media.
Uh, okay, and-and just to be clear, you have no idea where this video came from, and you have no idea who made it? I can guess.
Look, there are only five or six of us who do this for a living.
Ms.
Shaughnessy's job, while it might sound like a lot of money, is actually on the more modest end of things.
There are million-dollar assignments out there.
I'm guessing a competitor heard about the trouble I was in and saw a way to put me out of business, thin the herd.
That'd be my guess.
That's an interesting theory.
And I guess the only way that we'll ever know is by asking my colleague who gave him the tape.
If I can please ask counsel to approach the bench? Well, here we are.
And may I ask how you came into possession of this tape? It was given to me by someone.
I know that.
Who? Someone w-who is best described as a colleague - of Mr.
Alston's.
- A competitor? I suppose some might consider him that.
You've put us in an interesting position, Mr.
Olsen.
Now we can bring in this "competitor" He's out of the country at the moment.
put him on the stand, dare him to commit perjury.
Or right here, right now, you can put us all out of our misery.
Yes, Your Honor.
I know what I have to do, Your Honor.
Then we'll resume.
If it pleases the court, it's come to our attention that the integrity of the tape we just offered into evidence may not be all that was originally represented to us.
With Your Honor's permission, we'd like to no longer have it considered for authentication or to be considered in any way as relevant evidence with regard to this case.
So ordered.
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, I would ask that you ignore everything you saw on this tape.
Its contents are going to be struck from the record and you will put no weight to anything you saw or heard during its presentation.
On the other hand, any inference you might take away from the prosecutor offering it to the court and moments later withdrawing it from the court are yours freely to make.
I got to tell you, Marissa, it's moments like these that make life worth living.
Hello? Sorry to wake you, but I wanted to let you know I got a hot tip from a guy that I used to work with at the Bureau.
He fields complaints from parents overseas who think Hank and the people who do what he does broke the law.
The point is, um, I got an address for a woman they are 99% sure Hank worked for about a year and a half ago.
Aha.
Hey, I'm not too late, am I? You guys haven't rested your case or anything, right? No.
We could still get her on the stand.
In fact, if her story checks out, she could be our first witness on Monday.
Fingers crossed she even opens the door when I knock on it.
So how does it work at that so-called "law office" you practice at, Benny? Do they have somebody at the door who frisks you to make sure you have enough money before letting you inside? Is there a big sign outside the front that says, "Justice for Sale"? Listen, here is the real truth.
Where I work, the people I work with, we work with the Federal Public Defender's Office, the State Public Defender's Office, Legal Aid, and a variety of nonprofits in every borough.
In fact, you'd be amazed at how many times in the last eight years I defended innocent people, often unemployed and in some cases mentally challenged, that your office decided to prosecute despite lack of evidence.
That is why, one of my first priorities when I become district attorney is to beef up the Conviction Integrity Unit so that way we can help right the wrongs - that you - First of all, pardon me.
- Right what wrongs? - Mr.
Messina, Mr.
Messina, if you could please give Mr.
Colón a chance to finish There's nothing wrong with locking up bad guys, Benny.
That's the job.
Or have you been getting rich helping criminals walk free for so long that you've forgotten about that? Because I highly doubt that those pro bono clients you're talking about are the ones paying your salary.
How much do you bill an hour these days, Benny? $800? A thousand? $1,500 an hour? Let's face it, folks.
Benny Colón does not care about you.
Because Benny is all about the Benjamins.
I know you don't want to hear this, but "Benny's all about the Benjamins" is trending.
It'll blow over.
It's a meme.
If something like that makes a difference between winning and losing Welcome to the 21st century.
A lot of times it does.
Benny, the guy you're running against is a bully.
He's also a liar.
He has questionable legal ethics and as we all know, a drinking problem so severe, that he ended up in the hospital recently.
Let me level this playing field for you.
Let me leak the story about him getting his stomach pumped.
The voters have a right to know.
This guy is dangerous.
Just give me the word, Benny.
Okay.
Do what you got to do.
My twins were six when everything fell apart.
Lucas, my youngest, he was just three.
I wanted them to have as much normalcy as possible during the divorce.
And we'd always gone to Brazil for Christmas to see their grandparents.
So I agreed that Beto could still take them that year.
Then he never brought them back.
Didn't let them contact me.
I tried to go to São Paulo myself, but I couldn't get a visa.
I didn't know if I'd ever see my kids again.
And then Hank he saved us.
He brought your kids back.
Yeah.
Got them across the border on a plane, and back into my arms without so much as a scratch on them.
Would you be willing to go to court? Tell that story under oath to a jury? You want me to go to court? In Manhattan? Hank needs to prove that he's not a fraud.
And your story would go a long way.
No.
I'm sorry.
I-I can't.
I-I want to help Hank, but We can keep your identity a secret.
We can keep your address a secret.
We can get you in and out You don't understand.
It's Beto.
He's here in the Northeast.
He's looking for us.
A friend called just yesterday.
He tried to bribe her to get the address.
I mean you found us.
I just I can't.
You still in Pennsylvania? Yeah, I'm right in front of the house.
And? Well, and the good news is this woman's story proves that Hank is the real deal.
The bad news is that her ex-husband is in New York and he's looking for her.
She's just too terrified of him to testify.
I'm sorry, Bull.
Please tell Hank that I'm sorry I let him down.
Wait a second, so you're telling me that this woman's ex is back in the country trying to steal back his kids and you're right in front of the address he's looking for? Yeah.
That's exactly what I'm telling you.
Well, whatever you do, don't move.
I'm gonna make some calls.
If we can't get a satisfied mom to testify, maybe angry dad is the next best thing.
Tilda! I know you're in there! Tilda, open up this door or I'll kick it in! You know, destruction of property carries jail time in Pennsylvania.
Who are you? Where's Matilda? - Where are my kids? - Oh, they're long gone.
I'm Danny James.
I'm guessing you're Beto Fontes? I'll take that as a yes.
What's this? That's a subpoena to appear in federal court.
As a witness for the defense in the case of The United States v.
Hank Alston.
Hank Alston? I don't think so.
Oh, I do.
Federal judges don't like to be ignored.
If you don't comply with this subpoena, you'll be arrested, then deported.
And almost certainly barred reentry into the United States.
So I'd show up if I were you.
Thank you for joining us today, Mr.
Fontes.
Now you are a resident of São Paolo, Brazil, is that correct? Yes.
That's correct.
And what brings you to the States? I'm here on business.
Oh, would that be professional business or personal business? Just business.
I'm sorry, you're not answering my question, Mr.
Fontes.
Is the nature of your business professional or personal? I don't know about this, Bull.
This man clearly hates our client.
How can we be sure he's gonna say what we want? Actually, we're counting on the fact that he won't.
And then that he will.
Listen and learn.
Let's try it a different way.
Does my client, Hank Alston, have anything to do with your business here in the States? Your client steals children.
He does this for money.
You're not answering my question, Mr.
Fontes.
Step one.
Your Honor, as Mr.
Fontes is clearly unwilling to answer the questions being asked, unwilling to cooperate at all, I request permission to treat him as a hostile witness.
Permission granted.
Mr.
Fontes, you've just been declared a hostile witness.
Do you know what that means? No.
Nor do I care.
It means that I get to ask you leading questions.
Do you know what a leading question is? It means that I get to ask you a question that contains the answer that I'm looking for.
Now, normally I don't get to do that, it's not allowed.
But because you've been declared hostile You know what? Here, let me let me give you an example.
You are here in the United States because this is where your children live, is that correct? In fact, you came here to steal them back.
Didn't you? You do know that that's against U.
S.
law? And by the way, so is perjury.
I'm waiting for an answer, sir.
The witness will answer the question or be held in contempt.
I'm here to see my children.
I have a right to see my children.
Well, not according to U.
S.
law you don't.
Not since you kidnapped them from their mother.
Sorry, I forgot to tell you.
We're deep into step two.
You kidnapped your children from their mother, their legal guardian, and you held them captive in your home in Brazil, didn't you? No.
No? Yes, you did.
In fact, the only reason those kids are safely back in the States with their mother is because that man, my client, flew down to Brazil and rescued them.
"Rescued them"? From me? They are mine.
I am their father! Your client is the kidnapper! The thief! He snuck into my home in the middle of the night and snatched my children from their beds! I saw him climbing over the wall with my little boy! He is the criminal, not me! So you're testifying under oath that you saw my client break into your home and take your children for the sole purpose of returning them to their mother, who the U.
S.
government says is their primary parent? Hell yes.
Ta-da.
Ah, two of my favorite words in the English language.
"Not guilty.
" I can't thank you guys enough.
And Matilda and her kids? They're safe our team made sure they were safe.
I don't know what to say.
What's next? Where you jetting off to? Well I think the next thing is I shave off all this hair, get some different clothes, get another plane ticket to Russia, try one more time to bring that lady's little girl home.
Well, let us know how it goes.
Be careful.
I will.
Mr.
Palmer, Dr.
Bull.
Ladies and gentlemen of the press, thank you for coming out here today.
After a great deal of soul-searching, I have decided to withdraw from the race for district attorney of the city of New York.
Um Well, the truth is that I've been struggling for quite some time with a number of personal problems.
And I thought I had licked them.
But clearly I'm not quite there yet.
So for that reason, I'm gonna take a step back.
And I'm gonna focus on my recovery and my health
Don't be scared.
I'm Hank.
I'm a friend of your mom's.
She wanted me to give you this.
Albert! See? Rinie, it's Mommy.
Mommy? I miss you so much.
Every second of every day since your dad took you, you're all I think about.
Now listen to me, lovebug.
I need you to go with Hank.
He's a nice man, and he's gonna bring you home to me.
So just do what he says, and everything will be fine.
I promise.
Be safe.
I love you.
So what do you say, Irina? You want to go home? - Yeah? - Yeah.
- Okay then.
- But wait.
It's almost 3:00.
That means my dad's already waiting out front with his scary driver.
They're never gonna let you take me.
Who said anything about going out the front? Okay, come on.
Okay.
Hop in.
There you go.
Good job.
Buckle up, kiddo.
Damn.
It's my dad! All right, come on.
Irina! You got to go with your dad now, okay? You're gonna be okay, I promise.
It's okay.
- Good Morning, Dr.
Bull.
- No.
No? I'm sorry.
It's not a good morning? No.
It may well be a good morning.
That was just a preemptive "no.
" Preemptive "no"? I like to start some conversations by setting expectations as low as possible.
And beginning with a "no" usually gets that done.
See? I can tell by the look on your face, it's working.
Okay, the thing is, I need a favor.
No.
See? That wasn't bad, was it? The first one kind of softened you up, took the sting out of it.
You took it like a champ.
Okay, so, it's not really a favor.
- I have a friend.
- Oh, lucky you.
And he could really use your help.
He's not looking for a freebie.
He's willing to pay.
He was just worried that if he cold-called you, you wouldn't agree to meet with him.
And why would he think that? Well, given what he does for a living.
And what's that? No.
No? "No" what? No, I'm not gonna tell you what he does for a living because you're gonna go over to the conference room where he's waiting, and you're gonna ask him yourself.
Are you saying "no" to me? Well, it's more of a preemptive "no.
" See, you took it like a champ.
You're gonna want to bring Chunk with you.
Name's Hank.
Hank Alston.
Danny tell you about me? Uh, well, not very much.
Former Army Ranger? Former a lot of things.
But what I am right now is a child recovery agent.
A child recovery agent? Not familiar with that line of work.
Well, I wasn't either till I got into it.
Turns out, abduction by a family member is the single most common type of child abduction worldwide.
That I did know.
The way it works in the United States One parent abducts a child, takes 'em overseas, there's really very little legal recourse for the other parent to do anything stateside.
And that's when, I'm guessing, a guy like you steps in.
- There you go.
- This problem that Danny mentioned you were having It's related to recovering children? So what'd they get you on? Kidnapping? Nope.
No, they're coming after me for fraud.
This woman Heather Shaughnessy she hired me about a year ago.
Got custody of her daughter in the divorce, but agreed to let her ex have visitation.
The guy grew up in Moscow.
So on one of his visits, he just up and flew back to Russia, took the little girl with him.
And the State Department couldn't do anything, because Russia's not one of our Hague Convention treaty partners.
So I got on a plane, figured I'd spend a couple weeks in-country, come up with an extraction plan, reunite the girl with her mom, that would be that.
Just like I've done a dozen other times.
In Russia? Never in Russia.
Anyway, second I got boots on the ground I realized this wasn't gonna be business as usual.
Turned out the dad has ties to organized crime.
He was always surrounded by muscle, and rarely left the girl alone.
Seemed like the chances of getting her out were slim to none.
Then why not call the whole thing off? Tell Heather Shaughnessy you couldn't do it? Now you're staring at 15 years.
Not an easy call to make.
You ever met a parent whose child has been taken? Whose kid is out there, but they can't get to 'em? Besides, I'm a Ranger.
I was trained to do the impossible.
Or at least trained to believe I could do the impossible.
So what exactly went wrong? They caught up with us on a public street.
Dad's goon brandished a firearm.
At that point, situation became unsafe for the child.
Had no choice but to let her go.
Plus, Dad got a good look at me, so there was no coming back and trying again.
So I came home.
And that's when Ms.
Shaughnessy went to the FBI? Look, I get it.
200 grand's a lot to pay for nothing.
Except it isn't nothing.
Even in failure.
I had to cover my expenses, I had to hire fixers, bribe a couple bureaucrats to make sure I had a way out of the country.
None of that comes cheap.
Thank you for stopping by, Mr.
Alston.
Mr.
Palmer and I are gonna discuss a few things.
We'll be in touch.
Look, I get why you're skeptical.
I know it all sounds pretty shady.
Well, Mr.
Alston, we're not implying I'm no saint.
When I left the service, I struggled.
Drank too much, got in some fights.
I was so used to having a mission that working mall security back in Georgia just kind of I was lost.
And one night, I'm having beers with a high school buddy.
He starts talking about how his crazy ex up and left, took their boy to Mexico.
Do I know anyone who could help bring him back? And I realized I could help.
And I did help.
And something clicked.
I had a purpose again.
Please.
I don't have a family.
I only have my work, and I'm good at it.
Thanks for your time.
I'll I'll be waiting for your call.
It's open.
Boy, are you hard to get a hold of all of a sudden.
Why aren't you answering your phone? Debate prep, debate prep, debate prep.
Got to write an opening statement.
No more than 90 seconds, no less than 75.
Two more weeks, thank goodness.
So, did you hear? Your opponent finally acknowledged you today.
A.
D.
A.
Messina, is this finally turning into a two-man race? I'm sorry.
Who-who would the other man be? I'm kidding.
I'm kidding.
Look, Benjamin Colón and I go way back.
All right, he's a fantastic person, he's a nice man.
The question is, is he really someone you would want to be the district attorney of the greatest city on earth? I mean, based on his record, I wouldn't think so.
All right? The man walked away from the D.
A.
's office eight years ago to go into private practice with a firm that all but guarantees, "You know, if you pay us enough money, "we can pick a jury that will give you the verdict you want.
" I mean, come on.
Is that what we really want in a D.
A.
? Someone who's happy to sell justice to the highest bidder? Doesn't sound right to me.
I would think that voters have to Ah.
Okay.
Isn't he the one that you told me about that everyone said withheld evidence when you two were working as A.
D.
A.
s? Well, that's what I heard.
But it doesn't make it true.
Look, I'd much rather tell them about me, okay? Me I can talk about, me I can vouch for.
Well, he didn't hesitate to talk about you at that press conference this morning.
Look, I'm just saying that maybe this debate is a good time to level the playing field.
Benny, I just want you to win.
Listen, it will be what it will be, okay? I got to run my race, and Messina's got to run his.
Now, why don't you get out of here so that way I can write this opening statement.
Well, you still got my vote.
So our new client travels to foreign countries, bribes officials, goes onto private property and kidnaps children? When he's successful at what he sets out to do, yes.
And that doesn't make him a criminal? No.
Sometimes you have to fight fire with fire.
If one parent steals a child from the rightful custodial parent, then flees to a country where the rightful custodial parent has no legal standing, what else is there to do? Just give up? And Hank's not answerable for what he does in a foreign country.
Not in our courts anyway.
He's only answerable for what he does in this country.
Beg to differ.
He sold his services in this country to a citizen of this country.
Marissa's right, and that is precisely why the government is charging him with fraud and not bribery, not kidnapping, or any other crime that would be considered illegal in this country.
That's why we have to build our case around intent.
Intent? If we can prove Hank genuinely intended to rescue that little girl, then there is no fraud.
And if there is no fraud, there is no case.
How the hell are we gonna prove intent? As far as I can tell, there's not a shred of evidence that the man did anything but take that woman's money, fly to Russia and have himself a nice little vacay.
We are obviously gonna need our client's help with that.
And we know he's done this kind of work before, and for lots of different people, so all we have to do is demonstrate that fact, show his track record of success.
And that is gonna go a long way with the jury.
What do you mean, "no"? I mean no.
I can't give you a list of the names of satisfied customers.
First thing I tell a parent once they get their child back is to disappear.
Vanish.
Do anything they have to to avoid retaliation, and they do.
A lot of them change their names, walk away from good jobs and friends and family.
I can't very well track 'em down, ask 'em to compromise themselves because I'm in a bad situation.
You two guys okay? - I'm good.
- We're good.
I mean, I know our client didn't promise up front that he could guarantee that he could bring the child home, but still, she took out a second mortgage - to pay that man.
- That's very compelling, but we need a jury who understands it's irrelevant.
How is that irrelevant? And why didn't the man just give her back her money when things fell apart? For the same reason we don't give our fee back whenever we lose a case.
I mean, just because we lose every once in a while doesn't mean it wasn't our intent to win.
And the same goes for Hank.
Sometimes you pay for the process, and the outcome is not guaranteed.
For its first witness, the prosecution would like to call Ms.
Heather Shaughnessy.
Nothing like starting off with a bang.
And at this point you'd paid him Almost $150,000, which was everything I had.
And the thing was, every time I would talk to Hank, he would ask for more money.
The mission was going on longer than expected.
He had to bribe this one, he had to pay off this one.
I had to go to the bank, get a loan on my house.
I-I have to ask, Ms.
Shaughnessy, if Hank Alston never gave you proof of his progress locating or retrieving Irina, why on earth did you keep giving him money? What choice did I have? He said he could bring my baby back.
I had to have my baby back.
And I was a fool.
I can see that now.
My husband stole my child, the bank took my house.
And that fraud stole any hope I had! And now my child is sick, and there is nothing that I can do to help her.
Did she just say her daughter is sick? That's what it sounded like.
Did you just testify that your daughter is ill? Is this new information? I got a call at 3:00 a.
m.
this morning.
It was a doctor in Moscow in a hospital.
He had my daughter, but he didn't have any vaccination records.
No records at all.
She has a fever, and they can't figure out why.
And they need my help, but I can't help them.
Objection.
Your Honor, we all feel for Ms.
Shaughnessy, but everything that she's testifying as it relates to her daughter's possible illness is both hearsay and irrelevant.
We have no idea of knowing whether or not the phone call actually happened.
We don't know who the man on the other end of the phone was, if he was a doctor or not.
We don't even know if her daughter is truly sick.
And none of this has anything to do with my client or the matter at hand.
I can't help her! I can't find the vaccination records because they're in a box, and I had to leave my house, and I can't find it.
- Your Honor - And I don't have the money to go - to Moscow because he took it from me.
- Ms.
Shaughnessy.
- And now - Your Honor, objection! - Ms.
Shaughnessy.
- instead of being there, where I'd actually be useful, which is with her! Ms.
Shaughnessy.
And now the judge is gonna tell us we won the point, but they won the game.
Mr.
Palmer, your objection is sustained.
The jury will disregard everything having to do with the possible illness of Ms.
Shaughnessy's daughter.
Right.
And they're gonna forget their cell phone numbers and the first time they had sex.
I'm warning the witness to limit her testimony to direct answers to the questions put to her.
Is that understood? Yes, Your Honor.
I apologize, Your Honor.
Do you have any more questions for this witness? Not at this time, Your Honor.
Then let's take a 30-minute recess.
On a scale from one to ten, how do you guys think we're doing? We're talking fractions.
Fractions of fractions.
About the only thing my team at the FBI could verify is Mr.
Alston's military record.
He was, in fact, an Army Ranger.
And what about the other claims the defendant made to convince Ms.
Shaughnessy to purchase his so-called services; The dozen or so families he allegedly helped, for example? Well, there's no record of any of that.
As far as we can tell, Mr.
Alston knew that Ms.
Shaughnessy was desperate, and he told her what she wanted to hear.
And his trip to Russia, did he make that up, too? No.
Mr.
Alston did travel to Russia.
His name can be found on airline passenger manifests.
But there's no indication that he attempted to locate Irina Belov while he was over there.
None of the government agencies he claimed to have had contact with have any record of him.
There's no attainable surveillance that puts him near the music school that he claims to have staked out.
So if Mr.
Alston wasn't trying to rescue a little girl, do you have any evidence indicating what he was doing in Russia? Well, uh, he certainly appeared to be enjoying himself.
And what makes you say that? His credit card transactions have him staying at some nice hotels in the best parts of town, eating at some fancy restaurants.
And on what I can only imagine was one particularly wild night, Mr.
Alston charged $20,000 to a high-end strip club called the Kitty Kat Kabaret.
No further questions for this witness.
Agent Camargo.
$20,000, that's a that's a lot of drinks.
A lot of dances.
Like I said, a wild night.
Maybe.
Maybe not.
You ever heard of a man named Dmitri Bulgakov? Um, sorry, I have not, no.
According to our research, he's the registered owner of the Kitty Kat Kabaret.
I guess I'll have to take your word for it.
Yeah.
Now, Agent Camargo, would it surprise you to learn that Interpol has identified Dmitri Bulgakov, the owner of said strip club, as a suspected money launderer for the very same crime syndicate that Irina's father has been associated with? The witness will answer the question.
I did not know that, no.
But now that you do, wouldn't you agree that it's just as likely that, rather than spending all that money on dances and champagne, that in all probability, it was a bribe to get information on the location of Irina Belov and her father? Objection.
This calls for speculation.
Your Honor, Agent Camargo has an extensive background investigating transnational organized crime in the Bureau.
She knows how information is gathered in a place like Russia, in a city like Moscow.
I'm simply asking for her professional opinion.
Overruled.
Ask your question again, Mr.
Palmer, and the witness will answer it.
Again, isn't it possible that Hank Alston paid $20,000 to Dmitri Bulgakov as a bribe in exchange for information on the whereabouts of Irina Belov so that he could craft a plan to get her out of Moscow, and deliver her to her mother, Heather Shaughnessy? Sure, it's possible.
And one other thing.
You mentioned that you could find no evidence to support my client's claim that he had done this kind of work successfully for other families.
Not a shred of evidence, no.
And did you find any evidence - to the contrary? - Excuse me? I would think that disgruntled ex-clients would be easy to find if he had any.
So my question for you is were you able to find any? No, we were not.
No further questions, Your Honor.
It's open.
- Sorry to intrude.
- Hey Twice in one week.
What's the occasion? I know last time we spoke you said that you would run your race and Messina would run his.
Mm-hmm.
That's all I know how to do.
But Messina's dragging your name through the mud every chance he gets.
Whether it's you leaving the D.
A.
's office to come work for TAC, or how you worked for a corrupt boss all those years, like David Sherman.
I never saw an ounce of corruption the whole time I was there.
He doesn't miss an opportunity to let the voters know that you're unfit to be New York's district attorney.
Like I said, I cannot control what he says.
I can't control how he runs his campaign.
The only campaign I can control is my own.
What's this? Our friend Mr.
Kiehl wanted you to see it.
He thought you would find it useful.
Okay, so two years ago Right before he was promoted to head of the trial division.
Messina completed a stint in an outpatient alcohol rehabilitation program.
Good for him.
So you know what that means.
He was an outpatient.
He was still handling cases.
So? So it strongly suggests that he may have very well been impaired while doing the job.
And Kiehl thinks that maybe we might be able to get some people in the D.
A.
's office to go on the record about it.
Who are you? And what have you done to my sister? Izzy This sounds like Messina had a personal problem and he took care of it.
It's to be applauded, not used as a billy club against him.
And I'd agree with you, except Kiehl doesn't think he actually did take care of it.
Apparently, a few weeks ago, Messina's campaign had a big fundraiser event.
Messina left before he was scheduled to speak.
And his staff told everyone that it was an asthma attack.
Something about the flowers at the venue.
He was actually rushed to the hospital for alcohol poisoning.
They had to pump his stomach.
Well, uh He still didn't break any laws.
No, but he got so out of control that he nearly killed himself.
Plus, he had his staff lie about it.
I'm sorry, I don't think that's the person most New Yorkers want to be their top prosecutor.
What would you have me do? Huh? Would you have me call a press conference and announce that the man has a drinking problem? That's not me.
I'm not that guy.
Kiehl says we can leak it anonymously.
And he swears it will never be traced back to you, he just wants your blessing.
Oh.
O-Okay.
Well, uh, thank him for me.
Tell him I get it.
And also tell him, "Not until hell freezes over.
" I knew from doing my homework that the father's driver was his bodyguard, his enforcer.
I also knew he carried a Yarygin, MP-443 Grach.
That gun can fire 17 or 18 rounds, depending.
If I'd have made a run for it with little Irina, that's 17 or 18 chances for him to try to stop me.
More importantly, that's 17 or 18 chances he might have hit her.
And what about the government's assertion that you, you never really tried to rescue Irina, that you were on some sort of a vacation at your client's expense? Irina, the little girl, she rides horses at a school on Begovaya Street twice a week.
The Arabian is her favorite.
She loves practicing the piano but hates performing.
She makes her father take her to this restaurant called Marina's for breakfast every Sunday.
I think it's 'cause it's the only place in Moscow with decent American pancakes.
I know all this 'cause I did my job, did my homework.
I tried my damnedest to bring that little girl back to her mother, just like I try my damnedest for all my clients.
I don't deny that I failed.
But failing is very different than choosing not to do the work.
No further questions, Your Honor.
I know you can't see their faces, but I think they're starting to hear us.
For what it's worth, I found his explanation very reasonable.
Very credible.
I'm telling you, he's a good man.
Your Honor, the people would like to present a video that we believe proves the witness Hank Alston just perjured himself.
Objection, Your Honor.
This is the first that we're hearing about any video.
We've not had a chance to examine any supposed evidence, let alone attempt to authenticate the video.
The video is a recording of Mr.
Alston.
He can authenticate it, Your Honor.
Very well.
I'll allow it.
Yeah, man, I've been working on my tan, but I get red first.
I burn first thing.
Cheers.
Is that you in the video, Mr.
Alston? I actually don't know.
Excuse me? You're under oath, Mr.
Alston, and I must tell you, the man on that screen certainly looks like you.
Now I'm gonna ask you one more time, is that you in the video? You're right.
It certainly looks like me.
But I have no recollection of being in that place, I can't recall ever owning that shirt, and my hand to God, I'm well aware of the fact that I'm under oath.
Bull, do you have any idea what's actually on that video, what this is about? - Not a clue.
- Perhaps if we play a little more of it? With the court's permission? Perhaps that will refresh the witness's memory? I'm told it's, uh, at a bar in Bangkok.
- You've been to Bangkok? - I have.
Your Honor, just for the record, my client's admission that he has been to Bangkok in no way constitutes authentication of this video.
Duly noted.
The jury will keep in mind that the video has not been authenticated.
That notwithstanding, let's see a little more of it.
Perhaps it will refresh the witness's memory.
Obviously, if it doesn't, we'll react accordingly.
Thank you, Your Honor.
So why abduction recovery, man? Like, what do you dig so much about the gig? What's not to love, bro? Think about it.
Desperate people are stupid people.
Desperate parents? You just hit the jackpot.
They'll give you as much money as you want.
You take a little, buy a plane ticket, have yourself a nice vacay, and just bank the rest.
Spin some crap about the mission going south Blah, blah, blah what are they gonna do about it? To me.
That's definitely not me.
I never been in that place, I never wore those clothes, and I've never said those words, not to anyone, not ever.
Was that not your face? Was that not your voice? It appears to be my face, it sure sounded like my voice, but that doesn't make it me.
Well, why don't we leave that for the jury to decide? No further questions.
Chunk, ask where the tape came from.
Look at his face.
Trust me, he knows.
You have a theory about that video, don't you? I sure do.
You care to share it with all of us? Objection.
Counsel is inviting the witness to speculate.
On the contrary, Your Honor.
This witness is an expert at getting into and getting out of places that he has not been invited to or is he allowed.
Now, he is in many ways, a master of disguise, a master of illusion.
And in so many words, he has intimated to this court that what we have just seen is an illusion.
I would very much like the jury to have the benefit of his expert opinion as to how it might have come to be.
Well done.
Given that we played your tape despite the fact that it remains unauthenticated by the witness, it doesn't seem unreasonable to allow that same witness an opportunity to explain what he thinks we saw.
The witness will answer the question.
I believe it's what's known as a deepfake.
And would you please explain to the jury what a deepfake is? It's like Photoshop for video.
You take a person in an existing video and you replace them with someone else's likeness, someone else's voice.
They're becoming very easy, very inexpensive to make.
You see a lot of them on social media.
Uh, okay, and-and just to be clear, you have no idea where this video came from, and you have no idea who made it? I can guess.
Look, there are only five or six of us who do this for a living.
Ms.
Shaughnessy's job, while it might sound like a lot of money, is actually on the more modest end of things.
There are million-dollar assignments out there.
I'm guessing a competitor heard about the trouble I was in and saw a way to put me out of business, thin the herd.
That'd be my guess.
That's an interesting theory.
And I guess the only way that we'll ever know is by asking my colleague who gave him the tape.
If I can please ask counsel to approach the bench? Well, here we are.
And may I ask how you came into possession of this tape? It was given to me by someone.
I know that.
Who? Someone w-who is best described as a colleague - of Mr.
Alston's.
- A competitor? I suppose some might consider him that.
You've put us in an interesting position, Mr.
Olsen.
Now we can bring in this "competitor" He's out of the country at the moment.
put him on the stand, dare him to commit perjury.
Or right here, right now, you can put us all out of our misery.
Yes, Your Honor.
I know what I have to do, Your Honor.
Then we'll resume.
If it pleases the court, it's come to our attention that the integrity of the tape we just offered into evidence may not be all that was originally represented to us.
With Your Honor's permission, we'd like to no longer have it considered for authentication or to be considered in any way as relevant evidence with regard to this case.
So ordered.
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, I would ask that you ignore everything you saw on this tape.
Its contents are going to be struck from the record and you will put no weight to anything you saw or heard during its presentation.
On the other hand, any inference you might take away from the prosecutor offering it to the court and moments later withdrawing it from the court are yours freely to make.
I got to tell you, Marissa, it's moments like these that make life worth living.
Hello? Sorry to wake you, but I wanted to let you know I got a hot tip from a guy that I used to work with at the Bureau.
He fields complaints from parents overseas who think Hank and the people who do what he does broke the law.
The point is, um, I got an address for a woman they are 99% sure Hank worked for about a year and a half ago.
Aha.
Hey, I'm not too late, am I? You guys haven't rested your case or anything, right? No.
We could still get her on the stand.
In fact, if her story checks out, she could be our first witness on Monday.
Fingers crossed she even opens the door when I knock on it.
So how does it work at that so-called "law office" you practice at, Benny? Do they have somebody at the door who frisks you to make sure you have enough money before letting you inside? Is there a big sign outside the front that says, "Justice for Sale"? Listen, here is the real truth.
Where I work, the people I work with, we work with the Federal Public Defender's Office, the State Public Defender's Office, Legal Aid, and a variety of nonprofits in every borough.
In fact, you'd be amazed at how many times in the last eight years I defended innocent people, often unemployed and in some cases mentally challenged, that your office decided to prosecute despite lack of evidence.
That is why, one of my first priorities when I become district attorney is to beef up the Conviction Integrity Unit so that way we can help right the wrongs - that you - First of all, pardon me.
- Right what wrongs? - Mr.
Messina, Mr.
Messina, if you could please give Mr.
Colón a chance to finish There's nothing wrong with locking up bad guys, Benny.
That's the job.
Or have you been getting rich helping criminals walk free for so long that you've forgotten about that? Because I highly doubt that those pro bono clients you're talking about are the ones paying your salary.
How much do you bill an hour these days, Benny? $800? A thousand? $1,500 an hour? Let's face it, folks.
Benny Colón does not care about you.
Because Benny is all about the Benjamins.
I know you don't want to hear this, but "Benny's all about the Benjamins" is trending.
It'll blow over.
It's a meme.
If something like that makes a difference between winning and losing Welcome to the 21st century.
A lot of times it does.
Benny, the guy you're running against is a bully.
He's also a liar.
He has questionable legal ethics and as we all know, a drinking problem so severe, that he ended up in the hospital recently.
Let me level this playing field for you.
Let me leak the story about him getting his stomach pumped.
The voters have a right to know.
This guy is dangerous.
Just give me the word, Benny.
Okay.
Do what you got to do.
My twins were six when everything fell apart.
Lucas, my youngest, he was just three.
I wanted them to have as much normalcy as possible during the divorce.
And we'd always gone to Brazil for Christmas to see their grandparents.
So I agreed that Beto could still take them that year.
Then he never brought them back.
Didn't let them contact me.
I tried to go to São Paulo myself, but I couldn't get a visa.
I didn't know if I'd ever see my kids again.
And then Hank he saved us.
He brought your kids back.
Yeah.
Got them across the border on a plane, and back into my arms without so much as a scratch on them.
Would you be willing to go to court? Tell that story under oath to a jury? You want me to go to court? In Manhattan? Hank needs to prove that he's not a fraud.
And your story would go a long way.
No.
I'm sorry.
I-I can't.
I-I want to help Hank, but We can keep your identity a secret.
We can keep your address a secret.
We can get you in and out You don't understand.
It's Beto.
He's here in the Northeast.
He's looking for us.
A friend called just yesterday.
He tried to bribe her to get the address.
I mean you found us.
I just I can't.
You still in Pennsylvania? Yeah, I'm right in front of the house.
And? Well, and the good news is this woman's story proves that Hank is the real deal.
The bad news is that her ex-husband is in New York and he's looking for her.
She's just too terrified of him to testify.
I'm sorry, Bull.
Please tell Hank that I'm sorry I let him down.
Wait a second, so you're telling me that this woman's ex is back in the country trying to steal back his kids and you're right in front of the address he's looking for? Yeah.
That's exactly what I'm telling you.
Well, whatever you do, don't move.
I'm gonna make some calls.
If we can't get a satisfied mom to testify, maybe angry dad is the next best thing.
Tilda! I know you're in there! Tilda, open up this door or I'll kick it in! You know, destruction of property carries jail time in Pennsylvania.
Who are you? Where's Matilda? - Where are my kids? - Oh, they're long gone.
I'm Danny James.
I'm guessing you're Beto Fontes? I'll take that as a yes.
What's this? That's a subpoena to appear in federal court.
As a witness for the defense in the case of The United States v.
Hank Alston.
Hank Alston? I don't think so.
Oh, I do.
Federal judges don't like to be ignored.
If you don't comply with this subpoena, you'll be arrested, then deported.
And almost certainly barred reentry into the United States.
So I'd show up if I were you.
Thank you for joining us today, Mr.
Fontes.
Now you are a resident of São Paolo, Brazil, is that correct? Yes.
That's correct.
And what brings you to the States? I'm here on business.
Oh, would that be professional business or personal business? Just business.
I'm sorry, you're not answering my question, Mr.
Fontes.
Is the nature of your business professional or personal? I don't know about this, Bull.
This man clearly hates our client.
How can we be sure he's gonna say what we want? Actually, we're counting on the fact that he won't.
And then that he will.
Listen and learn.
Let's try it a different way.
Does my client, Hank Alston, have anything to do with your business here in the States? Your client steals children.
He does this for money.
You're not answering my question, Mr.
Fontes.
Step one.
Your Honor, as Mr.
Fontes is clearly unwilling to answer the questions being asked, unwilling to cooperate at all, I request permission to treat him as a hostile witness.
Permission granted.
Mr.
Fontes, you've just been declared a hostile witness.
Do you know what that means? No.
Nor do I care.
It means that I get to ask you leading questions.
Do you know what a leading question is? It means that I get to ask you a question that contains the answer that I'm looking for.
Now, normally I don't get to do that, it's not allowed.
But because you've been declared hostile You know what? Here, let me let me give you an example.
You are here in the United States because this is where your children live, is that correct? In fact, you came here to steal them back.
Didn't you? You do know that that's against U.
S.
law? And by the way, so is perjury.
I'm waiting for an answer, sir.
The witness will answer the question or be held in contempt.
I'm here to see my children.
I have a right to see my children.
Well, not according to U.
S.
law you don't.
Not since you kidnapped them from their mother.
Sorry, I forgot to tell you.
We're deep into step two.
You kidnapped your children from their mother, their legal guardian, and you held them captive in your home in Brazil, didn't you? No.
No? Yes, you did.
In fact, the only reason those kids are safely back in the States with their mother is because that man, my client, flew down to Brazil and rescued them.
"Rescued them"? From me? They are mine.
I am their father! Your client is the kidnapper! The thief! He snuck into my home in the middle of the night and snatched my children from their beds! I saw him climbing over the wall with my little boy! He is the criminal, not me! So you're testifying under oath that you saw my client break into your home and take your children for the sole purpose of returning them to their mother, who the U.
S.
government says is their primary parent? Hell yes.
Ta-da.
Ah, two of my favorite words in the English language.
"Not guilty.
" I can't thank you guys enough.
And Matilda and her kids? They're safe our team made sure they were safe.
I don't know what to say.
What's next? Where you jetting off to? Well I think the next thing is I shave off all this hair, get some different clothes, get another plane ticket to Russia, try one more time to bring that lady's little girl home.
Well, let us know how it goes.
Be careful.
I will.
Mr.
Palmer, Dr.
Bull.
Ladies and gentlemen of the press, thank you for coming out here today.
After a great deal of soul-searching, I have decided to withdraw from the race for district attorney of the city of New York.
Um Well, the truth is that I've been struggling for quite some time with a number of personal problems.
And I thought I had licked them.
But clearly I'm not quite there yet.
So for that reason, I'm gonna take a step back.
And I'm gonna focus on my recovery and my health